Nassif v Harbour Radio Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 41 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Nassif v Harbour Radio Pty Ltd [2024] FCA 466

File number(s): NSD 785 of 2020
Judgment of: ABRAHAM J  
Date of judgment: 7 May 2024
Catchwords:

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – reinstatement of proceeding – extension of time under r 1.39 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) – self-executing order – dismissal of proceeding – power to extend time where proceeding dismissed – stay of proceeding – power to extent time where proceeding stayed – discretionary power – purpose of power to extend time – conduct of applicant in prosecuting proceedings – prosecution of proceedings under s 37M of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth)

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – non-publication order under s 37AF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) – necessity of non-publication order to protect safety of person under s 37AG(1)(c) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth)

HELD – application that proceedings be reinstated dismissed – application seeking extension of time for payment of security of costs dismissed – application seeking extension of time for stay application dismissed –application seeking non-publication order dismissed

Legislation:

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) ss 75, 76, 79, 91, 135, 136

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 37AF, 37AG, 37M

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) rr 1.39, 2.25, 5.21, 5.22, 5.23

Limitation Act 1969 (NSW) s 14B

Cases cited:

AB (a pseudonym) v CD (a pseudonym) [2019] HCA 6; (2019) 364 ALR 202

Andresakis and Skouteris v Alesus Holdings Pty Ltd [2006] NSWCA 294; (2006) 68 NSWLR 507

Ann Street Mezzanine v Beck [2011] FCA 1212

Aon Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University [2009] HCA 27; (2009) 239 CLR 175

Aust-Pol Engineering v Australian Maritime Safety Authority [1998] FCA 1198

Blunden v Commonwealth [2014] ACTSC 123

Brisbane South Regional Health Authority v Taylor [1996] HCA 25; (1996) 186 CLR 541

DSLB v Comcare [2023] FCA 1222

Equuscorp Pty Ltd v Lah [2009] ACTSC 113

FAI General Insurance v Southern Cross Exploration [1988] HCA 13; (1988) 165 CLR 268

Goodwill Group Pty Ltd v Pongrass AssociatesPty Ltd [2002] FCA 1203

Hawkins v Kingsway Group Ltd [2009] FCA 1073 

Hogan v Australian Crime Commission [2010] HCA 21; (2010) 240 CLR 651

Mander Forklift Pty Ltd v Singles [2014] ACTCA 44

Morres v Papuan Rubber & Trading Co Ltd (1914) 14 SR(NSW) 141

Murdoch v Private Media Pty Ltd (No 5) [2023] FCA 440

Skinner v Commonwealth of Australia [2012] FCA 1194

Stollznow v Calvert [1980] 2 NSWLR 749

Trajkovski v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group [2022] FCA 791

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Other Federal Jurisdiction
Number of paragraphs: 100
Date of hearing:  15 April 2024
Counsel for Applicant: Mr J Raftery
Solicitor for Applicant:  Giles George
Counsel for Respondents:  Ms R Enbom KC and Mr W Wu
Solicitor for Respondents:  Banki Haddock Fiora

ORDERS

NSD 785 of 2020

BETWEEN: 

JEAN KHAZEN NASSIF

Applicant

AND:

HARBOUR RADIO…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nassif v Harbour Radio Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCA 466
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Nassif v Harbour Radio Pty Ltd involved the first applicant, Nassif, seeking to reinstate proceedings that had been stayed due to a failure to comply with an order for security of costs. The application was dismissed by the Federal Court, which considered the applicant's conduct, the age of the proceedings, and the lack of evidence suggesting a timely prosecution upon any potential return to Australia. The court also dismissed applications for an extension of time and a non-publication order. The respondents argued that the applicant had no intention to prosecute the proceedings in a timely manner, supported by evidence of the applicant's absence from Australia, pending criminal charges, and adverse financial circumstances.

The court focused on the discretionary power under r 1.39 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) to extend time, considering whether it was in the interests of justice to grant the extension. The key consideration was the applicant's intention to prosecute the proceedings in a timely manner. The court noted the applicant's failure to prosecute the proceedings promptly, the age of the proceedings, and the repeated breaches of court orders, including self-executing orders. The court was not satisfied that the applicant would return to Australia to prosecute the proceedings within an acceptable time or in a manner consistent with s 37M of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth). The court held that there was no proper basis to grant the extensions of time sought to reinstate the proceedings, and dismissed the application with costs.

The court also dismissed the application for a non-publication order, finding no proper basis to protect the applicant's safety as required by s 37AG(1)(c) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth). The applicant's submissions were inadequate, and the evidence provided did not support the need for such an order. The court concluded that the applications were without merit and dismissed them all, ordering the applicant to pay the respondents' costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicant’s application that the proceedings be reinstated is dismissed.

2. The applicant’s application seeking an extension of time under r 1.39 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) for compliance with Order 1(a) made on 29 August 2023 is dismissed.

3. The applicant’s application seeking an extension of time under r 1.39 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) for compliance with Order 1 made on 1 March 2024 is dismissed.

4. The applicant’s application seeking a non-publication order under s 37AF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) is dismissed.

5. The applicant is to pay the respondents’ costs, by way of a lump sum, to be agreed or assessed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

As a preliminary matter, I note that this application was originally brought by what were the first and third applicants in these proceedings. Only the first applicant, being the applicant in these reasons, remains. The Court was informed during oral submissions for this application that the third applicant, JKN Hills Pty Ltd, was recently placed into voluntary administration. Accordingly, these proceedings, insofar as it relates to the third applicant, cannot continue: see s 440D of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). Immediate factual and procedural background The circumstances of this application arise because of the first, third and fourth applicants’ failure to comply with an order by Registrar Farrell dated 29 August 2023. Those orders relevantly provide: (1) The First, Third and Fourth Applicants are to provide security for the Respondents’ costs in the sum of $900,000.00 to be paid by way of the following 3 tranches:a. $300,000.00 within 28 days of the making of this Order;b. $300,000.00 within 14 days of the making of an order which lists the proceedings for final hearing; andc. $300,000.00 at least 28 days before the date for commencement of the final hearing of the proceedings.(2) …(3) The proceedings are stayed if any of Orders 1 and 2 are not complied with. Those applicants breached order 1(a) by lodging $300,000 with the Court on 9 October 2023, two weeks after the specified deadline. The proceedings were thereby stayed pursuant to Order 3. That had been the position since 27 September 2023. The fourth applicant discontinued its claims in these proceedings in November 2023. By 31 January 2024, the first and third applicants had taken no steps to seek to set aside the stay and prosecute the proceedings. As a result, the Court listed the matter for case management to be heard on 29 February 2024. Prior to that hearing, the respondents filed an application, with supporting affidavit, that the proceedings be dismissed pursuant to r 5.22(d) and r 5.23(1)(b)(i) of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) (FCR). The respondents’ position at that hearing was succinctly summarised in their submissions dated 28 February 2024 at [1]-[3] (emphasis in original):The applicants started this defamation proceeding in July 2020. The first applicant (Mr Nassif) left Australia in 2022 and has been an international fugitive since June 2023.The proceeding has been stayed since 27 September 2023 due to the applicants’ failure to provide a first tranche of security for costs within the time ordered. The security was later provided but the proceeding has remained stayed. The applicants have taken no steps since payment of the security on 9 October 2023 to seek to set aside the stay and prosecute the proceeding. They have informed the respondents that they do not propose to take any such step in the proceeding. They have stated that they want the proceeding to remain stayed until a criminal proceeding against Mr Nassif has been heard. However, there is no evidence that criminal charges are pending. Mr Nassif left Australia before he was charged and there is no evidence that he has returned and been charged. There is no evidence that he is returning to Australia to be charged. As such, the criminal proceeding may never be heard, and this Court has found that he will likely not return in the foreseeable future.The proceeding should not remain stayed until a time of the applicants’ choosing. In circumstances where they have not sought to prosecute the proceeding for a long period and have no immediate intention of doing so, the Court should dismiss the proceeding under FCR 5.22(d) and 5.23(1)(b)(i).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

This is in a context where Mr Nassif has been overseas since at least November 2022. There has been a warrant out for his arrest for fraud related offences since June 2023. On 1 February 2024, external administrators reported to the creditors of 57 Toplace companies in a manner damning of the applicant. As the respondents submitted, he will not be returning to a functioning and successful business, but the matters raised in the creditors’ report. His bank accounts are frozen. In August 2023, Registrar Farrell found Mr Nassif will not likely return to Australia for the foreseeable future.Evidence relied on The applicant read the following evidence, subject to objections (and passages not read):(1)affidavit of Ms Giles sworn 11 March 2024;(2)affidavit of Ms Giles sworn 22 March 2024; (3)affidavit of Ms Giles sworn 4 April 2024; and(4)affidavit of Ms Giles sworn 9 April 2024. In respect to the 11 March 2024 affidavit, [9] and [10] were only admitted as evidence being limited to the state of mind of the applicant. [11] (second sentence) and [13] were not read. Objection was taken to [3]-[8] and part of [12] for hearsay and failure to satisfy of s 75 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) (Evidence Act). It may be accepted that those paragraphs are drafted differently than others which state that Ms Giles was informed by the applicant of various matters. The source of the impugned paragraphs is not identified. The applicant submitted it can be inferred from the content of the affidavit. I am prepared to admit those paragraphs although the absence of detail affects the weight that can be attached to any aspect relied on by the applicant. In respect to the 22 March 2024 affidavit, [4] was not read. Objection was taken to [3] and [6]-[28] as hearsay and a failure to satisfy s 75. Objection was also taken to [6]-[11], [13]-[24], [26] (second sentence), [27] and [28], and all documents exhibited to the affidavit as inadmissible opinion by operation of s 76 and a failure to satisfy s 79: Evidence Act. I address these objections in detail below. Suffice to say at this stage that there is merit in the objections and most of the affidavit and accompanying exhibits are inadmissible. This 22 March 2024 affidavit is the affidavit referred to above at [16] as the confidential affidavit provided to chambers. Although the applicant relies on this affidavit in this application, it has still never been filed. The applicant submitted that Order 3 sought on this application (recited above at [2]) was to enable it to be filed. However, as this is to be relied on in relation to this application, there is no explanation why it was not filed in accordance with the orders for this application. The applicant also sought a non-publication order in respect to the 22 March 2024 affidavit. The applicant did not provide any evidence in support of his application, no written submissions were advanced, and there was no identification of the basis of the application by reference to s 37AG of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (FCA Act). Only when pressed during the hearing did the applicant submit that a non-publication order was necessary to protect his safety, relying on s 37AG(1)(c).

Decision

Reasons for decision

Moreover, although the applicant, in a hearsay statement, expressed the desire to prosecute these proceedings on his return, there is no evidence he intends to do so, let alone in a manner consistent with s 37M. Given his conduct thus far, there is no basis to infer such an intention. Indeed, the applicant failed to address the obvious: that in the current circumstances, he would be arrested on his return to Australia. Noting in that context that at the 29 February 2024 case management hearing, the applicant had requested these proceedings be stayed until the final determination of his criminal proceedings. Conclusion The applicant has not established that an extension of time should be granted to lodge the first tranche security for costs. That is sufficient to conclude that it is not in the interests of justice that the proceedings be reinstated, as the proceedings would by virtue of that, remained stayed. In any event, the applicant also has not established that an extension should be granted in respect to the filing of documents for a stay application. The applicant has not established any proper basis to reinstate these proceedings. The applications are dismissed, with costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The respondents relied on evidence including, inter alia, statements Mr Nassif made to the media as to his conduct and intention, including recent interviews he gave to the ABC (on 19 and 26 March 2024) which were broadcast on radio and published on the ABC News website on 5 and 6 April 2024 respectively. The respondents also provided detailed criticism of the material relied on by the applicant, including the purported medical evidence. Consideration Applying the relevant considerations to the evidence on this application, the applicant has not established that there is a proper basis to grant the extensions of time sought to reinstate the proceedings. First, the purpose of the power conferred by r 1.39 of the FCR is to relieve against injustice. In that context, given the circumstances of this case, a prime consideration – if not the prime consideration – is whether the applicant intends to prosecute the proceedings in a timely manner. The highpoint of the applicant’s case is a hearsay statement in the 11 March 2024 affidavit; Ms Giles deposes at [11] that Mr Nassif “informed [her] of his desire to prosecute these proceedings … upon his return to Australia” (emphasis added). It bears emphasising that the applicant’s own case, by the proposed stay application, is that if these proceedings are reinstated, he does not intend to prosecute them in a timely manner. The applicant’s application to reinstate the proceedings is to enable him to make an application to stay the proceedings until 1 October 2024 (by which time it is said he is to return to Australia). That is, he seeks the proceedings be reinstated, not to prosecute them, but to stay their progress for six months. On the evidence relied on by the applicant, his case for prosecuting the proceedings is dependent on his return to Australia. There is no evidence that he intends to prosecute his case if the stay application is refused. Absent his return, in the circumstances, the applicant has not identified any other consideration which would provide a proper foundation for exercising r 1.39 to reinstate the proceedings. I am not satisfied that Mr Nassif will likely return to Australia for the foreseeable future. More particularly, I am not satisfied that if the proceedings are reinstated the applicant would likely return to prosecute them within an acceptable time or in a manner consistent with s 37M of the FCA Act. The applicant has provided no proper evidence to suggest otherwise. Indeed, all the evidence on this application reflects the contrary. This is against the background of the applicant’s failure to prosecute the proceeding in a timely manner thus far, the age of these proceedings, and his repeated breaches of Court orders (including self-executing orders). Circumstances also suggesting he has little incentive to return for the foreseeable future are those described above at [25], including that there is a warrant out for the applicant’s arrest, that his companies are in administration, that the external administrator’s report to the creditors of 57 Toplace companies made adverse conclusions of the applicant’s conduct (which he would be faced with on his return), and that his bank accounts are frozen.