Diab Pty Ltd v YUM! Restaurants Australia Pty Ltd [2016] FCA 43
File number(s):
NSD 832 of 2014
Judge(s):
BENNETT J
Date of judgment:
5 February 2016
Catchwords:
CONTRACTS – representative action – respondent franchisor implemented a strategy setting maximum prices and product ranges for franchisees – whether, on the proper construction of the franchise agreement, the franchisor was in breach by reducing the prices on its ranges of pizzas – whether implementation of strategy would breach implied terms, including an implied term of good faith, of the franchise agreement – categories of damages: income/trading loss, capital loss
CONSUMER LAW – whether implementation of the strategy would involve unconscionable conduct by the respondent under s 21 of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) sch 2
NEGLIGENCE – whether the franchisor owes a duty of care to each franchisee in relation to any conduct or decision it makes and in the exercise of its powers under the franchisee agreement
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Diab Pty Ltd v YUM! Restaurants Australia Pty Ltd and more:
Diab Pty Ltd (DPL) brought a representative action against YUM! Restaurants Australia Pty Ltd (Yum) concerning the implementation of a strategy setting maximum prices and product ranges for franchisees. DPL argued that the implementation of the strategy was in breach of the franchise agreement, which included an implied term of good faith, and involved unconscionable conduct under the Competition and Consumer Act 2010. DPL also claimed that Yum owed a duty of care to each franchisee in relation to its conduct and decisions. The court had to decide whether the franchisor breached the franchise agreement by reducing the prices on its ranges of pizzas, whether the implementation of the strategy would breach implied terms, and whether it would involve unconscionable conduct. The court had to consider the categories of damages available, including income/trading loss and capital loss.
The court considered the arguments from both parties and examined the facts presented, including the chronology of pricing changes and the characterisation of the strategy. The court assessed the evidence provided by both parties, including the damages calculation and the assessment of income and capital loss. The court found that DPL's evidence was credible and that the implementation of the strategy was in breach of the franchise agreement, including the implied term of good faith. The court also found that the implementation of the strategy involved unconscionable conduct under the Competition and Consumer Act. The court awarded damages to DPL for income loss and capital loss, taking into account the evidence provided by both parties.
The court made orders for the proposed orders, redactions, and the standing over of the matter to be sent to chambers by specified dates. The orders were to be entered in accordance with Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. Proposed orders, by consent or as proposed by each party, be sent to chambers by 19 February 2016.
2. Any proposed redactions to the reasons, said to be confidential, be sent to chambers by 19 February 2016.
3. The matter be stood over to 23 February 2016 at 9.30am.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
Mr Gower has provided accounting support across a range of areas, including:·Analysis of the fairness of the acquisition considerations to be paid.·Valuation of businesses.·Due diligence investigations.·General financial analysis and advice in respect of the preparation of forecasts, feasibility studies and evaluation of the benefits of transactions.·Litigation engagements, involving providing evidence in respect of accounting matters generally and quantification of economic loss.5. FACTUAL BACKGROUND AND SUBMISSIONS ON THE FACTS DPL has analysed Yum’s closing submissions by subsequently providing a comprehensive table of responses to various of those submissions, and Yum has responded to these comments. Nonetheless, this section will summarise facts asserted and, where appropriate, the parties’ submissions as to the facts as presented prior to the table being provided by DPL. I will then turn to my consideration of the facts asserted and submissions advanced by the parties, taking the table, with Yum’s responses, into account as relevant.5.1 Chronology of pricing DPL provided a useful table that compared headline prices for Pizza Hut and Domino’s before the VS and at 1 July 2014 when the VS was implemented. Relevantly to the calculation of loss and damage, the analysis is of the prices of Pizza Hut pizzas before the VS, the prices due to the implementation of the VS and the prices of pizzas during the period of loss. Accordingly, the prices of the ranges of Pizza Hut pizzas, with a delivery fee of $8.00, before the VS were: As at 1 July 2014, the date of the implementation of the VS, the delivery price was increased to $8.95, the Legends range was changed to Favourites (with the number of pizzas increasing from 8 to 11 in the range) and the Mia and Signature ranges were removed. The prices of the ranges of Pizza Hut pizzas as at 1 July 2014 were: Yum says that major price adjustments were made to the ranges of pizzas following the implementation of the VS. Yum relies on Ms Syed’s affidavit dated 13 July 2015, which is relevantly summarised as follows:·On 14 August 2014, Yum increased the delivered price for the Classics range from $4.95 to $8.95, increased the delivered price for the Favourites range from $8.50 to $11.95 and the delivery fee was decreased from $8.95 to $4.95.·On 30 September 2014, Yum increased the delivered price for the Classics range from $8.95 to $9.95.·On 2 December 2014, Yum increased the pick up price for the Favourites range from $8.50 to $10.95. A new tier of pizza range was also introduced, which was called the Loaded Classics range. The price for this range was $7.95 and the delivered price was $10.95.·On 22 December 2014, Yum increased the fixed delivery fee from $4.95 to $7.95.·On 5 May 2015, Yum increased the pick up price for the Classics range from $4.95 to $6.95 (except on its website), increased the pick up price for the Loaded Classics range from $7.95 to $9.95 and increased the pick up price the Favourites range from $10.95 to $11.95.5.2 Characterisation of the VS
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
DPL submits that, pursuant to s 33Z(e) of the FCA Act, the Court can have regard to the approach taken to assess DPL’s damages and give directions in relation to the manner in which the amounts other group members can be calculated. DPL concedes that a complication may arise for some group members in relation to the calculation of capital loss where an outlet has closed. That is, if the closure of the outlet was caused by the VS, then the capital loss will represent the entirety of the capital value of the outlet as at 10 June 2014.11.2.1Mr Potter’s evidence Mr Potter provided a damages calculation of DPL’s loss and Mr Gower has offered no alternative calculation. DPL submits that Yum cannot resist an award of damages based on Mr Potter’s evidence by asserting, for example, that this evidence is insufficient in some respect. DPL contends that Mr Potter’s determination of DPL’s hypothetical EBITDA by taking an average of the two prior years EBITDA and assuming 0% growth is conservative. The factors contributing to this determination are:·DPL’s sales were growing in the first half of 2014; ·DPL maintained its 2-to-1 advantage over Domino’s in the Greater Macarthur Region;·DPL’s sales growth, as at 10 June 2014, showed a positive “run rate” of 3.5%;·DPL’s stores had been recently upgraded; and·There was no reason to expect that, absent the VS, DPL would have experience reduced earnings after 1 July 2014. DPL notes Mr Gower’s criticism that there were changes in a number of cost items in DPL’s accounts for the period after 1 July 2014. DPL submits that Mr Diab was not cross-examined on any of these items and these criticisms should be disregarded. In any event, DPL contends that the changes were all brought about by the VS and that Mr Potter discounted the profitability back to 10 June 2014 using DPL’s after-tax discount rate of 12.6%, which has the consequence of making allowances for normal business risks that DPL would have faced post 1 July 2014. Mr Gower said that he did not accept that all of the risks to which he had pointed were taken into account in the discounting process. DPL contends that Mr Gower did not seek to identify which, if any risks were not taken into account beyond this generalised statement. Accordingly, DPL submits, the Court is entitled to accept Mr Potter’s evidence that the risks and contingencies have been fully taken into account in the discounting process.11.2.2Income loss The explanation of Mr Potter’s calculation for income loss is in section 9 of Mr Potter’s second report. Mr Potter concluded that DPL’s income loss as at 10 June 2014 is $438,164.11.2.3Capital loss Mr Diab gave evidence that the usual way in which outlet sales prices are determined is by using the outlet’s EBITDA and applying an EBITDA multiple. DPL says that Yum contests this evidence as their approach is that the EBITDA multiple method is one factor that is taken into account in determining a selling price and other qualitative factors are also relevant, including outlet location, competitor activity, age and condition of the outlet and the remaining length of the IFA. DPL contends that that the EBITDA multiple can be adjusted to take into account these factors.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ms Broad acknowledged that the prior year loss of $270 per week per store presented to the Franchisees in the Franchisee Update did not reflect her own estimate for period 3 of 2013 which she calculated as a loss of $257 per week per store. DPL suggests that the most likely explanation for the $270 per week per store figure is that it was based upon an average of the ACT franchisee data from period 5 to period 11 in 2013, which showed an average weekly loss per store of $273. DPL contends that this figure included a deduction for head office costs which, if removed, would have resulted in a profit of $239 per week per store for the ACT franchisee in 2013. That is, if this profit figure were used, there would have been a loss of approximately $980 per week per store, comparing 2013 and weeks 5 – 9 of the ACT Test.5.3.3.3DPL’s conclusion on the presentation of the ACT Test during the Franchisee Update presentation DPL concludes that Yum actively engaged in a “public relations exercise” by presenting manipulated data to the Franchisees, which presented a false picture of the profitability of the ACT Test. Further, DPL contends that even if Yum did not have the full 12 weeks of data at the date of the presentations to the Franchisees on 14 and 15 May 2014, it certainly did have data at the time of the interlocutory hearing before Jagot J and it failed to make any qualification or explanation to the Franchisees or to the Court. It follows, DPL says, that Yum was in breach of its implied obligations to act reasonably and cooperatively in relation to the exercise of its power to set maximum prices under clause C1 of the IFA, because the true result of the ACT Test was that the VS prices caused the ACT franchisee to make a loss and thus Yum had no justification for reducing the price points for the Franchisees by application of the VS.5.3.4ACT sales results DPL contends that Yum presented misleading sales results in the Franchisee Update, as it compared an SSSG of -5%, from the 12 weeks before the ACT Test to a range of increases in sales during the ACT Test, ranging from 14% to 48%. DPL argues that the presentation of SSSG in the Franchisee Update was misleading for the following reasons, as put to Ms Broad:·The prior 12 week period was never a valid comparison, as it included Christmas and the January holidays, which as times when Canberra sales are traditionally low due to Parliament not sitting, school holidays and the public service shuts down. The trend is clear when one assesses the decline in PSA sales in the past two years over this period.·The 48% increase in Week 6 reflected an abnormal dip in the prior year, which was associated with the transition period prior to the ACT franchisee taking over control of all the ACT outlets. ·Weeks 7 and 8 in 2014 were inflated due to the misalignment of Easter dates between the two years. That is, in 2014 Parliament was sitting in both of those weeks, whereas in the prior year Parliament sat for only one of those weeks as the other was during Easter.