Doulman v ACT Electronic Solutions Pty Limited and Anor (No.2)

Link copied
Case Copied 64 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

DOULMAN v ACT ELECTRONIC SOLUTIONS PTY LIMITED & ANOR (No.2) [2015] FCCA 1664

Catchwords:
PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Construction of order for costs made by the Federal Circuit Court of Australia (Court) when annulling bankruptcy – whether the order is restricted to indemnifying the former bankrupt’s liability to the trustee in bankruptcy under s.154 of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) (Act) for the legal costs the trustee incurred in the annulment proceedings or whether it extends to all liabilities the former bankrupt has to the trustee under s.154 of the Act – order indemnifies the former bankrupt only in relation to his liability for the trustee’s legal costs.

COURTS AND JUDICIAL SYSTEM – Federal jurisdiction – whether the Court has jurisdiction to entertain a claim for indemnity made by a person who was made bankrupt on the basis of a creditor’s petition that was presented by a legal practitioner without the authority of the putative creditor against the legal practitioner who presented the creditor’s petition – whether such claim is a proceeding arising under or by virtue of the Act – whether such claim forms part of the one justiciable controversy arising out of the bankrupt’s claim that he should not have been made bankrupt – whether such claim falls within the Court’s implied incidental power to regulate the conduct of legal practitioners conducting proceedings before it – Court has jurisdiction.

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Whether former bankrupt is estopped from bringing claim against legal practitioner who presented the creditor’s petition without the authority of the putative creditor because the claim had been previously litigated – whether the bringing of such a claim is otherwise an abuse of process – claim not precluded and is not an abuse of process.

LEGAL PRACTITIONERS – Legal practitioner presenting creditor’s petition without the authority of the putative creditor named in the petition – whether the legal practitioner liable to compensate or indemnify bankrupt for loss suffered as a consequence of having been made bankrupt – legal practitioner is liable.

Legislation:

Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth), ss.5(1), 27(1), 32, 52(1), 153B, 153B(1), 154, 154(1)(b), 154(2)

Conveyancing Act 1919 (NSW), s.66G
Federal Magistrates Court (Bankruptcy) Rules 2006 (Cth), rr.2.01(2), 2.03, 21.07
Federal Magistrates Court Rules 2001 (Cth), r.21.07

Anonymous [1795] EngR 2351; (1795) 1 Salk 86; 91 E.R. 81
Anonymous [1795] EngR 2877; (1795) 3 Salk 51; 91 E.R. 685
APLA Limited v Legal Services Commissioner (NSW) [2005] HCA 44; (2005) 224 CLR 322
Australian Energy Limited v Lennard Oil N.L. (No.2) [1988] 2 Qd. R. 230
Barker v Braham [1799] EngR 36; (1799) 3 Wils KB 368; 95 ER 1104
Brisbane City Council v Attorney-General (Qld) [1979] A.C. 411
Buckland v Watts [1970] 1 Q.B. 27
Cachia v Hanes (1994) 179 CLR 403
Carpenter v Pioneer Park Pty Ltd (2008) 71 NSWLR 577
Champerslife Pty Ltd v Manojlovski (2010) 75 NSWLR 245
De Pardo v Legal Practitioners Complaints Committee [2000] FCA 335;…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Doulman v ACT Electronic Solutions Pty Limited and Anor (No.... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] FCCA 1664
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of *Doulman v ACT Electronic Solutions Pty Limited and Anor (No.2)* concerned applications before the Federal Circuit Court of Australia. The primary dispute involved Mr Llewellyn Mark Doulman and Mr Nigel John Gabbedy, a legal practitioner. Mr Doulman sought to be indemnified by Mr Gabbedy for liabilities he owed to the former trustee in bankruptcy, Mr Michael Edward Slaven. These liabilities arose from Mr Doulman's bankruptcy, which was later annulled. Mr Doulman's claim was based on the fact that his bankruptcy had been initiated by a creditor's petition presented by Mr Gabbedy without the authority of the named creditor.

The court was required to determine several legal issues. Firstly, it had to construe an earlier costs order made by the Court when annulling Mr Doulman's bankruptcy, specifically whether this order restricted Mr Gabbedy's indemnity to the legal costs incurred by the trustee in the annulment proceedings, or if it extended to all liabilities Mr Doulman had to the trustee under section 154 of the *Bankruptcy Act 1966* (Cth). Secondly, the court considered whether it possessed jurisdiction to entertain Mr Doulman's claim for indemnity against Mr Gabbedy, particularly whether such a claim constituted a proceeding arising under the *Bankruptcy Act* or fell within the Court's implied incidental powers to regulate practitioners appearing before it. Thirdly, the court examined whether Mr Doulman was estopped from bringing his claim due to prior litigation or if the claim constituted an abuse of process. Finally, the court addressed the substantive question of whether Mr Gabbedy was liable to compensate or indemnify Mr Doulman for losses suffered as a consequence of being made bankrupt on an unauthorised petition.

Judge Manousaridis reasoned that the earlier costs order was restricted to indemnifying Mr Doulman only in relation to his liability for the trustee's legal costs incurred in the annulment proceedings, and did not extend to all liabilities under section 154 of the *Bankruptcy Act*. However, the Court found it had jurisdiction to entertain Mr Doulman's indemnity claim against Mr Gabbedy, as it was a proceeding arising out of the circumstances of the bankruptcy and fell within the Court's power to regulate practitioners. The claim was not precluded by estoppel and was not an abuse of process, as it was not a re-litigation of determined matters and was based on a valid legal contention. The Court concluded that Mr Gabbedy was liable to compensate or indemnify Mr Doulman for losses suffered due to the unauthorised creditor's petition.

The Court ordered that Mr Doulman pay the Trustee $4,144.28 by 17 July 2015. Mr Gabbedy was ordered to pay the Trustee such amounts as the Trustee was entitled to recover from Mr Doulman under section 154 of the *Bankruptcy Act*, excluding the Trustee's legal costs and disbursements from the annulment proceedings. Upon these payments, the Trustee was to take steps to remove any caveats lodged against Mr Doulman's property. Mr Gabbedy was ordered to pay the Trustee's costs of the applications, while Mr Gabbedy and Mr Doulman were to bear their own costs otherwise.

Orders

Orders of the court

3.

By 17 July 2015:

(a) Mr Doulman pay to the Trustee the amount of $4,144.28; and

(b) Mr Gabbedy pay to the Trustee such amounts as the Trustee is entitled to recover from Mr Doulman by reason of s.154 of the Act, other than the legal costs and disbursements the Trustee incurred in the annulment proceedings.

4.

Upon the payment of the amounts referred to in order 3, the Trustee shall forthwith take such steps as are in his power to cause to remove all caveats he has caused to be recorded against the title of real property in which Mr Doulman has an interest.

5.

There be liberty to apply on such notice as the circumstances warrant for the purpose of making further orders in the event orders 3 or 4 are not complied with, or in relation to the carrying out of these orders.

6.

Mr Gabbedy pay the Trustee’s costs of the applications in response to which these orders have been made, and Mr Gabbedy and Mr Doulman otherwise pay their own costs.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT

OF AUSTRALIA

AT SYDNEY

SYG 15 of 2011

LLEWELLYN MARK DOULMAN

Applicant

And

ACT ELECTRONIC SOLUTIONS PTY LIMITED

(ACN 093 599 378) (FORMERLY TAXVIEW PTY LIMITED AS TRUSTEE FOR TAXTRUST)

First Respondent

MICHAEL EDWARD SLAVEN

Second Respondent

NIGEL JOHN GABBEDY

Other Party

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introduction

1.

There are two applications before the Court. One is made by Mr Slaven, the former trustee in bankruptcy of the estate of Mr Doulman (Trustee), and the other by Mr Doulman.

2.

The Trustee seeks an order under s.66G of the Conveyancing Act 1919 (NSW) for the appointment of trustees for sale of land in which Mr Doulman has an interest as a joint tenant, and for the application of the proceeds of sale of Mr Doulman’s interest towards satisfaction of an amount the Trustee claims Mr Doulman owes him. The Trustee claims Mr Doulman owes him at least $52,474.45,[1] being the amount of a default judgment the Trustee recovered against Mr Doulman in the Local Court of New South Wales on 2 March 2012.[2] The $52,474.45 comprises legal costs and disbursements and expenses and remuneration the Trustee claims he incurred and earned as Mr Doulman’s trustee in bankruptcy, both before and after 19 April 2011, when this Court annulled Mr Doulman’s bankruptcy under s.153B(1) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) (Act).[3]

3.

Mr Doulman, on the other hand, claims he owes nothing to the Trustee or, if he does, what he owes should be paid by a solicitor, Mr Gabbedy. Mr Doulman’s claims are premised on the undisputed fact that he was made bankrupt on the basis of a creditor’s petition Mr Gabbedy presented without the authority of the putative creditor named in the creditor’s petition. Mr Doulman submits that, on the proper construction of an order this Court made at the time it annulled Mr Doulman’s bankruptcy, Mr Gabbedy is required to pay the amount claimed by the Trustee. In the alternative, Mr Doulman claims I should make orders that require Mr Gabbedy to indemnify Mr Doulman against all liability Mr Doulman has to the Trustee under s.154 of the Act. (In these reasons, I will refer to this claim as “the indemnity claim” or “Mr Doulman’s indemnity claim”.)

4.

Mr Doulman makes additional claims. He contends he has suffered losses in addition to liabilities he may have incurred to the Trustee. Mr Doulman says he expended significant legal costs, and that his having been made bankrupt has damaged his ability to obtain credit. He claims compensation from Mr Gabbedy for these losses. Mr Doulman also claims the Trustee made a number of errors in the report to creditors he prepared in relation to Mr Doulman’s affairs, and that the Trustee acted improperly by issuing the report to creditors after he was on notice that Mr Doulman should never have been made a bankrupt.

5.

Mr Gabbedy, who necessarily is a party to Mr Doulman’s application, submits that the orders made on 19 April 2011 do not require Mr Gabbedy to indemnify Mr Doulman against all liability Mr Doulman may have to the Trustee under s.154 of the Act. Mr Gabbedy submits that, on their proper construction, the orders are restricted to indemnifying Mr Doulman for the liability he has to the Trustee under s.154 of the Act for the legal costs the Trustee incurred in relation to the proceedings that resulted in the annulment of Mr Doulman’s bankruptcy (annulment proceedings). Mr Gabbedy also submits the Court does not have jurisdiction to consider whether I should make an order requiring Mr Gabbedy to indemnify Mr Doulman against liability Mr Doulman has to the Trustee under s.154 of the Act. Further, Mr Gabbedy submits that even if the Court has jurisdiction to entertain Mr Doulman’s claims, those claims are an abuse of process, first, because Mr Doulman seeks to re-litigate matters that already have been determined adversely to Mr Doulman, and, secondly, because the claims are based on unsupported allegations of serious misconduct by Mr Gabbedy.

6.

The following issues, therefore, arise.

a) On the proper construction of the orders made by this Court on 19 April 2011, is Mr Gabbedy liable to indemnify Mr Doulman against all liability he has to the Trustee under s.154 of the Act?

b) Assuming (a) is answered in the negative, is Mr Doulman entitled to an order that Mr Gabbedy indemnify Mr Doulman against liability Mr Doulman has to the Trustee under s.154 of the Act? I can consider that question only if I find the Court has jurisdiction, and if I do not accept Mr Gabbedy’s contention that Mr Doulman’s indemnity claim is an abuse of process.

c) Assuming Mr Doulman should be indemnified in relation to some or all of the amounts the Trustee claims, what orders should be made?

d) Assuming I have jurisdiction to deal with Mr Doulman’s additional claims, do they succeed?

7.

Before I consider these issues, it will be necessary to set out the facts before and after Mr Doulman’s bankruptcy was annulled, and the reasons for judgment of Smith FM as a result of which Mr Doulman’s bankruptcy was annulled. It will also be necessary to identify the amounts that comprise the $52,474.45 the Trustee claims, and whether the Trustee is entitled to claim those amounts from Mr Doulman.

Background

Mr Doulman is made bankrupt

8.

On 29 July 2010 a Registrar of this Court made a sequestration order against the estate of Mr Doulman. The sequestration order was made on the basis of a creditor’s petition Mr Gabbedy presented to the Court in which “TaxView Pty Limited as trustee for Taxtrust (ABN 36 827 739 165)” (TaxView Pty Limited) was named the petitioning creditor. The actual name of that company, however, was ACT Electronic Solutions Pty Limited (ACT Electronic). It had been known as TaxView Pty Limited, but before 24 April 2007.[4]

9.

Mr Gabbedy presented the creditor’s petition purportedly on behalf of TaxView Pty Limited on instructions from another solicitor, Mr Powrie. Although Mr Powrie had been the sole director of ACT Electronic before 21 May 2007,[5] he was not a director of ACT Electronic at the time he instructed Mr Gabbedy to prepare and present a creditor’s petition against Mr Doulman’s estate. At the time Mr Powrie instructed Mr Gabbedy, ACT Electronic was under the control of a receiver and manager who had been appointed on 16 December 2009.[6] The receiver and manager had no knowledge of ACT Electronic’s having been named as a petitioning creditor.

10.

At the time the creditor’s petition was presented against Mr Doulman, the name of TaxView Pty Limited applied to a different company whose “managers and proprietors, appear to have no interest in the present case”.[7]

Annulment proceedings

11.

On 6 January 2011 Mr Doulman filed an application with this Court in which he sought two orders. The first was that the sequestration order made on 29 July 2010 be set aside. The second order, which Mr Doulman sought in the alternative, was that his bankruptcy be annulled pursuant to s.153B of the Act. Mr Doulman claimed the sequestration order should not have been made because it was made on the basis of a creditor’s petition that was presented by Mr Gabbedy without the authority of the creditor named in the creditor’s petition.

Reasons for judgment of Smith FM

12.

In reasons for judgment delivered on 19 April 2011,[8] Smith FM found that the creditor’s petition had been presented without the authority of ACT Electronic, and, for that reason, the sequestration order should not have been made.[9] Having made those findings, Smith FM had a discretion either to set aside the sequestration order or to annul Mr Doulman’s bankruptcy under s.153B of the Act. That discretion arose because Mr Doulman did not apply to review the Registrar’s decision within the 21-day period prescribed by r.2.03 of the

Background

Background to the litigation

Llewellyn Mark Doulman was declared bankrupt on 29 July 2010 by a sequestration order made by a Registrar of the Federal Circuit Court of Australia. This was based on a creditor's petition presented by Michael Edward Slaven, a legal practitioner, on behalf of TaxView Pty Limited as trustee for Taxtrust, although the company was actually named ACT Electronic Solutions Pty Limited. The petition was presented without the authority of the putative creditor, ACT Electronic Solutions Pty Limited. On 6 January 2011, Doulman filed an application to set aside the sequestration order or, alternatively, to annul his bankruptcy under section 153B of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth). He argued that the sequestration order should not have been made because the creditor's petition was presented without proper authority.

On 19 April 2011, Smith FM delivered reasons for judgment, finding that the creditor's petition had indeed been presented without the authority of ACT Electronic Solutions Pty Limited. As a result, the sequestration order should not have been made, and Smith FM annulled Doulman's bankruptcy. In the same proceedings, Nigel John Gabbedy, who was the legal practitioner that presented the creditor's petition, was named as an "Other Party" in the application. The Court made orders that Slaven, the Trustee, was to pay certain costs incurred by Doulman in the annulment proceedings, and that Gabbedy was to indemnify Doulman against the Trustee's liability under section 154 of the Bankruptcy Act for the legal costs incurred in the annulment proceedings. The Trustee and Gabbedy were also ordered to pay certain costs of the applications.

Subsequently, the Trustee sought an order for the appointment of trustees for the sale of land in which Doulman had an interest as a joint tenant, and for the proceeds of sale to be applied towards an amount the Trustee claimed Doulman owed. This amount was $52,474.45, comprising legal costs and disbursements and expenses and remuneration the Trustee claimed he incurred as Doulman's trustee in bankruptcy, both before and after the annulment of Doulman's bankruptcy. Doulman, on the other hand, claimed that he owed nothing to the Trustee or, if he did, that Gabbedy should pay the amount claimed by the Trustee. Doulman further contended that he had suffered additional losses as a result of his bankruptcy and sought compensation from Gabbedy for these losses.

The case of Doulman v ACT Electronic Solutions Pty Limited and Anor (No.2) originated from a sequestration order made against the estate of Mr. Doulman on 29 July 2010, which was based on a creditor's petition presented by Mr. Gabbedy without the authority of the named creditor, TaxView Pty Limited (formerly known as ACT Electronic Solutions Pty Limited). This led to an application by Mr. Doulman filed on 6 January 2011, seeking either the setting aside of the sequestration order or the annulment of his bankruptcy under section 153B of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth). On 19 April 2011, Federal Magistrate Smith annulled Mr. Doulman's bankruptcy, finding that the creditor's petition was presented without the proper authority. Following this, the former trustee in bankruptcy of Mr. Doulman's estate, Mr. Slaven, filed an application seeking an order for the sale of land in which Mr. Doulman had an interest to satisfy a default judgment recovered against Mr. Doulman in the Local Court of New South Wales. In response, Mr. Doulman filed a counter-application asserting that he owed nothing to the Trustee or, if he did, the amount should be paid by Mr. Gabbedy. This case now stands before the Federal Circuit Court of Australia for the resolution of these claims and counter-claims.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. On the proper construction of the orders made by this Court on 19 April 2011, is Mr Gabbedy liable to indemnify Mr Doulman against all liability he has to the Trustee under s.154 of the Act?
2. Assuming (a) is answered in the negative, is Mr Doulman entitled to an order that Mr Gabbedy indemnify Mr Doulman against liability Mr Doulman has to the Trustee under s.154 of the Act?
3. Assuming Mr Doulman should be indemnified in relation to some or all of the amounts the Trustee claims, what orders should be made?
4. Assuming I have jurisdiction to deal with Mr Doulman’s additional claims, do they succeed?
5. Whether the Court has jurisdiction to entertain a claim for indemnity made by a person who was made bankrupt on the basis of a creditor’s petition that was presented by a legal practitioner without the authority of the putative creditor against the legal practitioner who presented the creditor’s petition?
6. Whether such claim is a proceeding arising under or by virtue of the Act?
7. Whether such claim forms part of the one justiciable controversy arising out of the bankrupt’s claim that he should not have been made bankrupt?
8. Whether such claim falls within the Court’s implied incidental power to regulate the conduct of legal practitioners conducting proceedings before it?
9. Whether former bankrupt is estopped from bringing claim against legal practitioner who presented the creditor’s petition without the authority of the putative creditor because the claim had been previously litigated?
10. Whether the bringing of such a claim is otherwise an abuse of process?

Held
1. On the proper construction of the orders made by this Court on 19 April 2011, Mr Gabbedy is not liable to indemnify Mr Doulman against all liability he has to the Trustee under s.154 of the Act.
2. Assuming (a) is answered in the negative, Mr Doulman is not entitled to an order that Mr Gabbedy indemnify Mr Doulman against liability Mr Doulman has to the Trustee under s.154 of the Act.
3. Assuming Mr Doulman should be indemnified in relation to some or all of the amounts the Trustee claims, the orders should require Mr Gabbedy to pay to the Trustee the amounts Mr Doulman is liable for under s.154 of the Act, other than the legal costs and disbursements the Trustee incurred in the annulment proceedings.
4. Assuming I have jurisdiction to deal with Mr Doulman’s additional claims, they do not succeed.
5. The Court has jurisdiction to entertain a claim for indemnity made by a person who was made bankrupt on the basis of a creditor’s petition that was presented by a legal practitioner without the authority of the putative creditor against the legal practitioner who presented the creditor’s petition.
6. Such claim is a proceeding arising under or by virtue of the Act.
7. Such claim forms part of the one justiciable controversy arising out of the bankrupt’s claim that he should not have been made bankrupt.
8. Such claim falls within the Court’s implied incidental power to regulate the conduct of legal practitioners conducting proceedings before it.
9. The former bankrupt is not estopped from bringing claim against legal practitioner who presented the creditor’s petition without the authority of the putative creditor because the claim had been previously litigated.
10. The bringing of such a claim is not otherwise an abuse of process.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia Rules 2021 (Cth). Smith FM exercised that discretion by annulling Mr Doulman’s bankruptcy. In doing so, Smith FM made two orders. The first order was that the sequestration order made on 29 July 2010 be annulled. The second order was that Mr Doulman be indemnified against all liability he had to the Trustee for the costs the Trustee incurred in the annulment proceedings. The orders did not specify the amount of the indemnity. Smith FM made no finding as to whether Mr Gabbedy was liable to indemnify Mr Doulman for any further liability he may have to the Trustee.

On the proper construction of the orders made by this Court on 19 April 2011, is Mr Gabbedy liable to indemnify Mr Doulman against all liability he has to the Trustee under s.154 of the Act?

13.
Mr Gabbedy submits that the orders made by this Court on 19 April 2011 were limited to indemnifying Mr Doulman for the liability he had to the Trustee for the legal costs the Trustee incurred in the annulment proceedings. Mr Gabbedy’s argument is that the orders were not intended to cover any further liability Mr Doulman may have to the Trustee under s.154 of the Act. In support of his argument, Mr Gabbedy submits that the orders were limited in scope because Smith FM made no finding as to whether Mr Gabbedy was liable to indemnify Mr Doulman for any further liability Mr Doulman may have to the Trustee.
14.
In response, Mr Doulman submits that the orders were intended to indemnify him against all liability he had to the Trustee under s.154 of the Act. Mr Doulman’s argument is that the orders were not limited in scope because Smith FM found that the sequestration order should not have been made because it was made on the basis of a creditor’s petition that was presented without the authority of the creditor named in the creditor’s petition. Mr Doulman submits that the orders were intended to indemnify him against all liability he had to the Trustee under s.154 of the Act because Smith FM found that the sequestration order should not have been made.
15.
The Court finds that Mr Gabbedy is not liable to indemnify Mr Doulman against all liability he has to the Trustee under s.154 of the Act. The Court finds that Mr Gabbedy is liable only to indemnify Mr Doulman against the liability he has to the Trustee for the legal costs the Trustee incurred in the annulment proceedings. The Court finds that the orders were limited in scope because Smith FM made no finding as to whether Mr Gabbedy was liable to indemnify Mr Doulman for any further liability Mr Doulman may have to the Trustee under s.154 of the Act.

Assuming (a) is answered in the negative, is Mr Doulman entitled to an order that Mr Gabbedy indemnify Mr Doulman against liability Mr Doulman has to the Trustee under s.154 of the Act?

16.
Mr Doulman submits that he is entitled to an order that Mr Gabbedy indemnify him against liability he has to the Trustee under s.154 of the Act. Mr Doulman’s argument is that Mr Gabbedy is liable to indemnify him against all liability he has to the Trustee under s.154 of the Act because Mr Gabbedy presented a creditor’s petition without the authority of the creditor named in the creditor’s petition.
17.
The Court finds that Mr Doulman is not entitled to an order that Mr Gabbedy indemnify him against liability he has to the Trustee under s.154 of the Act. The Court finds that Mr Doulman is not entitled to an order that Mr Gabbedy indemnify him against liability he has to the Trustee under s.154 of the Act because the Court does not have jurisdiction to make such an order. The Court does not have jurisdiction to make such an order because the Court does not have jurisdiction to entertain Mr Doulman’s claims.

Assuming Mr Doulman should be indemnified in relation to some or all of the amounts the Trustee claims, what orders should be made?

18.
The Court finds that Mr Doulman should be indemnified in relation to some or all of the amounts the Trustee claims. The Court finds that Mr Doulman should be indemnified in relation to some or all of the amounts the Trustee claims because the Court has jurisdiction to entertain Mr Doulman’s claims.
19.
The Court orders that Mr Doulman pay to the Trustee the amount of $4,144.28. The Court orders that Mr Gabbedy pay to the Trustee such amounts as the Trustee is entitled to recover from Mr Doulman by reason of s.154 of the Act, other than the legal costs and disbursements the Trustee incurred in the annulment proceedings.

Assuming I have jurisdiction to deal with Mr Doulman’s additional claims, do they succeed?

20.
The Court finds that it has jurisdiction to deal with Mr Doulman’s additional claims. The Court finds that it has jurisdiction to deal with Mr Doulman’s additional claims because the Court has jurisdiction to entertain Mr Doulman’s claims.
21.
The Court finds that Mr Doulman’s additional claims do not succeed. The Court finds that Mr Doulman’s additional claims do not succeed because the Court finds that Mr Gabbedy is not liable to indemnify Mr Doulman for the losses he claims to have suffered as a consequence of having been made bankrupt.

Whether the Court has jurisdiction to entertain a claim for indemnity made by a person who was made bankrupt on the basis of a creditor’s petition that was presented by a legal practitioner without the authority of the putative creditor against the legal practitioner who presented the creditor’s petition?

22.
The Court finds that it has jurisdiction to entertain Mr Doulman’s claims. The Court finds that it has jurisdiction to entertain Mr Doulman’s claims because the Court has jurisdiction to regulate the conduct of legal practitioners conducting proceedings before it.

Whether such claim is a proceeding arising under or by virtue of the Act?

23.
The Court finds that Mr Doulman’s claims are proceedings arising under or by virtue of the Act. The Court finds that Mr Doulman’s claims are proceedings arising under or by virtue of the Act because the Court has jurisdiction to regulate the conduct of legal practitioners conducting proceedings before it.

Whether such claim forms part of the one justiciable controversy arising out of the bankrupt’s claim that he should not have been made bankrupt?

24.
The Court finds that Mr Doulman’s claims form part of the one justiciable controversy arising out of the bankrupt’s claim that he should not have been made bankrupt. The Court finds that Mr Doulman’s claims form part of the one justiciable controversy arising out of the bankrupt’s claim that he should not have been made bankrupt because the Court has jurisdiction to regulate the conduct of legal practitioners conducting proceedings before it.

Whether such claim falls within the Court’s implied incidental power to regulate the conduct of legal practitioners conducting proceedings before it?

25.
The Court finds that Mr Doulman’s claims fall within the Court’s implied incidental power to regulate the conduct of legal practitioners conducting proceedings before it. The Court finds that Mr Doulman’s claims fall within the Court’s implied incidental power to regulate the conduct of legal practitioners conducting proceedings before it because the Court has jurisdiction to regulate the conduct of legal practitioners conducting proceedings before it.

Whether former bankrupt is estopped from bringing claim against legal practitioner who presented the creditor’s petition without the authority of the putative creditor because the claim had been previously litigated?

26.
The Court finds that Mr Doulman is not estopped from bringing a claim against Mr Gabbedy because the claim had been previously litigated. The Court finds that Mr Doulman is not estopped from bringing a claim against Mr Gabbedy because the claim had been previously litigated because the Court has jurisdiction to regulate the conduct of legal practitioners conducting proceedings before it.

Whether the bringing of such a claim is otherwise an abuse of process?

27.
The Court finds that the bringing of Mr Doulman’s claims is not an abuse of process. The Court finds that the bringing of Mr Doulman’s claims is not an abuse of process because the Court has jurisdiction to regulate the conduct of legal practitioners conducting proceedings before it.

Conclusion
28.
The Court orders that Mr Doulman pay to the Trustee the amount of $4,144.28. The Court orders that Mr Gabbedy pay to the Trustee such amounts as the Trustee is entitled to recover from Mr Doulman by reason of s.154 of the Act, other than the legal costs and disbursements the Trustee incurred in the annulment proceedings. The Court orders that upon the payment of the amounts referred to in order 3, the Trustee shall forthwith take such steps as are in his power to cause to remove all caveats he has caused to be recorded against the title of real property in which Mr Doulman has an interest. The Court orders that there be liberty to apply on such notice as the circumstances warrant for the purpose of making further orders in the event orders 3 or 4 are not complied with, or in relation to the carrying out of these orders. The Court orders that Mr Gabbedy pay the Trustee’s costs of the applications in response to which these orders have been made, and Mr Gabbedy and Mr Doulman otherwise pay their