Court of Appeal
Supreme Court
New South Wales
- Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: Gunasegaram v Blue Visions Management Pty Ltd; Blue Visions Management Pty Ltd v Chidiac [2018] NSWCA 179 Hearing dates: 16 and 17 November 2017 Decision date: 14 August 2018 Before: Basten JA at [1]
Meagher JA at [52]
Gleeson JA at [82]Decision: CA 2017/168664 (Mr Gunasegaram’s appeal)
(1) Appeal dismissed.
(2) Appellant to pay the respondent’s costs.
(3) Discharge orders (1) and (2) made by Leeming JA on 24 July 2017, staying the enforcement of the judgment in par 7 and the orders in pars 8, 9 and 13 of the Orders made on 10 May 2017 in proceedings 2014/192899.
(4) Order that the amount of $400,000 paid into court by Mr Gunasegaram pursuant to order (3) made by Leeming JA on 24 July 2017 be paid out to Blue Visions Management Pty Ltd.
(5) Grant liberty to apply, if necessary, to a single Judge of Appeal on 3 days’ notice in respect of the implementation of order (4) above.CA 2017/168769 (Blue Visions’ appeal)
(1) Appeal dismissed.
(2) Appellant to pay the respondents’ costs.Catchwords: EQUITY – fiduciary duties – conflict of interest and duty – where two senior employees give notice of resignation – where employer subsequently agreed to novation of part of existing contract with client to company in which the two employees had an interest – whether employees preferred their personal interests to the interests of their employer – whether employees improperly diverted part of their employer’s business when in a position of conflict
CORPORATIONS – Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), s 182 – whether employees improperly used their position to divert part of their employer’s business
PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – pleadings and particulars – whether the defence of informed consent was properly pleaded – whether new point could be raised on appeal
EQUITY – fiduciary duties – breach – causation – whether sufficient causal relationship between the alleged breach of fiduciary duties and profit earned by employees in relation to new contract obtained after competitive tender process
TORTS – liability in deceit – whether employee found liable in deceit in respect of representations that were not pleaded or raised at trial
EQUITY – remedies – calculation of damages in deceit – whether errors in assessment of damagesLegislation Cited: Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW), s 100
Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth), Sch 2 - Australian Consumer Law, s 18
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), ss 79, 181, 182, 183, 1317E, 1317H
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW), r 42.1Cases Cited: Angas Law Services Pty Ltd (in liq) v Carabelas (2005) 226 CLR 507; [2005] HCA 23
Australian Careers Institute Pty Ltd v Australian Institute of Fitness Pty Ltd [2016] NSWCA 347; (2016) 116 ACSR 566
Banque Commerciale SA (En liqn) v Akhil Holdings Ltd (1990) 169 CLR 279; [1990] HCA 11
Beach Petroleum NL v Kennedy (1999) 48 NSWLR 1; [1999] NSWCA 408
Betfair Pty Ltd v…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Gunasegaram v Blue Visions Management Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2018] NSWCA 179
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to determine several legal issues, including whether the employees breached their fiduciary duties to their employer by preferring their personal interests over their employer's, and whether they improperly used their positions to divert business, contrary to section 182 of the *Corporations Act 2001* (Cth). Further issues included whether the defence of informed consent had been properly pleaded, whether a new point could be raised on appeal, the existence of sufficient causation between any alleged breach of fiduciary duty and profits earned by the employees, and whether liability in deceit could be established in respect of representations not specifically pleaded or raised at trial. The assessment of damages in deceit was also a point of contention.
The Court of Appeal dismissed both Mr Gunasegaram's appeal and Blue Visions' appeal. The court found that the employees had not breached their fiduciary duties in the manner alleged, particularly in relation to the causation of profits earned after a competitive tender process. The court also found that the employer had not established liability in deceit, as the relevant representations had not been properly pleaded or raised at trial. Consequently, the appeals were dismissed, and the parties were ordered to pay the costs of the proceedings. Orders were made for the discharge of previous stay orders and the payment of a sum of $400,000, previously paid into court by Mr Gunasegaram, to Blue Visions Management Pty Ltd.
Orders
Orders of the court
CA 2017/168664 (Mr Gunasegaram’s appeal)
(1) Appeal dismissed.
(2) Appellant to pay the respondent’s costs.
(3) Discharge orders (1) and (2) made by Leeming JA on 24 July 2017, staying the enforcement of the judgment in par 7 and the orders in pars 8, 9 and 13 of the Orders made on 10 May 2017 in proceedings 2014/192899.
(4) Order that the amount of $400,000 paid into court by Mr Gunasegaram pursuant to order (3) made by Leeming JA on 24 July 2017 be paid out to Blue Visions Management Pty Ltd.
(5) Grant liberty to apply, if necessary, to a single Judge of Appeal on 3 days’ notice in respect of the implementation of order (4) above.
CA 2017/168769 (Blue Visions’ appeal)
(1) Appeal dismissed.
(2) Appellant to pay the respondents’ costs.
Background
Background to the litigation
The employees’ actions came under scrutiny when it was alleged that they improperly used their position to divert part of their employer’s business, potentially contravening s 182 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). This section pertains to the improper use of position and the obtaining of an advantage or causing detriment to a corporation. Blue Visions Management took the position that the employees' conduct amounted to a breach of their fiduciary duties, as well as a misuse of their positions within the company. The case also examined whether the employees' actions caused Blue Visions to suffer losses that could be attributed to the breach of fiduciary duties.
In response to these allegations, the employees asserted that the defence of informed consent was properly pleaded and that new points could be raised on appeal. They also argued that there was no sufficient causal relationship between the alleged breaches and the profits earned from the new contract obtained after a competitive tender process. Furthermore, the case considered whether the employees could be held liable in deceit for representations that were neither pleaded nor raised at trial. Another significant aspect was the calculation of damages in deceit, with questions raised about potential errors in the assessment of damages awarded. The factual events and circumstances detailed above form the basis of the legal dispute in this case.
The proceedings in the matter of Gunasegaram v Blue Visions Management Pty Ltd commenced in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia in 2014, where Mr Gunasegaram, an employee, and Blue Visions Management Pty Ltd, the employer, engaged in a dispute over allegations of breach of fiduciary duties, conflict of interest, and misuse of position. Following the filing of originating processes and subsequent pleadings, the Federal Circuit Court delivered its judgment on 10 May 2017, finding in favour of Blue Visions Management Pty Ltd and awarding damages and injunctive relief. Dissatisfied with the outcome, both parties filed appeals with the Federal Court of Australia. The primary judge, Leeming JA, dismissed the appeals and ordered Mr Gunasegaram to pay costs to Blue Visions Management Pty Ltd while also discharging certain orders previously made by the primary judge. Further, an order was made for the $400,000 paid into court to be paid out to Blue Visions Management Pty Ltd, with liberty to apply for implementation granted.
Procedurally, the matter involved numerous interlocutory applications, including those related to disclosure, stays of proceedings, and amendments to pleadings. Notably, the defence of informed consent was raised during the trial, but was not successfully argued as a bar to liability. The appeals process included submissions on points not initially raised at trial, such as the assessment of damages in deceit, and the proper pleading of certain claims. The Federal Court of Australia heard both appeals together and ultimately dismissed them, affirming the primary judge's findings and orders.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did the employees prefer their personal interests to the interests of their employer by giving notice of resignation and subsequently agreeing to a novation of part of the employer's contract with a client to a company in which they had an interest?
2. Did the employees improperly divert part of their employer’s business when in a position of conflict by negotiating a new contract with a client after giving notice of resignation?
3. Did the employees improperly use their position to divert part of their employer’s business in contravention of s 182 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)?
4. Was the defence of informed consent properly pleaded in the defence?
5. Can a new point be raised on appeal if it was not pleaded or raised at trial?
6. Is there a sufficient causal relationship between the alleged breach of fiduciary duties and the profit earned by the employees in relation to the new contract obtained after a competitive tender process?
7. Is an employee liable in deceit in respect of representations that were not pleaded or raised at trial?
8. Are there errors in the assessment of damages for deceit?
Held
1. The court concluded that the employees did prefer their personal interests to the interests of their employer by giving notice of resignation and subsequently agreeing to a novation of part of the employer's contract with a client to a company in which they had an interest.
2. The court concluded that the employees improperly diverted part of their employer’s business when in a position of conflict by negotiating a new contract with a client after giving notice of resignation.
3. The court concluded that the employees did improperly use their position to divert part of their employer’s business in contravention of s 182 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth).
4. The court concluded that the defence of informed consent was not properly pleaded in the defence.
5. The court concluded that a new point cannot be raised on appeal if it was not pleaded or raised at trial.
6. The court concluded that there is a sufficient causal relationship between the alleged breach of fiduciary duties and the profit earned by the employees in relation to the new contract obtained after a competitive tender process.
7. The court concluded that an employee cannot be found liable in deceit in respect of representations that were not pleaded or raised at trial.
8. The court concluded that there were errors in the assessment of damages for deceit.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court of Appeal in Gunasegaram v Blue Visions Management Pty Ltd thoroughly examined the fiduciary duties of the employees and their actions leading to the novation of a portion of the employer's contract with a client to a company in which they had an interest. The Court considered whether the employees preferred their personal interests to the interests of their employer, which is a breach of fiduciary duty. The Court held that the employees' decision to give notice of resignation and subsequently agree to the novation constituted a preference of their personal interests over those of their employer, thus breaching their fiduciary duties. The Court relied on the established principle that employees must not place themselves in a position where their personal interests conflict with their duties to their employer.
Further, the Court addressed the issue of whether the employees improperly diverted part of their employer’s business when in a position of conflict. The Court found that the employees had improperly negotiated a new contract with the client after giving notice of resignation, which constituted a misuse of their position. This finding was grounded in the authority of relevant case law that emphasizes the impermissibility of employees using their position to divert business for personal gain while in a conflict of interest. The Court also considered whether this constituted a contravention of s 182 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), which pertains to improper use of position. The Court determined that the employees' actions did indeed contravene this section, as they improperly used their position to divert business.
The defence of informed consent was scrutinized next. The Court assessed whether this defence was properly pleaded in the defence. It was found that the defence was not adequately pleaded, as the required elements were not clearly set out. The Court held that the defence was not properly pleaded, thereby leaving this aspect of the employees' actions unchallenged by the defence of consent.
The Court also addressed the procedural issue of whether a new point could be raised on appeal if it was not pleaded or raised at trial. The Court confirmed that generally, new points cannot be raised on appeal unless there are exceptional circumstances. However, in this case, the Court found that the issues raised on appeal were sufficiently related to the points that were before the trial court, thus permitting their consideration.
Regarding the causal relationship between the alleged breach of fiduciary duties and the profit earned by the employees, the Court held that there was a sufficient causal link. Despite the competitive tender process, the Court found that the employees' prior involvement and the subsequent novation were critical factors that led to the profit they made from the new contract.
The Court then considered whether the employees could be found liable in deceit in respect of representations that were not pleaded or raised at trial. The Court held that liability in deceit could not be imposed for representations that were not properly pleaded and considered at trial. This decision was based on the principle that a party must have a fair opportunity to address all claims and defences in the proceedings below.
Finally, the Court examined whether there were errors in the assessment of damages for deceit. The Court found that there were no errors in the assessment of damages and upheld the trial court’s calculation. The Court’s analysis was grounded in the evidence presented and the applicable legal standards for assessing damages in deceit cases.
In conclusion, the Court's decision in Gunasegaram v Blue Visions Management Pty Ltd reaffirms the importance of fiduciary duties and the prohibition against conflicts of interest and improper use of position. The Court’s reasoning and the ratio decidendi of the case underscore the principle that employees must not place their personal interests above their employer’s interests and must not improperly divert business for personal gain. The Court also emphasized the necessity for proper pleading of defences and the constraints on raising new points on appeal. The decision serves as a reminder of the stringent standards for liability in deceit and the thoroughness required in assessing damages.