Home Grown Brands Australia Pty Ltd v Sperling Enterprises Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 85 min read

Federal Circuit Court of Australia

Home Grown Brands Australia Pty Ltd v Sperling Enterprises Pty Ltd [2021] FCCA 1597

File number(s): SYG 2234 of 2019
Judgment of: JUDGE MANOUSARIDIS
Date of judgment: 16 July 2021
Catchwords: CONSUMER LAW – applicant supplier of nipper boards under particular brand name – respondent supplier of nipper boards under different brand name – whether applicant’s nipper boards have a reputation based on features associated with its nipper boards – whether in designing its nipper boards respondent appropriated features associated with applicant’s nipper boards – whether by importing, selling, and promoting for sale its nipper boards respondent engaged in trade or commerce in misleading or deceptive conduct or made misleading representations – respondent did not engage in misleading or deceptive conduct and did not make any misleading representations – application dismissed
Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth), Sch 2, ss 18(1), 29(1)

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth), ss 55, 56, 57(1), 58(1), 59(1), 144(1)

Federal Rules of Evidence 1975 (US)

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), s 52(1)

Cases cited:

A.G. Spalding & Bros v A.W. Gamage Ltd (1915) 32 RPC 273

American Safety Table Co. v Schreiber & Goldberg 269 F2d 255 (2d Cir 1959)

Apand Pty Ltd v The Kettle Chip Company Pty Ltd (1994) 52 FCR 474

ASIC v Rich [2005] NSWSC 417

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Air New Zealand Ltd [2012] FCA 1355

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Pfizer Australia Pty Ltd [2018] FCAFC 78

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v TPG Internet Pty Ltd [2020] FCAFC 130

Bodum v DKSH Australia Pty Limited [2011] FCAFC 98

Bradmill Industries Ltd v B & S Products Pty Ltd [1980] FCA 154; (1980) 53 FLR 385

Butcher v Lachlan Elder Realty Pty Ltd [2004] HCA 60

Cadbury Schweppes Pty Ltd v Darrell Lea Chocolate Shops Pty Ltd [2007] FCAFC 70

Campbell v Backoffice Investments Pty Ltd [2009] HCA 25

Campomar Sociedad Limited v Nike International Limited [2000] HCA 12

Chase Manhattan Overseas Corporation v Chase Corporation Ltd (1986) FCR 375

Dodds Family Investments Pty Limited v Lane Industries Pty Limited [1993] FCA 259

Dyno Nobel Inc v Orica Explosives Technology Pty Ltd (No 2) [2019] FCA 1552

Educational Broadcasters Adelaide Incorporated v Australian Broadcasting Corporation [2016] FCA 1502

General Electric Co (of USA) v General Electric Co Ltd [1973] RPC 297

Global Sportsman Pty Ltd v Mirror Newspapers Ltd (1984) 2 FCR 82

Google Inc v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission [2013] HCA 1

Hansen Beverage Company v Bickfords (Australia) Pty Ltd [2008] FCAFC 181

Homart Pharmaceuticals Pty Ltd v Careline Australia Pty Ltd [2017] FCA 403

H P Bulmer Ltd v J Bollinger SA [1978] RPC 79

Interlego AG v Croner Trading Pty Limited [1992] FCA 624

Mars Australia Pty Ltd v Sweet Rewards Pty Ltd [2009] FCA 606

Parkdale Custom Built Furniture Pty Ltd v Puxu Pty Ltd [1982] HCA 44

Pinnacle Runaway Pty Ltd v Triangl Limited [2019] FCA 1662

Re Equity Access Limited v Westpac Banking…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Home Grown Brands Australia Pty Ltd v Sperling Enterprises P... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] FCCA 1597
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this matter before Manousaridis J of the Supreme Court of New South Wales, Home Grown Brands Australia Pty Ltd (the applicant) alleged that Sperling Enterprises Pty Ltd (the respondent) engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct and made misleading representations in contravention of the Australian Consumer Law (ACL). The dispute concerned the supply and promotion of nipper boards, with the applicant claiming its boards had a reputation based on specific features, and that the respondent had appropriated these features in its own nipper boards, thereby misleading consumers.

The court was required to determine whether the respondent's nipper boards, imported, sold, and promoted for sale, constituted misleading or deceptive conduct or misleading representations under sections 18(1) and 29(1) of the ACL, respectively. Specifically, the court had to assess whether the respondent's actions conveyed or had a tendency to convey certain representations alleged by the applicant, and whether these representations originated from the same source.

Manousaridis J reasoned that while evidence suggested the applicant's and respondent's nipper boards looked very similar when displayed side-by-side, this similarity alone did not establish misleading conduct. The court accepted evidence that customers typically inquired about specific brands or "nipper boards" rather than selecting solely based on visual appearance in-store. Given the evidence of the respondent's sales and promotion of its own boards, the court found it could not infer that the respondent made any statements or engaged in conduct that could reasonably suggest the boards originated from the same source. Consequently, the court concluded that the storing of the boards side-by-side could not have conveyed to a reasonable consumer a representation to the effect of those alleged by the applicant, nor could it have caused a reasonable consumer to wonder whether such a representation was conveyed.

As a result of these findings, the court was not satisfied that the respondent engaged in conduct that contravened section 18(1) of the ACL. It followed that the applicant's claims based on contraventions of section 29(1) of the ACL also failed, as they relied on the same factual allegations. The application was therefore dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

This relationship between the authenticity of a document and the relevance of its contents is reflected in s 57(1) of the Evidence Act (emphasis added):If the determination of the question whether evidence adduced by a party is relevant depends on the court making another finding (including a finding that the evidence is what the party claims it to be), the court may find that the evidence is relevant:(a) if it is reasonably open to make that finding; or(b) subject to further evidence being admitted at a later stage of the proceeding that will make it reasonably open to make that finding. When applied to documents, s 57(1) of the Evidence Act assumes that the authenticity of a document – that is, the quality of a document’s being what the proponent claims it to be – is or at least may be relevant to determining whether the disputed document is relevant under s 56(1) of the Evidence Act; and where the relevance of a document under s 56 of the Evidence Act depends on a finding that the document is what the proponent claims it to be, the court may find the document is relevant if it is reasonably open to make a finding that the document is what the proponent claims it to be. That a disputed document has been admitted into evidence because the court has found it is relevant because it is reasonably open to find the document is what the proponent claims it to be does not mean the court as trier of fact must regard the document as being that which the proponent claims it to be. Subsection 57(1) of the Evidence Act only requires the court to determine, at the point questions of admissibility are raised, whether it is reasonably open to make a finding that the document is what the proponent claims it to be; it does not require or even authorise the court to find that the document is in fact what the proponent claims it to be. If the court finds it is reasonably open to find that the document is what the proponent claims it to be, and finds the contents of the document are relevant, whether the document is in fact what the proponent claims it to be is to be determined by the court in its capacity as trier of fact at the time the court considers all of the evidence that has been admitted into evidence and makes its findings of fact. The process by which the proponent seeks to persuade the court as a trier of fact that the disputed document is what the proponent claims it to be is equally to be described as “authentication”; and it constitutes the second of the two stages at which the process of authentication of a disputed document occurs. If the common law rules of evidence applied, the question of the disputed document’s authenticity would have turned on the application of the ancient rule that, subject to exceptions, only the original of the document sought to be tendered would be admissible. As a matter of logic, proof that the disputed document is an original could not have been supplied by the contents of the document itself. Proof had to be supplied by evidence that lay outside its contents. The logical implication of the rule governing the admissibility of documents was summed up by saying that a document is not self-authenticating. That difficulty, however, is overcome by s 58(1) of the Evidence Act, which provides:If a question arises as to the relevance of a document or thing, the court may examine it and may draw any reasonable inference from it, including an inference as to its authenticity or identity.

Decision

Reasons for decision

There remains the evidence of Mr B Smith that in MSS’s store the Mirage board and Redback boards were stacked side-by-side, and Mr B Smith’s acceptance that in those circumstances the two boards looked very much alike. This evidence must be viewed in light of the other evidence Mr B Smith gave. As I have already noted, Mr B Smith said that customers who are seeking MSS’s junior nipper boards would call asking for them, or they would come into the store where customers would be presented with options; and that some customers specifically asked for “the Redback Board”, but Mr B Smith is not aware of anyone asking for a Mirage board. On this evidence, customers who attend MSS’s shop do not select from boards that are present in the store; they make enquiries of the person attending the store. They either ask for “the Redback board” or they ask about “nipper boards”. Given the other evidence about MSS’s sale and promotion of the Redback boards and the Mirage boards, it cannot be inferred that any person on behalf of MSS would have made any statement, or would have engaged in conduct that could reasonably have suggested that the Mirage boards and the Redback boards originate from the same source. Given the evidence I have accepted, the likelihood is that MSS, in response to an enquiry from a customer in relation to a nipper board, would have informed the customer of the Redback boards and the Mirage board; and if the customer had asked for “the Redback board”, MSS would have informed the customer of the Redback boards. In those circumstances, the storing side-by-side of the Redback boards and the Mirage boards could not have conveyed to the ordinary or reasonable member of the end user class a representation to the effect of any one of the Representations, or could not have even caused a reasonable or ordinary member of the end user class to wonder whether a representation to the effect of any of the Representations was conveyed.Conclusion For these reasons I am not satisfied that Sperling has engaged in any conduct that has conveyed or that has had a tendency to convey any of the Representations. It follows, therefore, that I am not satisfied Sperling has engaged in conduct that contravened s 18(1) of the ACL. That means Home Grown’s claims based on s 18(1) of the ACL fail.contravention of s 29(1) of the ACL? In the FACS Home Grown alleges that Sperling has contravened s 29(1) of the ACL. Home Grown relies on the same allegations of facts on which it relies for claiming that Sperling had contravened s 18(1) of the ACL. These include the allegations that Sperling made each of the Representations. Given I have found I am not satisfied Sperling engaged in conduct that conveyed, or had a tendency to convey any of the Representations, it follows that Home Grown’s claims based on contraventions of s 29(1) of the ACL also fail.damages Home Grown claims that it suffered loss and damage as a consequence of Sperling’s conduct. Although it is unnecessary for me to consider that question, it would be appropriate I do so, given that evidence has been led and submissions made in relation to this question.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established