Anderson Group Pty Ltd v Tynan Motors Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION:      The Anderson Group Pty Ltd v Tynan Motors Pty Ltd [No. 2] [2006]  NSWCA 120

FILE NUMBER(S):
40997/04

HEARING DATE(S):            22 and 23 September 2005

DECISION DATE:     18/05/2006

PARTIES:
The Anderson Group Pty Ltd - (Appellant)
Tynan Motors Pty Ltd - (Respondent)

JUDGMENT OF:      Santow JA Basten JA Young CJ in Eq   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: District Court

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):        DC 7208/02

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:     Hughes DCJ

COUNSEL:
J Gleeson SC and JJ Young (Appellant)
A S Martin SC and A RZahra (Respondent)

SOLICITORS:
Rockliffs (Appellant)
McMahons Lawyers (Respondent)

CATCHWORDS:
COSTS - successful appellant previously made formal offers of settlement on three occasions - whether costs should be awarded on indemnity basis - date from which indemnity costs should be assessed - whether offers were each a true compromise

LEGISLATION CITED:
Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW), s9(3), Schedule 6
Supreme Court Act, s38

DECISION:
The following orders are made in addition to the three orders made on 21 February 2006:
(1)  the verdict for the Appellant, in addition to the sum of $166,000, to include interest to 21 February 2006 in the sum of $91,422.79
(2)  the costs of the Appellant in the District Court to be assessed on an indemnity basis from 1 October 2002
(3)  the costs of the Appellant in this Court to be assessed on an indemnity basis from 8 September 2005

JUDGMENT:

- 8 -

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COURT OF APPEAL

CA 40997/04
DC 7208/02

SANTOW JA
BASTEN JA
YOUNG CJ in EQ

18 May 2006

THE ANDERSON GROUP PTY LTD v TYNAN MOTORS PTY LTD [No. 2]

Costs Judgment

  1. SANTOW JA:  I agree with Basten JA.

  2. BASTEN JA:  Following delivery of judgment in this matter on 21 February 2006, the Court received an application from the Appellant seeking a variation of the orders to provide for interest and to make the costs payable on an indemnity basis.  Directions were given as to the filing of any evidence and the exchange of written submissions.

  3. As appeared from the submissions for the Respondent, the only matter in issue was whether costs should be awarded on an indemnity basis, and if so, from what date.  The entitlement to interest was conceded.

  4. On three occasions the Appellant made formal offers of settlement.  Each involved a Calderbank letter, the two later letters being accompanied by a formal offer of compromise pursuant to the relevant Court rules.  Although the amount of the offer was in each case greater than the principal component of the claim, in no case did it reach the total amount, including interest from the date on which the vehicle was taken until the date of the offer.  The Appellant’s claim had  sought both principal and interest and, as it submitted in support of its application for a judgment including interest, such an award is almost invariable where a money judgment is obtained:  see Falkner v Bourke (1990) 19 NSWLR 574 at…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Anderson Group Pty Ltd v Tynan Motors Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] NSWCA 120
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In *Anderson Group Pty Ltd v Tynan Motors Pty Ltd (No 2)*, the New South Wales Court of Appeal considered an application for supplementary orders regarding costs following an successful appeal by Anderson Group Pty Ltd (the Appellant) against Tynan Motors Pty Ltd (the Respondent). The dispute concerned the assessment of costs on an indemnity basis, following the Appellant's prior offers of settlement.

The primary legal issues before the Court of Appeal were whether the Appellant, as the successful party, should be awarded costs on an indemnity basis, and if so, from what date such indemnity costs should be assessed, particularly in light of three formal offers of settlement made by the Appellant. The Court was required to determine if these offers constituted a "true compromise" sufficient to warrant an indemnity costs order.

The Court reasoned that one of the offers made in the District Court, dated 25 June 2003, involved only a marginal compromise and was arguably not a genuine compromise. This, coupled with the significant passage of time and the Appellant's initial adverse judgment, led the Court to give little weight to the District Court offers when considering the costs of the appeal. Consequently, the Court ordered that the ordinary costs order for the appeal would apply until the date from which indemnity costs were to be paid, as determined by an offer made in the Court of Appeal itself. The Court made supplementary orders, including that the verdict for the Appellant include specific interest, and that the Appellant's costs in both the District Court and the Court of Appeal be assessed on an indemnity basis from particular dates (1 October 2002 for the District Court and 8 September 2005 for the Court of Appeal).

Orders

Orders of the court

The following orders are made in addition to the three orders made on 21 February 2006:;

(1) the verdict for the Appellant, in addition to the sum of $166,000, to include interest to 21 February 2006 in the sum of $91,422.79;

(2) the costs of the Appellant in the District Court to be assessed on an indemnity basis from 1 October 2002;

(3) the costs of the Appellant in this Court to be assessed on an indemnity basis from 8 September 2005

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

YOUNG CJ
As noted above, the second offer made below, on 25 June 2003, involved a very marginal compromise of the claimed amount, and was not, arguably, a genuine compromise at all. That fact, combined with the passage of time since it was made and the circumstance that the Appellant had received an adverse judgment in the District Court, suggest that the Court should give little weight to either of the offers made in the District Court with respect to the costs of the appeal. Accordingly, the ordinary order with respect to costs in this Court will apply up until the date from which indemnity costs are to be paid pursuant to the offer made in this Court.Conclusions The orders made on 21 February 2006 were as follows:(1) appeal allowed;(2)orders in the District Court vacated and in lieu thereof enter a verdict for the Appellant for $166,000 with costs, both in this Court and in the District Court;(3)the Respondent is to have a certificate under the Suitors' Fund Act if qualified to receive such a certificate. These orders should stand, but the following supplementary orders should be made:(4)the verdict for the Appellant, in addition to the sum of $166,000, to include interest to 21 February 2006 in the sum of $91,422.79;(5)the costs of the Appellant in the District Court to be assessed on an indemnity basis from 1 October 2002;(6)the costs of the Appellant in this Court to be assessed on an indemnity basis from 8 September 2005. in EQ: I agree with Basten JA.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: YOUNG CJ