Zurich Australian Insurance Ltd v Cognition Education Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

For a Court ready (fee required) version please follow this link

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF NEW ZEALAND
SC 58/2013
[2014] NZSC 188
BETWEEN

ZURICH AUSTRALIAN INSURANCE LIMITED T/A ZURICH NEW ZEALAND
Appellant

AND

COGNITION EDUCATION LIMITED
Respondent

Hearing:

9 October 2013

Court:

Elias CJ, McGrath, William Young, Glazebrook and Arnold JJ

Counsel:

A R Galbraith QC and M J Francis for Appellant
M G Ring QC and P R Rzepecky for Respondent

Judgment:

19 December 2014

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is allowed.

BThere is no order for costs.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS

(Given by Arnold J)

Table of Contents

Para No

Introduction [1]
Disagreement concerning claim under contract frustration policy [5]
Summary of arguments [10]
Background to the Arbitration Act 1996 and art 8(1) [14]
Arbitration Act 1908 [15]
Arbitration (Foreign Agreements and Awards) Act 1982 [19]
Law Commission’s review of arbitration law [25]
The Arbitration Act 1996 [29]
Subsequent developments [33]
Our evaluation [36]
Decision [53]

Introduction

  1. This appeal concerns the circumstances in which a court should stay proceedings to allow a claim to be dealt with by arbitration in accordance with an agreement to arbitrate between the parties.  The parties to the appeal had a difference of view in relation to their contractual arrangements.  Cognition Education Ltd issued proceedings against Zurich Australian Insurance Ltd and sought summary judgment.  Zurich applied for a stay of the proceedings to allow an arbitration to occur.  The question is whether art 8 of sch 1 to the Arbitration Act 1996 requires a court to consider whether there is an arguable defence to the plaintiff’s claim sufficient to resist an application for summary judgment before ordering a stay of proceedings.

  2. After the hearing of this appeal, the parties advised that they had settled their dispute.  We have decided, however, that we should deliver judgment.  The Court considered the approach to be adopted in relation to post-hearing, pre-judgment settlements in Osborne v Auckland Council.[1]  It noted that, although a case which settles in these circumstances becomes moot, the Court retains a discretion to deliver judgment.  Where a case raises issues that are of public importance (as opposed to being of significance only to the parties), and full argument has been heard, the Court may decide to deliver judgment notwithstanding any settlement.  In this case, the issue is clearly important and of general significance, and we have heard full argument on it.

  3. Article 8 of sch 1 provides:[2]

    8        Arbitration agreement and substantive claim before court

    (1) A court before which proceedings are brought in a matter which is the subject of an arbitration agreement shall, if a party so requests not later than when submitting that party’s first statement on the substance of the dispute, stay those proceedings and refer the parties to arbitration unless it finds that the agreement is null and void, inoperative, or incapable of being performed, or that there is not in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Zurich Australian Insurance Ltd v Cognition Education Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZSC 188
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the court was an application by Zurich Australian Insurance Ltd (appellant) to stay the proceedings brought by Cognition Education Ltd (respondent) under an insurance policy. The court was asked to determine whether the High Court should stay the proceedings in favour of arbitration, in accordance with Article 8 of Schedule 1 of the Arbitration Act 1998 (Cth). The legal issue at the heart of this case was the interpretation and application of Article 8 of Schedule 1 to the Arbitration Act, specifically whether the additional words "or that there is not in fact any dispute between the parties with regard to the matters agreed to be referred" in Article 8(1) of the Act applied to the case at hand. Zurich argued that the court should not stay the proceedings because there was no actual dispute between the parties regarding the matters agreed to be referred to arbitration. Cognition, on the other hand, contended that the court should stay the proceedings and refer the parties to arbitration as per the arbitration clause in the insurance policy.

The court held that the additional words in Article 8(1) did not apply to the case at hand. The court reasoned that the added words were intended to address situations where there was no real dispute between the parties, which was not the case here. The court found that there was indeed a real dispute between the parties, as Cognition had a genuine claim under the policy that Zurich had declined. Consequently, the court was not precluded from staying the proceedings under Article 8(1) and should instead refer the parties to arbitration. The court found in favour of Zurich and ordered that the proceedings be stayed and the parties referred to arbitration in accordance with the arbitration clause in the insurance policy.

This decision highlights the importance of carefully considering the wording of arbitration clauses and the applicable legislation when determining whether to stay proceedings in favour of arbitration. The court's decision in this case will be of particular interest to parties involved in insurance disputes and those seeking to navigate the complexities of international commercial arbitration under Australian law.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Article 8 of sch 1 provides:[2]8 Arbitration agreement and substantive claim before court(1) A court before which proceedings are brought in a matter which is the subject of an arbitration agreement shall, if a party so requests not later than when submitting that party’s first statement on the substance of the dispute, stay those proceedings and refer the parties to arbitration unless it finds that the agreement is null and void, inoperative, or incapable of being performed, or that there is not in fact any dispute between the parties with regard to the matters agreed to be referred.(2) Where proceedings referred to in paragraph (1) have been brought, arbitral proceedings may nevertheless be commenced or continued, and an award may be made, while the issue is pending before the court. Article 8 is derived from the Model Law on International Commercial Arbitration adopted in June 1985 by the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law (UNCITRAL)[3] and endorsed by a resolution of the United Nations General Assembly in December 1985.[4] An important objective of the Model Law was to unify national laws dealing with international commercial arbitrations.[5] In the Model Law, art 8 does not contain the words “or that there is not in fact any dispute between the parties with regard to the matters agreed to be referred”. Their inclusion in art 8 of sch 1 was recommended by the Law Commission.[6] For ease of reference, we will refer to them as “the added words”. Before we discuss their meaning, however, we will set out the circumstances giving rise to the issue. The background is that the respondent, Cognition, had several contracts with the Abu Dhabi Education Council, an agency of the Government of Abu Dhabi, for the provision of management services for public schools, based on a public-private partnership model. It took out contract frustration cover with the appellant, Zurich. The policy contained an arbitration clause in the following terms:Any dispute, controversy or claim arising out of, relating to, or in connection with this Insurance Policy, shall be finally settled by arbitration. The arbitration shall be conducted in accordance with the Rules for the Conduct of Commercial Arbitrations of the Institute of Arbitrators and Mediators New Zealand in effect at the time of the arbitration and shall be conducted in English. The seat of the arbitration shall be Auckland, New Zealand or alternative[ly] Sydney, Australia if mutually agreed by all parties. A dispute arose between the Council and Cognition when the Council refused to make payments due under the contracts. Cognition ultimately settled the dispute with the Council, accepting less than its contractual entitlement. When it sought to recover the shortfall under its policy with Zurich, Zurich declined the claim. Cognition then sued on the policy and sought summary judgment. Zurich filed an appearance objecting to the High Court’s jurisdiction on the basis of the arbitration clause and sought a stay of the proceedings under art 8(1) to allow an arbitration to proceed.