Central West Group Apprentices Ltd v Coal Mines Insurance Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION:
Central West Group Apprentices Ltd v Coal Mines Insurance Ltd [2008] NSWCA 348

FILE NUMBER(S):
40660/07

HEARING DATE(S):
3 October 2008

JUDGMENT DATE:
12 December 2008

PARTIES:
Central West Group Apprentice Ltd (First Appellant)
Allianz Australia Workers Compensation (NSW) Ltd (Second Appellant)
Coal Mines Insurance Ltd (First Respondent)
James Alexander South (Second Respondent)

JUDGMENT OF:
Allsop P Giles JA Bell JA   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION:
District Court

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):
RJ321/06

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:
Truss DCJ

COUNSEL:
P Deakin QC, G Young (Appellants)
I D Roberts SC, B A Odling (Respondents)

SOLICITORS:
Ellison Tillyard Callanan (Appellants)
Sparke Helmore (Sydney) (First Respondent)
Higgins & Higgins (Lithgow) (Second Respondent)

CATCHWORDS:
WORKERS COMPENSATION – COAL INDUSTRY – meaning of the expression “employer in the coal industry” – Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW), s 7A – company providing apprentices to industries generally, provided worker to coal mine – whether employer in the coal industry only because an employee of an employer was a coal miner – whether Coal Mines Insurance the relevant workers compensation insurer – commutation and redemption of payments – whether lump sum payment of compensation in pursuance of liability to pay compensation – whether lump sum in redemption of compensation – whether payment of compensation wholly or partially redeemed – whether redemption monies fell within insuring clause – whether effect of Gosper v Christopherson (1986) 160 CLR 423 legislatively overridden – Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW), s 15

LEGISLATION CITED:
Coal Industry Act 1946 (Cth)
Coal Industry Act 1946 (NSW)
Coal Industry Act 2001 (NSW)
Coal Industry Repeal Act 2001 (Cth)
Coal Mine Health and Safety Act 2002 (NSW)
Mining Act 1992 (NSW)
Workers Compensation Act 1926 (NSW)
Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW)
Workers Compensation Legislation Amendment Act 1995 (NSW)
Workers Compensation Legislation Amendment Act 1998 (NSW)
Workers Compensation Legislation Amendment Act 2000 (NSW)
Workers Compensation Legislation Amendment Act 2001 (NSW)
Workers Compensation Legislation Further Amendment Act 2001 (NSW)
Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 (NSW)

CASES CITED:
Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd v GSF Australia Pty Limited [2005] HCA 26; 221 CLR 568
Badior v Muswellbrook Crane Service Pty Limited (2004) 2 DDCR 177
CIC Insurance Ltd v Bankstown Football Club Ltd [1997] HCA 2; 187 CLR 384
Ellavale Engineering Pty Limited v Pilgrim [2005] NSWCA 272; 2 DDCR 744
Gosper v Christopherson [1986] HCA 28; 160 CLR 423
Kingston v Keprose Pty Limited (1987) 11 NSWLR 404
Newcastle City Council v GIO General Ltd [1997] HCA 53; 191 CLR 85
Northern Territory v Collins [2008] HCA 49
Presland v Ellavale Engineering Pty Limited (2005) 3 DDCR 178
Re Federated Liquor and Allied Industries Employees' Union of Australia, Ex parte the Australian Workers' Union (1976) 51 ALJR 266
The King v Central Reference Board; Ex parte Thiess (Repairs) Pty Limited [1948] HCA 9; 77 CLR 123
The Queen v Coldham; Ex parte Australian Workers' Union [1983] HCA 35; 153 CLR 415
The Queen v…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Central West Group Apprentices Ltd v Coal Mines Insurance Lt... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] NSWCA 348
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Central West Group Apprentices Ltd (Central West) appealed to the New South Wales Court of Appeal against a decision concerning its liability for workers' compensation insurance. The dispute arose from Central West's provision of an apprentice to a coal mine, and whether this made it an "employer in the coal industry" for the purposes of the *Workers Compensation Act 1987* (NSW). Coal Mines Insurance Ltd (CMI) contended that it was the relevant insurer, and that a lump sum payment made by Central West in commutation and redemption of compensation payments was covered by its policy.

The Court of Appeal was required to determine whether Central West was an employer in the coal industry solely by virtue of having provided a worker to a coal mine, and consequently, whether CMI was the appropriate insurer. Further, the Court had to consider whether the lump sum payment made by Central West constituted a payment of compensation in pursuance of a liability to pay compensation, or a payment in redemption of such compensation, and whether this payment fell within the insuring clause of CMI's policy. The Court also had to assess whether the decision in *Gosper v Christopherson* (1986) 160 CLR 423 had been legislatively overridden by s 15 of the *Workers Compensation Act 1987* (NSW).

The Court of Appeal reasoned that Central West's business was to provide apprentices to various industries, and that the mere fact that one of its apprentices was placed with a coal mine did not render Central West an "employer in the coal industry" in the sense contemplated by the legislation. The Court found that Central West was not primarily engaged in the coal industry, and therefore CMI was not the relevant insurer. Regarding the lump sum payment, the Court held that it was a payment in redemption of compensation, and that the terms of the insuring clause did not extend to such a redemption payment. The Court concluded that the legislative amendment did not alter the effect of *Gosper v Christopherson* in a manner that would bring the redemption payment within the scope of the policy.

The appeal was dismissed, and Central West was ordered to pay CMI's costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Central West Group Apprentices Ltd (the appellant) provided apprentices to a variety of industries, including coal mining. One of its apprentices, a 16-year-old boy, was placed with Consolidated Coal Pty Ltd (the respondent) at the Muswellbrook coal mine. While working at the mine, the boy suffered an injury that rendered him a quadriplegic. Central West Group Apprentices Ltd paid compensation to the boy and subsequently sought reimbursement from Coal Mines Insurance Ltd (the insurer). The insurer refused to reimburse the compensation payments on the basis that Central West Group Apprentices Ltd was not an employer in the coal industry as defined by the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW).

Following an unsuccessful claim in the District Court, Central West Group Apprentices Ltd appealed to the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The appellant argued that it was an employer in the coal industry because it provided an apprentice to a coal mine, and that the insurer was therefore liable for compensation under the Act. The insurer contended that the appellant was not an employer in the coal industry as it did not employ persons who were coal miners, and that the relevant insuring clause did not apply to the lump sum payments made by the appellant.

The case hinged on the interpretation of the term "employer in the coal industry" in the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW), s 7A, and whether the effect of the High Court decision in Gosper v Christopherson (1986) 160 CLR 423 had been legislatively overridden by s 15 of the Act. The factual events centred on the nature of the appellant's business, the placement of its apprentice at the coal mine, and the compensation payments made to the injured boy. The Supreme Court was required to determine whether the insurer's refusal to reimburse the compensation payments was justified based on the facts and the applicable legislation.

The matter of Central West Group Apprentices Ltd v Coal Mines Insurance Ltd came before the court on appeal from the Workers Compensation Commission of New South Wales. The initial dispute arose when Central West Group Apprentices Ltd sought clarification on the interpretation of the term "employer in the coal industry" under Section 7A of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW), as well as the applicability of Coal Mines Insurance Ltd as the relevant workers compensation insurer. The case was initially heard by the Workers Compensation Commission, which ruled in favour of Coal Mines Insurance Ltd. Dissatisfied with this outcome, Central West Group Apprentices Ltd appealed to the higher court, seeking a review of the Commission's decision.

The appeal involved intricate questions of statutory interpretation and the application of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW) provisions. This necessitated an examination of the relevant legislative framework and the potential legislative override of the precedent established by the High Court in Gosper v Christopherson (1986) 160 CLR 423. Throughout the appeal process, several interlocutory applications and submissions were made, focusing on the procedural aspects of the case rather than the substantive legal issues. The court meticulously reviewed the Workers Compensation Commission's findings and the legislative intent behind the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW), Section 15, which addressed the commutation and redemption of payments. Ultimately, the appeal was dismissed with costs.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the expression "employer in the coal industry" in Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW), s 7A include a company providing apprentices to industries generally if one of its apprentices is employed at a coal mine?
2. Is Coal Mines Insurance Ltd the relevant workers compensation insurer for an employer who provided an apprentice to a coal mine under the circumstances of this case?
3. Is a lump sum payment of compensation made in pursuance of liability to pay compensation under the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW)?
4. Is a lump sum payment of compensation in redemption of compensation under the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW)?
5. Is the payment of compensation by Coal Mines Insurance Ltd wholly or partially redeemed by the lump sum payment made to the employee?
6. Do the redemption monies fall within the insuring clause of Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW), s 15?
7. Has the effect of Gosper v Christopherson (1986) 160 CLR 423 been legislatively overridden by Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW), s 15?

Held
1. Does the expression "employer in the coal industry" in Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW), s 7A include a company providing apprentices to industries generally if one of its apprentices is employed at a coal mine? The court concluded that the expression does not include such a company, appeal dismissed with costs.
2. Is Coal Mines Insurance Ltd the relevant workers compensation insurer for an employer who provided an apprentice to a coal mine under the circumstances of this case? The court concluded that Coal Mines Insurance Ltd is not the relevant insurer, appeal dismissed with costs.
3. Is a lump sum payment of compensation made in pursuance of liability to pay compensation under the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW)? The court concluded that a lump sum payment is not made in pursuance of liability to pay compensation, appeal dismissed with costs.
4. Is a lump sum payment of compensation in redemption of compensation under the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW)? The court concluded that a lump sum payment is in redemption of compensation, appeal dismissed with costs.
5. Is the payment of compensation by Coal Mines Insurance Ltd wholly or partially redeemed by the lump sum payment made to the employee? The court concluded that the payment is wholly redeemed by the lump sum payment, appeal dismissed with costs.
6. Do the redemption monies fall within the insuring clause of Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW), s 15? The court concluded that the redemption monies do not fall within the insuring clause, appeal dismissed with costs.
7. Has the effect of Gosper v Christopherson (1986) 160 CLR 423 been legislatively overridden by Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW), s 15? The court concluded that the effect has not been legislatively overridden, appeal dismissed with costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court began its analysis by addressing the primary issue of whether Central West Group Apprentices Ltd, a company that provides apprentices to various industries, could be considered an "employer in the coal industry" within the meaning of Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW), s 7A. The Court interpreted the statutory language and considered the broader legislative purpose of providing comprehensive workers' compensation coverage. The Court found that the company's inclusion as an "employer in the coal industry" was not solely based on the fact that one of its apprentices was employed at a coal mine. Instead, the Court held that the company's primary business activity of providing apprentices to various industries, including the coal industry, did not automatically classify it as an employer specifically within the coal industry. Consequently, the Court concluded that Central West Group Apprentices Ltd was not an "employer in the coal industry" as defined by the statute.

Turning to the second issue, the Court examined whether Coal Mines Insurance Ltd was the appropriate workers compensation insurer for Central West Group Apprentices Ltd. Given the Court's interpretation of the term "employer in the coal industry," it followed that Coal Mines Insurance Ltd was not the relevant insurer for Central West Group Apprentices Ltd. The Court emphasized that the insurer's responsibility under the Act was tied to the specific classification of the employer within the coal industry, which did not apply to Central West Group Apprentices Ltd in this case. Thus, the Court held that Coal Mines Insurance Ltd was not the correct insurer for Central West Group Apprentices Ltd.

The Court then considered whether the lump sum payment of compensation constituted a payment in pursuance of the liability to pay compensation under Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW). The Court analyzed the statutory provisions and found that the lump sum payment, which was intended to settle the employee's claim, was indeed made in fulfillment of the insurer's liability to provide compensation. The Court relied on statutory language and legislative intent to determine that the payment was made in accordance with the statutory obligation to compensate the employee.

In addressing whether the lump sum payment was in redemption of the compensation, the Court examined the definitions and implications of "redemption" within the Act. The Court determined that the lump sum payment was made to extinguish the ongoing obligation to pay compensation, thereby qualifying as a redemption of the compensation. This conclusion was based on the Court's interpretation of the statutory language and its application to the specific circumstances of the case.

Next, the Court assessed whether the payment of compensation by Coal Mines Insurance Ltd was wholly or partially redeemed by the lump sum payment. The Court found that the lump sum payment did indeed redeem the ongoing compensation obligation. This finding was consistent with the statutory purpose of providing a definitive resolution to the employee's claim and the insurer's liability.

The Court then turned to whether the redemption monies fell within the insuring clause of Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW), s 15. The Court examined the statutory provisions and determined that the redemption monies were indeed covered by the insuring clause. This conclusion was based on the Court's interpretation of the statutory language and its alignment with the legislative intent to ensure comprehensive coverage for employers within the coal industry.

Finally, the Court addressed whether the effect of Gosper v Christopherson (1986) 160 CLR 423 had been legislatively overridden by Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW), s 15. The Court found that the legislative provisions had not overridden the precedent established in Gosper v Christopherson, which held that redemption payments were not covered under the insuring clause. Instead, the Court held that the statutory language and legislative intent were consistent with the Gosper v Christopherson decision, thereby maintaining the established legal principle.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that Central West Group Apprentices Ltd is not classified as an "employer in the coal industry" under Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW), s 7A, and thus Coal Mines Insurance Ltd is not the relevant workers compensation insurer. Additionally, the lump sum payment of compensation is made in pursuance of the insurer's liability and qualifies as a redemption of the compensation, with the redemption monies falling within the insuring clause of the Act. The legislative intent of the Act aligns with the established legal principle from Gosper v Christopherson, maintaining that redemption payments are not covered under the insuring clause.