Reid v City of Gosnells

Link copied
Case Copied 77 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CIVIL

CITATION:   REID -v- CITY OF GOSNELLS [2023] WASC 48

CORAM:   ARCHER J

HEARD:   14, 28 & 30 JUNE, 1 & 7 JULY 2022 & FURTHER SUBMISSIONS IN AUGUST & SEPTEMBER 2022

DELIVERED          :   5 APRIL 2023

FILE NO/S:   CIV 2263 of 2021

BETWEEN:   JIM REID

Applicant

AND

CITY OF GOSNELLS

Respondent

WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION

Other Party


Catchwords:

Judicial review - Construction of planning legislation and planning schemes - Right to undertake 'public work' - Planning approval - Multiple activities - Proper approach to determining 'uses' - Proper construction of zones in Metropolitan Region Scheme - Must local planning schemes and development approvals under local and region schemes be 'consistent' with the MRS zone

Legislation:

Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA)

Result:

Application for judicial review allowed

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicant : K M Pettit SC & C M Fisher
Respondent : D W McLeod
Other Party : I A Repper & B Loftus

Solicitors:

Applicant : Glen Mcleod Legal
Respondent : McLeods
Other Party : State Solicitor's Office

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

ABT17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2020] HCA 34; (2020) 269 CLR 439

Aloi Holdings Pty Ltd v John Nominees Pty Ltd [2019] WASC 270

Bright Image Dental Pty Ltd v City of Gosnells [2018] WASCA 134

Castle and City of Rockingham [2018] WASAT 98

City of Canning v Avon Capital Estates (Australia) Ltd [2012] WASC 223

City of South Perth v ALH Group Property Holdings Pty Ltd [2016] WASC 141; (2016) LGERA 96

City of Swan v Snowdale Holdings Pty Ltd [2016] WASC 260

Council of the New South Wales Bar Association v EFA (a pseudonym) [2021] NSWCA 339

Dawe v Town Planning Board (Unreported, TPAT Appeal No. 5/1979, 17 December 1979)

Deputy Commissioner of Taxation v Clark [2003] NSWCA 91; (2003) 57 NSWLR 113

Epic Energy (Pilbara Pipeline) Pty Ltd v Commissioner of State Revenue [2011] WASCA 228; (2011) 43 WAR 186

Forrest & Forrest Pty Ltd v The Honourable William Richard Marmion, Minister for Mines and Petroleum [2017] WASCA 153; (2017) 51 WAR 425

Foster v Aloni [1951] VLR 481

G & G Corp Asset Management Pty Ltd and Presiding Member, Metropolitan East Joint Development Assessment Panel [2018] WASAT 9

General Nominees Pty Ltd (ATF Family Trust Four) v The Metro Inner-North Joint Development Assessment Panel [2022] WASC 114

Hossain v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] HCA 34; (2018) 264 CLR 123

House of Peace Pty Ltd v Bankstown City Council [2000] NSWCA 44; (2000) 48 NSWLR 498

Huntingdale Village Pty Ltd (receivers and managers appointed) v Corrs Chambers Westgarth (a firm) [No 3] [2016] WASC 366

Kelly v The Queen [2004] HCA 12; (2004) 218 CLR 216

Legal Services Board v Gillespie-Jones (2013) 249 CLR 492; [2013] HCA 35

Lizzio v Ryde Municipal Council (1983) 155 CLR 211

Mandurah Enterprises Pty Ltd v Western Australian Planning Commission [2008] WASCA 211

Marshall…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Reid v City of Gosnells and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] WASC 48
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Applicant, a resident of the City of Gosnells, sought judicial review of a decision by the Respondent, the City of Gosnells, to approve a development application for a new Operations Centre and Waste Transfer Facility on a former landfill site. The Applicant contended that the proposed development included activities that were prohibited uses in the relevant zone and that the City had failed to comply with relevant planning legislation in approving the development. The Applicant argued that the City was not entitled to undertake the proposed development as a 'public work' and that the approval of the development was inconsistent with the Metropolitan Region Scheme (MRS) and the City's Local Planning Scheme No. 6 (TPS 6). The court had to decide whether the proposed development was a 'public work', whether the City complied with relevant planning legislation, and whether the development approval was inconsistent with the MRS Rural Zone. The court had to determine the proper approach to determining 'uses' in proposed developments, the meaning of 'Civic Use' in TPS 6, and whether the green waste grinding was an existing use.
The court held that the proposed development was a 'public work' that the City was entitled to undertake. The court found that the City had complied with s 6(2) of the Planning and Development Act in relation to the Proposed Development. The court held that the judicial review application should not be dismissed as relief would not be futile. The court held that the proper approach to determining 'uses' in proposed developments was to consider the activities that would be carried on at the development and whether they were consistent with the relevant planning scheme. The court held that 'Civic Use' in TPS 6 meant any governmental purpose. The court held that the Proposed Development that was approved included activities that were prohibited uses in the relevant zone and that the development approval was inconsistent with the MRS Rural Zone. The court held that the green waste grinding was not an existing use and that the Proposed Development was inconsistent with the MRS Rural Zone. The court held that the Applicant had standing to seek a declaration and that the development approval was invalid.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The following facts were agreed (Agreed Facts).[2][2] Agreed Statement of Facts filed 1 March 2022.Site of the Respondent's proposed Operations Centre1.The site of the proposed Operations Centre (including the Waste Transfer Facility) together with the surrounding vegetated buffer, the subject of the Applicant's application for judicial review is:(a) Lot 239 on Plan 3327 (Volume 1463, Folio 89); (b)Lots 241 & 242 on Plan 3327 (Volume 1031, Folio 307);(c) Lot 3 on Diagram 16433 (Volume 1184, Folio 164);(d) Lot 4 on Diagram 16433 (Volume 1688, Folio 285);(e)Lot 500 on Deposited Plan 32254 (Volume 1436, Folio 456); and(f)Lot 501 on Deposited Plan 32254 (Volume 1152, Folio 804),(together referred to as the Site). 2.Each Lot within the Site is held in fee simple by the Respondent (the City).3.The Site is located wholly within the local government district of the City.4.The proposed Operations Centre has an area of 6.96 hectares containing each building and its curtilage. It comprises the central remediated portion of the former Orange Grove landfill site (landfill site). The proposal includes a 13.63 hectare vegetated buffer surrounding the Operations Centre, and the City has made available a further 28.6 hectares of [public open space] directly north intended as a further vegetated buffer. The total 49.19 hectares of the proposed New Operations Centre and buffers comprises the now disused landfill site, and is all owned in fee simple by the City.5.The proposed Operations Centre including the Waste Transfer Facility would provide services and facilities to the community of the City's district.6.The total 49.19 hectares of the proposed New Operations Centre and buffers is zoned Rural under the Metropolitan Region Scheme (MRS) and General Rural under the City of Gosnells Town Planning Scheme No. 6 (TPS 6).7.The proposed New Operations Centre is required to replace the City's Current Operations Centre in Maddington.The Applicant8.The Applicant resides on, but does not own, a rural residential lot of 1.0337 hectares at 89 Victoria Road, Wattle Grove. The residence on 89 Victoria Road is, at its nearest point: (a)approximately 350 metres from the northern boundary of the Site;(b)approximately 500 metres from the northern boundary of the site of the Operations Centre; and (c)approximately 550 metres from the nearest point of the Waste Transfer Facility.The Development Application to the City9.By letter dated 24 June 2020, the City's Infrastructure Directorate lodged a development application with the City's Development Control Unit which received and recorded the Application Description of the proposal as -'Development Application - Lots 242, 241, 3, 4, 239, 500 and 501 Brock Street, Orange Grove - Operations Centre and Waste Transfer Facility' -and recorded the Use Classes as 'Civic Use' and 'Use Not Listed' -'Waste Transfer Facility'.10.The City Development Application was for an Operations Centre that would provide to the City of Gosnells community the services and facilities detailed in para.32 of the Affidavit of Martyn Anthony Glover sworn 24 January 2022, and filed in this matter (MA Glover Affidavit).11.The New Operations Centre was proposed by the City as a composite use at which a range of activities would be carried on including those activities detailed in para.34 of the MA Glover Affidavit.12.The City says but the Applicant denies, that 'All of those activities would be carried on at the New Operations Centre, as parts of a single enterprise, under the management and direction of the City's Infrastructure Directorate.'

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Paragraph 25 of the Agreed Facts refers to a report for the Statutory Planning Committee of the WAPC for its reconsideration of the City's application. I will refer to this report as the 'WAPC Reconsideration Report'.[4] Paragraph 26 of the Agreed Facts states that that report referred to several plans, plans 10381-A01-B to 10381‑A010-B and 10381-A026-C. There was a typographical error in the reference in the report to plan 10381-A026-C, titled 'Site Plan: Site, Bund, Greenwaste Location and Building Locality Plan'. The '6' should have been a 'b'.[5] This plan, plan 10381-A02b-C,[6] had some red notations on it and was relied on by the applicant. I will refer to it as the 'Marked Plan'.[4] Affidavit of Sally Patricia Grebe sworn on 24 January 2022 filed in CIV 2277 of 2021 (Grebe Affidavit) page 446.[5] This was the view of both the applicant (ts 226) and the WAPC (ts 300). The City conceded it 'could be' - ts 395 - 396. There was no evidence of any plan with the designation '10381-A026-C'.[6] Grebe Affidavit page 516. The application for judicial review describes the ground of review as follows:Several of the uses purportedly approved by the City are uses that are classified 'X' uses for the General Rural zone in the City's Local Planning Scheme No. 6, whereas X uses are incapable of approval by reason of clause 67(1)(a) of the Planning and Development (Local Planning Schemes) Regulations 2015 Schedule 2, namely the 'X' uses of:(a)Green waste grinding.(b)Workshop and general stores building.(c)Motor vehicle repair.(d)Chemical mixing use.(e)Waste transfer facility.(f)Dog holding facility (kennel). The parties filed an agreed list of issues prior to the hearing. On further inquiry during the first day of the hearing, the parties agreed that one of the issues they had included on the list was not an issue, some amendment was required to other issues, and a new issue should be added. Further, after the first day of the hearing, the City withdrew its contention that the applicant did not have a special interest sufficient to give him standing to seek a declaration. In my view, the issues can best be described as follows:Public Works1.Was the Proposed Development a 'public work' that the City was entitled to undertake within the meaning of s 6 of the Planning and Development Act?2.If the answer to question 1 is 'yes', did the City comply with s 6(2) of the Planning and Development Act in relation to the Proposed Development?3.If the answer to question 2 is 'no', should the judicial review application nevertheless be dismissed as relief would be futile?Development ApprovalIf the answer to any of questions 1, 2 or 3 is 'no', the following questions arise.4.What is the proper approach to determining 'uses' in proposed developments?5.What does 'Civic Use' mean in TPS 6? In particular, does it mean any governmental purpose?6.What was the Proposed Development that was approved?7.What was/were the 'use(s)' of the Proposed Development? 8.Was the green waste grinding an existing use, such that development approval could be given even if it was a Prohibited Use?9.Was the Proposed Development inconsistent with the MRS Rural Zone?