Director of Public Prosecutions v Lombardo

Link copied
Case Copied 41 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

COURT OF APPEAL

S EAPCR 2022 0021
DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS Appellant
v
JOSHUA LOMBARDO Respondent

---

JUDGES: McLEISH, NIALL and KENNEDY JJA
WHERE HELD: Melbourne
DATE OF HEARING: 9 September 2022 
DATE OF JUDGMENT: 21 September 2022
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: [2022] VSCA 204
JUDGMENT APPEALED FROM: [2022] VCC 93 (Judge Cahill)

---

CRIMINAL LAW – Appeal – Sentence – Crown appeal – Category 2 offence subject to s 5(2H) of Sentencing Act 1991 – Dangerous driving causing death – Momentary lapse in judgement – Respondent turned onto highway while side window fogged and light of oncoming vehicle visible – Respondent youthful and remorseful with no prior convictions and excellent prospects of rehabilitation – Respondent suffering symptoms of anxiety and post-traumatic stress – Respondent reminded of offending by memorial at collision site – Judge found exceptions to s 5(2H) existed, allowing non-custodial sentence – Community correction order with unpaid community work condition – Whether open to find respondent had ‘impaired mental functioning’ within s 5(2H)(c)(ii) – Symptoms falling short of diagnosed illness at time of sentence inadequate, even if likely to deteriorate in custody – Whether open to find ‘substantial and compelling circumstances that are exceptional and rare’ within s 5(2H)(e) – Circumstances must be both powerful and wholly outside ‘run of the mill’ factors typical of relevant offending – Evaluative assessment for sentencing judge – Respondent’s circumstances, including memorial at collision site, not ‘exceptional and rare’ for driving offending – Findings not open.

CRIMINAL LAW – Appeal – Sentence – Crown appeal – Residual discretion – Whether Court should decline to interfere with sentence despite sentencing error – Reasons articulate principles for governance and guidance in future cases – Respondent completed seven months of community correction order, and most of prescribed work hours – Appeal filed on last day of appeal period – Rehabilitative progress would be undone by imposing term of imprisonment – Appeal dismissed.  

WORDS AND PHRASES – ‘impaired mental functioning’ – ‘substantial and compelling’ – ‘exceptional and rare’.

Sentencing Act 1991 ss 5(2H), 5(2HC), 5(2I), 10A; Mental Health Act 2014 s 4(1).

Georgiou v The Queen [2022] VSCA 172, Fariah v The Queen [2021] VSCA 213, Farmer v The Queen [2020] VSCA 140, Director of Public Prosecutions v Hudgson [2016] VSCA 254, Director of Public Prosecutions v Karazisis (2010) 31 VR 634, applied; Buckley v The Queen [2022] VSCA 138, Director of Public Prosecutions v Bowen (2021) 65 VR 385, explained.

---

Counsel

Appellant: Mr CB Boyce KC, with Ms B Goding
Respondent: Mr TR Marsh

Solicitors

Appellant: Ms A Hogan, Solicitor for Public Prosecutions
Respondent: Farrelly Legal

McLEISH JA

NIALL JA

KENNEDY JA:

  1. This appeal raises difficult questions about sentencing for the offence of dangerous driving causing death. In particular, it concerns the meaning and application of provisions of the Sentencing Act 1991 (‘the Act’) governing sentencing for ‘category 2 offences’, of which dangerous driving causing death is one.[1] Section 5(2H) of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v Lombardo and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] VSCA 204
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Director of Public Prosecutions v Lombardo, the appellant sought to appeal the sentence imposed on the respondent who was found guilty of a dangerous driving offence that resulted in the death of a pedestrian. The Court of Appeal was tasked with reviewing whether the trial judge was correct in his application of the law when imposing a non-custodial sentence. The respondent, who had no prior convictions and was youthful with good prospects for rehabilitation, was sentenced to a community correction order with unpaid community work as a condition. The Crown contested the sentence, arguing that it was inappropriate given the severity of the offence.

The legal issues central to this appeal revolved around the interpretation and application of section 5(2H) of the Sentencing Act 1991. Specifically, the court needed to determine whether the trial judge was correct in finding that the respondent had impaired mental functioning and whether the circumstances of the case were exceptional and rare enough to warrant a non-custodial sentence. The Crown argued that the respondent's symptoms of anxiety and post-traumatic stress, while serious, did not amount to impaired mental functioning as required by the statute, and that the respondent's circumstances were not sufficiently exceptional to warrant deviation from the mandatory minimum custodial sentence.

The Court of Appeal found that the trial judge's findings were not open on the evidence presented. The court held that the respondent's symptoms did not meet the threshold of a diagnosed mental illness at the time of sentencing, and therefore did not constitute impaired mental functioning. Furthermore, the court determined that the respondent's personal circumstances, including the presence of a memorial at the collision site, did not rise to the level of exceptional and rare circumstances that would warrant a non-custodial sentence. The court emphasised that such circumstances must be both powerful and wholly outside the ordinary factors typically considered in cases of this nature.

In light of the above findings, the Court of Appeal dismissed the Crown's appeal. The court noted that the respondent had already completed a significant portion of the community correction order, and that further interference with the sentence would undermine the respondent's rehabilitative progress. The appeal was dismissed on the grounds that the trial judge's findings were not open, and that imposing a custodial sentence at this stage would be disproportionate and counterproductive.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established