Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union v Fair Work Ombudsman (The Botany Cranes Case)

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union v Fair Work Ombudsman (The Botany Cranes Case) [2023] FCAFC 40

Appeal from:

ABCC v CFMMEU (No 3) (The Botany Cranes Case) [2021] FCA 363

ABCC v CFMMEU (The Botany Cranes Case) (No 4) [2021] FCA 525

File number: NSD 579 of 2021
Judgment of: BROMBERG, MOSHINSKY AND BROMWICH JJ
Date of judgment: 15 March 2023
Catchwords: INDUSTRIAL LAW – pecuniary penalties – where the ABCC brought proceedings against one union respondent and several individual respondents for contravention of the Building and Construction Industry (Improving Productivity) Act 2016 (Cth) – where the case was narrowed following mediation – where the union and the remaining respondents (four officials of the union) admitted contravening provisions of the Act in relation to (among other things) a picket – whether, in circumstances where the four officials engaged in a single unlawful picket, and their conduct was taken to have been engaged in also by the union, the union committed four contraventions of each relevant provision or only one contravention of each relevant provision – whether the officials and the union were liable for more than one pecuniary penalty for the contraventions of ss 47 and 52 of the Act or only one pecuniary penalty – whether the primary judge imposed penalties based on intent to coerce as distinct from intent to apply undue pressure – appeal allowed in part
Legislation:

Building and Construction Industry Improvement Act 2005 (Cth), ss 38, 44, 49

Building and Construction Industry (Improving Productivity) Act 2016 (Cth), ss 5, 38, 47, 52, 54, 81, 83, 84, 91, 92, 94, 95

Conciliation and Arbitration Act 1904 (Cth), ss 44, 45

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth), s 191

Fair Work Legislation Amendment (Secure Jobs, Better Pay) Act 2022 (Cth)

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), ss 348, 355, 500, 546, 556, 557, 793

Cases cited:

Ah Toy v Registrar of Companies for the Northern Territory (1985) 10 FCR 280

Aldi Foods Pty Ltd v Moroccanoil Israel Ltd [2018] FCAFC 93; 261 FCR 301

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Australian Workers’ Union [2021] FCA 861; 308 IR 195

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Automotive, Food, Metals, Engineering, Printing and Kindred Industries Union (The Australian Paper Case) (No 2) [2017] FCA 367

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union (The Constitution Place Case) [2020] FCA 1070; 299 IR 231

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union (The Kiama Aged Care Centre Case) [2021] FCA 920; 309 IR 353

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union [2018] HCA 3; 262 CLR 157

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union [2017] FCAFC 113; 254 FCR 68

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Hall (2018) FCAFC 83; 216 FCR 347

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Pattinson [2022] HCA 13; 399 ALR 599

Australian Competition and Consumer…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union v... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCAFC 40
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union (CFMMEU) and several of its officials were found to have contravened the Building and Construction Industry (Improving Productivity) Act 2016 (Cth) by engaging in unlawful picketing activities. The Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia was asked to consider the legal issues surrounding the number of contraventions committed, the liability for multiple pecuniary penalties, and the basis upon which penalties were imposed. The court had to decide whether the CFMMEU and the officials had committed multiple contraventions for a single unlawful picket, and if they were liable for multiple pecuniary penalties for the breaches of specific sections of the Act. Additionally, the court needed to determine whether the penalties were correctly imposed based on the intent to coerce rather than the intent to apply undue pressure.

The court found that the CFMMEU and the officials were liable for one contravention for each relevant provision, not multiple contraventions for the single unlawful picket. It also held that the penalties were imposed on the basis of intent to apply undue pressure, not intent to coerce. The court found errors in the primary judge’s assessment of cooperation and the consideration of personal payment orders. Consequently, the court set aside certain orders made by the primary judge and re-exercised the penalty discretion. The penalties imposed were adjusted to be paid by the CFMMEU and the officials to the Commonwealth of Australia within specified timeframes. Personal payment orders were also modified to prohibit any financial benefit from the CFMMEU for the penalties imposed on certain officials.

The court allowed the appeal in part, setting aside certain orders and re-exercising the penalty discretion. It ordered the CFMMEU and the officials to pay pecuniary penalties to the Commonwealth within specified timeframes. Personal payment orders were modified to prohibit any financial benefit from the CFMMEU for the penalties imposed on certain officials. The issue of costs was to be dealt with on the papers.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be allowed.

2. Paragraphs 15, 16(a), 16(b), 16(d), 17, 18, 19(a), 19(c), 19(d), 20, 21, 22 and 23 of the orders made by the primary judge on 19 May 2021 be set aside and in lieu thereof it be ordered that:

(a) within 28 days of these orders, the First Appellant (CFMMEU) pay to the Commonwealth of Australia a pecuniary penalty of:

(i) $190,000 for its contravention of s 47(1) of the Building and Construction Industry (Improving Productivity) Act 2016 (Cth) (BCIIP Act) on 25 January 2019; and

(ii) $150,000 for its contravention of s 54 of the BCIIP Act on 31 January 2019 and 1 February 2019.

(b) within 90 days of these orders, the Second Appellant (Mr Kera) pay to the Commonwealth of Australia a pecuniary penalty of $35,000 for his contravention of s 47(1) of the BCIIP Act on 25 January 2019.

(c) within 90 days of these orders, the Third Appellant (Mr Michael Greenfield) pay to the Commonwealth of Australia a pecuniary penalty of:

(i) $25,000 for his contravention of s 47(1) of the BCIIP Act on 25 January 2019; and

(ii) $18,000 for his contravention of s 54 of the BCIIP Act on 31 January 2019 and 1 February 2019.

(d) within 90 days of these orders, the Fourth Appellant (Ms Mallia) pay to the Commonwealth of Australia a pecuniary penalty of $15,000 for her contravention of s 47(1) of the BCIIP Act on 25 January 2019.

(e) within 90 days of these orders, the Fifth Appellant (Mr Byrnes) pay to the Commonwealth of Australia a pecuniary penalty of $3,500 for his contravention of s 47(1) of the BCIIP Act on 25 January 2019.

(f) each of the pecuniary penalties required to be paid by Mr Kera, Mr Michael Greenfield and Ms Mallia by these orders, shall be paid by that person personally in that he or she shall not, whether before or after the payment of the penalty:

(i) seek to have or encourage the CFMMEU in any way whatsoever, directly or indirectly, to pay him or her or for his or her financial benefit in any way whatsoever, any money or financial benefit referable to the payment of the penalties, whether in whole or in part; and

(ii) accept or receive from the CFMMEU in any way whatsoever, directly or indirectly, any money or financial benefit referable to the payment of the penalties, whether in whole or in part.

3. Within seven days of these orders, each party file and serve a written submission (of no more than three pages) on costs.

4. Within 14 days of these orders, each party file and serve any responding written submission (of no more than two pages) on costs.

5. Subject to further order, the issue of costs be dealt with on the papers.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The parties accepted that, if and to the extent that the appeal were successful, it would be appropriate for the Full Court to re-exercise the discretion to impose penalties (rather than this aspect being remitted). We have, therefore, re-exercised the discretion to impose penalties in relation to the relevant contraventions.Background and issues raised on appealThe period before 25 January 2019 From 2012, an enterprise agreement had covered Botany Cranes, its employees and the Union, with a nominal expiry date of 31 May 2015. In about February 2018, the Union began negotiating with Botany Cranes on behalf of its members who were employees with a view to arriving at terms for a replacement enterprise agreement. The Union provided Botany Cranes with its terms for a proposed enterprise agreement in February 2018. In about July 2018, the Union provided Botany Cranes with a further version of its proposed enterprise agreement (proposed Union EBA). The managing director of Botany Cranes, Mr Damian Griffiths, did not agree to or accept the proposed EBA. Other relevant employees of Botany Cranes included Ms Rhonda Hodges, operations manager, Mr Paul Hall, a mechanic, and Ms Tara Canin, a receptionist. In August 2018, Botany Cranes provided a copy of its proposed enterprise agreement to the Union. Botany Cranes’s employees voted to approve the proposed Union EBA on 23 August 2018. Botany Cranes’s non-acceptance of the proposed Union EBA was one of two industrial issues relevant to aspects of the contravening conduct. By 24 January 2019, Mr Griffiths had formed the view that Mr Byrnes was providing advance information to the Union about the location of sites at which Botany Cranes’s cranes were being used, thereby assisting the Union to interfere with its business. At about 1.00 pm that day, Mr Griffiths met with Mr Byrnes and told him that someone was tipping off the Union, to which Mr Byrnes responded with words to the effect “Maybe sign the EBA and it will stop”. Later that day, Mr Griffiths, not believing Mr Byrnes’s denial that he was sabotaging the business, terminated his employment with immediate effect. That termination was the second industrial issue relevant to aspects of the contravening conduct.25 January 2019 After the termination of Mr Byrnes’s employment on 24 January 2019, the Union circulated a text message to all its members, including Botany Cranes’s employees, calling upon them to attend the yard at Hale Street, Botany, to protest against that termination. A picket took place from about 5.30 am, with a group of about 50 members being assembled by about 6.45 am, with some, including Mr Kera, Michael Greenfield and Ms Mallia, wearing Union branded clothing. There was also present some 15 Union flags or banners. Some of the group blocked access to the yard. The group was addressed by each of Mr Kera, Michael Greenfield, Ms Mallia and Mr Byrnes as set out in the SOAF. Mr Kera was identified as being in charge. A number of NSW Police attended from 6.00 am. The bulk of the activity took place before about 9.00 am, but the picket continued with some members of the group until about 4.00 pm.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

We accept that extraordinary circumstances may justify the exercise of the discretion in s 546(3) in a manner different to that of the “usual order”. However, no such circumstances are either raised by the representations made by Ms Hodges, the NSW Police Force or Botany Cranes or are otherwise apparent. The only apparent purpose of the orders made by the primary judge in favour of Botany Cranes, Ms Hodges and the NSW Police Force is compensatory. As we have observed above by reference to long-standing authority, the use of s 81(5) for a compensatory purpose is inconsistent with the rationale governing the ordinary exercise of the discretion. We note in that respect that s 81(1)(b) of the Act empowers the Court to make an order “requiring the defendant to pay a specified amount to another person as compensation for damage suffered by the other person as a result of the contravention”. No such orders were sought in the proceeding below. It follows that we decline, in the exercise of discretion, to maintain this aspect of the penalty imposition approach taken by the primary judge and therefore will not remake orders for the payment of any part of the penalties to anyone other than the Commonwealth.Conclusion For these reasons, we set aside certain of the orders made by the primary judge and re-exercise the penalty discretion as set out above.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Michael Greenfield and the Union appeal against those penalties. In summary, they make the following contentions:(a)by grounds 14-16 of the amended notice of appeal, they contend that the penalties were imposed not only upon the basis of the admitted contravention (applying undue pressure as proscribed by s 54(1)), but also upon a more serious basis that was not pleaded or admitted, namely intention to coerce; further, they contend that there was no evidence of Michael Greenfield making, as found, “overbearing threats”; this is sought to be countered by the Commissioner’s notice of contention to the effect that, even if this error did occur, the penalties were nonetheless open to be imposed in the exercise of the penalty discretion;(b)by ground 22, they contend that there was no evidence that the contravening conduct was, as found by the primary judge, motivated by a desire by the Union not to run the risk of losing its appeal to the Full Bench of the Fair Work Commission regarding approval of the proposed Union EBA; and(c)by ground 28, they contend that the primary judge failed to take into account, as a mandatory relevant consideration under s 81(6)(b), that no loss or damage was suffered by Botany Cranes.Cooperation discount In the course of imposing the penalties summarised above, the primary judge found as follows in relation to the co-operation by the appellants at [114]:The Union is well-resourced and financially substantial, as is the branch. In pecuniary penalty proceedings, the Union frequently does what occurred in this proceeding; namely, agree facts so that the Court can impose penalties without requiring witnesses, including not only the persons adversely affected by contravening conduct but also the officials and members of the Union who engaged in that conduct, to give evidence. I accept that this has a benefit in avoiding the persons affected by the contravening conduct from having to give evidence in Court. But, in this case, that benefit occurred only after extensive interlocutory processes, in circumstances where, as the agreed facts, including the subpoenaed police video, revealed, there was no real prospect of a defence to the allegations of the contraventions on 25 January 2019, except perhaps as to the identity of the organiser, given what appeared to be Mr Kera’s role. By grounds 25 to 27, the appellants contend that the primary judge erred in this assessment of their co-operation by failing to take into account the public benefits of admissions and co‑operation, by taking into account an irrelevant consideration that there was no real prospect of a defence to the 25 January 2019 contraventions, and by failing to take into account as a relevant consideration that the resolution of the contraventions post-25 January 2019 were not the subject of police video or other objective evidence.Personal payment orders Additionally, the primary judge ordered that all of the penalties ordered to be paid by Mr Kera and Ms Mallia, $65,000 of the penalties to be paid by Michael Greenfield, and $3,500 of the penalties to be paid by Mr Byrnes, be paid by them personally without seeking or accepting any contribution by the Union. In the case of Mr Byrnes, this order was not sought by the Commissioner.