Caason Investments Pty Limited v Cao (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 70 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Caason Investments Pty Limited v Cao (No 3) [2020] FCA 91

File number: NSD 1558 of 2012
Judge: MURPHY J
Date of judgment: 10 February 2020
Catchwords: REPRESENTATIVE PROCEEDINGS – application by applicants for costs of and incidental to an application for a reimbursement payment – application by applicants for further payment from settlement fund – application for leave to file an application against the litigation funder, outside time limit set – application for costs by Scheme Administrator
Legislation: Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 33V, 33ZF, 37M
Cases cited:

Baffico v YMCA of Great Lakes Inc [2014] NSWCA 61

Caason Investments Pty Limited v Cao (No 2) [2018] FCA 527

Caason Investments Pty Ltd v International Litigation Partners No.3 Ltd [2018] FCAFC 176; (2018) 265 FCR 487

DarwallaMilling Co Pty Ltd & Ors v F Hoffman–La Roche Ltd & Ors (No 2) [2006] FCA 1388; (2006) 236 ALR 322

Goodwill Group Pty Ltd v Pongrass Associates Pty Ltd [2002] FCA 1203

Goodwill Group Pty Ltd v Pongrass Associates Pty Ltd [2003] FCAFC 51

Jackson v Goldsmith [1950] HCA 22; (1950) 81 CLR 446

Pople v Evans [1969] 2 Ch 255

Port of Melbourne Authority v Anshun Pty Ltd [1981] HCA 45; (1981) 147 CLR 589

Thirteenth Corp Pty Ltd v State [2006] FCA 979; (2006) 232 ALR 491

Tomlinson v Ramsey Food Processing Pty Ltd [2015] HCA 28; (2015) 256 CLR 507

Handley, Spencer Bower and Handley: Res Judicata (LexisNexis, 4th ed, 2009)

Date of hearing: 21 March 2019 and 22 May 2019
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Corporations and Corporate Insolvency
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 139
Solicitor for the First Applicant on 21 March 2019: Mr R Flory of Caason Investments Pty Ltd
Counsel for the First Applicant on 22 May 2019: Ms S Cherry
Solicitor for the Second Applicant: Mr T Burke of Wise Plan Pty Ltd
Counsel for the Respondents: The Respondents did not appear
Counsel for the Scheme Administrator: Mr D Healey
Counsel for the Funder: Mr A Byrne
Solicitor for the Funder: Cornwalls (formerly Russells)

ORDERS

NSD 1558 of 2012
BETWEEN:

CAASON INVESTMENTS PTY LIMITED (ACN 089 590 858)

First Applicant

WISE PLAN PTY LTD (ACN 007 008 577)

Second Applicant

AND:

SIMON XIAO FAN CAO

First Respondent

CHARLES MAO

Second Respondent

LARRY MARSHALL (and others named in the Schedule)

Third Respondent

JUDGE:

MURPHY J

DATE OF ORDER:

10 FEBRUARY 2020

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.To the extent it is necessary Mr Timothy Burke be granted leave to appear for the Second Applicant.

2.Pursuant to ss 33V and 33ZF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (the Act):

(a)subject to further order, Order 11(b) of the Orders of Justice Murphy made 6 December 2017 be stayed;

(b)the costs of and incidental to the First Applicant and Second Applicant’s application for approval of the Caason Representative Costs and Wise…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Caason Investments Pty Limited v Cao (No 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCA 91
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Caason Investments Pty Limited and Wise Plan Investments Pty Limited sought reimbursement of costs and expenses incurred in pursuing a class action. The applicants sought costs from both the settlement fund and the litigation funder. The Scheme Administrator sought reimbursement of costs and expenses incurred in the administration of the Scheme. The primary legal issue was whether the applicants were entitled to reimbursement of substantial costs and expenses from the settlement fund. The applicants argued that they were entitled to reimbursement of substantial costs and expenses, including those incurred after the settlement was reached. They also argued that they did not seek separate legal representation because they reasonably assumed that their costs would be recoverable from the settlement fund. The court rejected the applicants' arguments. The court found that the applicants' claims were overstated and that it was not reasonable for them to assume that they would be reimbursed such substantial costs. The court also found that the applicants' claims were partly based on a contention that they did not seek separate legal representation, which was not correct. The court ordered that the applicants be reimbursed a small amount of costs and expenses from the settlement fund. The court also ordered that the applicants may seek to recover any reasonable legal, accounting and administrative costs from the litigation funder pursuant to the variation letters. The court further ordered that the Scheme Administrator be reimbursed a reasonable amount for its costs and expenses. The court directed the parties to confer and endeavour to reach an agreement as to the appropriate order as to the costs of the applications.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. To the extent it is necessary Mr Timothy Burke be granted leave to appear for the Second Applicant.

2. Pursuant to ss 33V and 33ZF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (the Act):

(a) subject to further order, Order 11(b) of the Orders of Justice Murphy made 6 December 2017 be stayed;

(b) the costs of and incidental to the First Applicant and Second Applicant’s application for approval of the Caason Representative Costs and Wise Plan Representative Costs, as referred to in Order 10(c) and (d) of the orders dated 6 December 2017, be approved in the amount of $19,224.69 and paid to the First Applicant and Second Applicant by the Scheme Administrator in the same proportions as they incurred such expenses or otherwise as agreed between them;

(c) the amount of $28,995.15 be approved as reasonable costs incurred by the First Applicant and be paid to the First Applicant and Second Applicant by the Scheme Administrator in the same proportions as they incurred such expenses or otherwise as agreed between them; and

(d) the Applicants’ interlocutory application dated 1 March 2019 be otherwise dismissed.

3. The amount of $115,651.97 be approved as reasonable and paid to the Scheme Administrator in respect of its costs and disbursements.

4. Within 14 days of these orders the Scheme Administrator provide a short note to the Court outlining the outstanding steps required to be undertaken to finalise the administration of the Settlement Scheme, and any orders sought.

5. Within 14 days of these orders the parties and the intervener confer and endeavour to reach an agreement as to the appropriate order as to the costs of the applications, and file draft minutes of consent orders. If the parties cannot reach agreement within 14 days, each party must file short submissions (of no more than three pages) within seven days thereafter.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Third, the Scheme Administrator seeks reimbursement of costs and expenses incurred in the administration of the Scheme.THE FACTS AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY On 6 October 2017 the application for approval of the proposed settlement of the class action came before the Court. It became clear in the course of the hearing that the applicants were not ready to proceed with all parts of the application. Accordingly I heard the parts of the application which concerned whether the quantum and terms of the settlement were fair and reasonable, and adjourned the balance of the application to 16 November 2017. The balance of the application included the following ‘personal’ claims made by Caason and/or Wise Plan:(a)Caason and Wise Plan sought orders for $80,073.88 and $76,708.27 respectively, payable from the settlement fund, to reimburse them for time they claimed to have spent prosecuting the case on behalf of the class (the Representative Costs Claim, although called “the Reimbursement Claims” in Caason (No 2)); and(b)Caason and Wise Plan sought orders for payment of amounts from the Funder, pursuant to side agreements they entered into with the Funder to vary their funding agreements (the Variation Letters). Under the Variation Letters they were entitled to reimbursement of their “reasonable costs for [their] own legal, accounting and administrative work” including the time of senior company officers to be calculated at specified hourly rates (the Variation Letter Costs Claims). Caason and Wise Plan did not particularise the amounts claimed at that point but they subsequently claimed $1,014,644.37 and $116,260.14, respectively; and(c)Caason sought an equitable set-off of its Variation Letter Costs Claim against input tax credits (GST refunds) it had received for GST on legal invoices paid by the Funder on its behalf. Caason had claimed GST refunds from the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) for the periods up to 30 June 2017 and had been paid a total of approximately $397,251.51. It had also claimed a further amount of approximately $220,385 from the ATO which had not yet been accepted. Under the funding agreement and the Variation Letter, Caason was obliged to remit to the Funder any GST refunds it had received within seven days of receipt or crediting, but it failed to do so. Caason argued that the Funder had agreed that it could offset the GST refunds against its Variation Letter Costs Claim, which agreement the Funder denied. Further, at the time of the 16 November 2017 hearing the ATO was conducting an audit of Caason’s entitlement to claim GST refunds in relation to the legal costs paid by the Funder in the proceeding (the ATO review) and it had not yet made a decision as to Caason’s entitlement (the GST Refunds Issue). Subject to the outcome of the ATO review, Caason proposed to lodge further claims for GST refunds of $80,072.66 once the review was complete. There was a substantial overlap between the applicants’ Representative Costs Claims and Variation Letter Costs Claims because both sought reimbursement of costs and expenses the applicants claimed to have incurred in acting as the applicants in the proceeding. The Representative Costs Claims were more modest in quantum (at least initially) and claimed against the settlement fund whereas the Variation Letter Costs Claims were claimed from the Funder.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The applicants did not press proposed orders 6, 7, 8 and 9, which left proposed orders 1, 2, 3, 3A, 4 and 5 to be decided.The evidence The applicants relied upon the following evidence:(a)Caason relied on the following affidavits of Craig Anthony Astill, Managing Director of Caason, sworn:(i)11 September 2017 together with Confidential Exhibit CAA-3 (Third Astill Affidavit);(ii)5 October 2017 (Fourth Astill Affidavit);(iii)3 November 2017 together with Confidential Exhibit CAA-4 (Fifth Astill Affidavit);(iv)1 March 2019 together with exhibits CAA-5, CAA-6 and CAA-7 (Sixth Astill affidavit); (b)Wise Plan relied on an affidavit by Mr Timothy Burke, Company Director, sworn 1 March 2019;(c)the Scheme Administrator relied on affidavits of Amanda Kim Banton, sworn on 15 March 2019, and 21 March 2019, together with a Confidential Report about the GST claim dated 14 March 2019 as required by order 33(a) of the 6 December 2017 Orders; and (d)the Funder relied on the affidavit of Mr Sutherland, the Funder’s solicitor, sworn on 19 March 2019.ConsiderationProposed Order 1 The applicants sought leave to appear without being represented by an Australian Legal Practitioner. In relation to Caason, such an order was unnecessary because Mr Flory, who sought leave to appear for it informed the Court he was legally qualified and held a current practising certificate. Mr Timothy Burke appeared for Wise Plan and had previously provided the Court with evidence that he is legally qualified and held a practising certificate. In the event that Mr Burke does not hold a current practising certificate, I grant leave nunc pro tunc for him to appear to represent Wise Plan in the proceeding.Proposed Order 2 The applicants sought that Orders 11(a) and (b) of the 6 December 2017 Orders be struck out or stayed until further order. Order 11(a) of those orders required Caason to pay to the Scheme Administrator $397,251.51 it had received by way of GST refunds, within seven days. Order 11(b) of those orders required Caason to pay to the Scheme Administrator any further GST refunds it received after the date of the orders, within seven days of receipt or credit. As I explained in Caason (No 2) (at [225)-[231]), under the funding agreements the Funder entered into with the applicants and class members, any GST it paid was recoverable from any Court approved settlement or favourable judgment in the proceeding. While the Funder paid GST as a component of the invoices for legal costs it paid on behalf of the applicants, Caason’s funding agreement provided for it to claim input tax credits from the ATO in respect of the GST paid. Those GST refunds were not though received by Caason for its own benefit. Under clause 15 of the funding agreement it was required to remit to the Funder the GST refunds it received within seven days of receipt or crediting. To the extent that Caason received GST refunds and remitted them to the Funder, the amount of any settlement or judgment monies available for distribution to class members would be greater.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Although the applicants did not properly particularise the amount of costs they claimed, I proceed on the basis that the outer boundaries of the claims are those set out at [12] of the Sixth Astill Affidavit (as set out above at [83]). The applicants claim $508,547.24, comprising:(a)$312,896.74 invoiced by Mills Oakley as at July 2018;(b)$95,650.50 invoiced by PwC in relation to the GST Refund Issue; and(c)approximately $100,000 in further legal, accounting and administrative costs since the applicants’ Representative Costs were approved.Consideration regarding proposed order 5 For the reasons I explain below I am not persuaded that it is appropriate to order anything like the amount sought by the applicants, but I am prepared to order the reimbursement of a small amount. Caason may though seek to recover any reasonable legal, accounting and administrative costs from the Funder pursuant to the Caason Variation Letter. First, proposed order 5 is not in any real sense an application for a variation of Order 10(c) of the 6 December 2017 Orders. It is an application for a different order upon a largely different basis. Order 10(c) approved Caason’s Representative Costs together with reasonable “costs of and incidental to” that application. Under proposed order 5 the applicants seek different relief, namely reimbursement of substantial charges and costs which are quite different to the legal costs Caason incurred in seeking approval of its claim for Representative Costs. Second, the applicants’ contention that they should be reimbursed the substantial expenses and charges Caason has incurred is partly based upon the contention that they did not seek orders for separate legal representation and reasonably assumed that they would not be out-of-pocket for the costs they incurred. It is not however correct for the applicants to state that they did not request leave to be separately represented. At the 6 October 2017 hearing counsel for the applicants submitted that for the purposes of their personal claims the applicants should be separately represented when those claims were relisted for hearing. I accepted that submission. I did so because the applicants’ personal interests in seeking substantial Representative Costs from the settlement fund were likely to be in conflict with their fiduciary obligations to the class members. It was relevant too that they required separate representation in relation to their related Variation Letter Costs Claims against the Funder which were to be heard at the same time. In circumstances where the separate representation orders were made because of a possible conflict of interest I can see little basis for the contention that it was reasonable for the applicants to assume that the costs they incurred would be recoverable from the settlement fund. That is particularly so when the applicants’ claims were plainly overstated. That overstatement can be seen in the fact that:(a)Caason and Wise Plan claimed $80,073.88 and $76,708.27 respectively for their Representative Costs and I allowed only $26,730 and $22,513. Then the applicants sought $61,603.85 for the costs of and incidental to that claim which I have allowed only in the sum of $19,224.69; and(b)the applicants sought reimbursement of $508,547.24, from the settlement fund, most of which Caason incurred after settlement was reached, and without seeking or obtaining authorisation from the Court or the Scheme Administrator to do so. It was not reasonable for the applicants to assume that they would be reimbursed such substantial costs.