Chappell v Goldspan Investments Pty Ltd [No 4]

Link copied
Case Copied 70 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CIVIL

CITATION:   CHAPPELL -v- GOLDSPAN INVESTMENTS PTY LTD [No 4] [2019] WASC 434

CORAM:   ALLANSON J

HEARD:   17-21, 24-26 SEPTEMBER 2018

DELIVERED          :   29 NOVEMBER 2019

FILE NO/S:   CIV 1597 of 2014

BETWEEN:   PAULA SUSAN CHAPPELL as executor of the estate of ROBERT HASTINGS HITCHCOCK

Plaintiff

AND

GOLDSPAN INVESTMENTS PTY LTD

First Defendant

KEVIN ROBINSON

Second Defendant

NEIL ROBINSON

Third Defendant

PETER ROBERT HALLAM

Fourth Defendant


Catchwords:

Where the plaintiff the executor of the estate of the late Robert Hitchcock who died after commencing proceedings but before trial

Contract - Where the deceased and three defendants parties to shareholders agreement - Where company required to provide information to shareholders - Where shareholders agreed to procure compliance by company - Whether company failed to provide regular reports to shareholders - Whether failure breach of shareholders agreement - Whether plaintiff suffered loss

Contract - Where deceased released company from liability under share buy back - Whether defendants can claim benefit of release

Contract - Release - Where first defendant held shares on behalf of deceased - Where deceased released first defendant from liability in connection with the shares - Whether release confined to claims relating to first defendant holding the shares as trustee

Equity - Fiduciary duties - Where deceased and three of four defendants parties to shareholders agreement - Whether shareholders agreement and other circumstances gave rise to fiduciary duty on defendants to disclose information where non-disclosure might prejudice interests of the deceased

Practice and procedure - Whether fiduciary duty case at trial consistent with pleadings

Estoppel - Whether plaintiff estopped by conduct of deceased from asserting fiduciary or contractual duties to disclose information - Whether deceased and defendants had proceeded on common underlying assumption intended to affect their legal relations - Whether deceased had induced defendants to assume that he no longer asserted his contractual or other rights to be provided with information - Whether requirements of good conscience would bind deceased to the assumptions pleaded

Misleading or deceptive conduct - Where deceased resident in United States of America - Where defendants provided deceased with information about financial position and prospects of company - Where deceased sold his 20% shareholding to company in share buy back for $1.15 million - Where deceased not advised that defendants negotiating for the sale of the company as a going concern for $16 million plus earn out payments over two years - Whether deceased accepted price and terms as a result of non-disclosure - Whether conduct of defendants misleading or deceptive

Unconscionable conduct under statute - Where plaintiff relied on deceased's special disability due to ill health - Whether special disability proved

Practice and procedure - Statutory construction - Whether plaintiff may bring action for statutory causes of action following death of deceased - Whether plaintiff a person who suffered loss or damage by conduct of defendants in contravention of statute

Legislation:

Australian Consumer Law, s 236, s 237
Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Chappell v Goldspan Investments Pty Ltd [No 4] and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] WASC 434
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Chappell v Goldspan Investments Pty Ltd [No 4] involved the executor of the estate of Robert Hitchcock, who brought proceedings against the defendants, including Goldspan Investments Pty Ltd, following Hitchcock's death. The primary issues were whether there was a breach of the shareholders agreement, the enforceability of a release, and fiduciary duties owed by the defendants. The court also considered whether the defendants engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct and unconscionable conduct under statute.

The court held that the company did not breach the shareholders agreement by failing to provide regular reports, as the agreement did not mandate such reporting. The release signed by Hitchcock did not apply to the first defendant holding shares on behalf of Hitchcock. The court found that the shareholders agreement and the circumstances did not impose fiduciary duties on the defendants to disclose information. The court also determined that Hitchcock's conduct did not estop him from asserting his contractual or other rights to be provided with information. There was no evidence of misleading or deceptive conduct by the defendants. Finally, the court found that the plaintiff did not prove Hitchcock's special disability due to ill health, and thus, the plaintiff could not rely on this for unconscionable conduct under statute.

The court ordered that the defendants were not liable for breach of the shareholders agreement, that the release did not apply to the first defendant, and that there were no fiduciary duties imposed by the shareholders agreement. The court further found that Hitchcock's conduct did not estop him from asserting his rights, and there was no misleading or deceptive conduct. Finally, the court ruled that the plaintiff could not rely on Hitchcock's special disability for unconscionable conduct, and the action for statutory causes of action could not proceed following Hitchcock's death.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 24 February 2010, Mr Hitchcock wrote again to Neil Robinson, advising that he needed another heart procedure, and saying:Decision time is NOW. The doctor advises me to get my affairs settled as this next procedure is much more risky.The sale of my stock is now imperative. Neil find a way to get this done.[106][106] TB 3363 (emphasis in original). On 2 March 2010, Mr Muir gave a further update (including to Mr Hitchcock) on the position in New Zealand in which he said that the Industrial Portfolio Manager of Energy For Industry 'is very keen to work closely with us, not only on the Whirinaki project but in all new projects and would like to meet with the directors of Ctec'.[107][107] TB 3399. On 15 March 2010, Mr Hitchcock again pressed his need to get the sale over with as soon as possible, suggesting the general terms be settled even if payment could not be made at that time.[108] He wrote to Mr Hallam and Mr Van Veen again on 17 March 2010.[109][108] TB 3451.[109] TB 3455. On 23 March 2010, Mr Hitchcock wrote that he needed $43,000 by 3 April 2010 for medical expenses. He further said, 'I would like to see at least a general Letter of Intent to buy my 20% stock. Amount, Terms of Payment, etc. can be shown to be negotiated at a later date'. [110] [110] TB 3457. On 30 March 2010, Neil Robinson wrote to Mr Hitchcock, regarding the sale of the shares, in these terms:We have spoken about the problem, and unfortunately we haven't reach a resolution yet. I think the only way forward is we draft a sale document, and proxy where we each represent 25% of your voting rights, as per my proposal last year,could you revisit that and let me know your thoughts, and let's get something down on paper in a formal manner,[111][111] TB 3460. Mr Hitchcock wrote again on 30 March 2010, that the 'approach is okay'.[112][112] TB 3461. On 26 April 2010, Mr Hitchcock told Neil Robinson and the others that his heart now had an electrical problem and that he was going into hospital for the implant of a pacemaker. He again said, 'I really need to get the process started to sell my share of the company'. [113][113] TB 3485. On 24 June 2010, Ms Warner advised the directors of CTEC that, from 2 July 2010, CTEC would be overdrawn. 'In an attempt to get through the next couple of months, we are holding back on all payments that are not deemed to be a threat to the completion of the [Kwinana] project.[114][114] TB 3571. On 30 June 2010, Mr Hitchcock advised Mr Robinson and the others that the doctors were going to try to do a pacemaker implant on 8 July.[115][115] TB 3581. On 10 July 2010, Mr Hitchcock advised that he was home after the pacemaker implant and all looked okay.[116][116] TB 3630. CTEC's outlook was not sound in the third quarter of 2010. On 14 July 2010, Ms Warner advised Mr Robinson about amounts outstanding for CTEC's creditors, where an invoice was overdue and the creditor had been requesting payment.[117][117] TB 3650. On 26 July 2010, Neil Robinson was advised of potential back charges on the Kwinana project of around $1 million.[118] He informed his fellow directors. [118] TB 3753.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.