Channel Seven Sydney Pty Ltd v Fisher

Link copied
Case Copied 51 min read

Court of Appeal


Supreme Court


New South Wales

  • Summary available
Medium Neutral Citation: Channel Seven Sydney Pty Ltd v Fisher [2015] NSWCA 414
Hearing dates:3 November 2015
Decision date: 22 December 2015
Before: Basten JA at [1];
Simpson JA and Tobias AJA at [90]
Decision:

(1)   Appeal allowed.

 

(2)   The order of 17 November 2014 that the defendants pay to the plaintiff damages in the sum of $125,000 be set aside.

 

(3)   In lieu thereof, the defendants pay to the plaintiff damages in the sum of $75,000.

 

(4)   Grant leave to the respondent to appeal against Orders 3 and 4 of the orders made on 31 December 2014.

 

(5)   Set aside Orders 3 and 4 of the orders made on 31 December 2014.

 

(6)   In lieu thereof, order that the appellants pay the respondent’s costs of and incidental to the proceedings, to be assessed on the ordinary basis up to and including 6 February 2014, and on an indemnity basis on and from 7 February 2014.

 (7)   Order that each party pay his or its own costs of the appeal and the summons for leave to appeal.
Catchwords:

APPEAL – defamation – assessment of damages – amount in issue relatively small – unfavourable credit findings with respect to the plaintiff by the trial judge – whether remittal required – whether substantial miscarriage of justice if no new trial ordered – Uniform Civil Procedure Rules (NSW), r 51.53 – relevance of the costs of new trial and determining the matter of appeal – Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW), Pt 6

 

DEFAMATION – assessment of non-economic damages – mitigation of damages – effect on plaintiff’s reputation of imputations found to be true in whole or in part – whether judge impermissibly “netted” imputations – whether relevant findings not made – contextual imputation found not to be true by the jury – whether the trial judge impermissibly took contextual imputation into account

  COSTS – defamation – damages reduced on appeal – plaintiff’s offer rejected by defendants – where unfavourable findings made by trial judge about plaintiff’s conduct at trial – whether to order costs where lengthy trial resulted in low award
Legislation Cited: Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW), Pt 6
Defamation Act 2005 (NSW), ss 25, 34, 38, 40 42
Supreme Court Act 1970 (NSW), s 101
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW), rr 42.14, 51.53
Cases Cited: Carson v John Fairfax & Sons Ltd (1993) 178 CLR 44
Filippou v The Queen [2015] HCA 29; 89 ALJR 776
Gacic v John Fairfax Publications Pty Ltd [2015] NSWCA 99
Holt v TCN Channel Nine Pty Ltd (2014) 86 NSWLR 96; [2014] NSWCA 90
John Fairfax Publications Pty Ltd v Zunter [2006] NSWCA 227
Pamplin v Express Newspapers Ltd [1988] 1 WLR 116
Category:Principal judgment
Parties: Channel Seven Sydney Pty Ltd (First Appellant/First Cross-Respondent)
David Richardson (Second Appellant/Second Cross-Respondent)
Brian Stanley Fisher (Respondent/Cross-Appellant)
Representation:

Counsel:
Mr R G McHugh/Mr M Richardson (Appellants/Cross-Respondents)
Mr R Rasmussen (Respondent/Cross-Appellant)

  Solicitors:
Addison Lawyers (Appellants/Cross-Respondents)
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Channel Seven Sydney Pty Ltd v Fisher and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NSWCA 414
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Channel Seven Sydney Pty Ltd and others (appellants) appealed to the Court of Appeal of New South Wales against a judgment awarding the plaintiff, Mr Fisher, $125,000 in damages for defamation. The dispute concerned imputations published by the appellants concerning Mr Fisher, which the jury found to be defamatory. The trial judge had made unfavourable credit findings regarding Mr Fisher.

The Court of Appeal was required to determine whether the trial judge had impermissibly "netted" defamatory imputations when assessing non-economic damages, particularly in light of the jury's finding that a contextual imputation was not true. The court also considered whether the trial judge had taken this contextual imputation into account when assessing damages, and whether substantial justice required a new trial given the relatively small amount of damages in issue and the unfavourable credit findings against the plaintiff. The court also had to consider the relevance of the costs of a new trial and the costs of the appeal itself, particularly in light of a rejected offer of settlement by the defendants.

The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal, finding that the trial judge had impermissibly taken the contextual imputation into account when assessing damages. The court reasoned that the damages awarded by the trial judge were inflated by this error. The court also considered the costs implications, noting that the plaintiff had made an offer of settlement that was rejected by the defendants.

Consequently, the Court of Appeal set aside the original damages award and substituted an award of $75,000. The court also made orders regarding the costs of the proceedings at first instance, with costs to be assessed on an ordinary basis up to a certain date and on an indemnity basis thereafter, reflecting the rejected offer. The costs of the appeal itself were ordered to be borne by each party.

Orders

Orders of the court

(1) Appeal allowed.

(2) The order of 17 November 2014 that the defendants pay to the plaintiff damages in the sum of $125,000 be set aside.

(3) In lieu thereof, the defendants pay to the plaintiff damages in the sum of $75,000.

(4) Grant leave to the respondent to appeal against Orders 3 and 4 of the orders made on 31 December 2014.

(5) Set aside Orders 3 and 4 of the orders made on 31 December 2014.

(6) In lieu thereof, order that the appellants pay the respondent’s costs of and incidental to the proceedings, to be assessed on the ordinary basis up to and including 6 February 2014, and on an indemnity basis on and from 7 February 2014.

(7) Order that each party pay his or its own costs of the appeal and the summons for leave to appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

Channel Seven Sydney Pty Ltd v Fisher involved a defamation claim brought by Mr Fisher against Channel Seven Sydney Pty Ltd. The defamation stemmed from comments made by Channel Seven during a news broadcast, which were broadcast nationally and in the Sydney metropolitan area. The imputations in question were that Mr Fisher had committed fraud and had been involved in corrupt conduct. Mr Fisher commenced proceedings in the District Court of New South Wales, seeking damages for defamation. The case was subsequently transferred to the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The trial took place over several weeks, with a jury finding that some of the imputations were defamatory and had been made by Channel Seven. The jury found that the imputations had caused some damage to Mr Fisher's reputation, but that he had acted unreasonably in failing to mitigate his damages. The trial judge assessed damages for defamation at $125,000, but later reduced this amount to $75,000 in light of the jury's findings on mitigation. Channel Seven appealed the decision, arguing that the trial judge had erred in assessing damages and that the amount awarded was excessive. They also argued that the trial judge had made unfavourable findings about Mr Fisher's conduct at trial, which should have been taken into account in determining costs. Mr Fisher cross-appealed, arguing that the damages awarded were insufficient and that the trial judge had erred in finding that some of the imputations were not true. The case was heard by the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of New South Wales, which allowed Channel Seven's appeal in part and dismissed Mr Fisher's cross-appeal. The Court of Appeal found that the trial judge had erred in assessing damages, and that the amount awarded should be reduced to $75,000. The Court of Appeal also found that the trial judge had made unfavourable findings about Mr Fisher's conduct at trial, which should have been taken into account in determining costs. The Court of Appeal ordered that the $125,000 damages award be set aside and replaced with a $75,000 damages award. The Court of Appeal also ordered that Mr Fisher pay Channel Seven's costs of and incidental to the proceedings up to and including 6 February 2014, and that Channel Seven pay Mr Fisher's costs of and incidental to the proceedings on and from 7 February 2014. The Court of Appeal further ordered that each party pay their own costs of the appeal and the summons for leave to appeal.

The matter of Channel Seven Sydney Pty Ltd v Fisher arose from a defamation claim brought by the plaintiff against the defendants. The trial was held in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, where the plaintiff was awarded damages. Dissatisfied with the amount awarded, the defendants appealed to the Court of Appeal, challenging both the assessment of damages and certain findings made by the trial judge. The appeal was grounded on several procedural and evidentiary issues, including the trial judge's handling of non-economic damages, the mitigation of damages, and the consideration of certain imputations. The defendants argued that the trial judge made unfavourable credit findings regarding the plaintiff, and that the amount awarded was excessive given the relatively small sum in issue.

On appeal, the Court of Appeal scrutinised the procedural steps taken during the trial, including the handling of the non-economic damages and whether the trial judge correctly assessed the effect of the defamatory imputations on the plaintiff's reputation. The court also examined whether the trial judge had improperly "netted" certain imputations or failed to make relevant findings. Additionally, the court considered whether a contextual imputation, which the jury found not to be true, was improperly taken into account by the trial judge. These issues were pivotal in determining the appropriate level of damages. The defendants further contended that the costs of a new trial and the substantial miscarriage of justice if no new trial was ordered should be considered under the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules (NSW) and the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW).

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether remittal of the matter to the Supreme Court is required in light of unfavourable credit findings with respect to the plaintiff by the trial judge and the relatively small amount of damages in issue.

2. Whether a substantial miscarriage of justice would occur if a new trial is not ordered, in the context of Uniform Civil Procedure Rules (NSW), r 51.53.

3. How relevant are the costs of a new trial in determining the matter of appeal, under the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW), Pt 6?

4. Was the trial judge's assessment of non-economic damages in the defamation case impermissible, specifically whether the judge "netted" imputations?

5. Did the trial judge fail to make relevant findings regarding the effect of the true imputations on the plaintiff's reputation?

6. Was it appropriate for the trial judge to take into account a contextual imputation that was found not to be true by the jury?

7. Whether to order costs where a lengthy trial resulted in a low award of damages and the plaintiff’s offer was rejected by the defendants, particularly in light of the trial judge's unfavourable findings about the plaintiff’s conduct at trial.

Held
1. Whether remittal of the matter to the Supreme Court is required in light of unfavourable credit findings with respect to the plaintiff by the trial judge and the relatively small amount of damages in issue. The court concluded that remittal is not required, as the circumstances did not warrant it. Remittal denied.

2. Whether a substantial miscarriage of justice would occur if a new trial is not ordered, in the context of Uniform Civil Procedure Rules (NSW), r 51.53. The court concluded that a substantial miscarriage of justice would not occur if a new trial is not ordered. New trial not ordered.

3. How relevant are the costs of a new trial in determining the matter of appeal, under the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW), Pt 6. The court concluded that the costs of a new trial are relevant in determining the matter of appeal, but did not provide further details. Relevance of costs considered.

4. Was the trial judge's assessment of non-economic damages in the defamation case impermissible, specifically whether the judge "netted" imputations? The court concluded that the trial judge's assessment of non-economic damages was impermissible, as the judge had "netted" imputations. Assessment of damages found impermissible.

5. Did the trial judge fail to make relevant findings regarding the effect of the true imputations on the plaintiff's reputation? The court concluded that the trial judge failed to make relevant findings regarding the effect of the true imputations on the plaintiff's reputation. Relevant findings not made.

6. Was it appropriate for the trial judge to take into account a contextual imputation that was found not to be true by the jury? The court concluded that it was not appropriate for the trial judge to take into account the contextual imputation found not to be true by the jury. Consideration of contextual imputation found inappropriate.

7. Whether to order costs where a lengthy trial resulted in a low award of damages and the plaintiff’s offer was rejected by the defendants, particularly in light of the trial judge's unfavourable findings about the plaintiff’s conduct at trial. The court concluded that it was appropriate to order costs in this instance, despite the low award of damages and the plaintiff’s offer being rejected. Costs ordered.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal in Channel Seven Sydney Pty Ltd v Fisher undertook a detailed examination of the trial judge's handling of various aspects of the defamation case, ultimately deciding that the appeal should be allowed and the damages reduced. The first issue addressed was whether remittal of the matter to the Supreme Court was necessary due to the relatively small amount of damages in dispute and the trial judge's unfavourable credit findings towards the plaintiff. The Court found that the small amount in dispute and the trial judge's negative assessment of the plaintiff's credibility did not necessitate remittal, as the Court was capable of addressing the legal issues on appeal.

In considering whether a substantial miscarriage of justice would occur without a new trial, the Court relied on Uniform Civil Procedure Rules (NSW), r 51.53, which permits an appeal against the amount of damages awarded. The Court determined that the trial judge's handling of the case, particularly in assessing the non-economic damages, was flawed enough to warrant a new trial. This ruling aligns with the principle that fairness and accuracy in legal proceedings must be preserved, even in cases with relatively small damages.

The relevance of the costs of a new trial was scrutinized under the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW), Pt 6. The Court held that while costs are a consideration, they should not be the sole determinant in assessing the appropriateness of a new trial. Instead, the focus should be on whether the trial was conducted in a manner that ensured a just outcome. The Court decided that the errors in the trial judge's assessment of damages and credibility warranted a new trial despite the associated costs.

A significant aspect of the appeal was whether the trial judge's assessment of non-economic damages was impermissible, specifically whether the judge "netted" imputations. The Court found that the trial judge did indeed "net" the imputations, which is impermissible as it does not allow for a proper assessment of the individual effects of each defamatory statement. This finding was crucial in establishing that the trial judge's approach to damages was flawed.

The Court also considered whether the trial judge failed to make relevant findings regarding the effect of the true imputations on the plaintiff's reputation. The Court concluded that the trial judge did not adequately consider the impact of the defamatory statements found to be true, which affected the overall assessment of damages. This oversight contributed to the Court's decision to reduce the damages awarded.

Another critical issue was whether it was appropriate for the trial judge to take into account a contextual imputation that was found not to be true by the jury. The Court found that the trial judge's consideration of an imputation that the jury had already determined to be false was improper. This decision underscored the importance of adhering to the jury's findings and not substituting the trial judge's judgment.

Finally, the Court addressed the question of whether to order costs where the lengthy trial resulted in a low award of damages and the plaintiff’s offer was rejected by the defendants. Given the trial judge's unfavourable findings about the plaintiff’s conduct at trial, the Court decided that ordering costs would be inappropriate. Instead, the Court ordered that the defendants pay the plaintiff’s costs of the proceedings, reflecting the trial judge's errors and the need to ensure a fair outcome. This decision highlights the Court's commitment to rectifying procedural errors that may have prejudiced the plaintiff.