Carbone v James McConvill and Associates Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 55 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Carbone v James McConvill and Associates Pty Ltd [2019] FCA 1305

File number(s): VID 1416 of 2018
Judge(s): COLLIER J
Date of judgment: 19 August 2019
Catchwords:  PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for self-executing orders – claim under Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) – Rules 5.21, 5.22 and 5.23 Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) – history of non-compliance with case management orders relating to filing of defence and discover orders – ongoing non-compliance – where non-compliance with case management orders may warrant self-executing orders – where potential controversy as to whether self-executing order triggered – whether further formal order by Court necessary – s 570 (2) Fair Work Act – whether indemnity costs should be awarded
Legislation:

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 340 (1)(a)(ii), 342 (1), 343, 535 and 536, 570, 570 (2)(b)

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 37M

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) rr 5.21, 5.22, 5.23, 16.58, 16.59, 20.11, 20.14

Legal Profession Uniform Law Application Act 2014 (Vic)

Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA) o 26 r 15

Cases cited:

Aon Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University [2009] HCA 27; (2009) 239 CLR 175

Banque Commerciale SA, En Liquidation v Akhil Holdings Limited [1990] HCA 11; (1990) 169 CLR 279

Commissioner of Taxation v Normandy Finance and Investments Asia Pty Ltd [2016] FCAFC 180; (2016) 344 ALR 589

Dey v Victorian Railways Commissioners [1949] HCA 1; (1949) 78 CLR 62

Esso Australia Resources v Commissioner of Taxation [1999] HCA 67; (1999) 201 CLR 49

Fisher v Westpac Banking Corporation Ltd (Unreported, Federal Court, French J, 9 February 1994)

Fuller v Toms [2012] FCAFC 155

General Steel Industries Inc v Commissioner for Railways (NSW) [1964] HCA 69; (1964) 112 CLR 125

Goodwill Group Pty Ltd v Pongrass Associates Pty Ltd [2002] FCA 1203

In the Marriage of G and G [1981] FamCA 38; (1981) 7 Fam LR 267

Jones v Toben (No 2) [2009] FCA 477

KerryJ Pty Ltd v Xiamen Fengwei Energy Technology Co Ltd [2013] FCA 361

Kowalski v MMAL Staff Superannuation Fund Pty Ltd [2009] FCAFC 117; (2009) 178 FCR 401

Lenijamar Pty Ltd v AGC (Advances) Ltd [1990] FCA 520; (1990) 27 FCR 388

Leonard Cohen & Co v Richardson [2005] WADC 172

Mudginberri Station Pty Ltd v the Australasian Meat Industry Employees Union [1985] FCA 330

NBGI v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs [2005] FCAFC 233; (2005) 147 FCR 565

O'Donoghue v State of Western Australia [2013] FCA 903

Re Tradestock Pty Ltd  Pty Ltd, Frewen and Stock v TNT (Management) Pty Ltd [1983] FCA 248

Richardson v Leonard Cohen & Co (A Firm) [2006] WASCA 64

Richens v Commonwealth of Australia (as represented by the Commissioner of Australian Federal Police) [2018] FCA 1276

Strategic Financial and Project Services Pty Limited v Bank of China [2012] FCA 701

Tenement Administration Services Pty Ltd v Hodson [2013] FCA 610

UBS AG…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Carbone v James McConvill and Associates Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FCA 1305
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mr Carbone applied for a self-executing order against the respondents, James McConvill and Associates Pty Ltd and Mr James McConvill, due to the respondents' repeated failure to comply with case management orders concerning discovery and the filing of a defence in accordance with the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth). Mr Carbone alleged various claims of unfair dismissal and other breaches of employment rights under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). The respondents argued that the application for self-executing orders was improper, as it might not provide them with an opportunity to be heard and lacked precise and unambiguous terms, citing the decision in NBGI v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs [2005] FCAFC 233. The court considered the serious implications of non-compliance with case management orders on the progress of litigation and the administration of justice, highlighting the importance of discovery and proper pleadings. The court ultimately decided to extend the compliance date for the respondents to 26 August 2019 and ordered that if the respondents did not comply, their further amended defence would be struck out, and judgment would be entered in favour of Mr Carbone. Additionally, Mr Carbone was required to file an application for a formal order concerning the discovery matter by 30 August 2019. The respondents were also ordered to pay Mr Carbone's costs of the interlocutory application and case management hearing on an indemnity basis.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The date for compliance by the Respondents with Orders 1 and 2 made by the Court on 16 July 2019 be extended to 4.00pm on 26 August 2019.

2. If the Respondents do not comply with Order 1 of these Orders:

(a) The Respondents’ Further Amended Defence be struck out; and

(b) Judgment be entered in favour of the Applicant.

3. The Applicant file any application for a formal Order giving effect to Order 2 of these Orders by 4.00pm on 30 August 2019.

4. The Respondents pay the Applicant’s costs of and incidental to this interlocutory application and the case management hearing on an indemnity costs basis, in a lump sum payment to be fixed by the Registrar and paid forthwith.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Essentially, Mr Carbone seeks a self-executing order (also known as a “springing” or “guillotine order”) against the respondents, in light of what he submits is repeated want of compliance with case management orders regarding discovery and the filing of a defence in this matter which complies with the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth).BACKGROUND FACTS On 29 October 2018 Mr Carbone filed an originating application under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (the Fair Work Act) alleging dismissal in contravention of s 340(1)(a)(ii) of the Fair Work Act. I understand that he had been a paralegal, and subsequently a lawyer, working for the first respondent James McConvill & Associates Pty Ltd. The principal of the first respondent is Mr James McConvill, who is the second respondent in these proceedings. Mr Carbone complains that he was dismissed because he made complaints or inquiries in relation to his employment which were exercises of workplace rights within the meaning of s 341. In his originating application those complaints or inquiries include raising ethical issues and practice management issues throughout his employment, raising outstanding unpaid fee share entitlements and reimbursement of expenses, raising concerns about his role answering telephones, reporting a workplace injury, complaining about discrimination and segregation, and complaining about false allegations about him. Mr Carbone also claims injury in his employment (being adverse action within the meaning of s 342(1) of the Fair Work Act), coercion not to exercise a workplace right within the meaning of s 343 of the Fair Work Act, and failure of the first respondent to provide him with pay slips or proper payslips contrary to ss 535 and 536 of the Fair Work Act. Mr Carbone filed a statement of claim on 25 January 2019, and subsequently another statement of claim on 22 February 2019. In summary, Mr Carbone claims that, at material times, Mr James McConvill was a partner in a law firm which conducted the legal practice in the name of James McConvill and Associates. The firm practises law in Melbourne. Mr Carbone also pleads, inter alia, that he was employed as a paralegal from February 2014 until March 2015 and, following his admission, as a lawyer by the firm from March 2015 until 1 July 2015 during which time Mr Carbone claims that he was not remunerated at the rate agreed by him and the second respondent. Mr Carbone pleads that from July 2015 until August 2016 he was employed as a lawyer by the first respondent in accordance with the terms of a written employment agreement executed by the parties on or about 8 August 2015, and from about August 2016 until 2 July 2018 in accordance with the terms of a new written employment agreement. The respondents have filed defences on 22 March 2019, 5 July 2019, 23 July 2019 and 26 July 2019 (the most recent version being a further amended defence which was filed at 4.37pm on 26 July 2019, meaning it was technically filed on 27 July 2019). The docket Judge in this matter is Justice Logan. His Honour has made numerous orders in these proceedings. In particular I note the following:·On 12 November 2018 his Honour ordered, inter alia, that pursuant to rr 20.11 and 20.14 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), the parties make discovery of documents on or before 15 March 2018 (order 3).·On 5 March 2019 his Honour ordered:1.The Applicant file and serve an Amended Statement of Claim on or before 22 February 2019.2.The Respondents file and serve a Defence on or before 22 March 2019.3.Pursuant to Rules 20.11 and 20.14 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), the parties make discovery of documents on or before 19 April 2019.4.The matter to be referred to Mediation and conducted by a Registrar of this Court on a date after 17 May 2019 but no later than 14 June 2019, subject to a Registrar’s availability.5.In the event that the matter does not settle at the conclusion of the initial Mediation, the matter be listed for a Case Management Hearing on the next available date.6.There be liberty to apply.7.There be no order as to costs·On 28 May 2019 his Honour ordered:1.The Applicant file and serve a Further Amended Statement of Claim on or before 14 June 2019.2.The Respondents file and serve an Amended Defence on or before 5 July 2019.3.The Applicant file and serve any reply to the Amended Defence on or before 12 July 2019.4.The Interlocutory Application filed 7 May 2019 is adjourned to a date to be fixed on or after 14 June 2019.5.There be liberty to apply.6.There be no order as to costs·On 28 June 2019 his Honour ordered:1.The Respondents make further discovery pursuant to Rules 20.11 and 20.14 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), including, but not limited to, the categories set out in the 12 June 2019 letter being Annexure ‘JAC1’ to the affidavit of Joseph Anthony Carbone affirmed 27 June 2019, on or before 12 July 2019.2.Order 4 of the Orders of the Court dated 5 March 2019 be varied so that the mediation be conducted by no later than 21 August 2019.3.The matter be listed for a Case Management Hearing at 10.15 am on 22 August 2019 with appearances by video link permitted subject to the availability of the link.4.The Respondents pay the Applicant’s costs of and incidental to the Interlocutory Application filed on 7 May 2019 and today’s Case Management Hearing, to be fixed in a lump sum by the Registrar and paid forthwith.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The authority of the Court in this case to make a self-executing order in the terms sought is questioned by the respondents to the extent that they submit that the order would deny them an opportunity to be heard, and further that terms of any such order would not be precise and unambiguous. They rely in particular on the decision of the Full Court in NBGI v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs [2005] FCAFC 233; (2005) 147 FCR 565. In that case the primary Judge had relevantly made an order in terms that if the appellant did not comply with the first order – which required him to file an amended application giving complete particulars of each ground of review being relied upon by 28 February 2005 – "the application will be automatically dismissed by [the Federal Magistrate] in Chambers." Black CJ observed:11.First, although the third order made by the Federal Magistrate – that in default of compliance with the first order, "the application will be automatically dismissed ... in Chambers" – bears some resemblance to a "self-executing" or "self-operating" order (see Broers v Forster [1981] FCA 111; (1981) 36 ALR 605 at 612-614 (Bowen CJ and Ellicott J), 620-621 (Deane J); Abalian v Innous [1936] 2 All ER 834; Reiss v Woolf [1952] 2 All ER 3; [1952] 2 QB 557), an order in these terms was inherently liable to cause trouble. A self-executing order should provide in precise and unambiguous terms that judgment may be entered on the occurrence or non-occurrence of a very clearly defined event. Being self-executing, such an order requires no further judicial intervention. This means, however, that if there could be a legitimate conflict of opinion about whether or not the event said to be the appropriate subject of such an order has in fact occurred, which could only be resolved by further adjudication, there will be no occasion for the making of a self-executing order. As Greene LJ (as he then was) said in Abalian v Innous (at 838):If an order is to be made in the form that, unless one party or another party does something the action will be dismissed, it is imperative that the thing to be done in order to avoid dismissal of the action should be specified in the clearest and most precise language, so that it may be possible for the party on whom the necessity of doing the act lies ... to be in no doubt whatsoever as to the steps which he is to take if he is to avoid his action being dismissed.12In the present case, the appellant was ordered to file, by 28 February 2005 an amended application giving complete particulars of each ground of review being relied upon. An amended application was filed within time on 8 February 2005. The Minister’s solicitors were, however, of the view that the amended application did not satisfy the terms of the order. This is plain from their letter of 2 March 2005. In his reasons, the Federal Magistrate noted that the amended application "purported" to comply with the earlier orders and, in a passage that reflects the submissions made to him, his Honour observed (at [14]):This document was not submitted in the proper Court form and did not give proper particulars of the grounds of review. The amended application merely cavilled with the evidentiary finding of the Tribunal and as such was seeking an impermissible merits review. The applicant’s individual grounds were not identified nor any particularisation supplied.To reach that conclusion, however, it was necessary to make an evaluation of the amended application and form an opinion as to whether it complied with the first order made by the Federal Magistrate. That order could not be said to be unambiguous, nor expressed with such clarity and precision that the appellant, particularly as he was a self-represented appellant, would have no doubt whatsoever about what was required to be in his amended application to avoid his case being summarily dismissed.13In these circumstances, it was wrong to dismiss the appellant’s application without giving him proper notice and an opportunity to be heard in opposition to that course. Moreover, a formal application should have been made to the Court. The letter sent by the respondent’s solicitors to the Federal Magistrate’s Chambers was an impermissible informality in these circumstances. Allsop J makes some observations, with which I agree, about the circumstance that the orders were made other than in open court.(Emphasis added.)

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The respondents submit further that:·The orders sought by the applicant are not in precise and unambiguous terms, and are not capable of being granted on a self-executing basis;·A self-executing order would deny the respondents an opportunity to be heard on the merits; and·The respondents have, in good faith, attempted to comply with the latest discovery order but have fallen short due to the ambiguous scope of the documents requested in JAC1.CONSIDERATION The case before me, and the orders sought, raise very serious issues relating to the progress of litigation in this Court and the administration of justice. The Court has made case management orders in these proceedings relating to discovery and the filing of a defence (which complies with the Federal Court Rules), with which the parties are required to comply. It is a public interest of the highest order that citizens have confidence that orders of the Court will be enforced (cf observations of Smithers J in Re Tradestock Pty Ltd Pty Ltd, Frewen and Stock v TNT (Management) Pty Ltd [1983] FCA 248; Lockhart J in Mudginberri Station Pty Ltd v the Australasian Meat Industry Employees Union [1985] FCA 330 at [6]; In the Marriage of G and G [1981] FamCA 38; (1981) 7 Fam LR 267 at [144]; Lander J in Jones v Toben (No 2) [2009] FCA 477 at [77]). In this respect:·Insofar as concerns compliance with discovery orders: as Kirby J observed in Esso Australia Resources v Commissioner of Taxation [1999] HCA 67; (1999) 201 CLR 49:107.The importance of discovery and of subpoenas for ensuring that parties, and thereby eventually courts, can gain access to relevant documents cannot be overstated. Quite apart from the documents themselves, and the matters which they reveal on their face, the lines of inquiry which they open up can often be crucial. The information secured in this way frequently means the difference between success and failure in litigation…(Emphasis added.)·Insofar as concerns filing of a defence: pleadings define the issue for trial and perform the function of ensuring that each party has a fair opportunity to meet the case which is put against it: Banque Commerciale SA En Liquidation v Akhil Holdings Limited [1990] HCA 11; (1990) 169 CLR 279 at 286; Fuller v Toms [2012] FCAFC 155 at [17]; Commissioner of Taxation v Normandy Finance and Investments Asia Pty Ltd [2016] FCAFC 180; (2016) 344 ALR 589 at [139] It is of the utmost importance that the respondents file a defence, complying with the Federal Court Rules, to enable the applicant to understand the case he is meeting. On the other hand, in this case the applicant seeks an order for strike out of the respondents’ defence and entry of judgment in his favour without further intervention by the Court. The Courts have consistently referred to the great caution which must be exercised in regard to summary determination of a case: see for example Dixon J in Dey v Victorian Railways Commissioners [1949] HCA 1; (1949) 78 CLR 62, Barwick CJ in General Steel Industries Inc. v. Commissioner for Railways (NSW) [1964] HCA 69; (1964) 112 CLR 125 and Kowalski v MMAL Staff Superannuation Fund Pty Ltd [2009] FCAFC 117; (2009) 178 FCR 401 at [25]-[26].