Nguyen and Australian Community Pharmacy Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

Nguyen and Australian Community Pharmacy Authority [2016] AATA 966 (30 November 2016)

Division

GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s)

2015/1567

Re

John Nguyen

APPLICANT

And

Australian Community Pharmacy Authority

RESPONDENT

And

Joseph Ranallo

OTHER PARTY

DECISION

Tribunal

Mr S. Webb, Member

Date 30 November 2016
Place Perth

The Australian Community Pharmacy Authority recommendation against Mr Nguyen’s application for approval to supply pharmaceutical benefits at a premises is set aside. Instead, the Tribunal decides that Mr Nguyen’s application satisfies the legislative requirements and recommends it for approval.

...................[Sgd].....................................................

Mr S. Webb, Member

CATCHWORDS

PHARMACIST – application for approval to supply pharmaceutical benefits at a premises – requirement for a ‘supermarket’ within 500 metres of premises ‘at all relevant times’ – meaning of ‘supermarket’ and ‘retail store or market’ – primary business requirement in respect of the sale of a range of food, beverages, groceries and other domestic goods – ‘market’ allows for independent vendors and stall-holders under a singular management – periodic regular market operation of sufficient frequency to establish continuity ‘at all relevant times’ – existence of ‘supermarket’ not confined to hours of operation – requirement for supermarket within 500 metres satisfied  – decision set aside

LEGISLATION

Acts Interpretation Act 1901 – s 15AB

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 – ss 28, 30(1A), 33(1AB), 37, 39(1)

National Health Act 1953 – ss 90, 99K, 99L, 105AD

National Health (Australian Community Pharmacy Authority Rules) Determination 2011 –
ss 5, 9, Schedule 1 – item 130, Schedule 2 – item 211

CASES

Alcan (NT) Alumina Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Territory Revenue (NT) [2009] HCA 41

Elhelwe and Australian Community Pharmacy Authority and Ors [2015] AATA 219

Issa and Australian Community Pharmacy Authority and Anor [2012] AATA 374

Richardson v Austin [1911] HCA 28

Walkerden v Wodonga Pharmacy Limited [2015] FCA 273

OTHER MATERIALS

Macquarie Dictionary

National Health (Australian Community Pharmacy Authority Rules) Determination 2011 Explanatory Statement

Oxford English Dictionary

REASONS FOR DECISION

Mr S. Webb, Member

30 November 2016

  1. John Nguyen is a shareholder and sole director of Chele Pty Ltd (Chele). Chele applied for approval to supply pharmaceutical benefits from premises at ‘Market City’, owned by Perth Markets Limited (PML) at Canning Vale, Western Australia. The application was referred to the Australian Community Pharmacy Authority (the Authority) for assessment and recommendation. The Authority sought comment from local pharmacy operators and, ultimately, recommended against approval. Mr Nguyen applied for review of this decision.

    Facts

  2. The following factual findings are established by evidence and they are uncontroversial.

  3. On 19 August 2014, PML (formerly known as Perth Market Authority) (Lessor) and Chele as the trustee for the Chele Unit Trust (the Trust) (Lessee) and Thanh Le Thi Nguyen (Guarantor), executed a lease over Tenancy 1, Ground Floor, Block A on Lot 1002 at 280 Bannister Road Canning Vale (the Premises).[1]

    [1] T8.5 folio 247 and T8 folio 121.

  4. On 15 January 2015 (the Application Day), under s 90 of the National Health Act 1953 (the Health Act), application for approval to establish a new pharmacy…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nguyen and Australian Community Pharmacy Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] AATA 966
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Chele Pty Ltd for approval to supply pharmaceutical benefits at premises located within "Market City" in Canning Vale, Western Australia. The Australian Community Pharmacy Authority (the Authority) had recommended against the application, leading Mr Nguyen, a shareholder and director of Chele, to seek a review of that decision. The core of the dispute revolved around whether a "supermarket" existed within 500 metres of the proposed pharmacy premises, as required by the National Health Act 1953 and associated Rules.

The Tribunal was required to determine the meaning of "supermarket" and "retail store or market" within the context of the legislative requirements. Specifically, it needed to ascertain whether the operations at Market City, including its wholesale fresh food market, clearance market, community market, and retail centre, constituted a "supermarket" for the purposes of the Act. The Tribunal also had to consider the temporal requirement that such a facility must be present "at all relevant times."

The Tribunal reasoned that the legislative intent behind requiring a supermarket was to ensure access to a range of essential goods, particularly food and domestic items. It found that the various market operations at Market City, collectively, met this requirement, with the wholesale market, in particular, demonstrating a primary business focused on the sale of a wide range of food and groceries. The Tribunal further held that the term "market" could encompass operations with independent vendors under a singular management and that periodic, regular market operation could satisfy the "at all relevant times" criterion, establishing continuity. The existence of a supermarket was not confined to its operating hours.

Consequently, the Tribunal concluded that the requirement for a supermarket within 500 metres of the proposed premises was satisfied. The Authority's recommendation against Mr Nguyen's application was set aside, and the Tribunal recommended that the application be approved.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Australian Community Pharmacy Authority recommendation against Mr Nguyen’s application for approval to supply pharmaceutical benefits at a premises is set aside. Instead, the Tribunal decides that Mr Nguyen’s application satisfies the legislative requirements and recommends it for approval.

Background

Background to the litigation

John Nguyen is a shareholder and sole director of Chele Pty Ltd (Chele). Chele applied for approval to supply pharmaceutical benefits from premises at ‘Market City’, owned by Perth Markets Limited (PML) at Canning Vale, Western Australia. The application was referred to the Australian Community Pharmacy Authority (the Authority) for assessment and recommendation. The Authority sought comment from local pharmacy operators and, ultimately, recommended against approval. Mr Nguyen applied for review of this decision.Facts The following factual findings are established by evidence and they are uncontroversial. On 19 August 2014, PML (formerly known as Perth Market Authority) (Lessor) and Chele as the trustee for the Chele Unit Trust (the Trust) (Lessee) and Thanh Le Thi Nguyen (Guarantor), executed a lease over Tenancy 1, Ground Floor, Block A on Lot 1002 at 280 Bannister Road Canning Vale (the Premises).[1][1] T8.5 folio 247 and T8 folio 121. On 15 January 2015 (the Application Day), under s 90 of the National Health Act 1953 (the Health Act), application for approval to establish a new pharmacy was made on behalf of Chele.[2] The application specifies that approval is sought to establish a new pharmacy under item 130 of schedule 1 of the National Health (Australian Community Pharmacy Authority Rules) Determination 2011 (the Rules).[3][2] T7 and T8.[3] T8 folio 119. It is agreed by the parties, correctly in my view, that Chele had a legal right to occupy the Premises on and after the Application Day for the purposes of item 211 of Schedule 2 of the Rules. I do not need to go any further on this point. On 27 February 2015, the Authority decided to recommend against approval of the application.[4][4] T18 folio 498. Mr Nguyen applied for review. On 28 September 2016, the application came on for hearing and determination. PML operates a market facility business at Market City.[5] The business includes the operation of:(a)a wholesale fresh food market (the Wholesale Market) which operates from 5.30am to 2.30pm on weekdays and 6.00am to 8.00am on Sundays, and is not open to the public;(b)a fresh food clearance market (the Clearance Market) which operates from 6.00am to 10.00am on Saturday mornings, and is open to the public;(c)a community market (the Community Market) which operates from 7.00am to 1.00pm on Sundays, and is open to the public; and(d)a retail and business services centre (the Retail Centre) which operates every day of the week, and is open to the public. [5] Exhibit 4. The Premises are located in the Retail Centre, which is less than 500 metres in a straight line from the Wholesale Market, the Clearance Market and the Community Market. The Premises are located more than 1.5 kilometres in a straight line from the nearest approved pharmacy premises, and it is less than 500 metres in a straight line from a full time medical centre. The gross leasable area of each of the Wholesale Market, the Clearance Market, the Community Market and the Retail Centre are in excess of 2,500 square metres.IssuesConstraint on issues that may be raised by joined party - ruling

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

For these reasons the decision under review must be set aside.DECISION The Australian Community Pharmacy Authority recommendation against Mr Nguyen’s application for approval of a new pharmacy is set aside. Instead, the Tribunal decides that Mr Nguyen’s application satisfies the legislative requirements and recommends it for approval.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.