Smith & Ors v The Ministry of Defence

Link copied
Case Copied 143 min read

     

    Summary


    Trinty Term
    [2013] UKSC 41
    On appeal from: [2011] EWHC 1678 QB; [2012] EWCA Civ 1365

    JUDGMENT

    Smith and others (FC) (Appellants) v The Ministry of Defence (Respondent)
    Ellis (FC) (Respondent) v The Ministry of Defence (Appellant)
    Allbutt and others (FC) (Respondents) v The Ministry of Defence (Appellant)
    before
    Lord Hope, Deputy President
    Lord Walker
    Lady Hale
    Lord Mance
    Lord Kerr
    Lord Wilson
    Lord Carnwath
    JUDGMENT GIVEN ON

    19 June 2013

    Heard on 18, 19, 20 and 21 February 2013
    Appellant (Smith)
    Robert Weir QC
    Jessica Simor QC
    (Instructed by Hodge Jones & Allen LLP)
      Respondent
    James Eadie QC
    Sarah Moore
    Karen Steyn
    David Pievsky
    (Instructed by Treasury Solicitors)
         
    Intervener (JUSTICE)
    Alex Bailin QC
    Iain Steele
    Edward Craven
    (Instructed by Herbert Smith Freehills LLP)
      Intervener
    Helen Mountfield QC
    Elizabeth Prochaska
    (Instructed by The Equality and Human Rights Commission)
         
    Appellant
    James Eadie QC
    Sarah Moore
    Karen Steyn
    David Pievsky
    (Instructed by Treasury Solicitors)
      Respondent (Ellis)
    Robert Weir QC
    Jessica Simor QC
    (Instructed by Hodge Jones & Allen LLP)
         
    Appellant
    James Eadie QC
    Sarah Moore
    Karen Steyn
    David Pievsky
    (Instructed by Treasury Solicitors)
      Respondent (Allbutt)
    Richard Hermer QC
    Ben Silverstone
    (Instructed by Leigh Day & Co)
    LORD HOPE (with whom Lord Walker, Lady Hale and Lord Kerr agree)
  1. These proceedings arise out of the deaths of three young men who lost their lives while serving in the British Army in Iraq and the suffering by two other young servicemen of serious injuries. The units in which they were serving were sent to Iraq as part of Operation TELIC. This operation, which lasted from January 2003 to July 2009, had two distinct phases of military activity. The first began on 19 March 2003 when Iraq was invaded by coalition forces including those from the United Kingdom. The second phase began on 1 May 2003 when major combat operations ceased and were replaced by a period of military occupation. During much of that time there was a constant threat of enemy action by insurgents opposed to the interim Iraqi government.
  2. On 25 March 2003 Corporal Stephen Allbutt, who was the husband of the claimant Ms Deborah Allbutt, Lance Corporal Daniel Twiddy and Trooper Andrew Julien were serving with the Queen's Royal Lancers as part of the Royal Regiment of Fusiliers battle group during the fourth day of the offensive by British troops to take Basra. They were in one of a number of Challenger II tanks which had been placed at a dam in hull down positions to minimise their visibility to the enemy. Just after midnight a Challenger II tank of the Second Royal Tank Regiment which had been assigned to the 1st Battalion Black Watch battle group and was commanded by Lt Pinkstone crossed over onto the enemy side of a canal to take up a guarding position some distance to the south east of the dam. At about 0050 hrs Lt Pinkstone identified two hot spots through his thermal imaging sights which he thought might be personnel moving in…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Smith & Ors v The Ministry of Defence and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] UKSC 41
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established