Shaw Savill and Albion Co Ltd v The Commonwealth

Link copied
Case Copied 47 min read
66 CLR 344

SHAW SAVILL AND ALBION COMPANY

THE COMMONWEALTH Tort-Negligence-Acts done in course of war-like operations-Activities of combatant

services in time of war-Liability of Crown or member of forces-Evidence- Statement of First Naval Member--Whether conclusive.

An action for negligence brought against the Crown for acts done in the Oct. 30, 31.

course of active naval or military operations against the enemy must fail: per Rich A.C.J., Dixon, McTiernan and Williams JJ., on the ground that while in the course of actual operations against the enemy the forces of the Crown are under no duty of care to avoid loss or damage to private individuals; per Starke J., on the ground that such acts are not justiciable durante bello. No such immunity from action attaches, however, to activities of the combatant forces in time of war other than actual operations against the

Where an action for negligence is brought in respect of a collision with a warship, the question whether at the time of the collision the warship was engaged in active operations against the enemy is an issue which a court may decide for itself and whereon it is not bound to accept a statement of the First Naval Member of the Naval Board as conclusive.

DEMURRERS and MOTION.

Shaw Savill &Albion Co. Ltd. sued the Commonwealth of Australia in the High Court of Australia in Admiralty for damages in conse- quence of a collision which occurred between H.M.A.S. Adelaide and the motor vessel Coptic.

The statement of claim delivered by the plaintiff was substantially as follows :-1. The plaintiff company is a company duly incorpor- ated in the United Kingdom of Great Britain and registered in the State of New South Wales as a foreign company. The company

66 CLR 345

carries on business both within the Commonwealth of Australia and overseas. 2. The company is and was at all material times the owner of the motor vessel Coptic which on 3rd September 1940 was southerly bound off the coast of New South Wales on a voyage from Brisbane in the State of Queensland to Sydney in the State of New South Wales. 3. Whilst on that voyage at about ten minutes past one on the morning of 3rd September 1940, the Coptic came into collision with His Majesty's Australian Ship Adelaide which at all material times was under the command of Captain H. A. Showers an officer of the Naval Forces of the Commonwealth and duly appointed to that position in pursuance of the Naval Defence Act 1910-1934. At the time of the collision the officer in immediate control of the Adelaide was the officer of the watch Lieutenant R. E. Morley who is and was at all material times an officer of the Naval Forces of the Commonwealth appointed in pursuance of the Act. 4. Immediately before proceeding upon the voyage the Commonwealth Naval Control Officer at Brisbane, who was also an officer of the Naval Forces of the Commonwealth duly appointed under the Act, lawfully…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Shaw Savill and Albion Co Ltd v The Commonwealth and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1940] HCA 40
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Shaw Savill and Albion Co Ltd sued the Commonwealth of Australia in the High Court of Australia in Admiralty for damages arising from a collision between the plaintiff's vessel, the Coptic, and His Majesty's Australian Ship Adelaide. The plaintiff alleged that the collision was caused by the negligence of the Commonwealth's officers and servants in various respects, including failure to maintain a proper lookout, excessive speed, and improper navigation. The Commonwealth denied negligence and demurred to the statement of claim, asserting that the collision occurred during active naval operations against the enemy and was therefore not justiciable.

The central legal issue before the High Court was whether the Commonwealth, as the Crown in right of Australia, could be held liable in tort for acts or omissions occurring during active naval operations against the enemy in wartime. Specifically, the Court had to determine if such operations conferred immunity from suit for negligence, and if so, under what circumstances. A related issue was whether the determination of whether the Adelaide was engaged in active naval operations was a matter for the court to decide or if a statement from the First Naval Member would be conclusive.

The Court, comprising Rich A.C.J., Dixon, McTiernan, Starke, and Williams JJ., held that while acts done in the course of actual operations against the enemy are not justiciable, and therefore the Crown is not liable for negligence in such circumstances, this immunity does not extend to all activities of combatant forces in wartime. The Court reasoned that the duty of care to avoid loss or damage to private individuals is suspended during actual operations against the enemy. However, the Court also determined that it was within the jurisdiction of the court to decide whether a warship was engaged in active operations against the enemy at the time of a collision, and it was not bound to accept a statement from the First Naval Member as conclusive on this point.

The demurrers were overruled, and the motion to dismiss the suit was refused. The Court found that the defence alleging active naval operations against the enemy, if proven, would provide a valid defence during wartime. However, the Court also held that the question of whether the acts complained of were indeed part of such operations was a matter for judicial determination. The costs of the proceedings were to be costs in the cause.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.