Descon Group Australia Pty Ltd v 35 Merivale Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Descon Group Australia Pty Ltd v 35 Merivale Pty Ltd [2023] QSC 276

PARTIES:

DESCON GROUP AUSTRALIA PTY LTD
ACN 625 771 075

(applicant)

v
35 MERIVALE PTY LTD
ACN 167 068 804

(respondent)

FILE NO:

BS No 12325 of 2023

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

1 December 2023

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

26 October 2023

JUDGE:

Davis J

ORDERS:

1.   The injunctions made on 3 October 2023 and extended on each of 5 October, 23 October and 26 October 2023 are dissolved.

2.   The matter proceed as if started by claim.

3.   The application is otherwise dismissed.

4.   The parties exchange written submissions on costs by 4.00 pm on 15 December 2023.

5.   In the absence of any application being filed by 4.00 pm on 22 December 2023 seeking leave to make oral submissions on costs, the question of costs will be decided without further oral hearing.

CATCHWORDS:

CONTRACTS – BUILDING, ENGINEERING AND RELATED CONTRACTS – THE CONTRACT – CONSTRUCTION OF PARTICULAR CONTRACTS AND IMPLIED CONDITIONS – SECURITY AND RETENTION FUNDS – where the applicant is a builder – where the respondent is developing an apartment block – where the applicant was contracted to build the apartments – where pursuant to the contracts the applicant provided security by way of insurance bonds – where the applicant claims money owing – where the respondent claims money owing – where the respondent sought to call on the bonds – where the applicant obtained an injunction enjoining the respondent from calling on the bonds – whether the right to call on the bonds has arisen – whether those conditions are negative contractual stipulations qualifying the right of the respondent to call on the bonds – whether the bonds are a risk allocation mechanism

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – DETENTION, INSPECTION AND PRESERVATION – FREEZING ORDERS – where the applicant is a builder – where the respondent is developing an apartment block – where the applicant was contracted to build the apartments – where pursuant to the contracts the applicant provided security by way of insurance bonds – where the applicant claims money owing – where the respondent claims money owing – where the respondent sought to call on the bonds – where the applicant obtained an injunction enjoining the respondent from calling on the bonds – where the respondent sought to have the injunctions dissolved – where the applicant sought a freezing order to preserve the bonds – whether the respondent can satisfy any claim by the applicant – whether the interests of justice require a freezing order – whether a freezing order ought to be granted

EQUITY – EQUITABLE REMEDIES – INJUNCTIONS – INTERLOCUTORY INJUNCTIONS – RELEVANT CONSIDERATIONS – GENERALLY – where the applicant is a builder – where the respondent is developing an apartment block – where the applicant was contracted to build the apartments – where pursuant to the contracts…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Descon Group Australia Pty Ltd v 35 Merivale Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] QSC 276
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Descon Group Australia Pty Ltd (Descon) and 35 Merivale Pty Ltd (Merivale) were involved in a contractual dispute regarding the construction of an apartment project in South Brisbane. Descon, a builder, had entered into a contract with Merivale, a property developer, to construct the residential apartments known as "The Residences". As part of the contract, Descon provided security by way of insurance bonds. The dispute arose when Descon sought payment for work completed, while Merivale sought to call upon the insurance bonds provided by Descon. Descon obtained an interlocutory injunction to prevent Merivale from calling on the bonds, and subsequently sought a freezing order to preserve the bonds. Merivale, on the other hand, sought to dissolve the injunction and argued that Descon could simply file a claim if it believed it was entitled to payment.

The court had to decide several legal issues, including whether the right to call on the bonds had arisen, whether the conditions in the contract were negative stipulations that qualified the right of Merivale to call on the bonds, and whether the bonds were a risk allocation mechanism. The court also had to consider whether a freezing order should be granted to preserve the bonds and whether the interests of justice required such an order. Additionally, the court had to determine whether the injunction should be continued, whether Descon could demonstrate a prima facie case that Merivale was not entitled to call on the bonds, and whether the balance of convenience favoured continuing the injunction.

The court found that there was no evidence of a danger that would warrant a freezing order, and therefore refused the application for a freezing order. The court also concluded that the injunction should be dissolved as there was no point in dismissing the application only to see Descon file a fresh claim. Instead, the court ordered that the application proceed as if it were a claim, directing Descon to file a statement of claim and the parties to exchange written submissions on costs. The court further ordered that, in the absence of any application for leave to make oral submissions on costs, the question of costs would be decided without further oral hearing.

The final orders of the court were: (1) the injunctions made on 3 October 2023 and extended on each of 5 October, 23 October and 26 October 2023 are dissolved; (2) the matter proceed as if started by claim; (3) the application is otherwise dismissed; (4) the parties exchange written submissions on costs by 4.00 pm on 15 December 2023; and (5) in the absence of any application being filed by 4.00 pm on 22 December 2023 seeking leave to make oral submissions on costs, the question of costs will be decided without further oral hearing.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The injunctions made on 3 October 2023 and extended on each of 5 October, 23 October and 26 October 2023 are dissolved.

2. The matter proceed as if started by claim.

3. The application is otherwise dismissed.

4. The parties exchange written submissions on costs by 4.00 pm on 15 December 2023.

5. In the absence of any application being filed by 4.00 pm on 22 December 2023 seeking leave to make oral submissions on costs, the question of costs will be decided without further oral hearing.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant, Descon Group Australia Pty Ltd (Descon), filed an application (which was later amended) seeking various relief, but ultimately pressed for:1.an interlocutory injunction restraining the respondent, 35 Merivale Pty Ltd (Merivale), from calling upon insurance bonds held pursuant to contracts between them; alternatively2.a freezing order to similar effect.Background Descon is a builder. Merivale is a property developer. Merivale is developing a residential apartment project called “The Residences” (the Apartments) in Merivale Street, South Brisbane. By a contact dated 22 November 2021, Descon agreed to build the Apartments and Merivale agreed to pay Descon for so doing (the building contract). The building contract is in a standard form. It identifies a price for Descon to build the Apartments[1] which is payable by progress claim instalments.[2][1]Clause 2.1.[2]Clause 37.1 and item 33. Clause 37 concerns progress claims. It provides, relevantly:“37 Payment37.1Progress claimsThe Contractor shall claim payment progressively in accordance with Item 33, while WUC is being carried out prior to practical completion, at practical completion and at the final payment claim.An early progress claim shall be deemed to have been made on the date for making that claim.The date prescribed in this subclause 37.1 as the time for a progress claim is the ‘reference date’ for the purposes of the Payments Act.Each progress claim shall be given in writing by way of email to the email address in Item 14A, addressed to the attention of the Superintendent and shall include:(a)details of the value of WUC done and may include details of other moneys then due to the Contractor pursuant to provisions of the Contract; and(b)a declaration in the form contained in Annexure Part I executed by a person authorised to do so on behalf of the Contractor; and(c)a detailed construction program which is consistent with the form of Contractor’s program requirements attached at Annexure Part L and sets out the progress of WUC done.The Superintendent in receiving a progress claim does so as agent of the Principal for the purposes of the Payments Act. 37.2CertificatesThe Superintendent shall, within 10 business days after receiving such a progress claim, issue to the Principal and the Contractor a progress certificate which:(a)identifies the progress claim to which it relates;(b)states the amount of the payment, if any, that the Principal proposes to make (certified amount);(c)if the certified amount is less than the claimed amount, state why the certified amount is less, and if it less because the Principal is withholding payment for any reason, the Principal’s reason for withholding payment; and(d)states the amount of retention moneys and moneys due from the Contractor to the Principal pursuant to the Contract.The parties agree that any progress certificate issued by the Superintendent under this clause 37.2 is a payment schedule for the purposes of the Payments Act.The Superintendent in issuing a payment schedule does so as agent of the Principal for the purposes of the Payments Act.If the Contractor does not make a progress claim in accordance with Item 33, the Superintendent may issue the progress certificate with details of the calculations and shall issue the certificate dealing with the matters in paragraph (c).Failure by the Superintendent to set out in a progress certificate an amount which the Principal is entitled to retain, deduct, withhold or set off from the amount which would otherwise be payable to the Contractor by the Principal, will not prejudice the Principal’s right to subsequently exercise its rights to retain, deduct, withhold or set off any amount under the Contract.The Contractor shall within 2 business days of receipt of the progress certificate, provide a tax invoice to the Superintendent for the amount stated in the progress certificate as being payable to the Contractor by the Principal. The provision of such a tax invoice shall not prejudice any right that the Contractor may have to dispute the amount shown in the progress certificate.The Principal shall within 15 business days after receiving the progress claim, pay to the Contractor the balance of the progress certificate after setting off such moneys or amounts as the Principal elects to set off. If that setting off produces a negative balance, that negative balance shall become a debt due and payable by the Contractor to the Principal.Neither a progress certificate nor a payment of moneys shall be evidence that the subject WUC has been carried out satisfactorily, nor shall they prejudice any claim by or defence by the Principal. Payment other than final payment shall be payment on account only.At any time and from time to time, the Superintendent may by a further progress certificate correct any error which has been discovered in any previous payment schedule. …” (emphasis added)

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

For the reasons I have given, there is no evidence of such a danger and, in the circumstances, I would refuse the application for a freezing order.Conclusions and orders The injunction ought to be dissolved. Descon seeks orders that the application proceed as if it was a claim and there be directions that it file and serve a statement of claim. Merivale seeks an order that the application be dismissed. It submits that Descon can file a claim with a pleading if it sees fit. In my view, there is no point in dismissing the application only to see Descon file a fresh claim. It should be ordered that the application proceed as if it were a claim. I will direct the filing of a statement of claim. The filing of other pleadings is prescribed by the UCPR. I will order the exchange of written submissions on costs and that the determination on costs be made on those written submissions without further oral hearing unless a party applies for leave to make oral submissions on costs.Orders The orders are:1.The injunction made on 3 October 2023 and extended on each of 5 October, 23 October and 26 October 2023 are dissolved.2.The matter proceed as if started by claim. 3.The application is otherwise dismissed. 4.The parties exchange written submissions on costs by 4.00 pm on 15 December 2023.5.In the absence of any application being filed by 4.00 pm on 22 December 2023 seeking leave to make oral submissions on costs, the question of costs will be decided without further oral hearing.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.