Planet Kids Ltd v Auckland Council

Link copied
Case Copied 79 min read
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF NEW ZEALAND
SC 5/2013
[2013] NZSC 147
BETWEEN

PLANET KIDS LIMITED
Appellant

AND

AUCKLAND COUNCIL
Respondent

Hearing:

27 June 2013

Court:

Elias CJ, McGrath, William Young, Glazebrook and Gault JJ

Counsel:

G P Blanchard and J P Nolen for the Appellant
J A Farmer QC and L A O'Gorman for the Respondent

Judgment:

17 December 2013

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A.     The appeal is allowed.  A declaration is made that the settlement agreement subsists.

B.   The other orders sought by the appellant in its application for summary judgment are not made but the matter is referred back to the High Court to deal with the remainder of the application.

C.     The respondent is to pay to the appellant costs of $25,000 plus all reasonable disbursements to be fixed if necessary by the Registrar.  We certify for two counsel.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS

Para No
Elias CJ [1]
McGrath, Glazebrook and Gault JJ [18]
William Young J [173]

ELIAS CJ

[1]  Planet Kids Limited operated a childcare business on land leased from the Auckland Council.  The Council gave notice of intention to acquire the leasehold interest under the provisions of the Public Works Act 1981 because the land was required for roading purposes.  Planet Kids objected to the proposed taking.  Eventually the parties concluded a settlement agreement on 3 June 2010.

[2]  Under the settlement agreement, Planet Kids (which was accepted to be unable to relocate) was to receive compensation from the Council for the loss of goodwill arising from the closure of its business.  In addition, the Council agreed to forgo a disputed claim for rent said to be due under the lease.  In return, the Council was to receive a surrender of lease and vacant possession, a restraint of trade covenant from Planet Kids, and the chattels and plant on the premises.  A deposit of 10 per cent of the compensation was paid by the Council with the balance to be paid on settlement, which was set for 20 December 2010, or earlier should the parties agree.  By cl 8 of the settlement agreement it was agreed that the “[b]usiness shall remain at the sole risk of [Planet Kids] until the settlement date”.  Clause 9 affirmed that the Council was not purchasing Planet Kids’ business but was instead merely compensating Planet Kids for the closure of the business as if the business had been sold as a going concern and that Planet Kids remained liable for any obligations connected to the business.  Finally, the settlement agreement meant that the Council could tender for the road works before settlement and gave the Council and its agents the ability to enter upon the land, on 48 hours notice, for preliminary purposes associated with the roading project.  

[3]  In early August, Planet Kids gave notice to its staff that the business would be closing.  In September parents were advised that the business would close so that they could make other child care arrangements.  A tender for the road works…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Planet Kids Ltd v Auckland Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZSC 147
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Planet Kids Ltd operated a childcare business on land leased from the Auckland Council. The Council gave notice of its intention to acquire the leasehold interest under the Public Works Act 1981 because the land was required for roading purposes. Planet Kids objected to the proposed taking. Eventually, the parties concluded a settlement agreement on 3 June 2010. Under the settlement agreement, Planet Kids (which was accepted to be unable to relocate) was to receive compensation from the Council for the loss of goodwill arising from the closure of its business. In addition, the Council agreed to forgo a disputed claim for rent said to be due under the lease. In return, the Council was to receive a surrender of lease and vacant possession, a restraint of trade covenant from Planet Kids, and the chattels and plant on the premises. A deposit of 10 per cent of the compensation was paid by the Council with the balance to be paid on settlement. By cl 8 of the settlement agreement it was agreed that the “business shall remain at the sole risk of [Planet Kids] until the settlement date”. Clause 9 affirmed that the Council was not purchasing Planet Kids’ business but was instead merely compensating Planet Kids for the closure of the business as if the business had been sold as a going concern and that Planet Kids remained liable for any obligations connected to the business. The settlement agreement also meant that the Council could tender for the road works before settlement and gave the Council and its agents the ability to enter upon the land, on 48 hours notice, for preliminary purposes associated with the roading project. In early August, Planet Kids gave notice to its staff that the business would be closing. In September parents were advised that the business would close so that they could make other child care arrangements. On 2 October the building was destroyed by fire. It is not in dispute that the effect of cl 40.1 of the lease was that the lease terminated with immediate effect as a result of the destruction caused by the fire. The Council took the view that the settlement agreement had been brought to an end by frustration as a result of the termination of the lease and refused to pay the balance owing under the settlement agreement. Planet Kids then issued proceedings seeking judgment for the balance and made application for summary judgment. The Council applied to strike out Planet Kids’ claim and, in the alternative, itself sought summary judgment on its defence that the agreement was frustrated by the termination of the plaintiff’s lease and that it was not obliged to pay the sum claimed by Planet Kids. In the High Court, Peters J accepted the Council’s submission that the basis on which the settlement agreement was entered into was that Planet Kids was able to transfer a leasehold interest in the land at the date of settlement. Since this was impossible following termination of the lease following the fire, she held that the agreement was frustrated. Although Planet Kids’ application for summary judgment was declined, Peters J did not strike out its claim or enter summary judgment for the Council, pending further submissions on the effect of the Frustrated Contracts Act 1944. Planet Kids appealed to the Court of Appeal, overtaking the need for further submissions in the High Court because the additional matter of the effect of the Frustrated Contracts Act was dealt with in the judgment of the Court of Appeal. The Court of Appeal agreed with the determination in the High Court that the termination of the lease had frustrated the contract. Since Planet Kids no longer possessed a leasehold interest, following termination of the lease as a result of the fire, the settlement agreement was held to be “wholly or radically different from that which the parties had agreed”. The Court of Appeal considered that the overlay of the Public Works Act was important background since it took the view that the Council had “entered into the contract in the exercise of its powers under the Act”. Any basis of settlement for the claim under the Act was removed when the lease terminated. Planet Kids appeals with leave to this Court. The question for determination on the appeal is whether the Courts below were correct to hold that the settlement agreement was discharged by frustration. The Court held that the settlement agreement was not frustrated as a consequence of the fire. The agreement subsists. The appeal is allowed. A declaration is made that the settlement agreement subsists. The rest of the declaration and the other orders sought by Planet Kids in its application for summary judgment are not made. The remainder of the application is referred back to the High Court for determination. The Council is to pay to Planet Kids costs of $25,000 plus all reasonable disbursements to be fixed, if necessary, by the Registrar. The appeal is allowed. A declaration is made that the settlement agreement subsists. The rest of the declaration and the other orders sought by Planet Kids in its application for summary judgment are not made. The remainder of the application is referred back to the High Court for determination. The Council is to pay to Planet Kids costs of $25,000 plus all reasonable disbursements to be fixed, if necessary, by the Registrar.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.