DBE17 v The Commonwealth of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NETTLE J

DBE17 (BY HIS LITIGATION GUARDIAN
MARIE THERESA ARTHUR)  PLAINTIFF

AND

COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA  DEFENDANT

DBE17 (by his litigation guardian Marie Theresa Arthur) v Commonwealth of Australia

[2019] HCA 47

Date of Hearing: 8 & 22 November 2019
Date of Judgment: 6 December 2019

M124/2019

ORDER

1.The proceeding be remitted to the Victoria District Registry of the Federal Court of Australia.

2.The proceeding continue in the Federal Court as if the steps taken in the proceeding in this Court had been taken in that Court.

3.The Registrar of this Court forward to the proper officer of the Federal Court photocopies of all documents filed in this Court.

4.The costs of the proceeding in this Court be costs in the cause in the Federal Court.

Representation

B F Quinn QC with M W Guo for the plaintiff (instructed by Maurice Blackburn) at the hearing on 8 November 2019

B F Quinn QC with M L L Albert, M W Guo and S Zeleznikow for the plaintiff (instructed by Maurice Blackburn) at the hearing on 22 November 2019

A M Dinelli for the defendant (instructed by Australian Government Solicitor) at the hearing on 8 November 2019

N J Williams SC with A M Dinelli for the defendant (instructed by Australian Government Solicitor) at the hearing on 22 November 2019

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

NETTLE J.  

The nature of the proceeding

  1. This proceeding is a representative proceeding[1] instituted in the original jurisdiction of this Court by writ of summons by the plaintiff (by his litigation guardian) representing himself and every other person who is a "Group Member" as defined in the writ of summons. The claim is for damages for false imprisonment constituted of allegedly unlawful detention of the plaintiff and each other Group Member. The plaintiff claims that he, and each other Group Member, was purportedly detained pursuant to ss 189 and 196 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) while the Commonwealth received, investigated and determined the plaintiff's (or other Group Member's) application for a visa to enter and remain in Australia, or determined whether to permit a valid application for a visa to be made ("the visa purposes"), and that, subject to certain exceptions, the detention of the plaintiff and of each other Group Member for the visa purposes "was only lawful for the period of time for which one of the visa purposes was being pursued and carried into effect as soon as was reasonably practicable". It is further claimed that, to the extent that the Commonwealth detained the plaintiff and each other member of the subgroup of Group Members who arrived in Australia after 12 August 2012 ("Subgroup Members") otherwise than for the visa purposes, the purpose of the detention of the Subgroup Member was that of removing him or her from Australia to a regional processing country pursuant to Pt 2…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read DBE17 v The Commonwealth of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] HCA 47
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiff, DBE17, commenced a representative proceeding in the High Court of Australia seeking damages for alleged unlawful detention of Group Members under sections 189 and 196 of the *Migration Act 1958* (Cth). The plaintiff contended that detention was only lawful for the period necessary to pursue specific purposes, such as processing visa applications or effecting removal, and that such purposes were not pursued with reasonable practicability or that detention continued beyond the point where these purposes were capable of fulfilment. The plaintiff sought an order remitting the proceeding to the Federal Court of Australia pursuant to section 44(2A) of the *Judiciary Act 1903* (Cth).

The central legal issues before the Court were whether section 476B of the *Migration Act* prohibited the High Court from remitting the proceeding to the Federal Court, and whether section 486B of the *Migration Act* rendered the representative proceeding incompetent in its current form. Section 476B(1) stipulates that the High Court must not remit a matter "that relates to a migration decision" to a court other than the Federal Circuit Court. Section 486B(1) defines "migration proceedings" broadly to include proceedings that "raise an issue in connection with visas... or removal of unlawful non-citizens," and subsection (4) prohibits representative or class actions in such proceedings.

Nettle J determined that section 476B of the *Migration Act* did not prohibit the remission of this proceeding. His Honour reasoned that the plaintiff's claim for damages for false imprisonment, while arising from detention under the *Migration Act*, was not a "migration decision" for the purposes of section 476B. Furthermore, Nettle J found that section 486B, which prohibits representative actions in proceedings that "raise an issue in connection with visas... or removal of unlawful non-citizens," was limited in its application to judicial review proceedings. As the present proceeding was a claim for damages and not a judicial review, section 486B did not render it incompetent.

Consequently, Nettle J ordered that the proceeding be remitted to the Federal Court of Australia, with all steps taken in the High Court to be considered as having been taken in the Federal Court. The Registrar was directed to forward relevant documents to the Federal Court, and the costs of the proceeding in the High Court were to be costs in the cause in the Federal Court.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The proceeding be remitted to the Victoria District Registry of the Federal Court of Australia.

2. The proceeding continue in the Federal Court as if the steps taken in the proceeding in this Court had been taken in that Court.

3. The Registrar of this Court forward to the proper officer of the Federal Court photocopies of all documents filed in this Court.

4. The costs of the proceeding in this Court be costs in the cause in the Federal Court.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

NETTLE J
Finally, it is to be observed that the expression "raises an issue ... in connection with visas" in s 486C entails a further constructional issue: as to whether it limits the operation of s 486C to judicial review proceedings for review of decisions to grant, give, suspend, cancel, revoke or refuse visas, or whether it reaches beyond that to judicial review of decisions other than decisions to grant, give, suspend, cancel, revoke or refuse visas – decisions that are, however, concerned with issues connected with decisions to grant, give, suspend, cancel, revoke or refuse visas. There are some observations of the Federal Court which suggest that the former may be the preferable construction[27]. But for present purposes it is not a question that needs to be decided. It is sufficient for the disposition of this matter that, upon its proper construction, s 486C of the Migration Act is limited to judicial review proceedings and so does not apply to this proceeding.[27]See for example NAMU of 2002 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2002) 124 FCR 589 at 592 [4] per Black CJ, Sundberg and Weinberg JJ; Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs v Al Masri (2003) 126 FCR 54 at 63 [23] per Black CJ, Sundberg and Weinberg JJ. Conclusion For the reasons given, I do not consider that s 476B of the Migration Act prohibits this Court from remitting the matter to the Federal Court or that s 486B renders the proceeding incompetent in its present form. I order accordingly, by consent, that the matter be remitted to the Federal Court.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: NETTLE J

Section 486B of the Migration Act provides, so far as is relevant, as follows: "Multiple parties in migration litigationApplication of section(1)This section applies to all proceedings (migration proceedings) in the High Court, the Federal Court or the Federal Circuit Court that raise an issue in connection with visas (including if a visa is not granted or has been cancelled), deportation, taking, or removal of unlawful non-citizens.Consolidation of proceedings(2)Consolidation of any migration proceeding with any other migration proceeding is not permitted unless the court is satisfied that:(a)the consolidation would otherwise be permitted under other relevant laws (including Rules of Court); and(b)the consolidation is desirable for the efficient conduct of the proceedings.(3)No appeal lies from a decision by the court not to consolidate proceedings under subsection (2).Other joint proceedings etc(4)The following are not permitted in or by a migration proceeding:(a) representative or class actions;(b)joinder of plaintiffs or applicants or addition of parties;(c)a person in any other way (but not including as a result of consolidation under subsection (2)) being a party to the proceeding jointly with, on behalf of, for the benefit of, or representing, one or more other persons, however this is described.Relationship with other laws(5)This section has effect despite any other law, including in particular:(a)Part IVA of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976; and(b) any Rules of Court...."The statutory context Section 486B is one of six provisions comprising Pt 8A of the Migration Act and was originally inserted into the Migration Act by the Migration Legislation Amendment Act (No 1) 2001 (Cth) ("the 2001 Act"). The other provisions of Pt 8A are:(1)s 486A, which provides that an application to this Court for "a remedy to be granted in exercise of the court's original jurisdiction in relation to a migration decision" (as inserted into the Act, the provision referred to an application "for a writ of mandamus, prohibition or certiorari or an injunction or a declaration in respect of a [stipulated decision]") has to be made to this Court within a specified period of the date of notification of the decision;(2)ss 486AA and 486AB, which respectively provide for intervention by the Attorney-General in a proceeding resulting from an application referred to in s 486A and that the making of an application referred to in s 486A does not affect the operation of the decision, prevent the taking of action to implement the decision or prevent the taking of action in reliance on the making of the decision;(3)s 486C, which specifies the persons who may commence or continue certain kinds of judicial review proceedings in the Federal Circuit Court or the Federal Court that "raise[] an issue ... in connection with visas" and relate to the validity, interpretation or effect of a provision of the Act or the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth); and(4)s 486D, which provides that a person may not commence a judicial review proceeding in relation to a tribunal decision in the Federal Circuit Court or the Federal Court or this Court without disclosing any judicial review proceeding already brought by the person in any court in relation to the decision.