Moreton Bay Regional Council v Mekpine Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

FRENCH CJ,
KIEFEL, BELL, GAGELER AND NETTLE JJ

MORETON BAY REGIONAL COUNCIL  APPELLANT

AND

MEKPINE PTY LTD  RESPONDENT

Moreton Bay Regional Council v Mekpine Pty Ltd

[2016] HCA 7

10 March 2016

B60/2015

ORDER

1.Appeal allowed with costs.

2.Set aside orders 2 and 3 of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Queensland made on 2 December 2014, and in their place order that the appeal be dismissed with costs.

On appeal from the Supreme Court of Queensland

Representation

D F Jackson QC with A N S Skoien for the appellant (instructed by Moreton Bay Regional Council)

G W Diehm QC with P D Hay for the respondent (instructed by Hillhouse Burrough McKeown Pty Ltd)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

Real property – Resumption of land – Leases – Where registered lease expressed to confer interest over specified lot of land that was later amalgamated with adjacent lot – Where land previously part of adjacent lot resumed by local council – Whether lessee's interest extended to entire amalgamated lot upon registration of plan of subdivision under Land Title Act 1994 (Q) – Whether lessee had compensable interest in resumed land under Acquisition of Land Act 1967 (Q), s 12(5).

Real property – Leases – Retail leases – Construction and interpretation – Whether necessary to construe lease otherwise than in accordance with natural and ordinary effect of its terms.

Statutes – Interpretation – Function of definition clause – Whether definition of "Common Areas" in retail shop lease inconsistent with definition of "common areas" in Retail Shop Leases Act 1994 (Q), s 6.

Words and phrases – "common areas", "interest in land", "outgoings", "plan of subdivision", "registered lease", "registration of an instrument", "resumed land", "retail shop lease", "retail shopping centre".

Acquisition of Land Act 1967 (Q), ss 2, 12(5).
Acts Interpretation Act 1954 (Q), s 36.
Land Title Act 1994 (Q), ss 12, 49, 49A, 50, 64, 65, 182, 183, 184, Sched 2.
Retail Shop Leases Act 1994 (Q), ss 3, 5, 6, 7(1), 8, 19, 20, 38(2), 40(1), Pt 3 Div 2, Schedule.

  1. FRENCH CJ, KIEFEL, BELL AND NETTLE JJ.   This is an appeal from a judgment of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Queensland.  The respondent ("Mekpine") was a tenant in a shopping centre.  Mekpine's registered lease was expressed to be over certain premises on land described as "Lot 6 on RP 809722" ("former Lot 6").  The lessor subsequently registered a plan of subdivision under the Land Title Act 1994 (Q) ("the LTA") to amalgamate former Lot 6 and an adjacent lot ("former Lot 1"[1]) to create a larger lot ("new Lot 1"[2]).  When part of the land, which was part of former Lot 1, was resumed by the appellant ("the Council"), Mekpine claimed compensation under the Acquisition of Land Act 1967 (Q) ("the ALA").

    [1]Former Lot 1 was on RP 847798.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Moreton Bay Regional Council v Mekpine Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] HCA 7
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia heard an appeal concerning a dispute between Moreton Bay Regional Council and Mekpine Pty Ltd regarding a retail lease and the subsequent resumption of land. Mekpine Pty Ltd held a registered lease for a shop within a shopping centre located on former Lot 6. The lessor later acquired adjacent former Lot 1 and, following amalgamation of the two lots into a new Lot 1, a portion of this new Lot 1 was resumed by the Council. The central question was whether Mekpine's leasehold interest extended to the entirety of the new Lot 1, or remained confined to the portion of the new Lot 1 that had originally comprised former Lot 6.

The legal issues before the Court were primarily concerned with the interpretation of the lease agreement and relevant Queensland legislation, specifically the *Land Title Act 1994* (Qld) and the *Acquisition of Land Act 1967* (Qld). The Court was required to determine whether the registration of a plan of subdivision amalgamating former Lots 6 and 1, and the subsequent endorsement of Mekpine's lease on this plan, had the effect of extending Mekpine's leasehold interest to the entire new Lot 1. Furthermore, the Court had to consider whether Mekpine possessed a compensable interest in the resumed land under section 12(5) of the *Acquisition of Land Act 1967* (Qld). This also involved examining the definition of "Common Areas" within the lease and its potential inconsistency with the definition in the *Retail Shop Leases Act 1994* (Qld).

The High Court reasoned that the *Land Title Act 1994* (Qld) establishes a system of title by registration, where a lot created by the registration of a plan of subdivision is a distinct parcel of land. Upon the amalgamation of former Lots 6 and 1, these former lots ceased to exist as separate entities, and a new Lot 1 was created. The Court held that Mekpine's registered lease, which originally referred to premises on former Lot 6, did not automatically extend to the entirety of the new Lot 1 upon amalgamation. The lease's interest in land remained confined to that part of the new Lot 1 which had previously been former Lot 6. Consequently, Mekpine did not hold a compensable interest in the resumed land, as their leasehold interest did not encompass the resumed portion of the new Lot 1. The Court also found that the definition of "Common Areas" in the lease was not supplanted by the definition in the *Retail Shop Leases Act 1994* (Qld).

The High Court allowed the appeal, setting aside the orders of the Court of Appeal and ordering that Mekpine's appeal to that court be dismissed with costs. Mekpine was ordered to pay the Council's costs in the High Court.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed with costs.

2. Set aside orders 2 and 3 of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Queensland made on 2 December 2014, and in their place order that the appeal be dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

The question in the appeal is whether Mekpine's rights under a lease of premises on former Lot 6 remained over that part of new Lot 1 which previously lay within former Lot 6 or whether they extended to the entirety of new Lot 1. For the reasons which follow, it should be concluded that Mekpine's interest in land remained confined to that part of new Lot 1 which previously lay within former Lot 6.The facts In March 1999, Mekpine entered into a 10 year retail lease ("the Lease") of a shop ("the Premises") within the Castle Hill Shopping Court in Murrumba Downs, Queensland ("the Shopping Centre") with options to renew. At that time, the Shopping Centre lay within the land comprised in former Lot 6. The Premises were defined in Item 3 of the Schedule to the Lease as: "Shop 1 at Castle Hill Shopping Court, Corner Dohles Rocks Road and Ogg Road, Murrumba Downs, Queensland, 4503".The Schedule to the Lease included a diagram setting out the metes and bounds of the Premises and former Lot 6. Clause 6.1 of the Lease conferred on Mekpine a right of exclusive possession of the Premises for the permitted use of operating a supermarket. In addition, cl 6.8 of the Lease provided that Mekpine was entitled to use the "Common Areas", in common with other tenants, as follows: "The Lessee and the Lessee's Employees may use the Common Areas but must obey all reasonable directions and rules given by the Lessor relating to their use. The Lessee must not obstruct the Common Areas or Car Park." "Common Areas" were defined in cl 1.2 of the Lease as "those areas of the Building or the Land which have not been leased or licensed by the Lessor". "Land", which appears in the definition of "Common Areas", was defined as "the lot described in Item 2 of the Form 7 in this Lease" and Item 2 of the Form 7 referenced former Lot 6 as the relevant "Land". Clause 15 further provided, however, in broad terms, that the Lease did not give Mekpine any rights to the Common Areas other than those specifically provided for in the Lease, that the Common Areas were the property of the lessor and that the lessor retained a right to use, control, manage, alter, close or deal with the Common Areas as the lessor might deem appropriate. The Lease was registered in the freehold land register kept under and for the purposes of the LTA on 25 January 2002. Subsequently, the lessor acquired former Lot 1, which was adjacent to former Lot 6, and obtained planning approval to extend the Shopping Centre over former Lot 1 on condition that former Lot 1 be amalgamated with former Lot 6 and that the area which later became the resumed land be excluded from the proposed development and kept clear of permanent structures and improvements. In accordance with that approval, in 2007 former Lot 1 was amalgamated with former Lot 6 by registration of a plan of subdivision under Div 3 of Pt 4 of the LTA, thereby creating new Lot 1 ("the Plan of Subdivision"). The Lease was endorsed on the Plan of Subdivision under the heading "EXISTING LEASE ALLOCATIONS" and identified as an encumbrance on the title.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH CJ, KIEFEL, BELL AND NETTLE JJ GAGELER J
In short, the RSLA definition of "common areas" did not supplant the definition of Common Areas in the Lease, and Mekpine does not have a compensable "interest" in the Resumed Land[33].[33]ALA, s 12(5).Conclusion For these reasons, the appeal should be allowed. Orders 2 and 3 of the Court of Appeal made on 2 December 2014 should be set aside. In lieu, it should be ordered that the appeal to the Court of Appeal is dismissed with costs. Mekpine should pay the Council's costs in this Court. The orders proposed in the joint reasons for judgment will have the effect of reinstating the negative answer given by the Land Appeal Court to the question of whether Mekpine had an interest which was compensable under the ALA on the resumption of the Resumed Land. I agree with those orders. In relation to the construction and application of the RSLA, I agree with the joint reasons for judgment and have nothing to add. In relation to the construction and application of the LTA, I prefer to state my own reasons. The LTA adopts the conventional design of providing for title by registration as distinct from registration of title[34]. It defines "lot" to mean "a separate, distinct parcel of land created", relevantly, on "the registration of a plan of subdivision"[35]. It provides that "[a] lot or part of a lot may be leased by registering an instrument of lease for the lot or part"[36]. It defines "instrument" not only specifically to include a "plan of survey"[37], of which a plan of subdivision is a kind[38], but also to extend to any "document that deals with a lot and may be registered"[39]. It provides in s 182 that "[o]n registration of an instrument that is expressed to ... create an interest in a lot, the interest ... is ... created in accordance with the instrument ... and ... vests in the person identified in the instrument as the person entitled to the interest". It defines "registered proprietor" to mean a person recorded in the register as "a person entitled to an interest in a lot"[40], and it provides subject to immaterial exceptions that "[a] registered proprietor of an interest in a lot holds the interest subject to registered interests affecting the lot but free from all other interests"[41]. [34]Peldan v Anderson (2006) 227 CLR 471 at 480 [20]; [2006] HCA 48.[35]Schedule 2 to the LTA, "lot". See also s 49A of the LTA.[36]Section 64 of the LTA.[37]Schedule 2 to the LTA, "instrument".[38]Section 49 of the LTA.[39]Schedule 2 to the LTA, "instrument".[40]Schedule 2 to the LTA, "proprietor" and "registered proprietor".[41]Section 184(1) of the LTA. On the registration of a plan of subdivision which provides for "amalgamation of 2 or more lots to create a smaller number of lots"[42], "[a] lot defined in the plan is created as a lot"[43]. It is implicit in the definition of a lot as a separate and distinct parcel of land that lots amalgamated must cease to exist. That is because the definition does not admit of the coexistence of overlapping lots. [42]Section 49(b) of the LTA.[43]Section 49A(2) of the LTA.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FRENCH CJ, KIEFEL, BELL AND NETTLE JJ, GAGELER J

Full text does not contain this section.