MIGRATION – appeal from a decision of the Federal Circuit Court of Australia – where student visa was cancelled – whether the Administrative Appeals Tribunal failed to take into account relevant considerations – whether the Tribunal took into account irrelevant considerations – whether the Tribunal misconstrued or misapplied s 116(1)(e) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) – where bridging visa E was refused – whether the Tribunal did not afford the appellant procedural fairness – whether the Tribunal failed to take into account a relevant consideration – where protection visa was refused – whether the Tribunal failed to consider an integer of the appellant’s claims – whether the Tribunal misunderstood the true nature of the appellant’s claims to fear harm
Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Category:
Catchwords
Number of paragraphs:
72
Counsel for the Appellant:
Mr R Knowles on a pro bono basis
Counsel for the First Respondent:
Mr D Brown
Solicitor for the First Respondent:
Australian Government Solicitor
ORDERS
VID 339 of 2018
BETWEEN:
DOY17
Appellant
AND:
MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER PROTECTION
First Respondent
ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL
Second Respondent
JUDGE:
STEWARD J
DATE OF ORDER:
26 SEPTEMBER 2019
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1.The appeal be dismissed with costs as agreed or assessed.
2.The Administrative Appeals Tribunal be added as the second respondent.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
STEWARD J:
The appellant arrived in Australia in 2013 as the holder of a student visa. In 2015 he was charged with one count of “stalking” and four counts of an “indecent act with a child under 16”. The appellant’s visa was then cancelled by a delegate of the first respondent (the “Minister”) pursuant…
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read DOY17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and more:
The matter before the court was an appeal by the appellant, DOY17, against decisions made by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) and the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection. The appellant, who had been charged with and subsequently convicted of multiple indecent acts involving a child under 16 years of age, had his student visa cancelled. The AAT affirmed the delegate’s decision to cancel the visa, refused a bridging visa E, and denied a protection visa application. The appellant challenged these decisions, arguing that the AAT failed to take into account relevant considerations, considered irrelevant factors, misconstrued or misapplied the relevant statutory provisions, and did not afford him procedural fairness.
The central legal issues revolved around the correctness of the AAT’s decisions in light of the appellant’s submissions. Specifically, the court examined whether the AAT appropriately considered the relevant migration law provisions, such as section 116(1)(e) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth), in the context of the appellant's criminal convictions and their implications for his presence in Australia. Additionally, the court scrutinized whether the AAT correctly interpreted the nature of the appellant's claims for a protection visa and whether it adhered to principles of procedural fairness during the decision-making process.
The court found that the AAT had correctly exercised its discretion under the Migration Act, taking into account all relevant considerations and appropriately applying the law. The Tribunal’s analysis of the CCTV footage and the victim’s statements was thorough and consistent with the evidence presented. The court further held that the AAT did not misconstrue the appellant's claims or fail to consider significant aspects of his application. As such, the appeal was dismissed with costs awarded to the respondents as agreed or assessed. The AAT was added as the second respondent to reflect its involvement in the proceedings.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The appeal be dismissed with costs as agreed or assessed.
2. The Administrative Appeals Tribunal be added as the second respondent.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
Ultimately, whether leave should be granted depends on the interests of justice. A key factor will be the merits of the proposed grounds. Another will be whether the appellant had legal representation in the Circuit Court. Yet another dimension is the appropriateness of this Court, when it exercises appellate jurisdiction, being used as a court of first instance: EBO17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 1227 at [53] per Robertson J. Background The evidence discloses that the appellant was charged with five offences and then convicted twice in 2015 of an indecent act with a child under the age of 16. His student visa had earlier been cancelled (that is, before he was convicted) as a delegate was satisfied that the appellant’s presence in Australia “is or might be a risk to the safety of a segment of the Australian community, in this case children and minors”. The delegate arrived at this decision based upon the fact of the five charges. They were as follows:1.The accused at Sunshine on 24/03/2015 did wilfully commit an indecent act namely kissing with a child under the age of 16 years to whom he was not married.2.The accused at Sunshine on 24/03/2015 did wilfully commit an indecent act namely taking hold of the victim’s breasts with a child under the age of 16 years to whom he was not married.3.The accused at Sunshine on 24/03/2015 did wilfully commit an indecent act namely putting his hand up the victim’s skirt with a child under the age of 16 years to whom he was not married.4.The accused at Sunshine on 24/03/2015 did wilfully commit an indecent act namely rubbing his penis against the victim’s body with a child under the age of 16 years to whom he was not married.5.The accused at Sunshine on 24/03/2015 did stalk another person namely [redacted] in that the accused did act in any other way that could reasonably be expected to arouse apprehension or fear in the victim for their own safety or that of any other person. The child in question was 12 years old. The best description of what happened may be found in the reasons of the Tribunal’s decision affirming the delegate’s decision not to grant a bridging visa. Those reasons included a consideration of what the appellant asserts had happened. It is worth setting out those reasons in some detail. Senior Member Fice found as follows (at [35]-[46]):35.In a written statement made on 7 September 2016 [the appellant] described the incident in the following way:One day in March 2015 [24 March 2015] I was going to the bus stop to go home. I saw from the schedule that it would depart in 30 minutes. During this wait, I met a girl.She smiled at me and I wanted to improve English so I talked to her. I asked her: “how old are you?” She said: “I am 18 years old”. She had a lot of make up on. While we were waiting she met four people and she hugged and kissed all of them.I asked her what she was doing there and she said she was waiting for someone. She asked me what I did and we talked for a while.She was friendly to me. I only hugged her because she hugged me first, she was a friend and she even gave me her number.I think the Australian people are friendly and open minded. When girls are friends with boys they kiss each other and say good bye and leave. I was accused of kissing and hugging the girl, but I did not know she was under 16 years, because she said she was 18.She lied to me about being over 18 so that I felt comfortable to continue chatting and behave in a mature way towards her. I kissed her and she voluntarily kissed me. I did not force her to kiss me. It was a minor mistake without intention to break the law on my part.36.I had in evidence CCTV footage which discloses the course of events quite clearly. They took place after 9 p.m. on 24 March 2015. Initially, the victim together with a male person appears, walking past the bus stop shelters where the offence eventually took place. The victim is clearly small in stature and although wearing a jacket with a hood, her dress is readily identifiable as part of a school uniform. There are two other young male persons standing near the bus shelter, one of which is plainly known to her. She goes up to that person and greets the person with a kiss on the cheek. Those four persons then stand around apparently waiting for a bus to arrive. 37.Shortly thereafter, another group of young people arrive and she greets one of those young persons with a kiss on the cheek and a hug. She then gives another one of those young persons a brief hug. The group then walks out of camera shot, disappearing behind the bus shelter. At this stage, [the appellant] is not in view and not obviously present around the bus shelters in question.38.Between 5 and 10 minutes later, [the appellant] first appears walking towards a crosswalk area at right angles while talking on a mobile telephone. The victim is not in view at that time. As [the appellant] is about to cross into the crosswalk area at right angles, the victim appears on the other side of the road walking towards the crosswalk. [The appellant] appears to end his telephone conversation while walking across the crosswalk at right angles while the victim commences to cross the road on the crosswalk a short distance behind him. [The appellant] does not appear to have seen the victim at this stage. As the victim walks across the crosswalk [the appellant] turns his head to the left, noticing her come towards him but behind. [The appellant] is watching the victim as she walks across the crosswalk, having himself slowed down to look at her. As the victim passes behind him, [the appellant] turns to the right and changes direction moving in the same direction as the victim. There is no obvious verbal exchange between the two as the victim walks past [the appellant] on his right side but [the appellant] continues to turn to his right and watches her pass by going to where toilets are located. [The appellant] then walks behind her off to her left also heading for the toilets. The victim does not look back at him or acknowledge his presence. [The appellant] watches her go into the toilet and he appears to go to the male toilets which are situated to the left.39.A short time later the victim reappears from the toilet and commences crossing the road back towards the bus shelters. As the victim reaches the other side of the road heading towards a bus shelter [the appellant] reappears from the toilet entrance and appears, at first, to turn towards the right away from the bus shelter. He then turns his head towards the left and notices the victim about to enter the bus shelter. [The appellant] watches her apparently reading a bus timetable and although looking away from her to his right side, he begins to cross the road on the crosswalk heading towards the bus shelter. The victim, by this time, has taken a seat on the bus shelter. [The appellant] looks both left and right, as if to see who else is around and as he walks up to the bus shelter he appears to make verbal contact with the victim. [The appellant] again appears to look in the direction of the camera as if looking to see if other persons might be about before walking up to the bus shelter and sitting down beside the victim.40.A short time afterwards, it is obvious that [the appellant] has physical contact with the victim but there is no obvious sign of the victim being a wilful participant in that contact. After a short time [the appellant] stands up, turning towards the victim and leaning towards her. There is plainly physical contact between the two, and when he stands up again it is clear that his right hand was down at the lower part of the victim’s body. [The appellant] gets up again standing in front of the victim but then sits down again. He then gets up again and plainly is using his right hand to touch the body of the victim. He then turns around facing her directly with his left hand on her shoulder and, while standing, leans forward to place his head on the left side of the victim’s head. [The appellant] appears to have his left arm draped around the back of the victim’s head and appears to be restraining her. 41.The victim then appears to turn to her left and stand up. She attempts to move forward out of the bus shelter but is restrained by [the appellant], who pushes her back, standing in front of her with her back against the back wall of the bus shelter. With the victim pinned against the back wall of the bus shelter, [the appellant]’s left arm moves down and obviously makes contact with the lower part of her body. The contact appears clearly to be sexual. [The appellant] ceases that activity as a bus drives past the bus shelter. However he commences again when the bus passes. Throughout this activity, the victim appears motionless. Eventually she turns away to her left again and attempts to walk out of the bus shelter and it is clear that [the appellant] has both arms around her shoulders and appears to be restraining her. Although she attempts to walk away he walks in front of her and pushes her back towards the bus shelter again. In fact he pushes her back into the bus shelter and recommences the activity he was previously engaged in. [The appellant]’s hands are obviously in the lower region of his own body and her body and the contact can only be described as sexual. It is sufficiently clear from the video that he is removing part of her clothing. There is no evidence whatsoever of active participation by the victim. Eventually, [the appellant] allows the victim to move from the bus shelter out onto the footpath where he can be seen to be readjusting his clothing. At that point two other persons appear in the picture walking towards [the appellant] and the victim.42.The victim and [the appellant] then appeared to engage in a discussion on the footpath in front of the bus shelter and the victim appears to point to an oncoming bus, perhaps indicating that was the bus she was waiting for. As the victim walks towards the bus, [the appellant] places his left arm around the victim and leads her back towards the bus shelter. In fact they walked behind the bus shelter and disappear from view. 43.Another CCTV camera records [the appellant] and the victim walking towards the bus which the victim had pointed to. [The appellant] is following the victim. On getting into the bus, the victim appears to speak to the driver while [the appellant] stands on the doorstep. The driver appears to talk to [the appellant] briefly before disembarking from the bus. [The appellant] proceeds to enter the bus and the CCTV on-board the bus shows him taking a seat in the same row as the victim but on the other side of the aisle. Shortly thereafter, two Protective Service Officers arrive and have a discussion with the bus driver. The bus driver re-enters the bus and opens the midsection doors to where the Protective Service Officers have moved. The victim then alights from the bus followed by [the appellant]. They are then interrogated individually by those officers. At one point [the appellant] walks away from the officer interrogating him and attempts to go over to the victim to speak with her. The Protective Service Officer moves towards him and brings him back away from the victim. The bus moves off while the Protective Service Officers continue to talk to both [the appellant] and the victim. Shortly thereafter the police arrive.44.I had in evidence a number of documents produced by the Minister’s representatives pursuant to s. 501G of the Migration Act (G documents). They included the transcript of an interview with the victim conducted by Victoria Police at 2 minutes past 12 a.m. on 25 March 2015; a statement prepared by one of the police officers who had been notified of the incident and attended the scene at Sunshine railway station; a statement from each of the Protective Service Officers who attended the incident following notification by the bus driver; and a witness statement from the bus driver.45.The transcript of the interview with the victim accurately describes the conduct of [the appellant] which I observed when viewing the CCTV footage. While it is not possible to see the express detail described by the victim of the offending sexual contact made by [the appellant], the actions of [the appellant], including the positioning of his hands and arms and the obvious interference with clothing of the victim, throughout the incident are entirely consistent with her description of the events. In the course of the hearing, [the appellant] was shown the CCTV footage but continued to maintain that his conduct was restricted to hugging and kissing the victim. It plainly was not.46.Despite the CCTV footage showing that [the appellant] made the contact with the victim rather than her initiating the contact, he continued to maintain that he did not follow her into the bus shelter. His explanation was that he was looking at the bus timetable and then saw the victim. That evidence was plainly false. As I have described above, his conduct was clearly predatory and targeted the young girl. To begin with, he was walking away from the area where the toilets are situated when he first noticed the victim. When he saw her go into the toilet he turned and went into the male toilet. After she came out of the female toilets and had crossed the road towards the bus shelter, he came out of the male toilet and initially turned to the right apparently searching for her. When he saw her, he turned left and followed her to the bus shelter.