Davaria Pty Limited v 7-Eleven Stores Pty Ltd (No 11)

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Davaria Pty Limited v 7‑Eleven Stores Pty Ltd (No 11) [2022] FCA 331

File number(s): VID 180 of 2018
VID 182 of 2018
Judgment of: O’CALLAGHAN J
Date of judgment: 31 March 2022
Date of publication of reasons:  6 April 2022
Catchwords: REPRESENTATIVE PROCEEDING – approval of settlement sum – s 33V(1) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) – power under s 33V(1) to approve proposed settlement sum separately from the power under s 33V(2) – whether the proposed settlement is fair and reasonable both as between the applicants and group members and the respondents – role of contradictor considered – approval under s 33V(1) granted – hearing adjourned for further submissions in relation to s 33V(2) approval
Legislation: Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) Part IVA, ss 33V, 33V(1), 33V(2), 33ZF, 37AF, 37AG
Cases cited:

Botsman v Bolitho (No 1) (2018) 57 VR 68

Caason Investments Pty Limited v Cao (No 3) [2020] FCA 91

Davaria Pty Ltd v 7‑Eleven Stores Pty Ltd (2020) 281 FCR 501

Newstart 123 Pty Ltd v Billabong International Ltd [2016] FCA 1194; (2016) 343 ALR 662

Division: General Division
Registry: Victoria
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub‑area: Commercial Contracts, Banking, Finance and Insurance
Number of paragraphs: 41
Date of hearing: 28‑31 March 2022
Counsel for the Applicants: Mr D Pritchard SC with Mr P Tucker, Mr NYH Li and Mr A Rizk
Solicitor for the Applicants: Levitt Robinson
Counsel for 7‑Eleven Stores Pty Ltd: Mr RG Craig QC with Mr AN McRobert
Solicitor for 7‑Eleven Stores Pty Ltd: Norton Rose Fulbright
Counsel for 7‑Eleven Inc: 7‑Eleven Inc did not appear
Counsel for Galactic Seven Eleven Litigation Holdings LLC: Mr SG Finch SC with Mr DTW Wong
Solicitor for Galactic Seven Eleven Litigation Holdings LLC: Madison Marcus
Contradictor: Mr JA Redwood SC with Mr RK Jameson
Costs referee:  Ms EM Harris

ORDERS

VID 180 of 2018
BETWEEN:

DAVARIA PTY LIMITED (ACN 165 206 404)

First Applicant

KAIZENWORLD PTY LTD (ACN 163 833 565)

Second Applicant

AND:

7‑ELEVEN STORES PTY LTD (ACN 005 299 427)

First Respondent

7‑ELEVEN INC (A TEXAS CORPORATION)

Second Respondent

GALACTIC SEVEN ELEVEN LITIGATION HOLDINGS LLC

Third Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

O’CALLAGHAN J

DATE OF ORDER:

31 MARCH 2022

THE COURT NOTES THAT:

1.Pursuant to section 33ZB of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (the FCA Act), the persons affected and bound by these orders are:

(a)the Applicants;

(b)any group member in the proceeding that has not opted out of the proceeding (Group Members);

(c)Stewart Alan Levitt trading as Levitt Robinson (solicitors for the Applicants);

(d)Galactic Seven Eleven Litigation Holdings LLC (the litigation funder); and

(e)7‑Eleven Stores Pty Ltd (ACN 005 299 427, the First Respondent).

2.This proceeding and proceeding VID182/2018 have settled on the terms set out in the Class Action Settlement Deed dated 4 August 2021 between:

(a)the Applicants in this proceeding (Davaria Pty Ltd and Kaizenworld Pty Ltd), on their own…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Davaria Pty Limited v 7-Eleven Stores Pty Ltd (No 11) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FCA 331
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court, Davaria Pty Limited and Kaizenworld Pty Limited, on behalf of a class of group members, sought approval of a settlement with 7-Eleven Stores Pty Ltd. The applicants alleged that 7-Eleven engaged in unconscionable conduct and breached the Australian Consumer Law by not paying certain rebates and charges to the applicants and other franchisees. The applicants sought approval of a settlement under the representative proceedings provisions in Part 3 Division 3ZF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth). The key legal issues before the Court were whether the proposed settlement was fair and reasonable, and whether the role of the contradictor had been adequately considered. The Court found that the settlement was fair and reasonable both as between the applicants and the group members, and the respondents. The Court also found that the contradictor had been given an opportunity to make submissions and that their role had been adequately considered. The Court granted approval of the settlement under section 33V(1) of the FCA Act and adjourned the hearing for further submissions in relation to approval under section 33V(2). The Court ordered that the settlement be approved on the terms set out in the Class Action Settlement Deed and the Settlement Scheme. The Court also appointed Steven Nicols as the Administrator of the Settlement Scheme, ordered that 7-Eleven pay the Settlement Sum to a trust account, and made various orders in relation to costs, security for costs, and confidentiality.

Orders

Orders of the court

Approval of the settlement

1. Pursuant to sections 33V and 33ZF of the FCA Act that the settlement of this proceeding as against 7‑Eleven be approved on the terms set out in:

(a) the Class Action Settlement Deed dated 4 August 2021 between:

(i) the Applicants in proceeding VID180/2018 (Davaria Pty Ltd and Kaizenworld Pty Ltd), on their own behalf and on behalf of the group members in that proceeding, and their directors/shareholders (Mr Pareshkumar Davaria, Ms Khushbu Pareshkumar Davaria, Mr Jatinder Pal Singh, and Ms Suman Meet Kaur) on their own behalf and on behalf of the Group Members in this proceeding VID182/2018;

(ii) Levitt Robinson;

(iii) Galactic; and

(iv) 7‑Eleven; and

(b) The Settlement Scheme annexed to these orders.

Administration of the settlement scheme

2. Steven Nicols of the accounting firm Nicols & Brien be appointed as the Administrator of the Settlement Scheme.

Payment of the settlement sums

3. 7‑Eleven to pay the Settlement Sum of $98,000,000 to a trust account nominated by the Administrator within 14 days of the date on which:

(a) the appeal period in respect of paragraph 1 of these orders (Approval Order) has expired without any appeal or application for leave to appeal having been filed; or

(b) any orders from an appeal from the Approval Order have been Finally Approved.

In this order, “Finally Approved” means that an application for leave to appeal or an appeal from the Approval Order has been filed and the ultimate outcome of that appeal (including any subsequent appeal or application for leave to appeal) is that the Approval Order is upheld or an order materially similar or substantially equivalent to the Approval Order is made.

Security for costs

4. The security for 7‑Eleven’s costs and any interest thereon held in the Federal Court’s high‑interest bearing account be paid to Levitt Robinson’s trust account, to be returned to Galactic, and the Registry is so directed.

Confidentiality orders

5. In addition to Order 1 of the Court made on 15 February 2022, pursuant to ss 37AF(1)(b) and 37AG(1)(a) of the FCA Act, until further order of the Court, in order to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice, the documents in the Consolidated Confidentiality Schedule as Annexure A to these orders be treated as confidential, not be published or made available and not be disclosed to any person or entity except as permitted by the relevant party identified with respect to the relevant document as set out in the Consolidated Confidentiality Schedule or by order of the Court.

Costs orders

6. There be no order as to the costs of the proceeding as between the Applicants and 7‑Eleven.

7. All existing costs orders in favour of the Applicants as against 7‑Eleven, or in favour of 7‑Eleven as against the Applicants, be vacated.

Consequential orders

8. Pursuant to section 33ZF of the FCA Act or otherwise, the Applicants be authorised nunc pro tunc on behalf of the Group Members bound by these orders to enter into and to give effect to the Class Action Settlement Deed and the obligations, rights, releases and transactions contemplated in it for and on behalf of those Group Members.

9. All existing undertakings (save for confidentiality undertakings provided in respect of the production of documents under subpoena) be discharged.

10. The further hearing of this proceeding be adjourned to 9.30am on 22 April 2022.

11. Liberty to apply.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011

Annexure ‑ Settlement Scheme

Annexure A

Consolidated Confidentiality Schedule

Document

Part of document

Parties permitted disclosure

1.

Confidential Affidavit of Nigel David Jones dated 29 October 2021 (including annexure(s))

Whole

Applicants, 7‑Eleven, Galactic, Contradictor

2.

Confidential Affidavit of Fredrick Schulman sworn 1 February 2022

[64]‑[70]

Applicants, 7‑Eleven, Galactic, Contradictor

3.

Confidential Exhibit FS‑2

Pp 34 to 392

Applicants, 7‑Eleven, Galactic, Contradictor

4.

Affidavit of Jatinder Pal Singh dated 12 November 2021

[11] (first sentence)

Applicants, Galactic, Contradictor

5.

Affidavit of Pareshkumar Chhaganlal Davaria dated 12 November 2021

[12] (second sentence)

Applicants, Galactic, Contradictor

6.

Affidavit of Stewart Alan Levitt dated 17 December 2021

[17] (the words between “Verma” and “Viresh”), [19] (the words between “Yu” and “Hemang”)

Applicants, Galactic, Contradictor

7.

Affidavit of Brett Richard Imlay dated 22 March 2022

Exhibit BRI‑53 pg 53‑158

Applicants, Galactic, Contradictor

8.

Affidavit of Brett Richard Imlay dated 24 March 2022

[8], [12]‑[13], [17]‑[19], Exhibit BRI‑55 pp 315‑397, Confidential Exhibit BRI‑56 pp 399‑403

Applicants, Galactic, Contradictor

9.

Applicants’ submissions dated 21 December 2021

[125] (the words between “store franchises” and “secondly”), [127] (2nd sentence, after “applicants,”), [136(a)] – and associated footnotes

Applicants, Galactic, Contradictor

10.

Applicants’ submissions dated 21 December 2021

[95]‑[99], [101], [104]‑[107] (until “day of mediation”), [111], [113], [118]‑[122], [128]‑[129] – and associated footnotes

Applicants, 7‑Eleven, Galactic, Contradictor

11.

Affidavit of Elizabeth Mary Harris dated 31 January 2022, Annexure EMH‑4

[35] (2nd line, between “raised” and “Counsel”), [46]‑[48], [49] (1st and 2nd sentences), [54] (1st sentence), [71] (3rd sentence), [72], [73] (2nd – 3rd line, from after “legal costs”), [86] (4th sentence), [89] (1st and 2nd sentence), [99]

Applicants, Galactic, Contradictor

12.

Contradictor’s submissions dated 9 March 2022

[10] (3rd sentence), fn 2, fn 9, [35] (2nd sentence and extract), [43] (1st sentence, after “conduct claims”; 2nd sentence; 3rd sentence between “placed” and “are”) , [44] (between “applications” and “these are”), fn 14‑15, [50] (after “Having said that” to the end of the 2nd line), fn 19‑21, fn 26‑28, [62] (4th sentence), [63] (between “Sixthly” and “the context in”), [64] (between “Finally” and “A more general observation”; between “be the fact” and “7‑Eleven itself knew”; final sentence), [65] (between “Commission Act 2001 (Cth)” and “we consider”), [66] (between “straightforward way” and “the case advanced”), fn 37, [69] (between “the above” and “the unconscionable”; between “Specifically” and “notwithstanding”), fn 44‑45, [72] (between “respectfully agree” and “that the claim”; between “prospects of success” and “In particular,”), [84] (between “Seventhly, whilst” and “the unconscionable conduct claim”; between “it does not appear” and “that the unconscionable conduct claim”), fn 64‑65, [88] (1st sentence; between “However” and “there is limited”), fn 69 (after “[28]”), fn 70‑71, [89], [91] (last sentence), fn 73‑76, [97] (1st line, between “if” and “there is”), [98] (3rd – 5th line, between “However” and “it appears”), fn 86, [99] (between “concerned” and “The claims appeared”), [101] (last sentence), [102] (2nd sentence and block quote), [106] (1st – 4th line, before “damages for loss”; 6th line, between “and” and “in such claims”), fn 97‑99, [112] (4th – 5th line, between “disagrees” and “that if”; between “liability” and the full stop), [130] (1st – 8th lines, before “it seems that Mr Meredith”), fn 120‑121, [140] (4th – 5th line, between “calculations” and “of the estimated losses”), fn 131‑132, [145] (first line, before “individual”), [152] (3rd line after “[125])”; 4th – 8th line, after “well‑reasoned”), [155] (2nd sentence), [156] (2nd, 4th, 5th and 6th sentences), [162] (3rd – 4th line, between “trial counsel” and “As part of”), [166] (first five lines, before “VID180 losses arise”; 6th and 7th lines, before “By comparison”; 7th line, between “By comparison” and “there is greater”; 12th line, between “We” and “suggest”; para (a), after “speculative”, [167] (4th – 5th line, between “convinced” and “that there would”), [169], fn 148‑149, [170] (last sentence), fn 151‑153, fn 155‑156, [175] (2nd sentence), fn 158, [178] (after “[19]”, including the block quote), [179], fn 160, [181], fn 161, [198] (1st – 3rd lines entirely), [240] (5th – 7th line, between “(b)” and “(c)”), [273] (2nd – 5th sentences), fn 194, [275], [276] (4th line, between “referred above)” and “especially”), fn 195, [280] (before “it is open to”), [281]‑[282], [283] (before “the Contradictor remains”), [284] (1st – 2nd line, between “ANZ Claims” and “but it is unclear”), [298] (after “this request”), – and associated footnotes

Applicants, Galactic, Contradictor

13.

Affidavit of Ambika Nand dated 23 March 2022

[21], [22], [23] (1st – 2nd lines, between “Corrections Notice” and “and so did not”), [25] (3rd – 4th line), [37], [41], Exhibit AN‑1 pp 97‑100, 129‑132, 146‑153, 171‑174

Applicants, Contradictor

14.

Applicants’ submissions in reply dated 25 March 2022

[23] (4th – 5th lines, between “7‑Eleven and,” and “further reason”; after “and Metcash”), [24], [25] (2nd sentence), [26] (3rd line, after “Rebates Claim”), [42] (3rd – 4th lines, between “by stores” and “the less”), [47] (3rd – 4th lines, between “the matter” and “points more”), [61(b)] (5th sentence), [61(d)] (1st sentence), [99] (3rd sentence, after “and ANZ”), fn 27, fn 29, fn 55, fn 91, fn 95, fn 108

Applicants, Galactic, Contradictor

15.

Exhibit C6 – advices of Applicants’ counsel

Whole

Applicants, Galactic, Contradictor

16.

Eighteenth affidavit of Jem Punthakey sworn 28 March 2022

Confidential Exhibit JJP‑18

Applicants, Galactic, Contradictor

17.

Supplementary Confidential Opinion of Applicants’ Counsel dated 1 November 2021

Whole

Applicants, Contradictor

18.

Exhibit C4 – Confidential Bulletin 13

Whole

Applicants, Galactic, Contradictor

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established