Country Carbon Pty Ltd v Clean Energy Regulator

Link copied
Case Copied 78 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Country Carbon Pty Ltd v Clean Energy Regulator [2018] FCA 1636

File number: VID 1108 of 2017
Judge: MORTIMER J
Date of judgment: 1 November 2018
Catchwords:

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – application for judicial review of decisions made by Clean Energy Regulator under the Carbon Credits (Carbon Farming Initiative) Act 2011 (Cth) – Regulator’s decisions imposed conditions on declarations obtained by applicant that its projects were “eligible offsets projects” including a requirement for consent to be obtained from holders of an “eligible interest” –  whether on proper construction of Act the conditions applied only to “sequestration projects” – whether conditions imposed were thus beyond power – conditions imposed not beyond power on proper construction of Act – application dismissed

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – cross-claim by native title holders seeking declarations that applicant had no “legal right to carry out” project – separate question identified regarding whether existence of such a right a jurisdictional fact on proper construction of the Carbon Credits (Carbon Farming Initiative) Act 2011 (Cth) – separate question answered in the negative   

STATUTORY INTERPRETATION – Circumstances in which it is open to a Court to change or insert words into statute as an exercise in statutory construction – not an appropriate circumstance

Legislation:

Constitution, s 75(v)

Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth), ss 15AB(1)(a), 15AB(1)(b), 34AB(1)(c)

Carbon Credits (Carbon Farming Initiative) Act 2011 (Cth), 3, 4, 5, 12, 13, 15, 22, 23, 27, 28A, 31, 43, 44, 45, 45A, 53, 53A, 54, 97, 98, 99

Carbon Farming Initiative Amendment Act 2014 (Cth)

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth), s 191

Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth), s 39B

Native Title Act 1993 (Cth), s 57(2)

Parliamentary Privileges Act 1987 (Cth), ss 16(3), 16(5)

Carbon Credits (Carbon Farming Initiative) Rule 2015 (Cth), s 50

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), rr 22.01, 22.02, 22.04

Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW), s 12(2)

Compensation to Relatives Act 1897 (NSW)

Sentencing Act 1991 (Vic), s 37

Sentencing Amendment (Community Correction Reform) Act 2011 (Vic), s 21, Sch 3, cl 5

Cases cited:

Alcan (NT) Alumina Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Territory Revenue [2009] HCA 41; 239 CLR 27

BGM16 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] FCAC 72; 252 FCR 97

Brennan v Comcare [1994] FCA 360; 50 FCR 555

BY Winddown Inc v Vautin [2016] FCAFC 168; 249 FCR 262

Cabal v Attorney-General of the Commonwealth [2001] FCA 583; 113 FCR 154

Carr v Western Australia [2007] HCA 47; 232 CLR 138

CIC Insurance Ltd v Bankstown Football Club Ltd [1997] HCA 2; 187 CLR 384

Colonial Bank of Australasia v Willan (1874) 5 PC 417

Corporate Affairs Commission of New South Wales v Yuill [1991] HCA 28; 172 CLR 319

DPP v Leys [2012] VSCA 304; 44 VR 1

Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Consolidated Media Holdings Ltd [2012] HCA 55; 250 CLR 503

Friends of Leadbeater’s Possum Inc v VicForests [2018] FCA 178; 228 LGERA 255

Greenwool for and on behalf of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Country Carbon Pty Ltd v Clean Energy Regulator and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FCA 1636
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Country Carbon Pty Ltd v Clean Energy Regulator was heard in the Federal Court of Australia. The applicant, Country Carbon, sought a judicial review of decisions made by the Clean Energy Regulator under the Carbon Credits (Carbon Farming Initiative) Act 2011 (Cth). The Regulator had imposed conditions on declarations obtained by Country Carbon that its projects were "eligible offsets projects", including a requirement for consent to be obtained from holders of an "eligible interest". The legal issues in the case were whether the conditions applied only to "sequestration projects" and whether the conditions imposed were beyond power on a proper construction of the Act.

The court found that the conditions imposed were not beyond power on a proper construction of the Act. The court also addressed a separate question regarding whether the existence of a "legal right to carry out" an offsets project was a jurisdictional fact that was a necessary precondition to the exercise of the Clean Energy Regulator’s discretion to declare the offsets project to be an eligible offsets project. The court answered this question in the negative. The court held that it was not an appropriate circumstance to change or insert words into the statute as an exercise in statutory construction.

The court dismissed the applicant’s judicial review application and answered the separate question. The court made orders dismissing the application for judicial review and awarding costs to the respondents. The court did not make any orders for costs in relation to the determination of the separate question. The court noted that the parties may wish to consider whether any further or other orders are appropriate on the cross-claim. If none are proposed, the cross-claim will be listed for a case management hearing at a date to be fixed.

In conclusion, the court found that the conditions imposed by the Clean Energy Regulator were not beyond power on a proper construction of the Act and that the existence of a "legal right to carry out" an offsets project was not a jurisdictional fact that was a necessary precondition to the exercise of the Clean Energy Regulator’s discretion to declare the offsets project to be an eligible offsets project. The court dismissed the applicant’s judicial review application and answered the separate question. The court awarded costs to the respondents and did not make any orders for costs in relation to the determination of the separate question.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application for judicial review filed on 12 October 2017 be dismissed.

2. The applicant pay the respondents’ costs of the application for judicial review, to be fixed in a lump sum.

3. If the parties agree on a lump sum figure in relation to the respondents’ costs of the application for judicial review, they are to file a joint minute of proposed orders on or before 4 pm on 15 November 2018.

4. In the absence of any joint minute of proposed order, pursuant to paragraph 3 of these orders:

(a) on or before 4 pm on 22 November 2018, the respondents file and serve an affidavit constituting a Costs Summary in accordance with paragraphs 4.10 to 4.12 of the Court’s Costs Practice Note (GPN-COSTS) dated 25 October 2016.

(b) on or before 4 pm on 29 November 2018, the applicant file and serve any Costs Response in accordance with paragraphs 4.13 to 4.14 of the Costs Practice Note (GPN-COSTS).

5. In the absence of any agreement having been reached on or before 6 December 2018, the matter of an appropriate lump sum figure for the respondents’ costs be referred to a Registrar for determination.

6. The separate question, stated in orders dated 19 March 2018, be answered as follows:

Separate question:

On the proper construction of the defined term “project proponent” in s 5 of the Carbon Credits (Carbon Farming Initiative) Act 2011 (Cth), is the existence of a “legal right to carry out” an offsets project a jurisdictional fact that is a necessary precondition to the exercise of the Clean Energy Regulator’s discretion to declare the offsets project to be an eligible offsets project under s 27 of the Carbon Credits (Carbon Farming Initiative) Act 2011 (Cth)?”

Answer:

No.

7. No order is made as to costs of the separate question.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The day prior to the hearing, the parties provided the Court with a copy of a notice to admit served by the applicant on the respondents, and correspondence between the parties concerning the notice. By the notice, the applicant sought to admit a number of matters alleged by the applicant to be facts, concerning consultations conducted by the Commonwealth Department of the Environment in 2013 and 2014 in relation to amendments made to the CFI Act in 2014, and an inquiry conducted by the Senate Environment and Communications Legislation Committee in relation to the 2014 amendments. At trial, the Court was advised that while agreement had been reached in relation to some of the matters outlined in the notice, the respondents challenged the admissibility of statements made in two paragraphs (paragraphs 3 and 6) on the basis that they were not properly characterised as “facts”. I deal with my determination in relation to this question later in my reasons.Factual and legislative background A statement of agreed facts for the purposes of the separate question was tendered pursuant to s 191 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth). Some of those agreed facts are also relevant to the judicial review application. In the judicial review application there were no controversial issues of fact. The CFI Act establishes a scheme providing incentives for the conduct of activities that will have the effect of reducing atmospheric carbon and other greenhouse gases. This is apparent from the objects of the CFI Act, set out in s 3:(1) This section sets out the objects of this Act.Climate Change Convention and Kyoto Protocol etc.(2)The first object of this Act is to remove greenhouse gases from the atmosphere, and avoid emissions of greenhouse gases, in order to meet Australia’s obligations under any or all of the following:(a) the Climate Change Convention;(b) the Kyoto Protocol;(c)an international agreement (if any) that is the successor (whether immediate or otherwise) to the Kyoto Protocol.Incentives(3)The second object of this Act is to create incentives for people to carry on certain offsets projects.Carbon abatement(4) The third object of this Act is to increase carbon abatement in a manner that:(a)is consistent with the protection of Australia’s natural environment; and(b) improves resilience to the effects of climate change.Purchase of carbon abatement by the Commonwealth(5)The fourth object of this Act is to authorise the purchase by the Commonwealth of units that represent carbon abatement. As AEA submitted, the incentive under the CFI Act takes the form of the issuing of Australian Carbon Credit Units for “eligible offsets projects” and providing for the purchase of those ACCUs that are “eligible carbon credit units” by the Commonwealth Government under “carbon abatement contracts”. As the simplified outline in s 4 of the CFI Act states, an ACCU is personal property and is generally transferable. Critical to the applicant’s arguments on the judicial review application is the fact that the scheme recognises two different kinds of offsets projects, referable to the kinds of activities to be conducted as part of the projects: sequestration offsets projects and emissions avoidance offsets projects. Div 12 of Pt 3 of the CFI Act deals with these two kinds of eligible offsets projects. Emissions avoidance offsets projects are assigned several categories. Broadly, sequestration offsets projects are designed to remove carbon dioxide from the atmosphere, and emissions avoidance offsets projects are designed to avoid the emission of greenhouse gases into the atmosphere. It is worthwhile setting out ss 53, 53A and 54:53 Emissions avoidance offsets projects(1)For the purposes of this Act, a project is an emissions avoidance offsets project if it is:(a) an agricultural emissions avoidance project; or(b) a landfill legacy emissions avoidance project; or(c) any other project to avoid emissions of greenhouse gases.(2) Paragraphs (1)(a) and (b) do not limit paragraph (1)(c).(3)For the purposes of this Act, a project is not an emissions avoidance offsets project if the project is a sequestration offsets project.53A Area‑based emissions avoidance projects(1)For the purposes of this Act, an emissions avoidance offsets project is an area‑based emissions avoidance project if it is a project of a kind specified in the legislative rules.(2)Subsection (1) does not, by implication, affect the application of subsection 13(3) of the Legislation Act 2003 to another instrument under this Act.54 Sequestration offsets projectsFor the purposes of this Act, a project is a sequestration offsets project if it is a project:(a)to remove carbon dioxide from the atmosphere by sequestering carbon in one or more of the following:(i) living biomass;(ii) dead organic matter;(iii) soil; or(b)to remove carbon dioxide from the atmosphere by sequestering carbon in, and to avoid emissions of greenhouses gases from, one or more of the following:(i) living biomass;(ii) dead organic matter;(iii) soil.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The parties may wish to consider whether any further or other orders are appropriate on the cross-claim. If none are proposed, the cross-claim will be listed for case management hearing at a date to be fixed.CONCLUSION There will be orders dismissing the applicant’s judicial review application, and answering the separate question. Given the conclusions I have reached, it is clear there should be a costs order in favour of the respondents on the judicial review application. Since the answer to the separate question does not dispose of the proceeding, and raises a single question of law, I do not consider it is appropriate to make any orders for costs in relation to the determination of that question. If any party wishes to be heard on a different form of costs order, that party can apply to vacate the costs order on the separate question and the Court will hear submissions on what other order is contended to be appropriate.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Section 27 of the CFI Act provides:27 Declaration of eligible offsets projectScope(1)This section applies if an application under section 22 has been made for a declaration of an offsets project as an eligible offsets project.Declaration(2)After considering the application, the Regulator may, by writing, declare that the offsets project is an eligible offsets project for the purposes of this Act.(3) A declaration under subsection (2) must:(a) identify the name of the project; and(b)if the project is an area‑based offsets project—identify, in accordance with the regulations or the legislative rules, the project area or project areas; and(c) identify the project proponent for the project; and(ca) identify the applicable methodology determination for the project; and(cb) identify the crediting period or periods for the project; and(d)identify such attributes of the project as are specified in the regulations or the legislative rules; and(e) if:(i) the project is a sequestration offsets project; and(ii)the application included a request that the project be treated as a 100‑year permanence period project;declare that the project is a 100‑year permanence period project; and(f) if:(i) the project is a sequestration offsets project; and(ii)the application included a request that the project be treated as a 25‑year permanence period project;declare that the project is a 25‑year permanence period project.Criteria for declaration(4)The Regulator must not declare that the offsets project is an eligible offsets project unless the Regulator is satisfied that:(a) the project is, or is to be, carried on in Australia; and(b) the project is covered by a methodology determination; and(c)the project meets such requirements as are set out in the methodology determination in accordance with paragraph 106(1)(b); and(d)the project meets the additionality requirements set out in subsection (4A) of this section; and(e) the applicant is the project proponent for the project; and(f) the applicant passes the fit and proper person test; and(g)if the project is a sequestration offsets project—the project area, or each project area, meets the requirements set out in subsection (5) of this section; and(l)the project meets the eligibility requirements (if any) specified in the regulations or the legislative rules; and(m) the project is not an excluded offsets project.Note 1: Methodology determinations are made under section 106.Note 2: For the fit and proper person test, see section 60.Note 3: For excluded offsets project, see section 56.(4A) The additionality requirements mentioned in paragraph (4)(d) are:(a) either:(i)the requirement (the newness requirement) that the project has not begun to be implemented; or(ii)if the methodology determination that covers the project specifies, for the purposes of this subparagraph, one or more requirements that are expressed to be in lieu of the newness requirement—those requirements; and(b) either:(i)the requirement (the regulatory additionality requirement) that the project is not required to be carried out by or under a law of the Commonwealth, a State or a Territory (other than the National Greenhouse and Energy Reporting Act 2007); or(ii)if the methodology determination that covers the project specifies, for the purposes of this subparagraph, one or more requirements that are expressed to be in lieu of the regulatory additionality requirement—those requirements; and(c) either:(i)the requirement (the government program requirement) that the project would be unlikely to be carried out under another Commonwealth, State or Territory government program or scheme in the absence of a declaration of the project as an eligible offsets project; or(ii)if the legislative rules specify, for the purposes of this subparagraph, one or more requirements that are expressed to be in lieu of the government program requirement—those requirements.(4B)For the purposes of subparagraph (4A)(a)(i), in determining whether the project has begun to be implemented, disregard any of the following activities that have been, or are being, undertaken in relation to the project:(a) conducting a feasibility study for the project;(b) planning or designing the project;(c) obtaining regulatory approvals for the project;(d) obtaining consents relating to the project;(e) obtaining advice relating to the project;(f) conducting negotiations relating to the project;(g) sampling to establish a baseline for the project;(h) an activity specified in the legislative rules;(i) an activity that is ancillary or incidental to any of the above activities.(4C)For the purposes of subparagraph (4A)(a)(i), the following are examples of when a project has begun to be implemented:(a) making a final investment decision in relation to the project;(b)acquiring or leasing a tangible asset (other than land) that is for use wholly or mainly for the purposes of the project;(c) commencing construction work for the purposes of the project;(d)in the case of a sequestration offsets project—preparing soil for seeding or planting that is for the purposes of the project;(e)in the case of a sequestration offsets project—seeding, planting or fertilising plants that are for the purposes of the project;(f)in the case of a sequestration offsets project—installing an irrigation or drainage system for the purposes of the project.(4D)For the purposes of paragraph (4C)(a), final investment decision has the meaning generally accepted within the corporate finance community.(4E) For the purposes of paragraph (4C)(b), disregard an asset that is a minor asset.(5) The requirements mentioned in paragraph (4)(g) are:(a) the project area is Torrens system land or Crown land; and(b)the project area is not specified in the regulations or the legislative rules.Note: For specification by class, see subsection 13(3) of the Legislation Act 2003.(10) The Regulator must not make a declaration under subsection (2) if:(a) the project is an area‑based offsets project; and(b)the project area is, or any of the project areas are, to any extent subject to a carbon maintenance obligation.(11)The Regulator must not make a declaration under subsection (2) in relation to a project (the new project) if:(a)a notice was given under section 88, 89, 90 or 91 in relation to a project (the prior project) that is or was:(i) an eligible offsets project; and(ii) a sequestration offsets project; and(aa) the new project is an area‑based offsets project; and(b)the project area, or any of the project areas, for the new project was or were identified in the relevant section 27 declaration as the project area or project areas for the prior project; and(c)the notice required a person to relinquish a particular number of Australian carbon credit units; and(d)the person did not comply with the requirement within 90 days after the notice was given; and(e)the penalty payable under section 179 in respect of the non‑compliance with the requirement (including any late payment penalty payable under section 180 in relation to the section 179 penalty) has not been paid in full.Timing(14)The Regulator must take all reasonable steps to ensure that a decision is made on the application:(a)if the Regulator requires the applicant to give further information under subsection 24(1) in relation to the application—within 90 days after the applicant gave the Regulator the information; or(c) otherwise—within 90 days after the application was made.When a declaration takes effect(15) A declaration under subsection (2) takes effect when it is made.Notification of declaration(17)As soon as practicable after making a declaration under subsection (2), the Regulator must give a copy of the declaration to:(a) the applicant; and(b)if the declaration relates to a sequestration offsets project—the relevant land registration official.Refusal(18)If the Regulator decides to refuse to declare the offsets project as an eligible offsets project, the Regulator must give written notice of the decision to the applicant.Declaration is not legislative instrument(20) A declaration made under subsection (2) is not a legislative instrument.