Suzanne Yates and Ors and Australian Community Pharmacy Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

[2012] AATA 610

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number

2012/0750

Re

Suzanne Yates and Ors

APPLICANT

And

Australian Community Pharmacy Authority

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Senior Member Bernard J McCabe

Date 27 August 2012
Place Brisbane

The decision under review is set aside and a decision substituted recommending the applicant's premises be approved to supply pharmaceutical benefits.

............................[Sgd].............................

Senior Member Bernard J McCabe

CATCHWORDS

HEALTH AND COMMUNITY SERVICES – Pharmaceutical benefits – Approval to supply pharmaceutical benefits – catchment area – overlap of catchment area – whether proposed premises regarded as a reasonable and practical option to residents – decision under review set aside and substituted.

CASES

Issa and Australian Community Pharmacy Authority [2012] AATA 374
Newman and Australian Community Pharmacy Authority [2010] AATA 1055
Re Maryborough/Hervey Bay Friendly Society Chemists Ltd andAustralian Community Pharmacy Authority [2008] AATA 932
Strutt v Australian Community Pharmacy Authority & Ors [2006] FMCA 1245

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member Bernard J McCabe

11 September 2012

  1. The outcome of this case turns on a simple question: would residents of the Highlands Reserve residential estate in Upper Coomera regard a pharmacy located at Brygon Creek as a reasonable and practical alternative for their pharmacy needs?

  2. I gave my decision in this matter at the resumed hearing on 27 August 2012. I told the parties I was satisfied residents of Highlands Reserve would make use of the pharmacy that has already been established by the applicant at Brygon Creek, albeit that it currently operates without the approval to dispense Pharmaceutical Benefits’ Scheme (PBS) medicines. The decision under review was set aside and a decision was made in substitution that the Secretary recommend an approval be granted to the applicant’s pharmacy. I did not provide reasons at the time of the decision: I agreed to provide the decision as a matter of urgency as the applicant faced a looming commercial deadline. I said I would provide reasons as soon as possible. These are my reasons.

    A PRELIMINARY ISSUE: WHAT MATERIAL IS BEFORE THE TRIBUNAL?

  3. The Tribunal pointed out in its recent decision in Issa and Australian Community Pharmacy Authority [2012] AATA 374 that the applicant was not able to present new material to the Tribunal that was not provided to the Authority at the time the original application was lodged. Issa had only recently been delivered when this matter came on for hearing, and its significance may have been missed. The applicant tendered a good deal of new evidence in support of her application. There was no objection taken to the tender of the evidence at the time, although the respondent subsequently asked the Tribunal to consider whether the material ought to be received in light of the rule discussed in Issa. I decided it was appropriate that all of the tendered material be provided because it would assist me in my deliberations. The material included data that had only just been released from the Australian Bureau of Statistics following the recent census. It also included some…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Suzanne Yates and Ors and Australian Community Pharmacy Auth... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] AATA 610
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Suzanne Yates and others have brought a case against the Australian Community Pharmacy Authority. The applicants, including experienced pharmacists, argue for the approval of a new pharmacy at Brygon Creek. The respondents opposed the approval, citing concerns about the proximity to other pharmacies and the potential impact on the local community. The Administrative Appeals Tribunal was tasked with determining whether the new pharmacy should receive a Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme (PBS) approval. The key issues before the Tribunal included whether the new pharmacy would provide a reasonable and practical option for the community and whether it would unduly compete with existing pharmacies.

The Tribunal considered the rapid growth of the Brygon Creek area, highlighted by recent census data, and the presence of a cluster of medical and allied health facilities nearby. The Tribunal also noted the absence of large supermarkets in the immediate vicinity, suggesting that residents would still need to travel elsewhere for their weekly shopping. The Tribunal concluded that while the existing Pharmacy Essentials may remain popular, the new pharmacy would provide a reasonable and practical option for the community once approved. The Tribunal also found that the applicant's failure to include all relevant material in her initial application did not warrant exclusion of the new evidence, given the circumstances.

In light of the above, the Tribunal set aside the original decision and substituted it with a recommendation that the applicant's premises be approved. The Tribunal found that the new pharmacy would serve as a reasonable and practical option for the community, thereby meeting the criteria for PBS approval.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The Tribunal pointed out in its recent decision in Issa and Australian Community Pharmacy Authority [2012] AATA 374 that the applicant was not able to present new material to the Tribunal that was not provided to the Authority at the time the original application was lodged. Issa had only recently been delivered when this matter came on for hearing, and its significance may have been missed. The applicant tendered a good deal of new evidence in support of her application. There was no objection taken to the tender of the evidence at the time, although the respondent subsequently asked the Tribunal to consider whether the material ought to be received in light of the rule discussed in Issa. I decided it was appropriate that all of the tendered material be provided because it would assist me in my deliberations. The material included data that had only just been released from the Australian Bureau of Statistics following the recent census. It also included some of the material I referred to in my decision in Newman and Australian Community Pharmacy Authority [2010] AATA 1055 at [12]. I am satisfied the circumstances of the case warrant the introduction of the material – particularly as there was no suggestion the applicant failed to provide the material in support of her original application in an attempt to preserve a commercial advantage for herself.BACKGROUND The applicant is an experienced pharmacist. She has owned and operated a number of pharmacies in the area where she established the new premises in December 2010. Those other establishments had PBS approvals. She gave evidence that she anticipated there would be no difficulty in getting a PBS approval for the new Brygon Creek premises – which explains why she commenced trading from there without a PBS approval. Unfortunately for her, the approval process has not run smoothly.The site of the pharmacy and its immediate surrounds Brygon Creek is within the Upper Coomera area, which is located on the western side of the Pacific Motorway on the northern end of the Gold Coast. The area is growing very quickly. The recent census suggests there are many young families moving into the new residential estates nearby, like Highland Reserve. The new pharmacy is located within a small shopping precinct just off Reserve Road. The Brygon Reserve Shopping Village includes an IGA Express supermarket, a number of smaller shops, like a café and a video store, and a bank. The Gold Coast Institute of Technology, a small training provider, also has premises there. The centre is described by the applicant’s consultant experts as “an important top-up shopping and convenience destination for surrounding residents”: exhibit one, p 201. Having visited that centre, I accept the description. Residents would not complete their weekly shop at the centre. They would probably travel to one of the other shopping centres which host a larger supermarket for that purpose. I will have more to say about that later. The pharmacy is located in a cluster of buildings that are contiguous to the Brygon Reserve Shopping Village. That cluster of buildings includes a large medical centre. I was told there are now six doctors working within the medical centre, including four female doctors. The Coomera Community Child Health Centre is located nearby; there is an orthodontic clinic and other allied health professionals, including visiting psychologists and podiatrists within the precinct: exhibit one, p 201. There is also a large childcare centre with 325 places. A tavern complex is located within the precinct, and there is a retirement complex located within 300 metres of the centre.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

That is not to say I anticipate the bulk of the population will suddenly shift its allegiance from Pharmacy Essentials to the applicant’s premises. The attraction of the Pharmacy Essentials location means it may remain the most popular choice for the residents of Highland Reserve. But that is not the test. It is enough that the population as a whole regards the applicant’s premises as a reasonable and practical option. I am satisfied that will be the case once the applicant’s premises become approved.CONCLUSION The decision should be set aside. I decide in substitution that a recommendation be made that the applicant’s premises be approved.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established