IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY
I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE
CIV-2017-404-001871
[2018] NZHC 571
IN THE MATTER of an appeal against the decision of the District Court at Auckland BETWEEN
ELITE UNDERLAY LIMITED
Applicant
AND
ECO RUBBER INDUSTRIES LIMITED
Respondent
Hearing: 5 December 2017 Appearances:
M D Branch for Applicant
M C Donovan for Respondent
Judgment:
29 March 2018
JUDGMENT OF COURTNEY J
This judgment was delivered by Justice Courtney on 29 March 2018 at 10.30 am
pursuant to R 11.5 of the High Court Rules Registrar / Deputy Registrar Date……………………….
ELITE UNDERLAY LTD v ECO RUBBER INDUSTRIES LTD [2018] NZHC 571 [29 March 2018]
Introduction
[1] In 2013 Elite Underlay Ltd (Elite) had a business in Hamilton manufacturing carpet underlay using recycled rubber crumb from the tyre industry. It agreed to sell the business to Eco Rubber Industries Ltd (Eco Rubber). Under the contract, Elite was to continue managing the business. Eco Rubber was to pay Elite $3,000 plus GST per month for management services for the first 36 months and $4,000 plus GST per month thereafter. This arrangement could only be terminated by agreement or by Eco Rubber if Elite was negligent in managing the business.
[2] Two months after the contract was entered into, the oven used to manufacture the underlay was badly damaged by fire. Some repairs were undertaken but before they were completed Eco Rubber decided to cease production altogether. It dismantled the oven, moved it into storage and stopped paying the management fee. Elite sued for the management fees due from the first month of non-payment to 1 July 2015 ($44,850) and a declaration as to Eco Rubber’s liability to pay $4,000 plus GST until 31 October 2023.
[3] Judge B A Gibson found that the management fee was only payable while there was an operation that needed to be managed, and the contract did not require Eco Rubber to continue paying the management fee once production had ceased. Elite appeals. It says that the Judge wrongly interpreted the contract as a result of:
(a)failing to consider the issue of termination;
(b)wrongly treating Elite’s bargaining position as a relevant consideration in the interpretation of the contract and, in doing so, making factual findings that were not supportable on the evidence;
(c)relying on inadmissible evidence of the parties’ subjective intentions;
(d)failing to take into account evidence of clauses deleted from drafts of the contract;
(e)failing to apply the contra proferentem rule against Eco Rubber; and
(f)failing to consider the commercial absurdity resulting from the construction contended for by Eco Rubber.
Factual background
Elite’s history
[4] Prior to 2013, Elite’s director and shareholder, Surindar Nanua, had some years’ experience in the manufacture of rubber underlay using recycled rubber. In 2009, he became involved with two companies, Pinnacle Underlay Ltd and Impacta- phonic Ltd (together Pinnacle), which produced carpet underlay from recycled rubber. Mr Nanua also owned the intellectual property associated with the manufacturing process and was paid by…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Elite Underlay Limited v Eco Rubber Industries Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2018] NZHC 571
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
Elite argued that the contract required ongoing production for the management fees to be payable, and that Eco Rubber could not unilaterally cease production without breaching the contract. The District Court had ruled in favour of Eco Rubber, finding that the management fees were contingent on the actual provision of management services and that Eco Rubber could lawfully cease production.
On appeal, the High Court found that the District Court had erred in several respects. Firstly, the Court held that the District Court had failed to properly consider the termination clause and its implications. The Court found that the contract did not permit Eco Rubber to terminate the Management Agreement by unilaterally ceasing production. The Court interpreted the contract as a whole, taking into account the intention of the parties and the context in which the contract was made, and concluded that Eco Rubber's actions constituted a breach of contract.
The appeal was allowed, the decision of the District Court was set aside, and judgment was entered in favour of Elite on the issue of liability. The matter was remitted for further evidence and submissions on the issue of damages. Additionally, the costs order made by the District Court was set aside, and the parties were directed to submit memoranda on costs for the District Court proceedings and the present appeal.