Crime and Misconduct Commission v Assistant Commissioner Ross Barnett

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read
CITATION: Crime and Misconduct Commission v Assistant Commissioner Ross Barnett [2010] QCAT 690
PARTIES: Crime and Misconduct Commission
v
Assistant Commissioner Ross Barnett and Bryan Alan Eaton
APPLICATION NUMBER:   OCR079-10
MATTER TYPE: Occupational regulation matters
HEARING DATE:     Determined on papers
HEARD AT:  Brisbane
DECISION OF: Hon J B Thomas
DELIVERED ON: 9 September 2010
DELIVERED AT:      Brisbane

ORDERS MADE:

(1) The Crime and Misconduct Commission is granted leave to adduce new evidence under section 219H of the Crime and Misconduct Act 2001, namely the inquest finding of the state coroner dated 14 October 2004 (attachment 1 to the application).

(2)  The Crime and Misconduct Commission is also granted leave to adduce evidence of attachments 2 and 3 to the application and copies of position descriptions for all QPS positions for the rank “Senior Sergeant” and below.

(3)  Leave is granted to all parties to apply for further directions before hearing.

CATCHWORDS : 

Police discipline – penalty – right of CMC to appeal against inadequacy – CMC’s role and status in such reviews – suggested application of Hardiman principle to avoid duplication of representation –
Whether “new evidence” may be received – whether coroner’s findings should be received – need for relevance – limited basis for reception – whether evidence “new” –

Crime and Misconduct Act 2001, ss 219A, 219BA(1), 219G, 219(H)
Police Service Administration Act 1990, s 7.4
Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009, ss 7(2), 20, 28(3)
Coroners Act 1958, s 43
Coroners Act 2003, s 51

APPEARANCES and REPRESENTATION (if any):

APPLICANT: 

Submissions from J J Allen, counsel for applicant

RESPONDENT: 

M D Nicholson, counsel for first respondent, and P E Smith, counsel for second respondent

REASONS FOR DECISION

Nature of proceedings and jurisdiction

  1. The principal proceedings are the CMC’s application for review of a disciplinary decision against a policeman (Sergeant Eaton) who was found guilty of police misconduct. A penalty was imposed of reduction in his level of salary from paypoint 4.4 to 4.3 for a period of 12 months. They were commenced by the CMC pursuant to section 219G of the Crime and Misconduct Act 2001 which gives the CMC the right to apply to QCAT for the review of a “reviewable decision”. That term is defined in section 219BA(1)(a) of that Act to include a decision of the present kind.

  2. The CMC was not a party to the original disciplinary action against Sergeant Eaton which was conducted within the police service pursuant to section 7.4 of the Police Service Administration Act 1990.

  1. The present application is brought by the CMC under section 219H of the Crime and Misconduct Act 2001 to adduce “new evidence”. The respondents are respectively the decision-maker (Assistant Commissioner Barnett) and Sergeant Eaton.

  1. The Parties have consented to my determination of that application on the papers, which include all the evidence on which the original disciplinary proceedings were based.

The “new evidence”

  1. The application listed four categories of additional facts, the first of which is described as “Inquest Finding of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Crime and Misconduct Commission v Assistant Commissioner Ros... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] QCAT 690
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Crime and Misconduct Commission brought an application to the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal, challenging the decision of Assistant Commissioner Ross Barnett to impose a penalty on a police officer. The CMC argued that the penalty was inadequate and sought to adduce new evidence to support its claim. This included the findings of a state coroner's inquest and additional documentary evidence. The Assistant Commissioner opposed the application, arguing that the CMC's role and status in such reviews meant that the CMC should not be allowed to adduce new evidence. Furthermore, the Assistant Commissioner argued that the CMC should not be permitted to represent the interests of both the public and the police officer in the review process, as this would contravene the principle established in Hardiman v Criminal Justice Commission of Queensland.

The tribunal considered whether the CMC had the right to appeal against the adequacy of the penalty and adduce new evidence, and whether the coroner's findings and other documentary evidence should be admitted. The tribunal noted that the CMC's role and status in such reviews meant that it was necessary to limit the CMC's ability to adduce new evidence in order to avoid duplication of representation. However, the tribunal found that the CMC's role did not prevent it from adduced new evidence in certain circumstances. The tribunal held that the coroner's findings and other documentary evidence were relevant to the CMC's case and should be admitted.

The tribunal granted leave for the CMC to adduce the new evidence, including the coroner's findings and other documentary evidence. The tribunal also granted leave for all parties to apply for further directions before the hearing. The tribunal found that the CMC's role and status in such reviews did not prevent it from adduced new evidence in certain circumstances, and that the evidence in question was relevant to the CMC's case. The tribunal emphasised the need for relevance and a limited basis for the reception of new evidence to avoid duplication of representation.

Orders

Orders of the court

(1) The Crime and Misconduct Commission is granted leave to adduce new evidence under section 219H of the Crime and Misconduct Act 2001, namely the inquest finding of the state coroner dated 14 October 2004 (attachment 1 to the application).

(2) The Crime and Misconduct Commission is also granted leave to adduce evidence of attachments 2 and 3 to the application and copies of position descriptions for all QPS positions for the rank “Senior Sergeant” and below.

(3) Leave is granted to all parties to apply for further directions before hearing.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.