Goodwill Group Pty Ltd v Pongrass Associates Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Goodwill Group Pty Ltd v Pongrass Associates Pty Ltd [2002] FCA 1203

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – pleadings – directions – failure to comply with directions – self-executing order – requirement to file affidavit evidence in support of application – whether order complied with – sufficiency of evidence – criteria for assessment – summary dismissal – Order 20 – whether  reasonable cause of action – whether application frivolous or vexatious – partial compliance with self-executing order – no case disclosed as against one respondent – case dismissed as against one respondent – amendment – statement of claim – security for costs.

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) s 52

Fair Trading Act 1987 (NSW) s 42

FAI General Insurance Co Ltd v Southern Cross Exploration NL (1988) 165 CLR 268 

THE GOODWILL GROUP PTY LTD v PONGRASS ASSOCIATES PTY LIMITED AND OTHERS
N661 OF 1999

FRENCH J
26 SEPTEMBER 2002
PERTH


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

N661 of 1999

BETWEEN:

THE GOODWILL GROUP PTY LTD
ACN 056 258 201
Applicant

AND:

PONGRASS ASSOCIATES PTY LIMITED
ACN 070 660 954
First Respondent

PONGRASS INVESTMENTS GROUP PTY LIMITED
ACN 000 704 932
Second Respondent

MOUNTAIN SUNSET PTY LTD
ACN 053 954 582
Third Respondent

ACME AVALANCHE PTY LTD
ACN 058 604 907
Fourth Respondent

STEVEN PONGRASS
Fifth Respondent

STEPHEN CHARLES BERRY
Sixth Respondent

PETER GEORGE KENSEY
Seventh Respondent

JUDGE:

FRENCH J

DATE OF ORDER:

26 SEPTEMBER 2002

WHERE MADE:

PERTH

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

A.       On the Respondents’ amended notice of motion filed 12 July 2001 seeking dismissal of the application:

1.The application is dismissed as against the Fifth Respondent.

2.The Applicant is to pay the costs of the Fifth Respondent as taxed or agreed.

3.The motion is otherwise dismissed.

4.The costs of the motion as against the remaining respondents are the applicant’s costs in the proceedings.

B.       On the First, Second, Fourth and Fifth Respondents’ Motion filed 19 September 2001 for security for costs:

1.The Applicant is, on or before 24 October 2002, to provide security for the costs of the First, Second and Fourth Respondents of and incidental to these proceedings in the amount of $80,000 by way of bank guarantee to be deposited with the District Registrar at the New South Wales Registry of the Court or in such other form as is agreed between the parties, such security to be in addition to the security given by the Applicant pursuant to the order of Katz J made on 3 August 2000.

2.The costs of the motion be in the cause.

C.       On the Sixth and Seventh Respondents’ amended motion for security of costs filed 10 October 2001:

1.The Applicant is, on or before 24 October 2002, to provide security for the costs of the Sixth and Seventh Respondents of and incidental to these proceedings in the amount of $80,000 by way of bank guarantee to be deposited with the District Registrar at the New South Wales Registry of the Court…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Goodwill Group Pty Ltd v Pongrass Associates Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] FCA 1203
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Goodwill Group Pty Ltd v Pongrass Associates Pty Ltd, the parties were engaged in a commercial dispute related to an asset sale agreement. The applicant, Goodwill Group, sought damages from the respondents, including Pongrass Associates and other entities, alleging misrepresentation regarding the stock level and value of the purchased business. The case came before the court to decide several key issues, including whether the application should be dismissed, whether the statement of claim should be further amended, and whether additional security for costs should be provided by the applicant.

The court examined the legal issues surrounding the dismissal of the application, the need for further amendment to the statement of claim, and the requirement for additional security for the costs of the action. Affidavits from various parties, including solicitors and respondents, provided detailed accounts of the procedural history, delays, and financial implications of the litigation. The applicant argued that delays were due to the unavailability of key personnel and the missing stock audit report, while the respondents contended that the applicant's delays prejudiced them and warranted dismissal.

The court concluded that while some delays were attributable to the applicant, the application should not be dismissed outright. The court allowed the applicant to amend its statement of claim, subject to paying the respondents' costs incurred due to the amendment. Additionally, the court ordered the applicant to provide further security for the costs of the action, requiring a bank guarantee of $80,000 for each set of respondents, on top of the existing security.

The final orders included dismissing the application against one respondent, requiring the applicant to pay the dismissed respondent's costs, and allowing the amendment of the statement of claim with certain conditions. The applicant was also mandated to provide additional security for the costs of the action by a specified date. The matter was set for further directions to facilitate trial programming.

Orders

Orders of the court

A. On the Respondents’ amended notice of motion filed 12 July 2001 seeking dismissal of the application:

1. The application is dismissed as against the Fifth Respondent.

2. The Applicant is to pay the costs of the Fifth Respondent as taxed or agreed.

3. The motion is otherwise dismissed.

4. The costs of the motion as against the remaining respondents are the applicant’s costs in the proceedings.

B. On the First, Second, Fourth and Fifth Respondents’ Motion filed 19 September 2001 for security for costs:

1. The Applicant is, on or before 24 October 2002, to provide security for the costs of the First, Second and Fourth Respondents of and incidental to these proceedings in the amount of $80,000 by way of bank guarantee to be deposited with the District Registrar at the New South Wales Registry of the Court or in such other form as is agreed between the parties, such security to be in addition to the security given by the Applicant pursuant to the order of Katz J made on 3 August 2000.

2. The costs of the motion be in the cause.

C. On the Sixth and Seventh Respondents’ amended motion for security of costs filed 10 October 2001:

1. The Applicant is, on or before 24 October 2002, to provide security for the costs of the Sixth and Seventh Respondents of and incidental to these proceedings in the amount of $80,000 by way of bank guarantee to be deposited with the District Registrar at the New South Wales Registry of the Court or otherwise in such form as is agreed between the parties, such security to be in addition to the security given by the Applicant pursuant to the order of Katz J made on 3 August 2000.

2. The costs of the motion be in the cause.

D. Further Amended Statement of Claim:

1. The Applicant has leave to amend its statement of claim in the terms of the further amended statement of claim filed in Court on 6 September 2001.

2. The Applicant is to pay the Respondents’ costs thrown away by reason of the amendment.

3. Amended Defences are to be filed and served by 7 November 2002.

E. Directions

1. The parties are at liberty to apply for further and consequential directions.

2. The matter will be listed for further directions on 29 November 2002 at 9am EST with a view to programming to trial and fixing provisional trial dates.

3. At the relisted directions hearing the parties are to be aware of the availability of counsel and witnesses and be in a position to provide reliable estimates of time for trial on the basis that the matter may be listed for trial in March or April 2003.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The questions for decision are: 1(a)Whether the application stands dismissed by operation of the springing order of Katz J made on 1 May 2001.(b)Whether the application should be dismissed in whole of in part pursuant to the amended motion filed on 12 July 2001 on behalf of all respondents. 2.Whether, if the application is not dismissed, the statement of claim should be further amended pursuant to the amended notice of motion filed by the applicant on 26 July 2001.3.Whether, if the application is not dismissed, there should be an order for additional security for the costs of the action to be provided by the applicant pursuant to the motion of the Pongrass respondents and the amended motion of the sixth and seventh respondents respectively filed on 19 September 2001 and 10 October 2001.The Evidence Received in Relation to the Motions A number of affidavits were relied upon in relation to the various motions. They were as follows: A.Evidence put in by counsel for the Pongrass respondents, Mr Corsaro.(1)Affidavit of Ronald William Jarvin sworn 24 April 2001 (less par 63 which was not read).Jarvin is a member of the firm Prentice Jarvin, the solicitors for the Pongrass respondents. In his affidavit he set out a detailed interlocutory history of the proceedings and exchanges of correspondence with the applicant’s solicitors formerly Dibbs Crowthers & Osborne, now Dibbs Barker Gosling. A significant element of the correspondence related to attempts by the applicant’s solicitors to obtain a copy of a written stock audit/inventory said to have been initialled by the parties at the time of signing of the Asset Sale Agreement in July 1996. On 8 January 2001, the applicant’s solicitors advised Jarvin that their client would not be in a position to file and serve its evidence in chief until it had located a copy of the stock audit. In a letter dated 30 January 2001, the solicitors said: “As you are aware, the applicant’s case alleges that (inter alia) the level and value of the stock to be purchased was misrepresented to it by the respondents. Accordingly the stock audit needs to be considered before the applicant can complete its evidence in chief.” (2)Affidavit of Ronald William Jarvin sworn 1 May 2001. This affidavit annexed complete versions of documents, incomplete versions of which had been exhibited to the affidavit of 24 April 2001. [Annexures Q and CC](3)Affidavit of Steven Ronald Pongrass sworn 23 July 2001. In this affidavit Pongrass referred to the pleadings as they then stood. He noted that although the transaction under the Asset Sale Agreement was completed on 2 July 1996 he was only served with the application initiating these proceedings on 20 March 2000. He was unaware, prior to service of those documents upon him, of any allegation that the applicant had been misled. He noted also that the proceedings were filed three years to the day after the Asset Sale Agreement was finalised. He said he was funding the litigation for the Pongrass respondents as the companies involved had insufficient assets to pay the costs of the action. He referred to the prejudicial effects of the protracted proceedings on him in business circles and the time involved for him in instructing solicitors and counsel and also the effect on his family.(4)Second affidavit of Steven Ronald Pongrass sworn 23 July 2001. In this second affidavit Pongrass indicated that his legal costs to that date were $69,075.35. He was concerned that the amount of $80,000 lodged by way of security for costs would be insufficient. B.Evidence put in by counsel for Berry and Kensey – Ms R McColl SC(1)Affidavit of Alan William Blanch sworn 24 April 2001. Blanch is a partner in the firm Hickson Wisewoulds, the solicitors for Berry, the sixth respondent. Like Jarvin, he set out a detailed interlocutory history and exchanges of correspondence with the solicitors for the applicant. (2)Affidavit of Christopher Gordon Price sworn 30 April 2001 (filed in Court on 26 July 2001). Price is a solicitor employed by Hickson Wisewoulds, acting for Berry. He exhibited a letter dated 24 April 2001 from the applicant’s solicitors apologising for their failure to comply with the timetable for filing their client’s evidence. The delay was said, in the letter, to have arisen because of the late discovery by the Pongrass respondents of documents which had to be analysed by an expert accountant engaged by the applicant. Price said that this letter was the only communication he had received since a letter from his firm dated 26 March 2001 pointing out the applicant’s failure to comply with the Court’s timetable. (3)Affidavit of Christopher Price sworn 20 July 2001. This affidavit exhibited correspondence to the applicant’s solicitors seeking further and better particulars of the amended statement of claim on 30 May 2000 and 3 July 2000 and replies from the applicant’s solicitors of 21 June 2000 and 2 August 2000 respectively providing particulars.(4)Affidavit of Christopher Price sworn 25 July 2001. This affidavit referred to the $70,000 bank guarantee deposited with the Court as security for Berry’s costs. His legal costs to the date of swearing of the affidavit were approximately $64,794. If the statement of claim were further amended total legal costs would considerably exceed $70,000.C.Evidence put in by counsel for the applicant – Mr B Walker SC(1)Affidavit of Emma Jane Hodgman sworn 30 April 2001. Ms Hodgman is a solicitor employed by Dibbs Barker Gosling, the solicitors for the applicant. She deposed that at the time of swearing her affidavit the applicant had been unable to file or serve its evidence in chief because of delays in accessing and analysing documents sought from the solicitors for the Pongrass respondents. At the time of swearing the affidavit the applicant’s lay evidence was nearing completion and the expert accountant had prepared a preliminary report. (2)Affidavit of Emma Jane Hodgman sworn 22 May 2001. This affidavit was by way of a detailed reply to the affidavits of Blanch and Jarvin complaining of delays occasioned by the applicant. In this affidavit, Ms Hodgman identified as the reasons for delay in complying with the Court’s timetable: (a)the unavailability of the principal of the applicant (Bradley Cooper) to give instructions; (b)the missing stocktake report and the time spent trying to locate it; (c)recent delays in obtaining copies of tax returns from the Pongrass respondents for the applicant’s expert witnesses to analyse.Ms Hodgman attributed part of the delay to the time taken in dealing with the applications for security for costs. She gave a history of her attempts to locate the missing stocktake document. She asserted that the applicant would suffer prejudice if the claim were to be dismissed as it would be statute barred. The applicant had, at the time of her affidavit, spent $92,000 in legal fees on the matter. (3)Affidavit of Emma Jane Hodgman sworn 19 June 2001. In this affidavit Ms Hodgman annexed letters to the respondents dated 22 May 2001 which had enclosed copies of a proposed further amended statement of claim. Also annexed were letters in reply from the respondents’ solicitors dated 1 June 2001 and 4 June 2001. (4)Affidavit of Bradley David Cooper sworn 23 May 2001. In this affidavit Cooper said that the applicant is his nominee company through which he became a shareholder of Phoenix in May 1996. He also said he had been unable to locate a copy of the stocktake carried out on the business before it was purchased. This had caused delays. Delays had also been caused as a result of himself not being available to instruct his solicitors. He said he had been working extremely long hours on FAI Home Security Pty Ltd, of which he was Chief Executive Officer and Chairman.

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH J
A proposed further amended statement of claim was filed on 6 September 2001 and a motion by Berry and Kensey for security for costs on 19 September 2001. A motion by the Pongrass respondents for additional security in the amount of $150,000 was also filed on 19 September. An amended notice of motion was also filed on behalf of Berry and Kensey on 10 October seeking additional security in the sum of $150,000. The outstanding motions came before Katz J on 10 October and his Honour reserved his decision. In January 2002, his Honour resigned from the Court due to a serious illness. The matter was later transferred to my docket on the basis that I would decide the motions on the papers, including the transcript of oral argument before Katz J on 26 July and 10 October 2001. The Questions for Decision The questions for decision are: 1(a)Whether the application stands dismissed by operation of the springing order of Katz J made on 1 May 2001.(b)Whether the application should be dismissed in whole of in part pursuant to the amended motion filed on 12 July 2001 on behalf of all respondents. 2.Whether, if the application is not dismissed, the statement of claim should be further amended pursuant to the amended notice of motion filed by the applicant on 26 July 2001.3.Whether, if the application is not dismissed, there should be an order for additional security for the costs of the action to be provided by the applicant pursuant to the motion of the Pongrass respondents and the amended motion of the sixth and seventh respondents respectively filed on 19 September 2001 and 10 October 2001.The Evidence Received in Relation to the Motions A number of affidavits were relied upon in relation to the various motions. They were as follows: A.Evidence put in by counsel for the Pongrass respondents, Mr Corsaro.(1)Affidavit of Ronald William Jarvin sworn 24 April 2001 (less par 63 which was not read).Jarvin is a member of the firm Prentice Jarvin, the solicitors for the Pongrass respondents. In his affidavit he set out a detailed interlocutory history of the proceedings and exchanges of correspondence with the applicant’s solicitors formerly Dibbs Crowthers & Osborne, now Dibbs Barker Gosling. A significant element of the correspondence related to attempts by the applicant’s solicitors to obtain a copy of a written stock audit/inventory said to have been initialled by the parties at the time of signing of the Asset Sale Agreement in July 1996. On 8 January 2001, the applicant’s solicitors advised Jarvin that their client would not be in a position to file and serve its evidence in chief until it had located a copy of the stock audit. In a letter dated 30 January 2001, the solicitors said: “As you are aware, the applicant’s case alleges that (inter alia) the level and value of the stock to be purchased was misrepresented to it by the respondents. Accordingly the stock audit needs to be considered before the applicant can complete its evidence in chief.” (2)Affidavit of Ronald William Jarvin sworn 1 May 2001. This affidavit annexed complete versions of documents, incomplete versions of which had been exhibited to the affidavit of 24 April 2001. [Annexures Q and CC](3)Affidavit of Steven Ronald Pongrass sworn 23 July 2001. In this affidavit Pongrass referred to the pleadings as they then stood. He noted that although the transaction under the Asset Sale Agreement was completed on 2 July 1996 he was only served with the application initiating these proceedings on 20 March 2000. He was unaware, prior to service of those documents upon him, of any allegation that the applicant had been misled. He noted also that the proceedings were filed three years to the day after the Asset Sale Agreement was finalised. He said he was funding the litigation for the Pongrass respondents as the companies involved had insufficient assets to pay the costs of the action. He referred to the prejudicial effects of the protracted proceedings on him in business circles and the time involved for him in instructing solicitors and counsel and also the effect on his family.(4)Second affidavit of Steven Ronald Pongrass sworn 23 July 2001. In this second affidavit Pongrass indicated that his legal costs to that date were $69,075.35. He was concerned that the amount of $80,000 lodged by way of security for costs would be insufficient. B.Evidence put in by counsel for Berry and Kensey – Ms R McColl SC(1)Affidavit of Alan William Blanch sworn 24 April 2001. Blanch is a partner in the firm Hickson Wisewoulds, the solicitors for Berry, the sixth respondent. Like Jarvin, he set out a detailed interlocutory history and exchanges of correspondence with the solicitors for the applicant. (2)Affidavit of Christopher Gordon Price sworn 30 April 2001 (filed in Court on 26 July 2001). Price is a solicitor employed by Hickson Wisewoulds, acting for Berry. He exhibited a letter dated 24 April 2001 from the applicant’s solicitors apologising for their failure to comply with the timetable for filing their client’s evidence. The delay was said, in the letter, to have arisen because of the late discovery by the Pongrass respondents of documents which had to be analysed by an expert accountant engaged by the applicant. Price said that this letter was the only communication he had received since a letter from his firm dated 26 March 2001 pointing out the applicant’s failure to comply with the Court’s timetable. (3)Affidavit of Christopher Price sworn 20 July 2001. This affidavit exhibited correspondence to the applicant’s solicitors seeking further and better particulars of the amended statement of claim on 30 May 2000 and 3 July 2000 and replies from the applicant’s solicitors of 21 June 2000 and 2 August 2000 respectively providing particulars.(4)Affidavit of Christopher Price sworn 25 July 2001. This affidavit referred to the $70,000 bank guarantee deposited with the Court as security for Berry’s costs. His legal costs to the date of swearing of the affidavit were approximately $64,794. If the statement of claim were further amended total legal costs would considerably exceed $70,000.C.Evidence put in by counsel for the applicant – Mr B Walker SC(1)Affidavit of Emma Jane Hodgman sworn 30 April 2001. Ms Hodgman is a solicitor employed by Dibbs Barker Gosling, the solicitors for the applicant. She deposed that at the time of swearing her affidavit the applicant had been unable to file or serve its evidence in chief because of delays in accessing and analysing documents sought from the solicitors for the Pongrass respondents. At the time of swearing the affidavit the applicant’s lay evidence was nearing completion and the expert accountant had prepared a preliminary report. (2)Affidavit of Emma Jane Hodgman sworn 22 May 2001. This affidavit was by way of a detailed reply to the affidavits of Blanch and Jarvin complaining of delays occasioned by the applicant. In this affidavit, Ms Hodgman identified as the reasons for delay in complying with the Court’s timetable: (a)the unavailability of the principal of the applicant (Bradley Cooper) to give instructions; (b)the missing stocktake report and the time spent trying to locate it; (c)recent delays in obtaining copies of tax returns from the Pongrass respondents for the applicant’s expert witnesses to analyse.Ms Hodgman attributed part of the delay to the time taken in dealing with the applications for security for costs. She gave a history of her attempts to locate the missing stocktake document. She asserted that the applicant would suffer prejudice if the claim were to be dismissed as it would be statute barred. The applicant had, at the time of her affidavit, spent $92,000 in legal fees on the matter. (3)Affidavit of Emma Jane Hodgman sworn 19 June 2001. In this affidavit Ms Hodgman annexed letters to the respondents dated 22 May 2001 which had enclosed copies of a proposed further amended statement of claim. Also annexed were letters in reply from the respondents’ solicitors dated 1 June 2001 and 4 June 2001. (4)Affidavit of Bradley David Cooper sworn 23 May 2001. In this affidavit Cooper said that the applicant is his nominee company through which he became a shareholder of Phoenix in May 1996. He also said he had been unable to locate a copy of the stocktake carried out on the business before it was purchased. This had caused delays. Delays had also been caused as a result of himself not being available to instruct his solicitors. He said he had been working extremely long hours on FAI Home Security Pty Ltd, of which he was Chief Executive Officer and Chairman.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FRENCH J

Full text does not contain this section.