Barker v Commonwealth Bank of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 81 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Barker v Commonwealth Bank of Australia [2012] FCA 942

Citation: Barker v Commonwealth Bank of Australia [2012] FCA 942
Parties: STEPHEN JOHN BARKER v COMMONWEALTH BANK OF AUSTRALIA
File number: SAD 187 of 2010
Judge: BESANKO J
Date of judgment: 3 September 2012
Catchwords:

CONTRACTS – where applicant’s role with respondent Bank made redundant – where applicant subsequently retrenched – whether failure to give required notice prior to termination of employment or payment in lieu pursuant to written contract of employment – whether breach of contract – whether failure to give notice deprived applicant of chance to be redeployed during notice period pursuant to respondent’s redeployment policy.

Held: The respondent failed to give the applicant four weeks’ notice in breach of contract.

CONTRACTS – where respondent’s policies contained in a “Human Resources Reference Manual” and accessible on respondent’s intranet – whether policies terms of applicant’s employment contract – where statement of express exclusion of policies from employment contracts present in Human Resources Reference Manual – whether language of policies suggestive of contractual obligation or merely aspirational in nature – whether express incorporation – whether policies formed implied terms of applicant’s contract by virtue of custom or established practice of respondent.

Held: The statement of express exclusion prevents the policies being either implied as a matter of fact or expressly incorporated into the applicant’s employment contract.

CONTRACTS – existence of implied term of mutual trust and confidence in Australian law – whether serious breach by respondent of its own policy sufficient to breach implied term – whether serious breach of redeployment policy caused applicant loss or damage – whether damages available for breach of implied term – assessment of loss of chance – whether damages for hurt, disappointment and injury to reputation available – whether aggravated damages available.

Held: The applicant is entitled to damages for loss of chance to be redeployed due to respondent’s breach of implied term of mutual trust and confidence by acting in serious breach of its redeployment policy.

TRADE PRACTICES – misleading and deceptive conduct – where general manager of respondent represented to applicant that his role would not change following employment of state manager – where responsibility of applicant reduced by two-thirds – whether representation misleading or deceptive or likely to mislead or deceive for purposes of s 52, 53B and 51A of Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) – whether representation made in “trade or commerce”.

Held: The representation was not made in “trade or commerce” for purposes of Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth).

Legislation: Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 140
Fair Trading Act 1999 (Vic) s 9
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 51A, 52, 53B, 82
Cases cited:

Addis v Gramophone Co Ltd [1909] AC 488, cited
Baltic Shipping Co v Dillon (1993) 176 CLR 344, cited
Burazin v Blacktown City Guardian Pty Ltd (1996) 142 ALR 144, cited
Commonwealth of Australia v Amann Aviation Pty Ltd (1991) 174 CLR 64,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Barker v Commonwealth Bank of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] FCA 942
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Barker v Commonwealth Bank of Australia involved a claim by Mr Barker against the Commonwealth Bank of Australia, alleging wrongful termination of employment and subsequent damages. The dispute centred on the circumstances surrounding Mr Barker's departure from his position as an executive manager and the impact on his career prospects, particularly his claim that he was dismissed due to his opposition to certain internal practices. The case was heard and determined in the Federal Court of Australia.

The central legal issues addressed by the court included whether Mr Barker's termination was wrongful and if his subsequent inability to secure full-time employment was causally linked to his departure from the bank. Additionally, the court had to assess the quantum of damages, if any, that Mr Barker was entitled to claim for economic loss, general damages, and aggravated damages. The court had to evaluate the credibility of Mr Barker's evidence and the weight to be given to the documentary evidence and witness testimonies.

The court found that Mr Barker's claims of wrongful termination were unsubstantiated. It concluded that the evidence did not support Mr Barker's assertion that he was dismissed due to his opposition to certain practices within the bank. The court also noted that Mr Barker's claims of significant economic loss and other damages were not adequately supported by evidence. Although the court found Mr Barker to be a credible witness in some respects, it identified areas where his evidence was unreliable or exaggerated. The court ultimately awarded Mr Barker a sum of $317,500 in damages, reflecting the limited impact of his claims on his career prospects.

The court ordered that the Commonwealth Bank of Australia pay Mr Barker $317,500 in damages, with further hearings to determine the interest and costs associated with the judgment.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

I will set out the facts in chronological order as far as I am able. Where there is a dispute I will identify the dispute and the way in which I resolve it. THE FACTSBackground Mr Barker was born on 18 February 1964 and he completed year 11 at high school. In November 1981 he commenced employment with the Bank. He started in a variety of junior positions before being elevated to the position of teller. He then performed various roles which he described as trading bank examiner and savings bank examiner. He received high level performance reviews. In July 1989, Mr Barker was promoted to the position of loans officer at the Findon branch of the Bank. At that time there were four levels within the assistant manager band and Mr Barker was employed at a level known as “AMA”. The other three levels were “AMB”, “AMC” and “AMD”. In 1991, Mr Barker was promoted to the “AMB” level. His role was to assist the branch manager and he was part of the management team. In 1992, he was promoted to the “AMC” level and he continued to receive high level performance reviews. At about this time he was selected to take part in the Bank’s management development programmes. In 1993, he was promoted to the “AMD” level and he became an assistant relationship manager at the Hindmarsh Business Banking Centre of the Bank. He was required to report to a relationship manager who was responsible for managing “a portfolio of client relationships”. In 1995, Mr Barker was promoted to the level of manager. At that time, there were three levels within the manager band and they were “MA”, “MB” and “MC”. Mr Barker was promoted to the “MA” level. In 1996, Mr Barker became a relationship manager at the Hindmarsh Business Banking Centre. He was assisted by an assistant relationship manager. He continued to receive high performance reviews. He completed various courses to assist him in furthering his career as far as possible. At the beginning of 1999, Mr Barker took up a position as relationship manager at the Riverland Business Banking Centre of the Bank and he moved directly from the “MA” level to the “MC” level. Mr Barker said that he continued to receive outstanding performance reviews. He managed approximately 70 per cent of the total business in asset terms and he managed the largest customers of the Bank in the Riverland region. In 2001 or 2002, Mr Barker was transferred to the Adelaide Business Banking Centre of the Bank. He continued to hold the position of relationship manager and he remained at the “MC” level. He managed a large portfolio of corporate customers located in both the central business district of Adelaide and in regional areas in South Australia. He was rated exceptional in his annual performance review. During 2002 and 2003, Mr Barker continued to receive good performance reviews and those reviews contained a mixture of “Meets Expectations” or “Exceeds Expectations”. In November 2003, the executive manager for Corporate Banking, Adelaide, resigned. That was a level 3 position. The Bank had introduced a new management structure during the period between 2001 and 2002. Mr Barker had reported to the executive manager who had resigned. He applied for the position and in June 2004 he was successful in obtaining the position.Mr Barker’s contract in 2004

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Mr Barker makes a substantial claim for damages. Since leaving the Bank in April 2009, he has not obtained full-time employment with any other organisation. He has performed some consultancy work for which he has received fees. He claims past economic loss of $110,000 plus an amount for pre-judgment interest, future economic loss of $1,160,000, general damages of $200,000 and aggravated damages of $100,000.THE EVIDENCE CALLED AT THE TRIAL The parties exchanged written statements of the evidence to be given by the witnesses they intended to call at trial. Those statements were then tendered at trial as the witness’s evidence-in-chief. In some cases I allowed the witness to give some brief evidence-in-chief in addition to his or her statement. In addition to the evidence of witnesses called at trial, both parties tendered a number of documents. A number of key facts were established by documents or evidence which was not in dispute.Mr Barker’s Witnesses Mr Barker gave his evidence-in-chief by way of two written statements and brief oral evidence. His first written statement was a very lengthy document. He was subject to a long and vigorous cross-examination by counsel for the Bank. Much of his evidence may be accepted because it was either not contested, or related to matters which were, in any event, established by the documents. However, his evidence in some areas was unsatisfactory. He confidently asserted as facts a number of matters where his basis for doing so was either non-existent or, at best, tenuous. Examples are set out in the course of these reasons. Furthermore, I thought he exaggerated the nature of the personal relationship between Mr Formichella and Mrs Allen, and that he tried to minimise his part in the rumours which were circulating within the Bank as to the nature of that relationship. Finally, there were areas where I considered the evidence of another witness more reliable than the evidence of Mr Barker. These matters are referred to below. Mr Anthony Majstrenko is a manager with the CPS Credit Union. He was employed by the Bank in July 1997, and while at the Bank he worked as a credit manager in institutional banking and as a relationship executive in Mr Barker’s team. His employment with the Bank ended on 4 November 2009. He is a good friend of Mr Barker. His credit was challenged by the Bank on the basis of an act alleged to have occurred shortly before his departure from the Bank. He denied the allegation and it is not otherwise established by the evidence. I place no weight on the allegation. Nevertheless, for other reasons, I did not find him to be an impressive witness. I find it difficult to accept that he could not recall any expression of disappointment within his team about Mrs Albanese’s selection to participate in a leadership programme. I find it difficult to accept that he could not be more definite as to whether there were discussions about Mr Formichella favouring Mrs Albanese and his statement that he never contributed to those discussions. I reject his evidence that Mr Formichella was deliberately touching Mrs Albanese’s hand at the client Christmas function in December 2008. I prefer the evidence of Mr Formichella and Mrs Albanese on that topic.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Furthermore, the evidence of loss or damage is virtually non-existent. I mean by that, that even if, contrary to my earlier findings, the other elements of Mr Barker’s Trade Practices Act case were made out, there is virtually no evidence of what Mr Barker lost by not pursuing the inquiry about employment with NAB. After he left the Bank, Mr Barker made applications for employment with NAB, but failed the psychometric test. There is no evidence as to whether such a test was administered by NAB in 2006. I do not need to examine this question any further because of my earlier conclusion. CONCLUSION Mr Barker is entitled to judgment against the Bank in the sum of $317,500. I will hear the parties as to interest and costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established