Details
- Case
- [2023] FedCFamC2G 413
- Decision Date
-
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The case of Chen v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs concerns the judicial review of a decision by the Migration Review Tribunal to dismiss Ms Chen's application to review the refusal of a Student Visa. Ms Chen, a Chinese national, had a history of studying in Australia and had applied for a Student Visa to study a Diploma of Leadership and Management. Her application was refused on the basis that the delegate was not satisfied she intended to stay in Australia temporarily. Ms Chen applied for review of the decision, but did not attend the scheduled hearing due to illness. The Tribunal dismissed her application and confirmed the delegate's decision after she failed to apply for reinstatement within the specified period.
The legal issues in this case revolve around whether the Tribunal's decision to dismiss Ms Chen's application and the subsequent confirmation of the delegate's decision were legally sound. Specifically, Ms Chen argued that the Tribunal failed to provide clear instructions about the sufficiency of the medical evidence required for a hearing postponement, which deprived her of the opportunity to present her case. Additionally, she contended that the Tribunal's dismissal and confirmation decisions were unreasonable and invalid due to the alleged procedural errors.
The court considered the submissions of both parties and reviewed the applicable statutory provisions. The Minister argued that the Tribunal exercised its discretion reasonably and provided Ms Chen with adequate instructions about the required medical evidence. The Minister also submitted that the Tribunal's decision to dismiss and confirm was valid as it complied with the statutory requirements, including providing Ms Chen with a written statement and the opportunity to apply for reinstatement. The court found that the Tribunal did not commit a material jurisdictional error by dismissing Ms Chen's application. The Tribunal had made attempts to contact Ms Chen and offered a telephone hearing, but Ms Chen did not provide a detailed medical certificate as advised. Furthermore, the court held that the Tribunal did not deprive Ms Chen of the opportunity to appear as it had provided clear instructions and options for her to participate in the hearing.
In conclusion, the court dismissed Ms Chen's Judicial Review Application, finding that the Tribunal's decision to dismiss her review application and confirm the delegate's decision was legally sound. The court did not identify any material jurisdictional error in the Tribunal's actions, and therefore, the decisions under review were upheld.
Background
Background to the litigation
Ms Chen filed an affidavit (“Chen Affidavit”) together with the Judicial Review Application. An affidavit affirmed by Mr Cameron Retallick (“Retallick Affidavit”) was filed on behalf of the Minister on 24 May 2022.BACKGROUND The relevant background to the matter is as follows:(a)Ms Chen is a citizen of China who first arrived in Australia on 15 February 2005 as the holder of a TU571 student visa, a visa granted on her enrolment in high school in Australia: CB 71;(b)Ms Chen was subsequently granted a further TU571 visa to enable her to complete high school and Ms Chen thereafter held the following further student visas:(i)TU573 granted on 19 April 2007;(ii)TU572 granted on 27 May 2010;(iii)TU572 granted on 12 April 2011;(iv)TU573 granted on 6 October 2011;(v)TU573 granted on 2 October 2013;(vi)TU573 granted on 28 April 2014;(vii)TU573 granted on 6 October 2015;(viii)TU573 granted on 19 February 2016; and(ix)TU500 granted on 9 September 2016: CB 71;(c)as detailed in the Provider Registration and International Student Management System Ms Chen’s record demonstrates she has completed or attended the following courses of study:(i)Secondary School, 2005-2006;(ii)Diploma of International Business, 2009-2011;(iii)Bachelor of Business, 2013; and(iv)Master of Professional Accounting, 2015-2017: CB 71;(d)on 13 March 2017 Ms Chen applied for the Student Visa to study a Diploma of Leadership and Management with a prospective visa grant until 23 March 2018: CB 71;(e)on 8 June 2017 the Delegate’s Decision was to refuse to grant the Student Visa: CB 69-76, on the basis that Ms Chen did not meet the criteria in cl 500.212(a) of the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) in that the Delegate was not satisfied that Ms Chen intended genuinely to stay temporarily in Australia: CB 74;(f)on 23 June 2017 Ms Chen applied to the Tribunal for review of the Delegate’s Decision: CB 77-78;(g)on 14 August 2019 the Tribunal wrote to Ms Chen’s migration agent inviting Ms Chen to attend a hearing (“Tribunal Hearing” and “Tribunal Hearing Invitation” respectively) on 27 September 2019: CB 84-90;(h)on 19 August 2019 Ms Chen’s migration agent returned the completed Tribunal Hearing Invitation response to the Tribunal stating that Ms Chen would attend the Tribunal Hearing with her husband, but not her migration agent: CB 91-95;(i)on the morning of 27 September 2019: (i)Ms Chen contacted the Tribunal at 9.42am to advise that she could not attend the Tribunal Hearing “as she was unwell and was going to the doctor”. Ms Chen was asked by a Tribunal staff member that she provide a written request for postponement of the Tribunal Hearing and “a doctor’s certificate” before the Tribunal Hearing at 10:30am which Ms Chen said she would do. Ms Chen was told that the Tribunal would be advised that she would not be attending: CB 115;(ii)the Tribunal contacted Ms Chen’s migration agent who stated he did not know if Ms Chen was attending the Tribunal Hearing as he had not spoken to her, and he advised that he would try and contact Ms Chen and advise the Tribunal as soon as possible: CB 115;(iii)Ms Chen then emailed the Tribunal with a “Certificate for Personal Leave” completed by a pharmacist (“Pharmacist’s Certificate”): CB 114, which was relevantly in the following terms:CERTIFICATE FOR PERSONAL LEAVEThis certificate is to certify that on 27/09/19, Shuyin Chen 23/06/19 of [address omitted], adelaide SA 5000 presented at this pharmacy.In my professional opinion, based on the information provided to me at the time, they will be unfit to attend work for the period commencing 27/09/19 until 27/09/19 inclusive.This opinion was provided in my capacity as a pharmacist for the purpose of informing the employer of the named person that they are unfit for work due to illness/injury (cross one out) This certificate was provided in accordance with the evidence requirements under section 107(3) of the Fair Work Act 2009 by:Shao Shin Chan (PHA: [number omitted])[pharmacy stamp]Central Market AdelaideSigned: [signature omitted] Date: 27/09/19(iv)an email from the Tribunal was sent to Ms Chen’s migration agent by the Tribunal at 10.47am which noted that:(A)Ms Chen had contacted the Tribunal that morning regarding the Tribunal Hearing at 10.30am and that she had advised that she was unwell and would not be able to attend;(B)Ms Chen had stated that she was attending the doctor that morning and would provide a medical certificate before the commencement of the Tribunal Hearing to support her request for postponement;(C)the Tribunal Hearing could proceed as a teleconference if Ms Chen was unable to attend in person;(D)Ms Chen’s migration agent had advised the Tribunal staff member that he had not spoken to Ms Chen and that he would attempt to contact her; (E)if the Tribunal was to consider a postponement due to illness the Tribunal advised that a detailed medical certificate which clearly states that Ms Chen was too sick to attend the Tribunal Hearing in person, and not just saying that Ms Chen was ill, was required; and(F)as Ms Chen’s migration agent had been advised on the telephone, it should not be assumed that the Tribunal Hearing would be postponed and unless the Tribunal agreed to the postponement, the Tribunal Hearing would proceed as scheduled: CB 120, and(v)the Tribunal Dismissal Decision dismissing Ms Chen’s review application was made on the basis that Ms Chen failed to attend the Tribunal Hearing: CB 125-126, and was sent to Ms Chen’s migration agent by email at 3.55pm: CB121-124;(j)the Tribunal Dismissal Decision, made at 12.12pm on 27 September 2019: CB 126, noted that:(i)Ms Chen was invited to appear at the Tribunal Hearing and that the Tribunal Hearing Invitation stated that if Ms Chen did not attend the Tribunal Hearing, the Tribunal may dismiss the review application without any further consideration of the application or the information before it: CB 125 at [1];(ii)the Tribunal Hearing Invitation was sent to Ms Chen’s migration agent by email dated 14 August 2019: CB 125 at [2];(iii)Ms Chen’s migration agent sent the Tribunal an email on 19 August 2019 attaching the Tribunal Hearing Invitation and advising that Ms Chen would require the assistance of a Mandarin interpreter and that both Ms Chen and her husband would attend: CB 125 at [3];(iv)at about 9:40am on the morning of the Tribunal Hearing Ms Chen contacted the Tribunal to say she could not attend the hearing due to illness, and that she was asked to provide a written request to postpone the Tribunal Hearing and a medical certificate in support of her request prior to the start of the Tribunal Hearing at 10:30am, which Ms Chen said she would do: CB 125 at [4];(v)a Tribunal staff member later attempted to contact Ms Chen by telephone to offer a telephone hearing but Ms Chen’s telephone did not accept incoming calls: CB 125 at [5];(vi)the Tribunal then contacted Ms Chen’s migration agent by telephone and Ms Chen’s migration agent was told that Ms Chen should not assume that the review application would be postponed and Ms Chen’s migration agent was offered the option for the Tribunal Hearing to proceed by telephone. The Tribunal advised Ms Chen’s migration agent that a medical certificate simply stating that Ms Chen is unwell may not suffice to secure a postponement and that any medical certificate provided should be a detailed medical certificate that clearly states that Ms Chen is too sick to attend the Tribunal Hearing and not merely saying that she is ill: CB 125 at [6];(vii)under cover of an email of 27 September 2019 at 10:23am the Tribunal received the Pharmacist’s Certificate “that was prepared for the stated purpose of “… informing the employer of the named person that they are unfit for work due to illness/injury (cross one out)””: CB 126 at [7] (and the Court notes that neither option was crossed out);(viii)the Pharmacist’s Certificate does not indicate:(A)whether Ms Chen was suffering from an illness or from an injury, and only says that Ms Chen would be unfit to attend work for one day being the day of the Tribunal Hearing: CB 126 at [8]; and(B)what activities Ms Chen was incapable of performing, and whether she was capable of attending the Tribunal Hearing, and if not whether she was capable of attending the Tribunal Hearing by telephone: CB 126 at [9];(ix)Ms Chen did not appear before the Tribunal on the day and at the scheduled time and place of the Tribunal Hearing, and that having reviewed the Tribunal file, the Tribunal was satisfied that Ms Chen was properly invited to the Tribunal Hearing in accordance with s 379A(5) of the Migration Act and that the Tribunal Hearing Invitation had not been returned to sender: CB 126 at [10];(x)no satisfactory reason had been given for Ms Chen’s non-appearance: CB 126 at [11]; and(xi)in the circumstances, the Tribunal decided to dismiss the review application without further consideration of that application or the information before the Tribunal: CB 126 at [12];(k)following the Tribunal Dismissal Decision on 27 September 2019 at 3.55pm the Tribunal emailed Ms Chen’s migration agent attaching the Tribunal Dismissal Decision, and advising that Ms Chen may apply to the Tribunal, in writing, for reinstatement of the review application by 11 October 2019: CB 121-126, and specifically that (emphasis in original):You may apply to us, in writing, for reinstatment of the application by 11 October 2019. In a reinstatement application you should set out why you failed to appear at the hearing and provide any other information you want the Tribunal to take into consideration when deciding whether your reinstatement application should be granted.(l)on 15 October 2019 Ms Chen’s migration agent was notified by the Tribunal of the Tribunal Confirmation Decision made on 14 October 2019: CB 128-131;(m)in the Tribunal Confirmation Decision the Tribunal:(i)set out the background to the Tribunal Confirmation Decision: CB 131 at [1];(ii)set out the circumstances that saw the Tribunal make the Tribunal Dismissal Decision: CB 131 at [2];(iii)set out the circumstances of the notification of the Tribunal Dismissal Decision: CB 131 at [3];(iv)noted that Ms Chen had not applied for reinstatement of the review application within the 14 days from the date of the Tribunal Dismissal Decision and that as a consequence the Tribunal must “confirm” the Tribunal Dismissal Decision, and be taken to have affirmed the Delegate’s Decision: CB 131 at [4]-[5]. JUDICIAL REVIEW APPLICATIONLitigation History
Decision
Reasons for decision
The Judicial Review Application was filed in the Adelaide Registry of this Court (then the Federal Circuit Court) on 4 November 2019. Given that more than three years have passed since then it is appropriate to set out the litigation history of the matter, which is as follows:(a)the matter was listed for a first court date on 20 December 2019 before a Registrar in the Adelaide Registry of the Court;(b)on 19 December 2019 a Registrar made consent orders, including orders that the matter be “listed” for both a final hearing on a date to be advised and a directions hearing on a date to be advised; (c)save for the filing by the Minister of a Court Book in January 2020, nothing further happened on the matter until May 2022 when it was allocated to the docket of the presiding Judge, in the Perth Registry of the Court;(d)on 19 May 2022 the parties were notified of a directions hearing on 25 May 2022 before the presiding Judge;(e)on 25 May 2022 the parties attended the directions hearing and orders (“May 2022 Orders”), including the following orders, were made:(i)Ms Chen to file and serve any amended Judicial Review Application, further affidavits and an outline of submissions by 27 September 2022;(ii)the Minister to file and serve any amended response, affidavits in reply, and an outline of submissions by 10 October 2022; and(iii)for a final hearing by video link on 26 October 2022 at 9.00am AWST/11.30am ACDST before the presiding Judge;(f)Ms Chen did not file any documents pursuant to the May 2022 Orders; and(g)on 6 October 2022 the Minister filed written submissions pursuant to the May 2022 Orders.Decision sought to be reviewed The Judicial Review Application expressly sets out that it is the Tribunal Confirmation Decision that is sought to be reviewed, it being the decision made on “14-Oct-2019”: CB 3; Judicial Review Application, p 2. Further, Ms Chen would need an extension of time to review the Tribunal Dismissal Decision, and the Judicial Review Application expressly provides that no order for an extension of time is sought: CB 3; Judicial Review Application, p 2.Grounds The grounds of the Judicial Review Application are as follows (reproduced unaltered):1.Pursuant to the Precedent cases of Li v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2017] FCCA 2326 (“Li”) and Lim v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2018] FCCA 496, I make this application the Federal Circuit Court, hoping the Court to consider the legal unreasonableness of the Tribunal’s decision under s 368B(1A)(b) ( the dismissal decision ) of the migration act 1958, and in turn, considering the decision made by the second respondent under s 362 B(1C) (b) is legally invalid.I believe the Tribunal did not act in compliance with s357A(3) of the Migration act , 1958 by failing to provide me with clear instruction about what the medical evidence was to be deemed sufficient when it comes to the request for the adjournment of the hearing.The second respondent’s violation of the relevant procedural fairness provision resulted me in being deprived of the opportunity to appear before the Tribunal to give evidence and present argument.Particulars2.I was invited to attend the hearing scheduled by the Tribunal on 27-Sep-2019; Due to stress or/and changeable weather, I developed a medical condition the night before. I phoned the Tribunal, informing the second respondent that I was not able to attend the Hearing because of illness on 27-Sep-2019 in the morning around 9.40.Over the phone, I was advised by a member of the Tribunal Registry, that I had to provide it with a medical certificate plus a written request to rescheduling the hearing, which I did. My husband Yang Li sent through my medical certificate via email at 10: 22 am (A copy of the cover of the email with the medical certificate attached is enclosed in annexure 1(a) and 1(b)) It has to be pointed out that the Tribunal, at that stage, did not make me aware of what needed to be specified in the medical certificate nor did the Tribunal warn or remind me of the fact if the certificate to be provided were not accepted, the Presiding Member may refuse to postpone the hearing and proceed the hearing by dismissing my application.Following the conservation with the officer of the Tribunal Registry, I went back to sleep as I was having sensations of light headedness and nausea caused by the illness.Unexpectedly, two and half hours later, the Tribunal dismissed my application at 12: 12pm. (A copy of the Tribunal decision to dismiss my application is attached in annexure 2(a) and 2(b)). I conceded, that the Tribunal, under s3 59(2) of the Migration Act, did make attempt to contact me about the insufficiency of the medical certificate tendered and was offering me a chance of participating in the hearing via telephone, shortly after the initial conversation. but unfortunately, by the time when I leant this, the Tribunal had already dismissed my application. (A copy of the cover of the email that I received from Hang Chen; my migration agent is enclosed in Annexure 3 (a) 3(b)). I assert that the Tribunal should have given me clear direction about how a medical certificate would be regarded sufficient for postponement of a hearing at the point where I made initial contact with the Tribunal. Failing to have done so constitutes a judicial error, and as such, the dismissal decision under s 368B(1A) (b) is legally unreasonable and affirming decision under s362 B (1C) (b) invalid. Retallick Affidavit
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Minister submitted that:(a)the Tribunal exercised its discretion to dismiss the application under s 362C of the Migration Act in a manner which was reasonable. The Tribunal provided an evident and intelligible justification for the Tribunal Dismissal Decision: Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v Li [2013] HCA 18; (2013) 249 CLR 332; (2013) 87 ALJR 618; (2013) 297 ALR 225; (2013) 138 ALD 181 (“Li”) at [76] per Hayne, Kiefel and Bell JJ, noting that:(i)the Tribunal had attempted to contact Ms Chen to offer a telephone hearing: CB 125 at [5];(ii)Ms Chen’s representative was advised that any medical certificate sought to be relied upon should provide details and state that Ms Chen is too sick to attend the Tribunal Hearing: CB 125 at [6]; and(iii)the Pharmacist’s Certificate did not indicate whether Ms Chen would be capable of attending the Tribunal Hearing, or a Tribunal Hearing by telephone: CB 126 at [8]-[9];(b)the Tribunal Dismissal Decision was valid: the Tribunal complied with s 362B(1A)(b) of the Migration Act by providing Ms Chen with a written statement under s 362C of the Migration Act. The Tribunal’s notification of the Tribunal Dismissal Decision: CB 123-124, complied with the requirements of s 362C of the MigrationAct because it:(i)provided Ms Chen with a copy of the written statement: Migration Act, s 362C(5);(ii)was sent to Ms Chen within 14 days of the date of the Tribunal Dismissal Decision: Migration Act, s 362C(5)(a);(iii)was sent to Ms Chen by one of the methods specified in s 379A of the Migration Act: Migration Act, s 362C(5)(b) - specifically, the notification of the Tribunal Dismissal Decision sent to Ms Chen by email to the last email address provided to the Tribunal in connection with the review: Migration Act, s 379A(5); and(iv)explained the effect of s 362B(1B)-(1F) of the Migration Act: Migration Act, s 362C(6). Specifically, the Tribunal’s latter dated 27 September 2019 sent to Ms Chen’s migration agent explained that Ms Chen could apply for reinstatement of the Student Visa review application by 11 October 2019, being 14 days from the date on which Ms Chen was taken to receive notice of the Tribunal Dismissal Decision under s 379C(5) of the Migration Act. The information sheet accompanying that letter explained the operation of s 362(1B)-(1F) of the Migration Act, including what would occur if Ms Chen applied for reinstatement, and that if Ms Chen failed to apply for reinstatement the Tribunal Dismissal Decision would be confirmed, and what would happen if the Tribunal confirmed the Tribunal Dismissal Decision;(c)although it was open to her to do so, Ms Chen made no application for the reinstatement of her review application within 14 days of being notified of the Tribunal Dismissal Decision. By operation of law, the Tribunal was therefore bound to confirm the Tribunal Dismissal Decision to dismiss the review application and affirm the Delegate’s Decision: Migration Act, s 362B(1E); (d)the Tribunal complied with s 357A(3) of the Migration Act. Contrary to Ms Chen’s claim that the Tribunal failed to provide clear instruction about what medical evidence would be deemed sufficient to obtain an adjournment, the Tribunal Decision: CB 125 at [6], discloses that the Tribunal advised Ms Chen’s migration agent that a detailed medical certificate would be required; and(e)the Tribunal did not deprive Ms Chen of the opportunity to appear: Ms Chen was given an opportunity to appear before the Tribunal, as evidenced by the Tribunal’s steps as outlined above. CONSIDERATION Material jurisdictional error required