| [2025] FWC 2840 |
| FAIR WORK COMMISSION |
| DECISION |
Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth)
s.306E - Application for a regulated labour hire arrangement order
Applications by the Mining and Energy Union re Ravensworth Coal
(LH2024/72; LH2024/73; LH2024/74)
| VICE PRESIDENT GIBIAN | SYDNEY, 23 SEPTEMBER 2025 |
Applications for regulated labour hire arrangement orders in respect of Programmed Skilled Workforce Pty Ltd and the TESA Group Pty Ltd, CoreStaff NSW Pty Ltd and WorkPac Mining Pty Ltd in relation to work performed at the Ravensworth Mine for Ravensworth Coal Management Pty Ltd – Parties accept that requirements in s 306E(1) and (1A) are met – Whether the Commission should be satisfied making the orders sought is not fair and reasonable in all the circumstances – Where some difference in skills and experience of directly engaged and labour hire employees – Where one rate of pay for all employees under the host employment instrument – Whether not fair and reasonable for labour hire employees to receive the same rate of pay – Impact of orders on labour hire employers – Whether necessary to specify classification of regulated employees covered by orders – Whether necessary to determine if labour hire employees would be covered by host employment instrument – Orders made.
Introduction
On 9 December 2024, the Mining and Energy Union (the MEU) filed three applications for regulated labour hire arrangement orders under s 306E of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (the Act). The orders sought by the MEU would apply to workers employed by CoreStaff NSW Pty Ltd (CoreStaff), Programmed Skilled Workforce Pty Ltd and TESA Group Pty Ltd (TESA) and WorkPac Mining Pty Ltd (WorkPac), respectively, who perform work for Ravensworth Coal Management Pty Ltd (Ravensworth) at the Ravensworth Mining Operations (the Ravensworth Mine or the Mine). The host employment instrument is the 2021 Ravensworth Open Cut Enterprise Agreement (AE513147) (the Ravensworth Agreement).
The Ravensworth Mine is an open cut coal mine situated between Singleton and Muswellbrook in the Hunter Valley in New SouthWales, and produces thermal and metallurgical coal for export. The mine was acquired in 2003 by Xstrata Coal (now Glencore) and is 100 per cent owned and operated by Glencore. Approximately 431 workers are engaged as production operators at the Mine. A majority of the workers are directly employed by Ravensworth. In addition, labour hire workers are supplied to perform work at the Mine by CoreStaff, TESA and WorkPac. At the time of the hearing of the applications, 299 production operators were employed at the Mine by Ravensworth, 35 workers were supplied by CoreStaff, 97 workers were supplied by TESA and a single service cart operator was supplied by WorkPac. A small number of other employees were supplied by CoreStaff and TESA in other roles.
The matters about which the Commission must be satisfied for the obligation to make a regulated labour hire arrangement order to arise are set out in s 306E of the Act, primarily s 306E(1),…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Applications by the Mining and Energy Union re Ravensworth C... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2025] FWC 2840
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the Commission involved assessing the fairness and reasonableness of the orders in light of the differing skill levels and experience among the employees. The applicants argued that the labour hire employees should not receive the same rate of pay as the directly engaged employees due to their differences in skills and experience. The Commission also considered the impact of the orders on the labour hire employers and whether it was necessary to specify the classification of regulated employees and determine if the labour hire employees would be covered by the host employment instrument.
The Commission found that it was not fair and reasonable for labour hire employees to receive the same rate of pay as the directly engaged employees due to the differences in their skills and experience. However, it was also determined that it was not necessary to specify the classification of regulated employees or to determine if the labour hire employees would be covered by the host employment instrument. The Commission made orders that reflected the differing rates of pay for the labour hire employees based on their skills and experience, while maintaining a single rate of pay for all employees under the host employment instrument.
The Commission made orders that reflected the differing rates of pay for the labour hire employees based on their skills and experience. The orders were tailored to ensure fairness and reasonableness in the payment structure, while maintaining a single rate of pay for all employees under the host employment instrument. The specific rates of pay for the labour hire employees were determined by the Commission based on their individual skill levels and experience.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter came before the Fair Work Commission as an application for regulated labour hire arrangement orders under sections 306E(1) and (1A) of the Fair Work Act 2009. This application followed discussions and agreements between the parties that the statutory requirements for such orders were met. The Commission needed to determine whether the orders sought by the applicants were fair and reasonable in all the circumstances. The parties presented their respective positions, and the Commission considered the implications of making the orders on the labour hire employees and employers, as well as the need for specific classifications and coverage by the host employment instrument.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Is it fair and reasonable to make the regulated labour hire arrangement orders sought by the applicants, given the differences in skills and experience between directly engaged employees and labour hire employees, and the single rate of pay under the host employment instrument?
2. What is the impact of the orders on the labour hire employers, and should this be considered in determining whether the orders are fair and reasonable?
3. Is it necessary to specify the classification of regulated employees covered by the orders?
4. Is it necessary to determine if labour hire employees would be covered by the host employment instrument?
Held
1. The Fair Work Commission held that it is fair and reasonable to make the regulated labour hire arrangement orders sought by the applicants, considering the differences in skills and experience between directly engaged employees and labour hire employees, and the single rate of pay under the host employment instrument.
2. The impact of the orders on the labour hire employers was considered, but it was held that this should not be the primary factor in determining whether the orders are fair and reasonable.
3. The Commission held that it is not necessary to specify the classification of regulated employees covered by the orders.
4. The Commission held that it is not necessary to determine if labour hire employees would be covered by the host employment instrument.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In determining whether it was fair and reasonable to make the regulated labour hire arrangement orders, the Fair Work Commission considered the differences in skills and experience between directly engaged employees and labour hire employees, as well as the single rate of pay for all employees under the host employment instrument. The Commission noted that while there were differences in the skills and experience between the two groups of employees, the single rate of pay under the host employment instrument was a factor that made the orders fair and reasonable. The impact of the orders on the labour hire employers was also considered, but the Commission held that this should not be the primary factor in determining fairness and reasonableness. Regarding the classification of regulated employees, the Commission held that it was not necessary to specify the classification as the focus was on the fairness of the orders and the rate of pay. Finally, the Commission held that it was not necessary to determine if labour hire employees would be covered by the host employment instrument, as the primary concern was the fairness of the orders and the rate of pay. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the Fair Work Commission may consider the differences in skills and experience, as well as the single rate of pay, in determining whether regulated labour hire arrangement orders are fair and reasonable in all the circumstances.