Hitch v Baronja Investments Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 64 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

Hitch v Baronja Investments Pty Ltd [2025] FedCFamC2G 636

File number(s): SYG 1852 of 2023
Judgment of: JUDGE DOUST
Date of judgment: 2 May 2025
Catchwords: FAIR WORK – claim for the payment of monies – whether contravention of s 45 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) - whether failure to pay amounts payable pursuant to Social, Community, Home Care and Disability Services Industry Award 2010 - enquiry as to the extent of the applicants’ entitlements – no mention of Award in the contracts of employment – enquiry into correct classifications of the applicants’ roles under the Award
Legislation:

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 12, 45, 62(1), 539, 540(1), 545

Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia Act 2021 (Cth) s 134

Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) pt 10A

Social, Community, Home Care and Disability Services Industry Award 2010 cls 13.2, 13.3, 15, 16, 17, 20.1, 20.5, 20.5(a), 20.9, 25.1, 25.5, 25.7, 25.7(e), 25.8, 26.1, 28.4, 29, 29.2(a), 29.3(a), 31, schs B and E

Cases cited:

Amcor Limited v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (2005) 222 CLR 241; [2005] HCA 10

Bis Industries Ltd v Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union [2021] FCA 1374

City of Wanneroo v Australian Municipal, Administrative, Clerical and Services Union (2006) 153 IR 426; [2006] FCA 813

Health Services Union v Catering Industries (NSW) Pty Ltd (2023) 412 ALR 18; [2023] FCAFC 82

Hospital Employees' Industrial Union of Workers v Lee-Downs Nursing Home (1977) 57 WAIG 455

Re Colorado Products Pty Ltd (in prov liq) (2014) 101 ACSR 233; [2014] NSWSC 789

Re New South Wales Department of Community Services Community Living and Residential (Interim) (State) Award (2000) 100 IR 447; [2000] NSWIRComm 172

Transport Workers’ Union of Australia v Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Ltd (2014) 245 IR 449; [2014] FCAFC 148

Warramunda Village Inc v Pryde (2002) 116 FCR 58; [2002] FCA 250

Division: Division 2 General Federal Law
Number of paragraphs: 176
Date of last submission/s: 16 December 2024
Date of hearing: 2 December 2024
The Applicants: In person
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr M Foran
Solicitor for the Respondent: Ms C Costigan, Petrine Costigan Lawyers

ORDERS

SYG 1852 of 2023

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)

BETWEEN:

CRAIG HITCH

First Applicant

VREDE BIRD

Second Applicant

AND:

BARONJA INVESTMENTS PTY LTD ABN 86 071 230 709

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

JUDGE DOUST

DATE OF ORDER:

2 MAY 2025

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The matter be listed for further directions to hear from the parties about further directions and/or orders required in light of these reasons.

Note: The form of the order is subject to the entry in the Court’s records.

Note: The Court may vary or set aside a judgment or order to remedy minor typographical or grammatical errors (r 17.05(2)(g) Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth)), or to record a variation to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hitch v Baronja Investments Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FedCFamC2G 636
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Hitch v Baronja Investments Pty Ltd, the applicants, Craig Hitch and Vrede Bird, brought proceedings against the respondent, Baronja Investments Pty Ltd, seeking the payment of monies allegedly owed to them under the Social, Community, Home Care and Disability Services Industry Award 2010. The applicants, who were employed as carers, claimed that they were not paid in accordance with the terms of the Award. The applicants argued that the respondent failed to classify them correctly under the Award and consequently underpaid them. The dispute centred on whether the applicants were properly classified and paid according to the Award's provisions.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the respondent had contravened section 45 of the Fair Work Act 2009 by failing to pay the applicants the amounts payable pursuant to the Award. This required the court to determine the correct classifications of the applicants' roles under the Award and whether the payments made to the applicants complied with the Award's provisions. The court had to examine the terms of the employment contract and the nature of the work performed by the applicants to ascertain whether they were entitled to certain payments under the Award.

The court found that the applicants were entitled to be classified at Level 3 of the Award and should have progressed to Pay Point 2 after 12 months of continuous employment. The court determined that the applicants were entitled to payments for sleepover shifts, afternoon shift loading, and compensation for interruptions to sleepover shifts. The court concluded that the applicants were underpaid as the weekly rate of pay they received was less than the minimum weekly rate for a Level 3, Pay Point 2 position under the Award. The court instructed the parties to confer to quantify the extent of the underpayment and allowed them an opportunity to be heard regarding the claimed relief. The court would subsequently hear the parties on further steps necessary in the proceeding.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The provisions of the Award that arise for consideration in the present matter are dealt with below.FACTUAL BACKGROUNDThe applicants There was no challenge to the applicants’ evidence about their backgrounds and their entry into employment with the respondent and I accepted that evidence. The applicants are a mature aged couple with backgrounds in furniture making and homewares respectively. They each had children with special needs, but identified no formal qualifications in care work. The applicants made an application to the respondent for roles they were later offered. After the application recited the applicants’ occupational and relevant personal backgrounds, it stated:We have reached a stage in our lives where we would be able to care for someone else. We have no dependent children or pets. We have empathy and compassion for those less fortunate than ourselves. We would like to apply for the role as Carer’s (sic). We would be prepared to do any extra medical training required. There was no evidence of any advertisement or call for applications that pre-dated that application. Given the nature of the roles into which the applicants were employed, it is reasonable to infer that there was some contact between the parties prior to the application from which the applicants became aware of the respondent’s need to engage carers to provide care to the client.The respondent The respondent is a company that employed the applicants to provide care for the client. In the following reasons, the client is referred to as “the client”, and his family is referred to as “the client’s family” rather than by their names. References to the client’s name and to the client’s family which appeared in documents referred to below have been deleted and replaced with “the client” or “the client’s family” as the case may be and appear in square brackets. The hotel at which the client and his family resided is referred to hereafter as “the Hotel”.The contract of employment There was no dispute that the applicants were employed under a single written contract entitled “Full-Time Employment Contract” dated 10 September 2018 (the contract). That document was received into evidence, having been annexed to the affidavits of each of the deponents referred to above, being Mr Hitch and Ms Bird. The contract was 11 pages long and divided into two sections. The first section, which commenced on the first page, had the heading “Full-Time Employment Contract, Schedule – Key Data Summary” (the schedule). Six numbered paragraphs followed over that and the following page. Item 1 identified the employer, Item 2 identified the “Employees”. Item 3 was headed “Position”. Under that heading was the following description:Carers for [the client] and assistants to the [client’s] family at the [Hotel] (the Hotel). Item 4 was headed “Duties”. Under that heading was the following:Hours of WorkYour hours of work will be five (5) consecutive days per week with two (2) consecutive days off in each seven (7) day week. Your two (2) days off may or may not include weekend daysOne of you will be required to be in attendance at the Hotel and available to be on call to assist [the client] at all times during the said 5 day period, ie 24 hours per day, except when [the client] is on an outing or otherwise out of your care by arrangement with the employer

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The hearing proceeded on the basis that those questions would be considered first, and the task of calculating the extent of any underpayment would be undertaken following the determination of those questions. PROCEDURAL HISTORY AND EVIDENCE The applicants commenced the proceeding by filing, on 20 November 2023, an originating application using the Application – Fair Work Division form utilised by the Court. On 26 April 2024, the applicants filed an amended application (the amended application). The amended application set out a series of factual allegations, namely:(a)the facts of the employment and the contract;(b)the period of the employment;(c)the application of the Award;(d)the contract’s relevant provisions;(e)the span of work hours and the performance of work by the applicants;(f)the amounts paid to the applicants; and(g)the allegations of shortfall in Award payments, and the attempts made by the applicants to recover the monies they allege are due and owing to them. The amended application also attached three annexures: Annexure A detailing the annual payments in fact made to the applicants including “time in lieu monies received” and amounts paid to the applicants by the respondent following the raising of the dispute concerning the applicants’ entitlements, Annexure B which detailed the annual amounts claimed to be owed to the applicants under the Award, and Annexure C which was said to contain the shortfall in payments to the applicants. Given the way in which the matter proceeded, and the findings below about the applicants’ entitlements, those calculations are now of limited, if any, relevance. On 17 May 2024, the respondent filed a response to the amended application (amended response). The respondent indicated its opposition to the orders sought in the amended application, and set out, under the heading “Grounds of opposition or further orders” in the amended response, the respondent’s responses to the matters recited in the amended application. The matter was listed for hearing on 2 December 2024. At that hearing, at which the applicants were self-represented, the parties read the affidavits they had served in the proceeding. The applicants relied on the following:(1)Affidavit of Craig Hitch made on 21 May 2024;(2)Affidavit of Vrede Bird sworn on 21 May 2024;(3)Affidavit of Vrede Bird sworn on 11 July 2024;(4)Affidavit of Vrede Bird sworn on 25 November 2024; The respondent relied on the Affidavit of James Auswild sworn 5 July 2024. Mr Auswild was the director of the respondent and authorised to make an affidavit on its behalf. Neither party cross-examined any of the deponents of the affidavits. The only objection to any of the affidavit evidence was made by the respondent to Ms Bird’s 25 November 2024 affidavit. The applicants were given leave to read that affidavit notwithstanding that it had been filed outside the time provided for the filing of such evidence in the directions made by the Court. It contained Ms Bird’s response to a submission by the respondent that Mr Hitch had made an “uncorroborated assertion” that he had a home in Camden that he returned to on weekends, namely, Ms Bird’s evidence that she had entered into leases on properties in the Camden area during the period of the employment. The respondent did not seek an adjournment to deal with that evidence, despite being given an opportunity to make such an application. In the event, that affidavit is of marginal relevance.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I will give the parties an opportunity to address that issue at the next stage of the proceeding.CONCLUSION I am satisfied that each of the applicants was entitled to be classified at Level 3 of the Award and should have progressed to Pay Point 2 after 12 months continuous employment. The applicants were entitled to payments at the applicable rates for sleepover shifts, but as only one of them could be said to have been required under the contract to perform such shift on any night, are entitled to payment on the basis that each applicant performed a sleepover shift on average every second night. I am satisfied that the applicant performing the sleepover shift is entitled to payment for an interruption to their sleepover shift attracting the minimum payment. I am also satisfied that each applicant was entitled to payment of the afternoon shift loading on an 8 hour shift two days in each week. The contract of employment did not make express provision for payment of the above amounts. By the last two financial years of the employment, the weekly rate of pay payable to the applicants was less than the minimum weekly rate payable in respect of a Level 3, Pay Point 2 position under the Award. I am satisfied, having reviewed the applicants’ calculations, that the amounts in fact paid to the applicants throughout their employment, even when the additional amounts paid to the applicants following the termination of their employment are taken into account, were less than the total amounts that should have been paid to them pursuant to the Award over the period of their employment. The parties should now confer with a view to quantifying the extent of the underpayment and will have an opportunity to be heard as to the claimed relief in light of the above reasons. I will hear the parties as to further steps that are necessary in the proceeding in light of the above findings and reasons.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The applicants also stated as follows in their affidavits (emphasis in the original):Remuneration11.During the period of my employment, I was paid the amounts as set out in Annexure A to the Application. See Annexure "C".12.I took limited annual leave during the Employment. The days worked, leave taken and public holidays worked is calculated. See Annexure "D".The Award and the Shortfall13.I should be paid the Award by the Respondent in the amounts set out in Annexure B to the Application.14.The difference between what the Respondent paid and what I received is set out in Annexure C to the Application, Shortfall in Remuneration and Benefits. No objection was taken to that evidence, nor were the applicants cross-examined about it. Annexure B to the applicants’ affidavits contained two tables; the first setting out a calculation of the amounts payable to them under the Award on a weekly basis (the weekly pay table), and the second setting out a calculation of amounts payable in respect of public holidays (the public holidays table).The weekly pay table in Annexure B to the affidavits The weekly pay table contained a series of columns with the headings 1.7.18, 1.7.19, 1.7.20, 1.7.21, 1.7.22, and 1.7.23, obviously indicating the financial years commencing on those dates, during which the applicants were employed. In the columns below each of the headings were entries containing amounts of money. The following descriptions appeared in the left-hand column:(a)Weekly pay rate Level 3 – pay point 2(b)First Aid per week(c)Loading 17.5% x [weekly rate] x 4/52(d)Sunday 6pm – 11pm(e)On call Sunday night(f)Sleepover 5 nights x $47.04(g)Requirement to perform work during sleepover 1 x 1.5 (it was apparent from the “5.00” appearing in an adjacent column that the applicants were claiming for 5 such interruptions in each week)(h)Morning loading 7am – 9am 15% 2 x 5(i)Afternoon loading 8pm – 11pm 3 x 4(j)On call 4 nights x $19.20 It is apparent from the descriptions in the left-hand column of the weekly pay table that they refer to a number of Award provisions (with one qualification identified below). The words “Weekly pay rate Level 3 – pay point 2”, and the figures that appear in that row, unmistakeably refer to the minimum weekly wage for pay point 2 of the Level 3 classification level in sch E of the Award, adjusted at the commencement of each financial year to reflect Award increases. “Sleepover 5 nights x $47.04” is plainly a reference to the sleepover allowance the subject of cl 25.7 of the Award. The claim that five such payments were due to the applicants in each week was an assertion that the applicants, when they remained on the premises each night, performed a sleepover shift within the meaning of the Award. The reference to “Morning loading 7am - 9am” is a claim for payment of a loading for work performed between 7.00 am and 9.00 am in the morning but is not a reference to an award provision. Clause 29 of the Award, which deals with shiftwork, provides for an afternoon shift loading payable where a shift has finished after 8.00 pm and before midnight, and a night shift loading payable is where a shift finishes after 12 midnight or commences before 6.00 am Monday to Friday, but does not define any “morning shift” or provide for payment of any morning shift loading.