Higgerson and Prosegur Australia Pty Ltd (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 58 min read

Higgerson and Prosegur Australia Pty Ltd (Compensation) [2023] AATA 115 (2 February 2023)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2020/4266; 2021/8735

Re:Craig Higgerson

APPLICANT

AndProsegur Australia Pty Ltd

RESPONDENT

Decision

Tribunal:Emeritus Professor P A Fairall, Senior Member

Date:2 February 2023

Place:Sydney

Each of the decisions under review is set aside, and remitted to the Respondent with a finding that the Respondent is liable under section 12 of the Safety, Rehabilitation & Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) in respect of the injury sustained on 16 October 2019.

..................................[SGD]......................................

Emeritus Professor P A Fairall, Senior Member

Catchwords

WORKERS COMPENSATION – Self-licenced entity – Prior injury – Osteoarthritis – Whether Applicant suffers from ailment – Whether Applicant suffers from aggravation of prior injury – Whether employee entitled to compensation pursuant to s 12 or s 16 in respect of injury – Concurrent evidence – Inconsistency in medical evidence

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)

Safety, Rehabilitation & Compensation Act 1988 (Cth)

Cases

Commonwealth Banking Corporation v Percival (1988) 20 FCR 176

Commonwealth v Beattie (1981) 35 ALR 369

Ellison v Comcare [2022] FCA 95

Mellor v Australian Postal Corporation [2009] FCA 504

Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission v May (2016) 257 CLR 468; [2016] HCA 19

Ogden Industries Pty Ltd v Lucas (1967) 116 CLR 537

Tippett v Australian Postal Corporation [1998] FCA 335

Walters and Comcare (Compensation) [2021] AATA 14

Wuth v Comcare [2022] FCAFC 42

Secondary Materials

Notice of Variation of Licence – Prosegur Australia Pty Limited (No.32 of 2021): Gazette C2021G00504 at [7] < et al., Australian Financial Review, ‘Chubb Security Services sold to Spain’s Prosegur’, (Web Page, 16 December 2013) < FOR DECISION

Emeritus Professor P A Fairall, Senior Member

2 February 2023

  1. Mr Higgerson commenced employment with Brambles Security Services Ltd (Brambles) as an armed security guard in 1998, and worked continuously in that role until 2019. His specific role was to operate as the security guard within an armoured vehicle (AV). His employment transitioned to Chubb Security Services (Chubb), when it purchased the Security Armed Guard Division of Brambles in June 2000, and to Prosegur Australia Pty Ltd (PAPL), the Respondent in these proceedings, when it acquired Chubb on 16 December 2013.[1]

    [1] Thompson et al., Australian Financial Review, ‘Chubb Security Services sold to Spain’s Prosegur’, (Web Page, 16 December 2013) <>

    PAPL is a self-insured corporation under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) (the SRC Act).[2] Under the terms of its licence, it is not authorised to accept liability for injuries occurring outside the period covered by the licence, which is from 1 July 2007 and ending on 30 June 2025.[3]

    [2] PAPL’s self-insurance licence was granted by the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission on 25 June 2007, with a commencement date of 1 July 2007. See Notice of Variation of Licence – Prosegur Australia Pty Limited (No.32 of 2021): Gazette C2021G00504 at [7]

    [3] Clause 7 of the Licence states:

    Part…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Higgerson and Prosegur Australia Pty Ltd (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 115
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a claim for workers' compensation brought by Mr. Higgerson against Prosegur Australia Pty Ltd. The dispute centred on whether Mr. Higgerson was entitled to compensation under sections 12 or 16 of the relevant legislation in relation to an incident that occurred on 16 October 2019, which involved him slipping and jarring his left knee. The proceedings were heard by Emeritus Professor P A Fairall, Senior Member.

The court was required to determine several key legal issues. These included whether Mr. Higgerson suffered from an ailment, whether he suffered from an aggravation of a prior injury, and whether he was entitled to compensation under the relevant sections of the legislation. A significant aspect of the case involved the assessment of conflicting medical evidence provided by three specialists regarding the presence of an injury on 16 October 2019 and its relationship to Mr. Higgerson's pre-existing osteoarthritis.

The court's reasoning was informed by the medical evidence, which indicated a lack of evidence for a new physical injury on 16 October 2019, with some specialists noting the absence of any injury. However, the court found that while Mr. Higgerson's employment with Prosegur Australia Pty Ltd was not a significant contributor to the development of his osteoarthritis, and the incident did not accelerate its deterioration, the fall on 16 October 2019 did aggravate his original 2002 physical injury, making it worse. The court applied the principle that an aggravation of a pre-existing injury can constitute a compensable injury.

Ultimately, the court was satisfied that Mr. Higgerson suffered an aggravation of his original 2002 physical injury due to the incident on 16 October 2019, which made that injury worse. This finding was based on a consideration of medical notes, the subsequent course of his employment, his experience of debilitating knee pain, and the expert opinions presented.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Significantly, the three specialists agreed that there was no medical evidence of an injury occurring on 16 October 2019. Dr Steadman referred to this, somewhat pithily and I think inappropriately, as the “party line”. Dr Gill went further. The x-rays taken in 2019 and 2020 showed not merely an absence of medical evidence of physical injury, but “that there was medical evidence that there was no injury”.[38] The 16 October 2019 incident was, in relation to the left knee, bracketed by the x-rays taken in July 2019 and the MRI taken much later on 8 April 2021. Dr Bodel cautioned that he had not actually seen the x-rays, just read the reports.[39] [38] Transcript, 17 June 2022, 154.[39] In discussing the left knee, Dr Bodel referred to X-rays taken in February 2019, although the X-rays taken on that date did not include the left knee: see T20, 76 (95). The left knee was X-rayed on 12 July 2019: see T23. MEDICAL EVIDENCE CONTAINED IN PRE-HEARING REPORTS It is useful to compare the oral evidence given by the doctors with their pre-hearing observations.(a) Dr David Gill Dr Gill’s various medical reports span the period from 2008 to 2021.[40] He performed arthroscopies on the Applicant’s left knee in 2008 and 2012. [40] T5, T6, T7, T8, T10, T11, T12, T14, T15, T16, T25, T52. On 21 May 2008, Dr Gill wrote to Dr Isaacs about the treatment he proposed.[41] He stated:“I note the MRI scan which essentially shows that he has an ACL injury with cystic formation around it, and this is very suggestive of a more chronic problem. Indeed, the menisci are intact clinically. There is significant subchondral cysts in the mid-posterior medial tibial plateau, and I can see that there is cartilage lesions and loose cartilage coming off the medial femoral condyle.I do notice the cyst in the ACL and that they are quite large, in fact 20mm at the back of the knee. I feel that Craig probably has injured his ACL in January, 2002. At that time he has not injured his meniscus and hence has not had much more than subtle instability symptoms of the knee. He probably has damaged the medial articular cartilage of the medial tibial plateau/medial femoral condyle, and I think that it is an escalation in the symptoms from this area which is giving him the majority of his symptoms here. [Emphasis added]I feel that there are a couple of things that we should and should not do: I think that reconstruction of the cruciate ligament (given that he has not had significant amounts of instability over the years) is certainly not in his best interests. I think that performing an arthroscope, remove the loose bodies, chondroplasty the loose cartilage of the femur and assess the menisci, and removing the cysts should give him an improvement in his knee function, and perhaps also an improvement in the bending of his knee.Having said this, this would not return the knee to normal function. Once this is done we could consider options such as cortisone (I realise that a recent cortisone injection did not make much difference), Synvisc or otherwise may improve the function of his knee.I will write to the insurance company and seek approval for this to be undertaken.” [41] Hearing Book, 339, 369.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I make the following findings:(a)On or about 2 April 2002, Mr Higgerson slipped down the back-steps of an AV during the course of his employment with Chubb;(b)He received workers compensation under WorkCover in respect of his injury;(c)On or about 16 December 2013, his employment transitioned from Chub to PAPL;(d)PAPL is a self-insured corporation under the SRC Act;(e)PAPL is not authorised to accept liability for injuries occurring outside the period specified in its licence, which runs from the period commencing immediately after midnight (Australian Eastern Daylight Time) on 1 July 2007 and ending at the end of 30 June 2025 (Australian Eastern Standard Time); (f)The nature of his employment for PAPL was physically demanding. It involves lifting, squatting, rotating, climbing and descending narrow steps and doors, while armed and wearing body armour; (g)In the course of his overall employment as a security guard, he reported a number of workplace accidents, including injuries to his right hand, back, knees and tendon;(h)In the course of his employment by PAPL, he reported workplace incidents in 2015 (back sprain) and 2019 (left knee hyperextension);(i)He suffers from osteoarthritis of the left knee; (j)In 2012 his arthritis was diagnosed as mild or moderate, but by 2019 it was more severe;(k)On 8 October 2019, he was experiencing significant pain in his left knee;(l)On 16 October 2019, he slipped and fell down the back-steps of his AV while in the course of his employment, and jarred his left knee; (m)In the aftermath of this incident, Mr Higgerson experienced pain and discomfort in his left knee; (n)He reported the incident to his employer; (o)He sought medical treatment and obtained work incapacity certificates following the incident; (p)He has not worked in his original role since 16 October 2019;(q)In September 2021 his employment was terminated;(r)I am not satisfied that his employment with PAPL from around 2012 was a significant contributor to the development of his left knee osteoarthritis. It may have been material, but it was not substantially more than material;[110] (s)I am not satisfied that the incident on 16 October 2019 accelerated the rate of arthritic deterioration of his left knee; (t)The incident of 16 October is not clearly associated with any identifiable or detectable change in the physiology of the left knee. I am therefore not satisfied that he suffered a physical injury, in the primary sense of that word, on 16 October 2019; and[111](u)I am satisfied that the incident that occurred on 16 October 2019 caused aggravation to his original 2002 physical injury so as to make that injury worse.[110] See paragraph [107] above.[111] See paragraph [115] above.CONCLUSION On balance, I am satisfied that Mr Higgerson slipped down the back-steps of his AV on 16 October 2019 and aggravated his original 2002 physical injury so as to make that injury worse. In forming that judgment, I have considered several factors, including the medical notes arising from his initial consultations at the Kotara Family Practice, the subsequent course of his employment, his experience of debilitating left knee pain (both before and after the incident), and the opinions of the specialists who gave evidence in these proceedings.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.