Rolls Royce Industrial Power (Pacific) Ltd v James Hardie & Co Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 69 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION:      Rolls Royce Industrial Power (Pacific) Limited (Formerly John Thompson (Australia) Pty Limited) v James Hardie & Coy Pty Limited; James Hardie & Coy Pty Limited v The State of New South Wales; James Hardie & Coy Pty Limited v Rolls Royce Industrial Power (Pacific) Limited (Formerly John Thompson (Australia) Pty Limited) [2001]  NSWCA 461

FILE NUMBER(S):
40851/99
40852/99
40432/00

HEARING DATE(S):               2 - 4 October 2001

JUDGMENT DATE: 12/12/2001

PARTIES:
Rolls Royce Industrial Power (Pacific) Limited (Formerly John Thompson (Australia) Pty Limited) - Appellant/Respondent/Opponent
James Hardie & Coy Pty Limited - Appellant/Respondent/Claimant
The State of New South Wales - Respondent
Electricity Commission of New South Wales - Respondent

JUDGMENT OF:       Stein JA Fitzgerald AJA Davies AJA   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: Dust Diseases Tribunal

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):          DDT 34/94

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:     Curtis J

COUNSEL:
P Hall QC/Ms D Stewart/R Dalgleish - Rolls Royce - Appellant/Respondent/Opponent
F M Douglas QC/G M Watson - James Hardie - Appellant/Respondent/Claimant
J M Ireland QC/J Burn - The State of New South Wales - Respondent
V Goldrid - Electricity Commission of NSW - Respondent

SOLICITORS:
Hunt & Hunt - Rolls Royce - Appellant/Respondent/Opponent
Allens Arthur Robinson - James Hardie - Appellant/Respondent/Claimant
Crown Solicitor - The State of New South Wales - Respondent

CATCHWORDS:
TORT - negligence - mesothelioma - contribution - s 5 Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1946 - claim by employer for contribution by manufacturer and supplier - no warning of danger given - claim against State of New South Wales - premises inspected by State - whether inspectors subject to control by State - whether State had knowledge of danger and failed to adequately protect workers
TORT - negligence - indemnification - exemption from liability - s 5(2) Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1946 - whether exemption power available where both tortfeasors independently at fault - whether discretion miscarried
TORT - liability - contribution - apportionment - comparison of culpability - whether trial judge's discretion miscarried - whether apportionment unreasonable - whether employer entitled to a complete indemnity - independent tortfeasors - whether manufacturer had an overriding duty - inherently dangerous product
COSTS - party successful on one aspect of case - whether issue raised reasonably - whether proper exercise of discretion
COSTS - Calderbank letter - change of circumstance - cross-claim filed after Calderbank letter
PROCEDURE - leave to amend cross-claim refused - when discretion exercised unreasonably - 'relevant period' extended - no relevant cross examination - no pre-trial inquiry and preparation - whether qualified as a point of law under s 32 Dust Diseases Tribunal Act
PROCEDURE - previous settlement of related action - whether settlement amounted to binding admission - whether Tribunal bound by apportionment figures - whether settlement can affect third party proceedings - D

LEGISLATION CITED:
Dust Diseases Tribunal Act 1989
Law Reform (Married Women & Tortfeasors) Act 1935
Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1946
Limitation Act 1969
Limitation Act 1939 (UK)
Sale of Goods Act 1923
Scaffolding and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Rolls Royce Industrial Power (Pacific) Ltd v James Hardie &... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] NSWCA 461
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Rolls Royce Industrial Power (Pacific) Ltd (Rolls Royce) and James Hardie & Co Pty Ltd (James Hardie) were parties in a dispute concerning contribution claims arising from negligence leading to mesothelioma. The case was heard by Curtis J in the Dust Diseases Tribunal. Rolls Royce had brought contract claims against James Hardie, which were dismissed. Both Rolls Royce and James Hardie were found to have breached their duty of care to the plaintiff, with James Hardie's breach described as gross. James Hardie also sought contribution from the State of New South Wales (NSW), alleging NSW's negligence in failing to protect workers from known dangers.

The court was required to determine the extent of contribution between Rolls Royce and James Hardie, the apportionment of liability between them, and whether James Hardie was entitled to contribution from NSW. Specifically, the court had to consider if NSW had a duty of care to the plaintiff, whether it breached that duty, and if so, whether it was just and equitable for NSW to contribute to James Hardie's liability, given James Hardie's own significant culpability. The court also had to address disputes regarding costs, including the effect of a Calderbank letter and the allocation of costs for the contract claim.

Curtis J found that James Hardie was in breach of its duty of care to the plaintiff, and this breach was gross. Rolls Royce was also found to be in breach of its duty of care. The judge apportioned responsibility equally between James Hardie and Rolls Royce, meaning each was liable for 39.8% of the plaintiff's total judgment. Rolls Royce was awarded a verdict of $37,750 against James Hardie. Regarding the claim against NSW, Curtis J found that the relevant legislation did not grant NSW the power to control the risk-producing activity at the site. While acknowledging that a general law duty of care might exist for the State, the judge ultimately concluded that it was not just and equitable for NSW to contribute to James Hardie's liability, reasoning that James Hardie created the danger while the State merely failed to avoid it, and that the loss should not be borne by taxpayers when James Hardie profited from its dangerous products.

Orders

Orders of the court

See paragraph 152 for orders

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Furthermore, James Hardie claimed a s 5 contribution from the State of New South Wales (NSW), alleging that NSW would, if sued by the plaintiff, have been found liable to him in negligence. In essence, the claim was that NSW had knowledge of the dangers to which the plaintiff was exposed and adequate power to protect him, yet unreasonably failed to exercise those powers.Judgment of trial judge In giving judgment on 15 October 1999, Curtis J dismissed the contract claims brought by Rolls Royce against James Hardie. His Honour found that James Hardie was in breach of its duty of care to the plaintiff and that its breach was gross. Rolls Royce was also found to be in breach of its duty of care to the plaintiff and his Honour embarked upon the task of apportionment between it and James Hardie. Curtis J concluded that apportionment of responsibility should be equal between James Hardie and Rolls Royce. On the mathematics, this meant that both of them were liable for $147,250 of the plaintiffs’ judgments totalling $370,000. His Honour noted that that was 39.8% of the total liability, while Pacific Power bore 15% of the liability and another party, Wallaby Grip (which had contributed $20,000) 5.4%. In the result, his Honour entered a verdict of $37,750 in favour of Rolls Royce against James Hardie and ordered the latter to pay Rolls Royce’s costs of the hearing, with the exception of the costs of the contract claim, which he ordered that each party bear itself. This latter aspect of the costs order is in dispute, as is the disputed effect of a Calderbank letter. His Honour then turned to the claim for contribution by James Hardie against NSW. His Honour found that the relevant powers in the Scaffolding and Lifts Act 1902 as amended did not confer power on NSW to control the risk producing activity at Wallerawang. The statute conferred that power on inspectors, who were not subject to ministerial control or direction in the performance of their duties. Having dealt with the issue of breach of its statutory powers and obligations, his Honour turned to what he described as the ‘general law duty’. He said that if the correct approach was the ‘spectrum analysis’ of Kirby J in Pyrenees Shire Council v Day (1998) 192 CLR 330, then there were good reasons to impose a duty of care on the State, of which it was in breach. Further, that that breach was causative of the plaintiff’s injury and NSW, had it been sued by the plaintiff, would have been found liable. However, on the other hand, his Honour said that if the correct approach was the incremental one referred to by Brennan CJ and McHugh J in Pyrenees, the result might well be different, but ‘because of my views on apportionment’ he found it unnecessary to decide the nature of any duty owed or its breach. Turning immediately to apportionment, his Honour said that even if NSW should have been liable to Mr Hay (contrary to the finding) it was not just and equitable that it should contribute to the liability of James Hardie. His Honour added:… James Hardie created a danger which the State merely failed to avoid. James Hardie made large profits from selling vast quantities of asbestos products heedless of the dangers to others which James Hardie knew to be created by the use of these products. Essentially James Hardie submit that a loss inevitably flowing from these commercial activities should be borne in part, not out of James Hardie’s profits or risk capital, but by the taxpayers of New South Wales. Such a result would in my opinion be neither just nor equitable having regard to the State’s responsibility for the damage.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established