IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY
I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE
CIV-2018-404-002745
[2019] NZHC 989
BETWEEN JAMES LESTER MONTGOMERIE
Plaintiff
AND
ANDREW LAURIE MONTGOMERIE
First Defendant
MIA BELLA TRUSTEE LIMITED
Second Defendant
Hearing: 30 April 2019 Appearances:
D Neutze for the Plaintiff
W G C Templeton for the Defendants
Judgment:
8 May 2019
JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE SMITH
This judgment was delivered by me on 8 May 2019 at 3.00 pm, pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules
Registrar/Deputy Registrar
Solicitors / Counsel: Woodhouse Law, Auckland Brookfields, Auckland
Foy & Halse, Auckland
W G C Templeton, Auckland
MONTGOMERIE v MONTGOMERIE [2019] NZHC 989 [8 May 2019]
[1] This is an application by the plaintiff for summary judgment. The plaintiff seeks to recover amounts lent by him to the defendant under a loan agreement made in 2011 and varied in 2016. The loan agreement (as varied) was followed by a later agreement, made in March 2017, which was intended to cap the defendant's liability at a lower figure, and provide for repayment of the capped amount. If the defendant defaulted under the March 2017 agreement, his liability would revert to that provided for in the 2011 agreement as varied.
[2] The plaintiff contends that the defendant has failed to comply with the March 2017 agreement, and he has demanded payment of the amount of the debt calculated under the 2011 agreement (as varied), plus costs. The defendant says that he has complied with such of his obligations under the March 2017 agreement as he has been required to perform so far, and that the time for repayment of the bulk of the debt under the March 2017 agreement has not yet arrived.
The parties
[3] The plaintiff is a businessman based in Florida, United States, and he is the brother of the first defendant. The first defendant is a property developer based in Auckland.
[4] The second defendant (the Trust) is the trustee of a family trust associated with the first defendant.
Background
[5] The plaintiff lent money to the first defendant when the first defendant ran into financial difficulty following the global financial crisis in 2008. As part of the assistance he provided at that time, the plaintiff purchased the first defendant's family home on Waiheke Island (the property), with mortgage funding from the Bank of New Zealand, allowing the first defendant and his family to continue to live in the property on the basis that the first defendant would cover the interest payments on the BNZ mortgage and the rates and other outgoings on the property.
The Loan Agreement
[6] In 2011 the first defendant arranged for the Trust to refinance the BNZ mortgage. The Trust did that with the assistance of a loan from Westpac New Zealand Ltd, and the property was then transferred to the Trust. While this transaction had the effect of taking the plaintiff out of his liability to the BNZ under the mortgage, it did…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Montgomerie v Montgomerie and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2019] NZHC 989
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered two issues. First, whether the defendants breached their obligations under the March 2017 agreement, such that the plaintiff was entitled to demand payment of the total debt, minus the $200,000 paid on 28 March 2017, plus further interest to the date of judgment. The court concluded that the parties' intention was that payment of the capped debt had to be made by 15 October 2018, whether from the sources identified at cl 2 of the March 2017 agreement or from other sources. The court found that the capped amount was not repaid in accordance with the agreement, and the plaintiff was entitled to make immediate demand for the total debt, plus the additional costs and interest which he seeks.
Second, whether it was reasonably arguable for the defendants that the events of frustration made it impossible for the defendants to perform, or otherwise frustrated, the March 2017 agreement, so that the defendants were discharged from further performance of the March 2017 agreement. The court found that the parties' principal purpose in entering into the March 2017 agreement was to define particular circumstances in which the debt owing by the first defendant to the plaintiff would be capped at the significantly lower figure of NZ$1 million. The court held that the supervening events relied upon by the defendants cannot arguably have affected the foundation on which the parties contracted.
As a result, judgment was entered for the plaintiff, awarding him the sum of US$865,123.72, interest, and costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi