Foxtel Management Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Foxtel Management Pty Ltd v Australian Competition & Consumer Commission [2000] FCA 589

TELECOMMUNICATIONS – Promotion of competition in relation to analogue cable television programs – Facilitation of access under Part XIC of Trade Practices Act 1974 – Purported 1997 specification by Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (“ACCC”) pursuant to transitional legislation – Specification statement included not only analogue distribution service but also three optional adjunct services:  network management access function, conditional access function and subscriber premises servicing function – Challenge to validity of specification – Whether validity ought to be considered having regard to delay – Effect of ACCC’s omission to publish full copy of statement in Gazette – Whether ACCC was empowered to specify multiple services – Whether specification is uncertain – Whether the specified service (or any one of multiple services) is not an “eligible service” or not “necessary” for the purpose of enabling the supply of a broadcasting service – Severance of invalid elements – 1999 declaration under Part XIC of Trade Practices Act – Validity – Whether ACCC’s power exhausted by 1997 specification – Whether improper exercise of power – Alleged failure to take into account relevant considerations – Alleged taking account of irrelevant considerations – Alleged predetermination – Alleged error of law – Whether no evidence to support conclusions – Failure to make inquiries – Alleged unreasonableness – Whether FOXTEL is a “carriage service provider”. 

Trade Practices Act 1974, ss152AB, 152AG, 152AH, 152AL and 152AR

Telecommunications (Transitional Provisions and Consequential Amendments) Act 1997, s39

Telecommunications Act1997, ss87, 88, 93 and 97
Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977, s5
Acts Interpretation Act 1901, ss23(b), 33(1) and 46(1)(b)

FOXTEL MANAGEMENT PTY LIMITED v AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION

N1088 of 1999

FOXTEL MANAGEMENT PTY LIMITED v AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION

N1150 of 1999

SEVEN CABLE TELEVISION PTY LIMITED v TELSTRA CORPORATION LIMITED & ORS

N1095 of 1999

FOXTEL MANAGEMENT PTY LIMITED & ANOR v SEVEN CABLE TELEVISION PTY LIMITED & ORS

N217 of 2000

WILCOX J
SYDNEY

8 MAY 2000


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

N1088 of 1999

BETWEEN:

AND:

FOXTEL MANAGEMENT PTY LIMITED
Applicant

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION
Respondent

JUDGE:

WILCOX J

DATE OF ORDER:

8 MAY 2000

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.It be declared that the declaration made by Australian Competition and Consumer Commission under s152AL(3) of the Trade Practices Act 1974, concerning the analogue subscription television broadcast carriage service, that was notified in the Commonwealth of Australia Gazette dated 8 September 1999 is valid and effective in law.

2.The applicant, Foxtel Management Pty Limited, pay the costs incurred by the respondent, Australian Competition and Consumer Commission, in respect of this proceeding.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

N1150 of 1999

BETWEEN:

AND:

FOXTEL MANAGEMENT PTY LIMITED
Applicant

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Foxtel Management Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consu... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] FCA 589
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Foxtel Management Pty Ltd and Foxtel Cable Television Pty Ltd brought proceedings against the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission and other respondents, challenging the validity of certain statutory declarations and deeming statements made by the ACCC. The respondents had declared that Foxtel Management and Foxtel Cable constituted a "carriage service provider" under the Telecommunications Act 1997. The applicants sought declarations that neither Foxtel Management nor Foxtel Cable were "carriers" or "carriage service providers" within the meaning of the Act. The court was required to determine the validity of the statutory declarations and deeming statements issued by the ACCC and whether Foxtel Management and Foxtel Cable constituted a "carriage service provider" under the Telecommunications Act.

The court examined the statutory declarations and deeming statements issued by the ACCC and found them to be valid and effective in law. The court concluded that the applicants, Foxtel Management and Foxtel Cable, together constituted a "carriage service provider" within the meaning and for the purposes of the Telecommunications Act 1997. The court held that the services provided by Foxtel Management and Foxtel Cable, in conjunction with each other, constituted a "carriage service" as defined in the Act. The court rejected the applicants' argument that the services provided by Foxtel Cable were separate from those provided by Foxtel Management and that, therefore, they could not be considered as a single "carriage service provider".

The court declared that the declarations made by the ACCC were valid and effective in law and that Foxtel Management and Foxtel Cable, together, constituted a "carriage service provider" within the meaning and for the purposes of the Telecommunications Act 1997. The court also ordered Foxtel Management to pay the costs incurred by the ACCC in respect of the proceeding.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. It be declared that the declaration made by Australian Competition and Consumer Commission under s152AL(3) of the Trade Practices Act 1974, concerning the analogue subscription television broadcast carriage service, that was notified in the Commonwealth of Australia Gazette dated 8 September 1999 is valid and effective in law.

2. The applicant, Foxtel Management Pty Limited, pay the costs incurred by the respondent, Australian Competition and Consumer Commission, in respect of this proceeding.

1. It be declared that the statement dated 30 June 1997 entitled “Deeming of Telecommunications Services: A statement pursuant to section 39 of the Telecommunications (Transitional Provisions and Consequential Amendments) Act 1997” is valid and effective in law to the extent, and only to the extent, that it specifies as an access service the following service:

“The service, being an analogue service supplied by an (access provider), necessary for the purposes of enabling the supply by an (access seeker) of a broadcasting service by means of line links that deliver signals to end-users, and of a kind that was used for those purposes on 13 September 1996”.

2. The applicant, Foxtel Management Pty Limited, pay one half of the costs incurred by the respondent, Australian Competition and Consumer Commission, in respect of this proceeding.

1. It be declared that the applicants, Foxtel Management Pty Limited and Foxtel Cable Television Pty Limited, the suppliers of the service known as “FOXTEL subscription television service”, together constitute a “carriage service provider” within the meaning and for the purposes of the Telecommunications Act 1997.

2. The said applicants pay the costs of the respondents, Seven Cable Television Pty Limited and Television Radio Broadcasting Services Australia Pty Limited, incurred in connection with this proceeding.

Background

Background to the litigation

The fourth proceeding (N217 of 2000) was instituted on 14 March 2000. During the hearing of the three earlier proceedings, it became clear Foxtel Management was contending, not only that the 1997 deeming statement and 1999 declaration were invalid, but that those instruments had no application to the service Foxtel Management conducts in conjunction with Foxtel Cable Television Pty Limited (“Foxtel Cable”). In order to regularise the situation procedurally, without opposition from any party, I gave leave to Foxtel Management and Foxtel Cable to make instantly returnable a new application seeking appropriate declarations. This was done. During the course of the hearing, the applicants amended the form of the proposed relief. Ultimately, they sought only one declaration:“A declaration that neither the first nor second applicant is a ‘carrier’ or ‘carriage service provider’ within the meaning of and for the purposes of the Telecommunications Act 1997.”The facts(i)The contractual framework The subscription television service known as “FOXTEL” is based on a complex of, at least, three agreements. The earliest of the three agreements is an “Umbrella Agreement” between News Corporation and Telstra Corporation made on 9 March 1995. It was amended and restated on 14 April 1997. The purpose of the agreement was to state the terms of an “Alliance” between the two companies, whose objectives include the establishment, through joint venture entities, of “leading businesses within the broadband video home entertainment sector in Australia”. The agreement identifies the “Services” within the scope of the Alliance, including providing “to a Residential Subscriber either a Video Program on a Television … via a Set-Top Unit or an Audio Program via a Set-Top Unit”. The parties agreed that Telstra Corporation and Telstra Multimedia must be the exclusive supplier of all broadbanding services used by any joint venture entity. The agreement details Telstra Corporation’s responsibility to provide broadband access to homes and the financial obligations and entitlements of the parties. On 14 April 1997 two subsidiary agreements were executed. The first of them, called “Foxtel Partnership Agreement”, was made between Sky Cable, Telstra Media and Foxtel Management. It provides for Sky Cable and Telstra Media to carry on the FOXTEL business in partnership. Foxtel Management, a company controlled by a board comprising the Chief Executive Officer and three directors appointed by each partner, is appointed the partners’ exclusive agent to manage the business. The other agreement of 14 April 1997 is called “Broadband Co-operation Agreement”. The parties to this agreement are Telstra Multimedia and Foxtel Management, acting on behalf of the Foxtel Partnership referred to above. This agreement deals in detail with the provision of broadband facilities by Telstra Multimedia to FOXTEL. The evidence also includes a copy of the standard terms and conditions that govern the supply by FOXTEL to subscribers of residential cable television. In the document, the word “FOXTEL” is a reference to Foxtel Cable: see cl 15.6. The acronym “TMPL” refers to Telstra Multimedia: see cl 15.16. The word “Service” is defined as “the provision of Channels”: see cl 15.13. “Channels” means “the programming package which you have requested and FOXTEL has agreed to supply”: see cl 15.3. “Retransmitted Free-to-Air Broadcasts” are the programs of the subscriber’s local commercial television stations and the Australian Broadcasting Corporation and Special Broadcasting Service, where available: see cl 13.1.

Decision

Reasons for decision

WILCOX J
Issues
1. Whether the declaration made by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission concerning the analogue subscription television broadcast carriage service is valid and effective in law.
2. Whether the statement dated 30 June 1997 specifying a service as an access service is valid and effective in law.
3. Whether Foxtel Management Pty Limited and Foxtel Cable Television Pty Limited together constitute a 'carriage service provider' within the meaning and for the purposes of the Telecommunications Act 1997.

Held
1. The court held that the declaration made by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission concerning the analogue subscription television broadcast carriage service is valid and effective in law.
2. The court held that the statement dated 30 June 1997 specifying a service as an access service is valid and effective in law to the extent that it refers to a specific service used for enabling the supply of broadcasting services.
3. The court held that Foxtel Management Pty Limited and Foxtel Cable Television Pty Limited together do not constitute a 'carriage service provider' within the meaning and for the purposes of the Telecommunications Act 1997.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: WILCOX J

The court examined the validity and effectiveness of the declaration by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission concerning the analogue subscription television broadcast carriage service. It determined that the declaration was valid and effective in law as it complied with the statutory requirements under the Trade Practices Act 1974. The court noted that the declaration was properly notified and published, meeting the necessary legal criteria for its enforceability.

Regarding the statement dated 30 June 1997, the court found it to be valid and effective in law to the extent that it accurately specified the service as an access service. The court focused on the specific language used in the statement and its alignment with the service's purpose as outlined in the Telecommunications (Transitional Provisions and Consequential Amendments) Act 1997. The court emphasised that the statement's validity was limited to the description of the service as it was used on a particular date.

The court considered whether Foxtel Management Pty Limited and Foxtel Cable Television Pty Limited together constituted a 'carriage service provider' under the Telecommunications Act 1997. The court examined the contractual agreements and the roles of the two entities within the FOXTEL subscription television service. It concluded that the joint operation did not meet the statutory definition of a 'carriage service provider', as their roles and responsibilities did not align with the requirements set out in the Act. The court's decision highlighted the importance of the specific legal definitions and the roles of each entity in determining their classification under the Act.