Montgomerie v Montgomerie

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2019-404-001380

[2020] NZHC 3282

UNDER the Insolvency Act 2006

IN THE MATTER

of the bankruptcy of A L Montgomerie

BETWEEN

JAMES LESTER MONTGOMERIE

Judgment Creditor

AND

ANDREW LAURIE MONTGOMERIE

Judgment Debtor

Hearing: 1 October 2020

Appearances:

S Robertson QC for the Judgment Creditor A Gilchrist for the Judgment Debtor

Judgment:

11 December 2020


JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE GARDINER


This judgment was delivered by me on 11 December 2020 at 3.30 p.m. pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar Date.......................................

Solicitors:

Brookfields, Auckland

S Robertson QC, Auckland A Gilchrist, Auckland

MONTGOMERIE v MONTGOMERIE [2020] NZHC 3282 [11 December 2020]

Introduction

[1]    James Montgomerie is  a  businessman  based  in  the  United  States.  Andrew Montgomerie is a property developer based in Auckland. They are brothers. Around nine years ago, James lent Andrew a substantial sum of money, which Andrew has not repaid. Two years ago, James called up the loan and then obtained summary judgment of the debt. Still, Andrew did not pay. James issued a bankruptcy notice and then, when Andrew did not comply, applied to have Andrew declared bankrupt.

[2]    Andrew does not deny that a debt is owing to James, nor that he committed an act of bankruptcy in failing to comply with the bankruptcy notice which had been served on him. Instead, Andrew says that he and James, through their counsel, agreed a settlement of the debt, and that such a settlement forms an absolute defence to James’ application for adjudication.

[3]    James denies that he and Andrew concluded a settlement agreement. James maintains that Andrew has committed an act of bankruptcy and, as such, should be adjudicated bankrupt.

[4]    At the hearing, counsel referred to the parties by their first names in view of their common surname. I do the same in this judgment.

Issues

[5]    I need to view the evidence objectively and decide whether it shows that James and Andrew reached an agreement, that is, whether a contract was formed. This involves considering:

(a)Whether there was an intention to be immediately bound; and

(b)Whether all the essential terms were agreed.

Factual background

[6]    Andrew fell into financial difficulty because of the global financial crisis in 2008. James agreed to lend Andrew some money. On 26 August 2011, they entered

into a loan agreement (“the Loan Agreement”).1 Andrew did not repay the loan. The Loan Agreement was varied, first, on 25 May 2016 and, again, in July/August 2016.2 Andrew again did not pay. A further agreement was signed on 9 March 2017 (“the 2017 Agreement”).3 Again Andrew did not repay the loan (although he did reduce it by $200,000 in March 2017).4

[7]    In October 2018, James called up the amount owing under the Loan Agreement (USD 865,123.72 plus interest and costs). He commenced summary judgment proceedings in December 2018. Associate Judge Smith entered summary judgment against Andrew on 8 May 2019.5 Andrew appealed; the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Montgomerie v Montgomerie and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] NZHC 3282
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Montgomerie v Montgomerie [2020] NZHC 3282 concerns a bankruptcy application made by James Montgomerie against his brother, Andrew Montgomerie, who had not paid a debt owed to James. The key issue for the Court was whether the parties had agreed a settlement of the debt, and if so, whether that settlement formed an absolute defence to James' application for adjudication. The court found that the parties had not reached a settlement agreement, and that James was entitled to have Andrew declared bankrupt.

In reaching its conclusion, the Court considered the objective evidence of the parties' communications, including the relevant terms of the proposed settlement and whether there was an intention to be immediately bound. The Court found that while the essential elements of a settlement agreement were contained in a letter from Andrew's solicitor, Mr Burgess, James did not intend to, or in fact, agree to a settlement on those terms on the morning of 23 July 2020. Instead, James had only agreed to a further delay based on an increase in the initial payment amount.

The Court also considered the conduct of the parties, including the fact that Mr Hamilton did not arrange for the payment of the $7,500 to James, suggesting that Mr Hamilton considered that something more needed to happen before a binding agreement was reached. The Court concluded that the evidence indicated that James and Mr Woodhouse considered that all they were agreeing was that Andrew would make an immediate initial payment of $7,500 in return for James agreeing to adjourn the proceedings for one week so that negotiations on the balance of the settlement, including the frequency and amount of the interim payments, could continue.

Ultimately, the Court found that there was no concluded settlement agreement, and that the jurisdictional requirements for an order under s 36 of the Insolvency Act 2006 were met. Andrew had not asserted or established any other ground for opposition. The Court made an order for Andrew to be adjudicated bankrupt, and for Andrew to pay the costs and disbursements associated with the proceeding.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established