CUD16 v Minister for Immigration

Link copied
Case Copied 67 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

CUD16 v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & ANOR [2020] FCCA 1495
Catchwords:
MIGRATION – Protection Visa – decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal – whether Tribunal’s credibility findings illogical – whether Tribunal failed to make an enquiry – whether Tribunal was biased – no jurisdictional error – application dismissed.

Legislation:

Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss.424A, 424AA, 425, 476

Cases cited:

ALA15 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] FCAFC 30
Chan v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1989) 189 CLR 379
DAO16 v Minister for Immigration & Border Protection [2018] FCAFC 2
Lee v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs [2005] FCA 464
Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v DDK16 [2017] FCAFC 188
Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZIAI [2009] HCA 39; 83 ALJR 1123

Minster for Immigration & Citizenship v SZMDS [2010] HCA 16

Randhawa v Minister for Immigration, Local Government and Ethnic Affairs (1994) 52 FCR 437
SZBEL v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs [2006] HCA 63

SZBYR v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2007) 235 ALR 609

SZLGP v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2009] FCA 1470
SZRMQ v Minister for Immigration & Border Protection [2013] FCAFC 142
SZRUI v Minister for Immigration, Multicultural Affairs & Citizenship [2013] FCAFC 80

Applicant: CUD16
First Respondent: MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION, CITIZENSHIP, MIGRANT SERVICES AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
Second Respondent: ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL
File Number: MLG 2090 of 2016
Judgment of: Judge C. E. Kirton QC
Hearing date: 3 August 2018
Date of Last Submission: 3 August 2018
Delivered at: Melbourne
Delivered on: 10 June 2020

REPRESENTATION

Applicant: In person with the assistance of an interpreter
Solicitors for the Respondents: Sparke Helmore Lawyers
Second Respondent: Submitting appearance, save as to costs

ORDERS

  1. Pursuant to r.7.01 of the Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001 (Cth), the name of the First Respondent be amended to the “Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs”.

  2. The Applicant’s application filed on 26 September 2016 is dismissed.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
AT MELBOURNE

MLG 2090 of 2016

CUD16

Applicant

And

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION, CITIZENSHIP, MIGRANT SERVICES AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS

First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introduction

  1. By an application filed in this Court on 27 September 2016, the Applicant seeks judicial review of a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Tribunal) dated 7 September 2016. The Tribunal’s decision affirmed a decision of a delegate (Delegate) of the then Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Minister) not to grant the Applicant a Protection (Class XA) visa (Visa).

  2. This application is brought pursuant to s.476 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (Act). To be successful, the Applicant is required to demonstrate that the Tribunal has made a jurisdictional error.

  3. The materials before the Court include the judicial review application (Application), submissions prepared by the Applicant dated 13 July 2018 which were marked as Exhibit A1…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read CUD16 v Minister for Immigration and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCCA 1495
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, CUD16, sought judicial review of a decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) which affirmed the Minister for Immigration's decision to refuse the grant of a protection visa. The dispute centred on the Tribunal's findings regarding the applicant's credibility and the completeness of its assessment of the applicant's claims.

The legal issues before the court were whether the Tribunal's credibility findings were illogical, whether the Tribunal failed to make a necessary enquiry, and whether the Tribunal demonstrated bias. These questions arose from the applicant's contention that the Tribunal's adverse credibility findings were not supported by the evidence and that the Tribunal had not adequately investigated certain aspects of his claims.

The court adopted the Minister's submissions, which detailed the Tribunal's reasoning. The Tribunal had noted the applicant presented as educated and intelligent, with some consistent evidence. However, it expressed significant concern about the applicant raising new claims late in the process and embellishing existing ones. The Tribunal found the applicant's explanation for the late disclosure unconvincing due to inconsistencies and noted the absence of evidence of trauma affecting his ability to provide evidence, observing his active engagement at the hearing. The Tribunal rejected submissions that discrepancies arose from confusion or lack of opportunity to respond during the delegate interview, noting the applicant had opportunities to clarify questions and provide further submissions, which he did not do. Ultimately, the Tribunal did not accept the applicant's reasons for late disclosure and rejected specific new claims regarding his father's role as a cook and his own involvement with the LTTE, though it accepted his uncle's involvement with the LTTE at a lesser level than claimed. The court found no jurisdictional error.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Applicant, a national of Sri Lanka, lodged an application for a protection visa in Australia. The application was initially considered and rejected by a Delegate of the Minister for Immigration. The Applicant appealed this decision to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal). The Tribunal affirmed the Delegate's decision not to grant the Applicant the Visa.

The Applicant's claims involved allegations of persecution due to his family's involvement with the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE), a separatist group in Sri Lanka. The Applicant asserted that his father had worked as a cook for the LTTE, and that his uncle was a commander within the group. He also claimed personal involvement in assisting his uncle in the LTTE activities. However, these claims were made late in the process, and the Applicant provided varying accounts of these allegations. The Applicant attributed the delay in disclosing these claims to having been advised not to reveal his connection to the LTTE, as it would be used against him.

The Tribunal expressed concerns regarding the credibility of the Applicant's claims. It noted that the Applicant appeared well-educated and intelligent, and certain aspects of his evidence were consistent. However, the late introduction of new claims and the perceived embellishment of other aspects of his story raised significant doubts about the reliability of his account. Furthermore, the Tribunal found the Applicant's explanation for the delayed disclosure unconvincing due to inconsistencies in his statements and the absence of evidence supporting a claim of trauma affecting his ability to provide consistent evidence.

In considering the Applicant's claims, the Tribunal highlighted discrepancies in his accounts of his uncle's role within the LTTE and the extent of his father's involvement. Despite the Applicant's assertions, the Tribunal did not accept that his father was a cook for the LTTE, although it was willing to acknowledge the uncle's association with the group. However, the Tribunal rejected the claim that the uncle held a command position as alleged by the Applicant. These credibility concerns led the Tribunal to reject the new claims and uphold the original decision not to grant the protection visa.

The matter of CUD16 v Minister for Immigration came before the court following the decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) on 7 September 2016, which affirmed the decision not to grant the Applicant a protection visa. The Applicant sought judicial review of the AAT's decision, challenging the Tribunal's credibility findings, its failure to make an enquiry, and an alleged bias. This case represents a judicial review application brought to challenge the decision of the AAT. The Applicant's case was first heard and determined by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration, whose decision was subsequently reviewed by the AAT. The Applicant was dissatisfied with the AAT's affirmation of the delegate's decision and sought judicial review of the Tribunal’s decision on the grounds that it was illogical, failed to make a necessary enquiry, and was biased. Key procedural steps include the filing of the application for judicial review, the hearing of the matter, and the submissions made by both parties regarding the AAT's decision. The court is tasked with determining whether the AAT's decision contains any jurisdictional errors, without delving into the substantive merits of the case.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 7 September 2016, the Tribunal affirmed the decision not to grant the Applicant the Visa (Tribunal’s Decision)[13].[13] CB 271-292. The Tribunal’s Decision appears at Court Book pages 271-292. The Minister’s Written Submissions at [12]-[34] accurately, and in detail, summarise the Tribunal’s Decision. The Court adopts those submissions, with some alterations, as follows. The Tribunal first set out the background to the application before it and summarised the legal principles applicable to the protection visa criterion[14]. The Tribunal then summarised the Applicant’s claims, evidence and submissions and referred to the Delegate’s Decision and reasons[15].[14] CB 272-274, at [1]-[18].[15] CB 274, at [20]-[22]. The Tribunal first outlined the credibility concerns that it had:a)It noted that the Applicant presented as “well-educated and intelligent” and that certain aspects of his evidence had been consistent. However, the Applicant raising new claims at a late stage caused the Tribunal concern and the Tribunal also had significant concerns that the Applicant had attempted to embellish many aspects of his claims in order to strengthen his claims for protection[16].b)It considered that the Applicant’s explanation for raising new claims at a later stage (that he had been told not to disclose his involvement with the LTTE as the information would be used against him), was undermined due to inconsistencies in his evidence about the new claims in the written submissions and his evidence provided to the Tribunal at the hearing. The Tribunal further noted that no evidence had been provided regarding any trauma that may have affected the Applicant’s ability to provide evidence, and found that the Applicant was able to actively engage in the Tribunal hearing[17].c)It did not accept the submissions advanced that discrepancies arose as a result of the confusion surrounding how the Applicant was asked questions or because he was not given a chance to respond at the interview with the Delegate. The Tribunal also noted that the Applicant had been provided with opportunities to clarify the questions at the interview, including at the hearing, and that he had been provided with further time to provide written submissions after the hearing. Despite this, no further submissions were provided[18].[16] CB 275, at [25].[17] CB 275, at [26].[18] CB 275, at [27]. The Tribunal detailed the Applicant’s evidence regarding his father’s role as a cook and his own involvement with the LTTE and why the Applicant did not disclose this earlier[19]. Due to its credibility concerns, the Tribunal did not accept the Applicant’s reasons for the late disclosure of the new claims. It also noted inconsistencies in the Applicant’s evidence that led it to reject the Applicant’s new claims, namely that he had assisted his uncle in the LTTE, that his uncle was a commander in the LTTE, and that his father worked as a cook for the LTTE[20]. The Tribunal did not accept that the Applicant’s father was a cook for the LTTE though was willing to accept his uncle was involved in the LTTE. However, the Tribunal did not accept that the uncle’s involvement was at the level that the Applicant claimed.[19] CB 276, at [28]-[31].[20] CB 277-278, at [32]-[38].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the Tribunal’s assessment of the Applicant’s credibility, which formed the cornerstone of its decision. The Tribunal found that the Applicant’s presentation as “well-educated and intelligent” and certain consistent aspects of his evidence were overshadowed by his late introduction of new claims and his attempts to embellish his narrative. The court held that these concerns were neither illogical nor unreasonable, given the Applicant’s failure to substantiate his claims with credible explanations or evidence. The court underscored that while the Applicant’s explanation for the late disclosure—alleging he was advised not to reveal his LTTE involvement—was plausible, it was undermined by inconsistencies in his written submissions and oral testimony. This inconsistency and lack of corroborative evidence led the Tribunal to question the Applicant’s credibility.

Furthermore, the court scrutinised whether the Tribunal had adequately investigated the Applicant’s claims. The Tribunal provided a comprehensive summary of the Applicant’s claims, evidence, and submissions, and meticulously compared these with the Delegate’s Decision and reasons. The Tribunal also noted that the Applicant had ample opportunities to clarify his responses and provide additional submissions, which he failed to do. The court found the Tribunal’s approach to be thorough, leaving no doubt that the Tribunal had made a comprehensive inquiry into the Applicant’s claims. The court concluded that the Tribunal’s decision to reject the new claims due to credibility concerns was well-founded and aligned with the applicable legal principles.

The court then considered whether the Tribunal’s decision was influenced by bias or a failure to observe natural justice. The Tribunal’s detailed and reasoned approach, as well as its consideration of the Applicant’s submissions, demonstrated that it had acted fairly and without bias. The Tribunal’s rejection of the Applicant’s claims was based on credible grounds, namely inconsistencies and embellishments in the Applicant’s evidence. The court found no evidence to suggest that the Tribunal had acted in a biased manner or failed to adhere to the principles of natural justice.

The court also examined whether there was any jurisdictional error in the Tribunal’s decision. The court noted that the Tribunal had correctly applied the legal principles governing protection visas and had provided adequate reasons for its decision. The Tribunal’s conclusion that the Applicant’s claims were not credible was supported by the evidence and did not constitute a jurisdictional error. The court held that the Tribunal had exercised its discretion appropriately and had not erred in law.

Finally, the court addressed the Applicant’s late disclosure of new claims and the inconsistencies in his evidence. The Tribunal’s decision to reject these new claims was justified, given the Applicant’s failure to provide credible explanations for the late disclosure and the inconsistencies in his evidence. The court found that the Tribunal had appropriately weighed the Applicant’s credibility against the new claims and had reasonably concluded that these claims were not credible. The court supported the Tribunal’s decision, noting that the rejection of the new claims was in line with established legal principles.