Details
- Case
- [2021] FCA 1374
- Decision Date
-
CaseChat Overview and Summary
In Bis Industries Limited v Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union, the Federal Court was tasked with determining whether certain employees of Bis Industries Limited were covered by the Black Coal Award or the Manufacturing Award. The dispute arose when Bis Industries alleged that the Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union (CFMMEU) had engaged in protected industrial action that was not authorised by the Fair Work Act. The CFMMEU defended the action as authorised, arguing that the employees in question were covered by the Black Coal Award. The court had to decide whether the employees' work was sufficiently connected to the black coal mining industry to be covered by the Award.
The key legal issues revolved around the interpretation of the coverage clause of the Black Coal Award and whether the employees' roles were sufficiently connected to the black coal mining industry. The court examined the specific duties and the environment in which the employees performed their work. The parties presented differing views on whether the specificity of the classification in the Manufacturing Award or the environmental considerations should be the primary factor in determining the award coverage. The court had to balance these considerations under clause 4.8 of the Award.
The court held that the coverage of the Black Coal Award was not applicable to the employees in question. It found that the employees' work was not sufficiently connected to the black coal mining industry as defined by the Award. The court emphasised that the specificity of the classification in the Manufacturing Award was a more appropriate match for the employees' work. The court also noted that the environment in which the employees performed their work did not align with the typical operations of the black coal mining industry as outlined in the Award.
The court ordered that the employees were not covered by the Black Coal Award and that the Manufacturing Award applied to them. This decision meant that the industrial action taken by the CFMMEU was not authorised under the Fair Work Act, and the employees were subject to the terms of the Manufacturing Award rather than the Black Coal Award.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Initially, the CFMMEU was the sole respondent to the proceedings. However, shortly before the trial, and on the application of Bis, the Specific Employees were joined as respondents to the proceedings. The Specific Employees did not have representation in the trial. Instead they adopted the submissions of the CFMMEU. It had filed affidavits of the Specific Employees in the preparation of its own case. The evidence in the trial Bis led evidence from five witnesses: Ms Kathryn Winter, its Employee Relations Manager originally based in Perth but now in Brisbane; Mr Adrian Buttigieg, the Operations Manager of its Field Services Division for New South Wales and Queensland, who is based at Tomago; Mr Mark Doyle, the General Manager of the Underground Coal Services Division, who is also based at Tomago; and Ms Jennifer Flinn, a solicitor with MinterEllison who is based in Perth. The CFMMEU led evidence from Mr Davis, Mr West, Mr O’Neile and from Mr Adam Walkaden, its Senior National Legal Officer. The evidence in chief of all witnesses was given by affidavit. Ms Flinn and Mr Walkaden were not required to attend for cross‑examination. Although there were some differences in the evidence, I thought that, generally, each witness gave evidence honestly and was endeavouring to assist the Court. I will refer to some of the differences in the course of these reasons. The Black Coal Award The Black Coal Award is a modern Award made by the Fair Work Commission (the FWC) under Pt 2‑3 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (the FW Act). It commenced on 1 January 2010. The coverage clause, cl 4 provides (relevantly):4.1 This award covers:(a) employers of coal mining employees as defined in clause 4.1(b); and(b) coal mining employees.Coal mining employees are:(i)employees who are employed in the black coal mining industry by an employer engaged in the black coal mining industry, whose duties are directly connected with the day to day operation of a black coal mine and who are employed in a classification or class of work in Schedule A—Production and Engineering Employees or Schedule B—Staff Employees of this award;(ii)employees who are employed in the black coal mining industry, whose duties are carried out at or about a place where black coal is mined and are directly connected with the day to day operation of a black coal mine and who are employed in a classification or class of work in Schedule A—Production and Engineering Employees or Schedule B—Staff Employees of this award; and(iii)employees employed by a mines rescue service.4.2For the purposes of this award, black coal mining industry has the meaning applied by the courts and industrial tribunals, including the Coal Industry Tribunal. Subject to the foregoing, the black coal mining industry includes:(a)the extraction or mining of black coal on a coal mining lease by means of underground or surface mining methods;(b)the processing of black coal at a coal handling or coal processing plant on or adjacent to a coal mining lease;(c)the transportation of black coal on a coal mining lease; and(d)other work on a coal mining lease directly connected with the extraction, mining and processing of black coal.4.3 The black coal mining industry does not include:(a)the mining of brown coal in conjunction with the operation of a power station;(b)the work of employees employed in head offices or corporate administration offices (but excluding work in town offices associated with the day-to-day operation of a local mine or mines) of employers engaged in the black coal mining industry;(c)the operation of a coal export terminal;(d)construction work on or adjacent to a coal mine site;(e)catering and other domestic services;(f)haulage of coal off a coal mining lease (unless such haulage is to a wash plant or char plant in the vicinity of the mine); or(g)the supply of shotfiring or other explosive services by an employer not otherwise engaged in the black coal mining industry.NOTE: The coverage clause is intended to reflect the status quo which existed under key pre-modern awards in relation to the kinds of employers and employees to whom those awards applied and the extent to which the awards applied to such employers and employees. An example of the types of issues and some of the case law to be considered when addressing coverage matters can be found in Australian Collieries Staff Association and Queensland Coal Owners Association – No. 20 of 1980, 22 February 1982 … and in the Court decisions cited in this decision.…4.8Subject to clauses 4.1 and 4.2, where an employer is covered by more than one award, an employee of that employer is covered by the award classification which is most appropriate to the work performed by the employee and to the environment in which the employee normally performs the work. NOTE: Where there is no classification for a particular employee in this award it is possible that the employer and that employee are covered by an award with occupational coverage.
Decision
Reasons for decision
It seems that the present wording of cl 4.2 reflects the attempt by the Full Bench to provide “a clearer description” of the black coal mining industry. Court and tribunal decisions Before 2008, a number of authorities had considered the term “black coal mining industry” or a cognate and may be taken to be the decisions to which the chapeau to cl 4.2 and the Note to cl 4.3 refer. In addition to the assistance to be derived from their consideration of particular factual situations, these authorities also indicate different approaches to the resolution of the issue. In R v Drake‑Brockman; Ex parte National Oil Pty Ltd [1943] HCA 35; (1943) 68 CLR 51, the question was whether employees engaged in the extraction of crude oil from shale, and the subsequent processes to obtain petrol, were within the “shale mining industry” so as to come within the definition of “coal mining industry” for the purposes of a wartime regulation. It was held by majority (Latham CJ, Rich and Williams JJ) that they were not. That was so even though the extraction process was conducted at the place at which the shale was mined. Latham CJ said at 56:In my opinion the coal-mining industry is the industry which produces coal as the consequence of mining operations. Coal-mining operations include, not only the actual excavation of the coal from the seam, but also the removal of it from the pit to the surface and placing it upon the surface in a disposable form. All those operations would, according to the ordinary use of language, properly be included within coal‑mining operations and would be conducted as part of the coal-mining industry. The subsequent treatment of coal, however, by turning it into gas or into petrol or into dyes or other products, would not, in my opinion, be part of the coal-mining industry. The result of such processes would not be coal, but something else. Later, at 57, Latham CJ said that “the fact that two industries are carried on at the same place does not abolish the distinction between them. If a single company mined coal and then used the coal to manufacture gas in works alongside the mine, it would nevertheless still be the case that two industries were carried on by that company, one the mining of coal and the other the manufacture of gas”. Rich J, at 58, regarded the crude oil extraction process as “separate, distinct and independent from the operation which constitutes mining”. Likewise, Williams J, at 65, said that “the industry of coal mining would not include the manufacture of coal into other substances such as the manufacture of coal into gas”. Starke J in dissent said, at 59, that “expressions such as the … “coal‑mining industry” … are not technical expressions, but popular general descriptions without any definite or clear boundary lines. The character of the operations, their connected processes and usage must, in the end, determine the industrial classifications under which the operation should be placed”.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
As is apparent, Bis placed emphasis on the first factor to which cl 4.8 refers (the specificity of the classification in the Manufacturing Award) whereas the CFMMEU emphasised the second factor (the environmental consideration). Consideration In TWU v Coles Supermarkets, the Full Court endorsed the approach of the primary judge in determining the award classification which was “most appropriate” by regard to the primary purpose of the employment in question, the range of tasks for which the employees were trained, and the classification which was the “more comprehensive match” with the work in question: at [31]‑[35]. In Australian Workers’ Union v Coffey Information Pty Ltd [2013] FWCFB 2894; (2013) 232 IR 266 at 281, the Full Bench of the FWC adopted the approach of considering which of the two award classifications was more “specific” to the work in question: [24]We are unable to conclude that the classifications in the On-site Award are more appropriate to the classifications in the Manufacturing Award. The Manufacturing Award contains classifications which specifically cover laboratory work and the work of technical workers. The Manufacturing Award covers such employees on a very wide occupational basis. Less qualified employees are nevertheless covered by general semi-skilled classifications.[25]The On-site Award applies very widely to employers in the construction industry. The classifications are of a very general nature. They contain no specific mention of laboratory or testing work although the definition of the civil construction industry does. The technicians work on such projects as the company may be contracted to provide its specialist services from time to time. Long term employees will usually perform their work in a base lab or at multiple locations. Most of the work is performed at base labs. In our view a classification structure designed for workers in the construction industry cannot be considered more appropriate than the technical stream in the Manufacturing Award.[26]It follows that the Manufacturing Award covers the technicians and by virtue of clause 4.2(a) of the On-site Award, the On-site Award does not cover them. In Australian Workers’ Union v Cleanevent Australia Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 1477, Flick J referred to these authorities but, given his finding that the Amusement, Events and Recreation Award 2010 (the Amusement Award) did not cover the employment of the particular employees, it was not necessary for him to apply the “most appropriate” test. Nevertheless, his Honour went on to hold that the Cleaning Service Award was more appropriate having regard, amongst other things, to the circumstance that it was addressed specifically to the cleaning industry and the Amusement Award was not. I commence by noting that cl 4.8 requires a comparison by reference to two considerations: first, the work performed by the employee and, secondly, the environment in which the employee normally performs the work. There is no indication in cl 4.8 that either one of these factors is to be given greater weight than the other. I also note that both factors require regard to be had to the work actually performed by the employee. That is to say, the required comparison is factual.