Hayson v The Age Company Pty Ltd (No 2) [2020] FCA 361
File number:
NSD 870 of 2017
Judge:
BROMWICH J
Date of judgment:
19 March 2020
Catchwords:
DEFAMATION – Whether defamatory imputations alleged were conveyed – where same allegations were published earlier in separate articles that were not sued upon – whether aggravated damages warranted – held: the two admitted imputations were conveyed and the three disputed imputations were not – though damages could not be mitigated on the basis of allegations already published elsewhere, allegations in Melbourne-based paper not proven to have damaged Sydney-based reputation – applicant’s evidence in relation to hurt feelings overstated
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Hayson v The Age Company Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:
The case of Hayson v The Age Company Pty Ltd (No 2) was heard by the Federal Court of Australia, where the primary dispute centred on defamation claims made by Mr Hayson against The Age Company Pty Ltd. Mr Hayson alleged that articles published by the respondents defamed him by conveying specific imputations about his involvement in match-fixing in rugby league. The court was tasked with determining whether certain defamatory imputations were indeed conveyed by the publications, and if so, whether Mr Hayson was entitled to damages, including aggravated damages.
The key legal issues the court had to resolve included whether the published articles conveyed the defamatory imputations alleged by Mr Hayson, and if the damages claimed by him were justified, particularly in the context of aggravated damages. The court had to consider the credibility of Mr Hayson's evidence, the impact of prior controversies on his reputation, and the necessity for an award of aggravated damages. Additionally, the court needed to assess whether the publication of similar allegations in a different context could mitigate the damages claimed.
The court found that two of the admitted imputations were indeed conveyed by the publications, but the three disputed imputations were not. The court held that while the imputations were defamatory, the damages could not be mitigated based on previous publications elsewhere. The court also found that the defamatory imputations did not significantly damage Mr Hayson's reputation in Sydney, where he had substantial social standing. The evidence presented by Mr Hayson regarding the hurt and distress caused by the publications was considered overstated. Consequently, the court awarded Mr Hayson $50,000 in damages.
In summary, the court ruled in favour of Mr Hayson on the defamation claims, awarding him damages. However, the court declined to award aggravated damages, considering the evidence of hurt and distress to be exaggerated. The court also determined that the publication of similar allegations in another context did not reduce the quantum of damages owed to Mr Hayson.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. Verdict and judgment for the applicant.
2. The respondents pay the applicant the sum of $50,000.
3. Within 14 days of the making of these orders, or such other period as may be fixed by the Court, the parties furnish agreed or competing orders:
(a) for any evidence, submissions and other procedural steps proposed to adjudicate upon the question of costs, with the parties to indicate their views in the draft orders and/or in a covering email as to whether this can be determined on the papers, or also requires oral submissions by telephone or other remote means;
(b) for any other matter requiring orders or adjudication.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
Mr Hayson was the primary witness in his case. The evidence of his only other witness, Mr Nikolic, concerned his reaction to having The Age article read to him (an event he did not himself depose to having taken place) and is discussed further below.Mr Hayson’s background Mr Hayson grew up on the New South Wales Central Coast and has been a resident of Sydney for the past three decades. He described being actively involved in sport since his early teenage years, including as a New South Wales squash champion at 13 years of age and then as a player of rugby league, golf and tennis up until early adulthood. His social life, discussed further below, was based predominantly in sporting and gaming circles. As well as counting NRL players as friends, Mr Hayson described being friendly with prominent people in the horse racing industry, including Gai and Tom Waterhouse. He was also previously a co-owner of race horses alongside various NRL players. In 2001, in his early thirties, he purchased a hotel in Sydney which he converted to a brothel named Stiletto. Mr Hayson ceased being an owner of Stiletto in about 2014. He stated that he now earns money as a punter and by organising escorts. He thus has been actively involved in sports-related gambling for many years.Evidence as to prior controversies involving Mr Hayson going to his credit Before turning to the evidence specific to this case, it is convenient to address the challenge mounted to Mr Hayson’s credibility in cross-examination, as this has a material bearing on the conclusions reached as to the acceptance or otherwise of his evidence, especially on issues which turn on his account of events that that are difficult, if not impossible, to challenge directly. The respondents sought to make much of prior controversies concerning the applicant, in order to discredit him as a witness. To a limited extent, Mr Hayson made admissions that some of these controversies had a negative impact on his reputation, addressed cautiously in further detail below. During cross-examination, Mr Hayson admitted that he entered the main gaming area of Star Casino in June and September 2014, knowingly in breach of exclusion orders. On the second occasion, the duty manager told Mr Hayson he was not permitted there due to an exclusion order, to which he responded by falsely stating that the order had been overturned two years earlier. The respondents submit that the “flagrant” commission of two criminal offences, by way of separate and deliberate contraventions of an exclusion order under the Casino Control Act 1992 (NSW), are exacerbated by a “bare-faced lie” to the duty manager. While Mr Hayson readily admitted this was so, the respondents submit that he did so because he must have been aware of documents the respondents had which meant they had him “cold”. The better explanation is that Mr Hayson did not think that this mattered very much, which is not to his credit either. This is evidence of Mr Hayson’s willingness to lie when it is to his advantage. He pleaded guilty to summary charges for each incident and was given the benefit of not having a conviction recorded, an outcome which most commonly is only possible, or at least likely, with a guilty plea. They are relatively minor regulatory offences, but the necessary findings of guilt demonstrate that Mr Hayson, less than two years before the publication of The Age article, did not think he should have to comply with the exclusion orders, an important part of gambling regulation and control. More troubling than breaching the exclusion orders is lying about them so that they would not stand in the way of him entering the casino gaming area as was clearly intended by the orders being made. It indicates a determination to do as he pleases, and to lie about it if that is necessary to get what he wants. Lying to a duty manager at a casino is a very different matter to lying on oath in court. Nonetheless, Mr Hayson’s attitude towards legal obligations and to telling the truth when that was an impediment to getting what he wanted caused me to scrutinise his evidence more closely, and to be less willing to take what he said at face value.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
As well as counting NRL players as friends, Mr Hayson described being friendly with prominent people in the horse racing industry, including Gai and Tom Waterhouse. He was also previously a co-owner of race horses alongside various NRL players. In 2001, in his early thirties, he purchased a hotel in Sydney which he converted to a brothel named Stiletto. Mr Hayson ceased being an owner of Stiletto in about 2014. He stated that he now earns money as a punter and by organising escorts. He thus has been actively involved in sports-related gambling for many years.Evidence as to prior controversies involving Mr Hayson going to his credit Before turning to the evidence specific to this case, it is convenient to address the challenge mounted to Mr Hayson’s credibility in cross-examination, as this has a material bearing on the conclusions reached as to the acceptance or otherwise of his evidence, especially on issues which turn on his account of events that that are difficult, if not impossible, to challenge directly. The respondents sought to make much of prior controversies concerning the applicant, in order to discredit him as a witness. To a limited extent, Mr Hayson made admissions that some of these controversies had a negative impact on his reputation, addressed cautiously in further detail below. During cross-examination, Mr Hayson admitted that he entered the main gaming area of Star Casino in June and September 2014, knowingly in breach of exclusion orders. On the second occasion, the duty manager told Mr Hayson he was not permitted there due to an exclusion order, to which he responded by falsely stating that the order had been overturned two years earlier. The respondents submit that the “flagrant” commission of two criminal offences, by way of separate and deliberate contraventions of an exclusion order under the Casino Control Act 1992 (NSW), are exacerbated by a “bare-faced lie” to the duty manager. While Mr Hayson readily admitted this was so, the respondents submit that he did so because he must have been aware of documents the respondents had which meant they had him “cold”. The better explanation is that Mr Hayson did not think that this mattered very much, which is not to his credit either. This is evidence of Mr Hayson’s willingness to lie when it is to his advantage. He pleaded guilty to summary charges for each incident and was given the benefit of not having a conviction recorded, an outcome which most commonly is only possible, or at least likely, with a guilty plea. They are relatively minor regulatory offences, but the necessary findings of guilt demonstrate that Mr Hayson, less than two years before the publication of The Age article, did not think he should have to comply with the exclusion orders, an important part of gambling regulation and control. More troubling than breaching the exclusion orders is lying about them so that they would not stand in the way of him entering the casino gaming area as was clearly intended by the orders being made. It indicates a determination to do as he pleases, and to lie about it if that is necessary to get what he wants. Lying to a duty manager at a casino is a very different matter to lying on oath in court. Nonetheless, Mr Hayson’s attitude towards legal obligations and to telling the truth when that was an impediment to getting what he wanted caused me to scrutinise his evidence more closely, and to be less willing to take what he said at face value.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Mr Hayson did not make any detailed submissions to explain how this imputation was to be derived from the words that were published. I am not satisfied that this imputation has been established at any level. Mr Hayson has failed to establish imputation (e).Conclusion on the disputed imputations None of the disputed imputations have been established.Overview of the damages claim On the basis of the admissions made by the respondents as to imputations (a) and (b), Mr Hayson is entitled to damages. The respondents accept that is so, although they did not do so until their closing submissions, based on how the trial unfolded. The debate is one of quantum, involving factual and legal differences between parties, with a particular dispute as to what the Court should make of the evidence. As developed in the discussion of the relevant legal principles below, Mr Hayson seeks damages to cover hurt and distress (referred to in these reasons as hurt, or hurt feelings), reparation and vindication, and seeks to have the award elevated by a measure of aggravated damages. Damages for economic loss are not sought, and exemplary or punitive damages are not available by reason of s 37 of the Defamation Act 2005 (NSW), picked up and applied as surrogate federal law in this proceeding. Mr Hayson submits that his reputation has been severely and significantly damaged and he has suffered, and continues to suffer, extreme hurt and embarrassment for which he seeks substantial damages, including aggravated damages, in a large enough sum to vindicate him in relation to the false allegation of match-fixing. He contends that his evidence should be accepted and that the cross-examination of him did not seriously affect this. The respondents recognise the importance of Mr Hayson’s evidence, but submit that he had no credibility as a witness, and that his evidence should not be accepted in the absence of corroboration unless it was against interest. The competing submissions on Mr Hayson’s credit are addressed in the detailed consideration of his evidence below.Legal principles as to damages General damages for defamation have been described by the High Court as addressing three overlapping purposes addressing personal hurt and distress (again, referred to in these reasons as hurt, or hurt feelings), reparation for harm done to reputation, and vindication of reputation: Carson v John Fairfax & Sons Ltd (1993) 178 CLR 44 at 60-1; confirmed in Rogers v Nationwide News Pty Ltd [2003] HCA 52; 216 CLR 327 at [60] (see also [34]-[35], endorsing [60]). The respondents contend that there is no separate award for vindication. That is correct only insofar as vindication is a natural consequence of arriving at a decision to award damages, rather than a separate head of damages, as the High Court has made clear in both Carson and Rogers. As also made clear in both Carson and Rogers, the first two aspects – hurt and reparation – focus on the wrong done. The third aspect, vindication, looks to the attitude of others and what is needed to signal the gravity of what has been wrongly said and its impact on social standing. It is essentially concerned with the community in which the person defamed lives and works, in the context of that person’s prior social standing and the standing of the wrongdoer in conveying the imputation. Vindication has been described as requiring a sum sufficient to convince a bystander of the baselessness of the allegation made in the publication: see Ali v Nationwide News Pty Ltd [2008] NSWCA 183 at [75], citing and applying Cassell & Co Ltd v Broome [1972] AC 1027 at 1071; see also Hockey v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 652; 237 FCR 33 at [446] and the authorities there cited and summarised.