Azimitabar v Commonwealth of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Azimitabar v Commonwealth of Australia [2023] FCA 760

File number: VID 177 of 2021
Judgment of: MURPHY J
Date of judgment: 6 July 2023
Catchwords:

MIGRATION – applicant transferred to Australia for psychiatric assessment and treatment and detained in a hotel – whether subpara (b)(v) of the definition of “immigration detention” in s 5(1) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) empowered Minister to approve ‘another place’ of immigration detention – whether power in subpara (b)(v) of the definition of “immigration detention” to approve ‘another place’ of immigration detention was impliedly limited such that it did not include power to approve a de facto detention centre – whether hotels were lawfully approved as places of immigration detention – whether the applicant’s detention in the hotels was unlawful.

CONSTITUTIONAL LAW – whether lawfulness of immigration detention depends upon whether expenditure on the place of detention is properly authorised – whether the Commonwealth’s contracting and expenditure on the hotels as places of immigration detention was lawfully authorised by executive power under s 61 of the Constitution – whether the Commonwealth’s contracting and expenditure on the hotels as places of immigration detention was lawfully authorised by s 32B of the Financial Framework (Supplementary Powers) Act 1997 (Cth) and regulations

Legislation:

Constitution s 61

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 37AF, 37AG

Financial Framework (Supplementary Powers) Act 1997 (Cth) s 32B

Financial Framework Legislation Amendment Act (No 3) 2012 (Cth)

Financial Management and Accountability Act 1997 (Cth)

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 5, 14, 46A, 46B, 48B, 92, 93, 189, 196, 197AB, 198AD, 198AH, 198B, 198C, 253, 273, 496

Migration Amendment (Unauthorised Maritime Arrivals and Other Measures) Act 2013 (Cth) s 5AA

Migration Legislation Amendment Act 1989 (Cth) ss 5G, 59, 92, 93

Migration Amendment Act 1992 (Cth) ss 3A, 11, 38, 54L, 54K, 54W, 54ZD, 54Z

Migration Reform Act 1992 (Cth)

Migration Legislation Amendment Act 1994 (Cth) ss 4, 189, 196, 198

Financial Management and Accountability Regulations 1997 (Cth)

Financial Framework (Supplementary Powers) Regulations 1997 (Cth) reg 16

Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) reg 2.43

Cases cited:

Alcan (NT) Alumina Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Territory Revenue (NT) [2009] HCA 41; 239 CLR 27

Anthony Hordern & Sons Ltd v Amalgamated Clothing & Allied Trades Union of Australia [1932] HCA 9; 47 CLR 1

Attorney-General (Cth) v Oates [1999] HCA 35; 198 CLR 162

Attorney-General (SA) v Corporation of the City of Adelaide [2013] HCA 3; 249 CLR 1

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Valve Corporation (No 5) [2016] FCA 741

Aye v Minister for Immigration [2010] FCAFC 69; 187 FCR 449

AZC20 v Minister for Home Affairs [2021] FCA 1234

B v Secretary, Department of Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2004] FCA 699

Behrooz v Secretary of the Department of Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2004] HCA 36; 219 CLR 486

Bianca Hope Rinehart v Georgina Hope Rinehart [2014] FCA 1241

Burns Philp & Co Ltd v Murphy (1993)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Azimitabar v Commonwealth of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 760
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Azimitabar v Commonwealth of Australia, the Federal Court of Australia was asked to determine whether the Minister for Home Affairs had the authority to approve hotels as places of immigration detention and whether the applicant's detention in these hotels was lawful. The applicant, an Iranian citizen with psychiatric and psychological issues, was detained in hotels in Australia as part of his immigration detention process. The central legal issues revolved around the interpretation of the relevant provisions in the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) and the constitutionality of the Commonwealth's actions in approving hotels for immigration detention.

The court examined the definition of "immigration detention" under section 5(1) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) and whether the Minister had the authority to approve "another place" for immigration detention as per subpara (b)(v). The court also considered whether the power to approve "another place" was limited to de facto detention centres and whether the Commonwealth's expenditure on hotels for immigration detention was lawful under the Constitution and the Financial Framework (Supplementary Powers) Act 1997 (Cth).

In its reasoning, the court concluded that the Minister had the authority to approve hotels as places of immigration detention under subpara (b)(v) of the definition of "immigration detention". The court found that the power to approve "another place" was not limited to de facto detention centres, and therefore, hotels could be lawfully approved as places of immigration detention. Additionally, the court determined that the Commonwealth's contracting and expenditure on hotels for immigration detention was lawfully authorised by executive power under section 61 of the Constitution and section 32B of the Financial Framework (Supplementary Powers) Act 1997 (Cth).

As a result, the court dismissed the applicant's application, finding that the Minister had the power to approve hotels as places of immigration detention and that the applicant's detention in these hotels was lawful. The court ordered that the application be dismissed and that costs follow the event unless otherwise specified by the parties within the stipulated timeframe.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application be dismissed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

That should not, however, be understood as my approving the immigration detention the applicant was required to endure. I can only wonder at the lack of thought, indeed lack of care and humanity, in detaining a person with serious psychiatric and psychological problems in the Hotels for 14-months, primarily in a hotel room with a window that would only open 10cm, and for most of the time without access to an outdoor area to breathe fresh air or feel the sun on his face. For most of the time he was held in the Mantra Hotel he was restricted to his room, to the third floor of the hotel, and to the basement area when having meals. Anyone who endured even two weeks of hotel quarantine during the COVID-19 pandemic would surely understand how difficult that must have been. As a matter of ordinary human decency the applicant should not have been detained for such a period in those conditions, particularly when he was suffering from PTSD and a major depressive episode. But the decision in this case does not turn on the humanity of the applicant’s detention; it is about whether the Minister had power under the Act to approve the Hotels as places of immigration detention, and therefore to detain the applicant as he was. I consider the Minister had (and has) power to do so.2. THE EVIDENCE The parties jointly relied on a Statement of Agreed Facts dated 6 May 2022, and a further Statement of Agreed Facts dated 19 July 2022. The applicant also relies on:(a)his affidavit affirmed 29 April 2022 and the exhibits thereto, which was read in evidence. He was not cross-examined; and(b)the report of Emeritus Professor Richard Harding dated 9 May 2022 (Harding Report). It is primarily relevant to loss or damage, but the applicant also relies on it in support of his argument that the Hotels were de facto detention centres. Initially, the Commonwealth contended that the entirety of the Harding Report was inadmissible on the basis of relevance, and in the alternative that the report should be given no weight because Professor Harding failed to explain any proper basis for the opinions he expressed. The Commonwealth did not, however, continue with those objections, at least in this phase of the hearing. The report was received into evidence subject to a document titled Agreed Facts dated 19 July 2022 (Harding Agreed Facts) which sets out some agreed limitations in the basis for Professor Harding's opinions. Professor Harding was not cross examined. The Commonwealth relies on an affidavit of Gerard Watts, Superintendent of Detention Management and Planning, in the Australian Border Force (ABF), an agency within the portfolio of the Department of Home Affairs, affirmed 8 June 2022 and the exhibits thereto. Mr Watts was cross-examined.3. THE FACTS I have drawn this account largely from the two Statements of Agreed Facts, and the evidence of the applicant and Mr Watts. As I have said, the applicant is a 37-year-old citizen of Iran, of Kurdish ethnicity. He left Iran and arrived at Christmas Island, by boat, without a visa, in July 2013. At all material times Christmas Island was defined in s 5(1) of the Act to be an “excised offshore place”. The applicant was therefore an “unauthorised maritime arrival” and thus an “unlawful non-citizen” under the Act.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Upon the Commonwealth having again attended to that task I reached the view that the proposed redactions were appropriately calibrated to protect the matters about which the Commonwealth was concerned, and also to take account of the requirements of s 37AG and the interests of open justice. On 12 August 2022 I directed the Commonwealth to file and serve a redacted version of the affidavit of Mr Watts and the Court Book, which it attended to.9. CONCLUSION For the reasons I have explained, it is appropriate to dismiss the application. I am not aware of any reason why costs should not follow the event, and I will make such an order unless, within 14 days, either party proposes a different costs order and files written submissions (not exceeding three pages) in that regard. In that event, the opposing party shall file written submissions (not exceeding three pages) within seven days thereafter. Any application in relation to costs will then be dealt with on the papers.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Thereafter, from 11 November 2019 to 21 January 2021, the applicant was detained in Australia by, or on behalf of, the Commonwealth. From 11 November 2019 to 16 December 2020 he was detained at the Mantra Hotel, and from 17 December 2020 until 21 January 2021 at the Park Hotel. As I have said, the applicant was granted a bridging visa and released from immigration detention on 21 January 2021.3.1 Approval of the Mantra Hotel and the Park Hotel as ‘another place’ for immigration detention Throughout the period the applicant was detained in the Hotels delegates of the Minister issued written instruments approving (or at least, purporting to approve) the Mantra Hotel and later the Park Hotel as places of immigration detention. The following relevant written instruments are in evidence:(a)a written instrument dated 20 March 2019 by which a delegate of the Secretary of the Department, acting under powers as an “officer”, for the purpose of the definition of “immigration detention”, purported to approve the Mantra Hotel as a place of immigration detention, and revoke an earlier instrument of approval: Migration (APOD VIC 19/043: Approval of Places as Places of Detention) Instrument 2019;(b)a written instrument dated 2 February 2020 by which a delegate of the Minister for the purposes of subpara (b)(v) of the definition of “immigration detention” in subs 5(1) of the Act purported to approve the Mantra Hotel as a place of immigration detention, and repeal the 20 March 2019 instrument: Migration (Approval of Places of Immigration Detention) Instrument 2020/020; (c)a written instrument dated 12 August 2020 by which a delegate of the Minister for the purposes of subpara (b)(v) of the definition of “immigration detention” in subs 5(1) of the Act purported to approve the Mantra Hotel as a place of immigration detention, and repeal the 2 February 2020 instrument: Migration (Approval of Places of Immigration Detention) Instrument 2020/030; (d)a written instrument dated 11 December 2020 by which Mr Watts, a delegate of the Minister for the purposes of subpara (b)(v) of the definition of “immigration detention” in subs 5(1) of the Act purported to approve the Mantra Hotel and “Hotel on Swanston” at 701 Swanson Street, Carlton as places of immigration detention, and repeal the 12 August 2020 instrument: Migration (Approval of Places of Immigration Detention) Instrument 2020/036. The Hotel on Swanston was subsequently renamed the Park Hotel; and(e)a written instrument dated 21 December 2020 by which Mr Watts as a delegate of the Minister for the purposes of subpara (b)(v) of the definition of “immigration detention” in subs 5(1) of the Act purported to approve the Mantra Hotel and the Park Hotel, as places of immigration detention, and repeal the 11 December 2020 instrument: Migration (Approval of Places of Immigration Detention) Instrument 2020/038.3.2 The purpose for establishing the Hotels as places of detention The evidence shows that the Department contracted with Serco Australia Pty Ltd to operate the Hotels as immigration detention facilities, and indicates that the Department’s central purpose in approving the Hotels as places of immigration detention was so as to accommodate medical transferees to Australia from Nauru and Manus Island.