Apache Energy Ltd v Alcoa of Australia Ltd [No 2]

Link copied
Case Copied 77 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

TITLE OF COURT  :   THE COURT OF APPEAL (WA)

CITATION:   APACHE ENERGY LTD -v- ALCOA OF AUSTRALIA LTD [No 2] [2013] WASCA 213

CORAM:   McLURE P

BUSS JA
NEWNES JA

HEARD:   10 APRIL 2013

DELIVERED          :   17 SEPTEMBER 2013

FILE NO/S:   CACV 95 of 2012

CONSOLIDATED WITH CACV 94 OF 2012 AND CACV 97 OF 2012 BY ORDER DATED 4 SEPTEMBER 2012

BETWEEN:   APACHE ENERGY LTD

First Appellant

APACHE NORTHWEST PTY LTD
Second Appellant

HARRIET (ONYX) PTY LTD
Third Appellant

AND

ALCOA OF AUSTRALIA LTD
Respondent

ON APPEAL FROM:

Jurisdiction              :  SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

Coram  :LE MIERE J

Citation  :ALCOA OF AUSTRALIA LTD -v- APACHE ENERGY LTD [2012] WASC 209

File No  :CIV 1481 of 2011

Catchwords:

Tort - Negligence - Duty of care - Pure economic loss - Contracts for the supply of gas by the appellants to the respondent - Interruption in the supply of gas - Whether respondent's claim in negligence untenable - Whether summary judgment should be entered for the appellants

Legislation:

Petroleum Pipelines Act 1969 (WA), s 36A, s 38
Petroleum Pipelines Regulations 1970 (WA), reg 10 (repealed)
Rules of the Supreme Court of Western Australia 1971 (WA), O 16 r 1(1)

Result:

Leave to appeal refused
Appeals dismissed

Category:    A

Representation:

Counsel:

First Appellant              :     Mr J H Karkar QC & Mr G P Harris

Second Appellant          :     Mr J H Karkar QC & Mr G P Harris

Third Appellant            :     Mr K N Stewart & Ms A Richmond-Scott

Respondent:     Mr D G Collins SC & Mr K J Lyons SC

Solicitors:

First Appellant              :     Middletons

Second Appellant          :     Clifford Chance

Third Appellant            :     Lavan Legal

Respondent:     Tottle Partners

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Alcoa of Australia Ltd v Apache Energy Ltd [2012] WASC 209

Alcoa of Australia Ltd v Apache Energy Ltd [No 2] [2012] WASC 280

Astley v Austrust Ltd [1999] HCA 6; (1999) 197 CLR 1

Baker v Bolton (1808) 1 Camp 493; (1808) 170 ER 1033

Barclay v Penberthy [2012] HCA 40; (2012) 246 CLR 258

Bell v The State of Western Australia [2004] WASCA 205

Bow Valley Husky (Bermuda) Ltd v Saint John Shipbuilding Ltd [1997] 3 SCR 1210

British American Tobacco Australia Ltd v The State of Western Australia [2003] HCA 47; (2003) 217 CLR 30

British Columbia Hydro and Power Authority v BG Checo International Ltd [1993] 1 SCR 12

Bryan v Maloney [1995] HCA 17; (1995) 182 CLR 609

Caltex Oil (Australia) Pty Ltd v The Dredge 'Willemstad' [1976] HCA 65; (1976) 136 CLR 529

Caltex Refineries (Qld) Pty Ltd v Stavar [2009] NSWCA 258; (2009) 75 NSWLR 649

Canadian Pacific Hotels Ltd v Bank of Montreal [1987] 1 SCR 711

Caparo Industries Plc v Dickman [1990] 2 AC 605

Central Trust Co v Rafuse [1986] 2 SCR 147

Cifuentes v Fugro Spatial Solutions Pty Ltd [2009] WASC 316

Crimmins v Stevedoring Industry Finance Committee [1999] HCA 59

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Apache Energy Ltd v Alcoa of Australia Ltd [No 2] and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] WASCA 213
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Apache Energy Ltd v Alcoa of Australia Ltd [No 2], the appellants sought to appeal against an interlocutory decision of the General Division of the Supreme Court. The primary judge, Le Miere J, had dismissed the appellants' applications to summarily dismiss the respondent's claims against them for negligence resulting in pure economic loss. The primary dispute centred on contracts for the supply of gas by the appellants to the respondent, which were interrupted. The court was required to determine whether the respondent's claim in negligence was untenable and if summary judgment should be granted in favour of the appellants. The appeal was dismissed by the court, which refused leave to appeal and dismissed the appellants' appeals. The court further ordered that the appellants pay the respondent's costs of the applications for leave to appeal and the appeals, to be taxed if not agreed. The court's reasoning focused on the policy considerations that have historically prevented the recognition of a duty of care in cases involving pure economic loss, and whether those considerations were significant in this case. The court ultimately concluded that the requisite relationship of proximity existed between the parties, and the policy considerations were insignificant.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT: On 17 September 2013, this court refused leave to appeal and dismissed the appellants' appeals. See Apache Energy Ltd v Alcoa of Australia Ltd [No 2] [2013] WASCA 213. The appellants had applied for leave to appeal from an interlocutory decision of the primary judge, Le Miere J, in pending proceedings in the General Division of the Supreme Court. His Honour had dismissed the appellants' applications summarily to dismiss the respondent's claims against the appellants under the law of negligence for pure economic loss. On 17 September 2013, this court made the following orders:1.Leave to appeal be refused2.The appeals be dismissed.3.Until further order, the court will not publish the Confidential Schedule to the reasons of Buss JA to any person or entity except the parties to the appeals.4.The appellants pay the respondent's costs of the applications for leave to appeal and the appeals to be taxed, if not agreed.5.By 4.00 pm on 26 September 2013 the respondent file and serve written submissions as to the basis on which the costs of the two senior counsel for the respondent should be taxed.6.By 4.00 pm on 3 October 2013 the appellants file and serve any written submissions in response. Pursuant to Order 5, the respondent applied for this court to certify for two senior counsel in the appeal, alternatively for second counsel. The appellants accept that the respondent should be entitled to claim taxed costs for a senior counsel and a junior counsel in the appeal, but not for two senior counsel. The respondent's submissions in support of its application are, in summary, as follows:(a)Mr KJ Lyons SC, the second senior counsel, was made senior counsel on 27 November 2012.(b)At the three‑day hearing before the primary judge on 26 - 27 and 31 October 2011, Mr Collins SC appeared with Mr Lyons as his junior (and another junior, Mr De Young). The first and second appellants were represented by two senior counsel, Mr Karkar QC and Mr O'Callaghan SC, and by junior counsel, Mr Harris. The third appellant was also represented by senior counsel, Mr Howard SC, and junior counsel, Mr Lockhart.(c)The respondent filed its written submissions in the appeal on 26 October 2012. Those submissions were prepared by Mr Collins SC, Mr Lyons and Mr De Young. At the time, Mr Lyons was a junior counsel.(d)Mr De Young is no longer briefed in the matter. His brief ended after the written submissions were filed.(e)In these circumstances, in addition to the ground of complexity, it was less expensive to retain Mr Lyons as Mr Collins' junior in the appeals, given his longstanding involvement in the matter, rather than brief new junior counsel.(f)In addition, the fact that a single day 'pleading appeal' resulted in a 76‑page closely reasoned judgment of this court shows the matter was of sufficient complexity, particularly as to the law of vulnerability and causation and the inter‑relationship of those principles with some express terms of the gas supply contracts, to justify the involvement of two senior counsel on behalf of the respondent.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Their Honours observed that the policy considerations which have militated against the recognition of a relationship of proximity in cases involving pure economic loss include (618):(a)avoiding the imposition of liability 'in an indeterminate amount for an indeterminate time to an indeterminate class': Ultramares Corporation v Touche (1931) 174 NE 441, 444 (Chief Judge Cardozo); and(b)inconsistency with community standards as to what is ordinarily legitimate in pursuing personal advantage in the context of a competitive environment where one person's economic gain may be another's loss. Mason CJ, Deane and Gaudron JJ noted that there was no decision of the High Court which directly determined whether the relationship between the builder and the purchaser 'possessed the requisite degree of proximity to give rise to a duty', on the part of the builder, to take reasonable care to avoid the kind of economic loss suffered by the purchaser (619). Their Honours said that the resolution of that question necessarily required 'the articulation of both the factual components of the relevant category of relationship and the identification of any applicable policy considerations' (619). After engaging in that task, they concluded that the requisite relationship of proximity existed and that the policy considerations which ordinarily militate against the recognition of a relationship of proximity and a consequent duty of care with respect to pure economic loss were insignificant (627). Their Honours expressly confined the significance, for future cases, of their decision (630):It should be apparent from what has been written above that the decision in this case turns, to no small extent, on the particular kind of economic loss involved, namely, the diminution in value of a house when the inadequacy of its footings first becomes manifest by reason of consequent damage to the fabric of the house. In particular, the nature of the property involved, namely a building which was erected to be used as a permanent dwelling house, constitutes an important consideration supporting the conclusion that a relevant relationship of proximity existed between Mr Bryan, as the builder, and Mrs Maloney, as a subsequent owner. That being so, the decision in this case is not directly decisive of the question whether a relevant relationship of proximity exists in other categories of case or as regards other kinds of damage. In particular, the decision in this case should not be seen as determinative of the question whether a relationship of proximity can, in some circumstances, exist between the manufacturer and the purchaser or subsequent owner of a chattel in respect of the diminution in the value of the chattel which is sustained when a latent defect in it first becomes manifest (cf Rivtow Marine Ltd v Washington Iron Works (1973) 40 DLR (3d) 530). In Perre v Apand Pty Ltd [1999] HCA 36; (1999) 198 CLR 180, a number of farmers grew potatoes in a rural location in South Australia. Some of the potatoes were exported to Western Australia. The respondent negligently introduced a disease known as bacterial wilt on to the land of one of the farmers, Sparnon. Western Australian regulations prohibited the import into Western Australia of potatoes grown on land known to be affected by the disease and, also, of potatoes grown on land within a prescribed distance of the affected land. The appellants were involved in growing potatoes on land within the prescribed distance of the affected land. They claimed to have suffered financial loss. The issue was whether the respondent owed a duty of care to the appellants or any of them. No property belonging to or used by the appellants suffered any physical harm. The loss they had allegedly suffered was pure economic loss. The High Court held that the respondent owed the appellants a duty of care not to cause economic loss as a result of the introduction of the disease. There was, however, no majority agreement within the High Court as to the general principle to be applied.