Crime and Misconduct Commission v Deputy Commissioner Stewart (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read
CITATION: Crime and Misconduct Commission v Deputy Commissioner Stewart and Anor (No 2) [2012] QCAT 382
PARTIES: Crime and Misconduct Commission
v
Deputy Commissioner Ian Stewart
Paul Dalton
APPLICATION NUMBER: OCR201-11
MATTER TYPE: Occupational regulation matters
HEARING DATE: 18 June 2012
HEARD AT: Brisbane
DECISION OF: Hon James Thomas, AM QC, Member
Ms M Howard, Member
DELIVERED ON: 30 July 2012
DELIVERED AT: Brisbane
ORDERS MADE:

1.     The decision of Deputy Commissioner Ian Stewart of 22 August 2011 that particulars four and five of the charge of negligent operational management were not substantiated is confirmed;

2.     The sanction imposed by Deputy Commissioner Ian Stewart, on 22 August 2011, with respect to particulars one, two and three of the said charge, namely that the second respondent Paul Dalton's paypoint level be reduced from Sergeant paypoint 5 to Sergeant paypoint 1 for a period of 12 months, with accompanying directions, is confirmed.

CATCHWORDS: Police discipline – use of prisoner as informant and in covert operation – no statutory authorisation sought – whether a "controlled operation” under Police Powers and Responsibilities Act 2000 – level of sanction –observations on role of decision-maker in reviews brought by CMC

APPEARANCES and REPRESENTATION (if any):

APPLICANT:

Crime and Misconduct Commission represented by Mr T D Gardner (counsel)

RESPONDENT: 

Deputy Commissioner, Queensland Police Service (QPS), Regional Operations represented by Ms C Heffner

Mr Paul Dalton represented by Mr S Zillman SC

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. The parties will be referred to respectively as the CMC, the decision-maker and Sergeant Dalton.

  2. The CMC seeks a review of two determinations of the decision-maker –

    a)The decision-maker’s finding that the charges relating to particulars 4 and 5 were not substantiated; and

    b)The sanction imposed by the decision-maker on the substantiated charges.

  3. Our jurisdiction arises under sections 219BA(1), 219G and 219H of the Crime and Misconduct Act 2001, and sections 17-24 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Act 2009.  It is our duty to make up our own minds and conduct a fresh hearing on the merits consistently with the principles stated in Aldrich v Ross [2001] 2 Qd R 235.

Background

  1. The proceedings arise out of activity in which Sergeant Dalton, then a detective-sergeant in Rockhampton, engaged in 2004.  His activity involved the use of a notorious criminal, Henderson, as a police informant, and Henderson’s extraction from prison from time to time with a view to his use in a covert police operation.  His superior officers were aware of Sergeant Dalton’s activity and raised no objection.  However Sergeant Dalton failed to comply with numerous procedural requirements laid down in relation to the conduct of such activities.

  2. In 2008 Sergeant Dalton was charged with misconduct.  Proceedings were adjourned pending resolution of criminal charges which had been brought against him.  In late 2010 the criminal proceedings were terminated by the entry of a nolle prosequi in the District Court, and Sergeant Dalton returned to active duty. 

  3. The disciplinary hearing resumed in March 2011. 

  4. There was a single charge of misconduct, namely negligent…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Crime and Misconduct Commission v Deputy Commissioner Stewar... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] QCAT 382
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Crime and Misconduct Commission v Deputy Commissioner Stewart (No 2), the dispute revolved around the use of a prisoner as an informant and in a covert operation without seeking the statutory authorisation required under the Police Powers and Responsibilities Act 2000. The Deputy Commissioner of Police, Ian Stewart, was the respondent in this case, which was heard by the Supreme Court of Queensland. The CMC sought to review the Deputy Commissioner's decision not to substantiate two charges of negligent operational management against Paul Dalton, a police officer.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the Deputy Commissioner's decision to not substantiate two charges against Dalton, as well as the sanction imposed on him, was legally sound. The CMC argued that the Deputy Commissioner should have substantiated the charges and imposed a more severe sanction on Dalton for his involvement in the covert operation. The court had to determine whether the Deputy Commissioner's decision to not substantiate the charges and the sanction imposed was consistent with the statutory requirements and the overall objective of the Police Powers and Responsibilities Act 2000.

The court found that the Deputy Commissioner's decision to not substantiate the charges and the sanction imposed on Dalton were consistent with the statutory requirements and the overall objective of the Act. The court held that the covert operation in question did not amount to a "controlled operation" under the Act, as it did not involve the covert operative or the police officer engaging in any unlawful activities. The court also noted that the Deputy Commissioner had considered all relevant factors and had exercised his discretion in accordance with the statutory requirements. The court further held that the sanction imposed on Dalton was appropriate and proportionate to the nature and seriousness of the misconduct.

The Supreme Court of Queensland confirmed the Deputy Commissioner's decision not to substantiate two charges of negligent operational management against Dalton and the sanction imposed on him. The court held that the Deputy Commissioner's decision was legally sound and consistent with the statutory requirements and the overall objective of the Police Powers and Responsibilities Act 2000. The court also noted that the Deputy Commissioner had exercised his discretion in a fair and reasonable manner, taking into account all relevant factors. The court's decision provides useful guidance on the role of the decision-maker in reviews brought by the CMC and the standards that should be applied in such cases.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The decision of Deputy Commissioner Ian Stewart of 22 August 2011 that particulars four and five of the charge of negligent operational management were not substantiated is confirmed;

2. The sanction imposed by Deputy Commissioner Ian Stewart, on 22 August 2011, with respect to particulars one, two and three of the said charge, namely that the second respondent Paul Dalton's paypoint level be reduced from Sergeant paypoint 5 to Sergeant paypoint 1 for a period of 12 months, with accompanying directions, is confirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Relevantly section 173(1) provides that a Police Officer may apply for approval to conduct a controlled operation. The term was not otherwise explicitly defined, but its meaning is to some extent further indicated by section 172(2) which provides that that statutory committee appointed to approve such operations may only do so if satisfied:“Having regard to the nature and seriousness of the offence being or to be investigated, it is appropriate for persons to engage in otherwise unlawful activities for the purposes of gathering evidence that may lead to the conviction of a person for the offence.” (Our emphasis and underlining). This aspect is further mentioned in section 177(3) which states that the approving officer must not approve the application unless satisfied that the purpose of the proposed controlled operation is to gather evidence of chapter 5 criminal activity. It is not necessary to set out further details of the statutory scheme which is contained in chapter 5 of the PPR Act (ie sections 163 to 197). It is sufficient to note that there are stringent procedural requirements laid down for any police officer who elects to seek to gather evidence by the use of covert operatives in a fashion which may involve the operative or the police officer in illegal activity. Such activities run the risk of the covert agent being seen as aiding and abetting or otherwise becoming a party to the commission of a criminal offence. Substantial details are needed to be disclosed so that they may be reviewed both by senior police officers and by a special statutory committee which may authorise the conduct of such operations. Section 173(5) of the Act requires many details to be stated in order for approval to be obtained, including a description of the criminal activity in relation to which it is proposed to conduct the operation, and a description of each otherwise unlawful activity a covert operative who is not a police officer or a CMC officer may be required to engage in as part of the operation. The object of the legislation is stated in section 163 as “to ensure the effective investigation” of specified offences and organised crime. It contemplates that particular officers will approve the conduct of controlled operations that may involve particular police officers and others engaging in activities that may be unlawful as part of the investigation of specified offences; it aims to ensure that approval or authorisation is only given “in appropriate circumstances”; it aims to ensure, as far as practicable, that only appropriately trained persons act as covert operatives; it also aims to provide "appropriate protection from civil and criminal liability for persons acting in accordance with the legislation” and “to clarify the status of evidence obtained by persons who engage in controlled operations or controlled activities under this chapter”. Under the legislation then in force, it seems to us that a controlled operation should be regarded as a police procedure which would attempt to gather evidence in circumstances where police or their operative might become involved in illegality. The main purpose of the legislation appears to have been (and still is) to insulate the police from criminal liability when they gather evidence in operations that might suggest complicity or involvement on their part in illegality, and to remove the taint of illegality from such evidence as is gathered if and when a court might be called upon to determine whether such evidence should be received.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established