McKechnie Aluminium Solutions Limited v Macaulay Metals Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NEW PLYMOUTH REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA NGĀMOTU ROHE

CIV-2022-443-42

[2024] NZHC 358

BETWEEN

MCKECHNIE ALUMINIUM SOLUTIONS LIMITED
First Plaintiff

VERO INSURANCE NEW ZEALAND LIMITED
Second Plaintiff

AND

MACAULAY METALS LIMITED

Defendant

Hearing: 12 December 2023

Appearances:

A J Sherlock and S E M Corban for the Plaintiffs P Hunt and T Clark for the Defendant

Judgment:

28 February 2024


JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE SKELTON


[1]Before me is an application by the plaintiffs for orders:

(a)that leave be granted to the plaintiffs to apply for summary judgment against the defendant;

(b)that summary judgment be entered against the defendant for liability in respect of the plaintiffs’ claims set out in the amended statement of claim;

MCKECHNIE ALUMINIUM SOLUTIONS LIMITED v MACAULAY METALS LIMITED [2024] NZHC 358

[28 February 2024]

(c)or, in the alternative to (b), that the issue of liability be determined following a trial which is to take place ahead of a trial to determine quantum;

(d)directing that costs of an incidental to this application be fixed and paid to the plaintiffs.

[2]        I note that the parties have agreed in advance of the hearing that, if the plaintiffs’ application for summary judgment is not successful, then the issue of liability is to be determined at trial ahead of a separate trial to determine quantum.

[3]        The case relates to a fire at the first plaintiff’s premises at 36 Paraite Road, Bell Block, New Plymouth on 10 January 2020. The plaintiffs allege that the defendant caused the fire by negligently undertaking “hot cutting” work as part of dismantling work undertaken at the premises on the day of the fire. The plaintiffs say that the point of origin of the fire was the flat roof of an office (Mr Dittert’s office) adjacent to where the defendant’s workers were undertaking the dismantling work. The defendant says that it has a credible defence to the plaintiffs’ claim, namely that the work it undertook on 10 January 2020 did not cause the fire.

What happened?

[4]        The defendant contracted with the first plaintiff to dismantle and remove a redundant aluminium extrusion press from the first plaintiff’s premises. The aluminium extrusion press comprised of an extrusion press, rollout tables and auxiliary plant, including (i) the fans and ducts above the press, and (ii) the steel frame supports on which the fans were mounted above the rollout tables.

[5]        The defendant started work on site on 9 December 2019. The bulk of the work was completed prior to 24 December 2019, with most of the press including the auxiliary  plant  and  ducts  being  dismantled  between  9  December  2019  and     24 December 2019.

[6]        The last major section of the press to be cut was removed from the site between 6 and 9 January 2020. On 10 January 2020, the defendant removed the remaining rollout tables and fan supports.

[7]        There were two other contractors working on site on 10 January 2020. Farnsworth Roofing was undertaking work on…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McKechnie Aluminium Solutions Limited v Macaulay Metals Limi... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NZHC 358
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiffs, McKechnie Aluminium Solutions Limited and Vero Insurance New Zealand Limited, have brought proceedings against the defendant, Macaulay Metals Limited, for damages for fire damage allegedly caused by the defendant's negligence. The plaintiffs seek leave to apply for summary judgment against the defendant. The application was made over a year after the proceeding was filed. The defendant opposes the application for leave on the basis that there has been an unjustified delay in filing the application for summary judgment, and that the plaintiffs have not satisfied the Court that the defendant has no arguable defence to the plaintiffs' claims. The Court found that the plaintiffs had not satisfactorily explained the delay in filing the application for summary judgment. The Court also found that the plaintiffs had not satisfied the Court that the defendant had no arguable defence to the plaintiffs' claims. The plaintiffs had not satisfied the Court that the defendant's affidavit evidence on all the issues discussed by the Court passed the threshold of credibility for the purposes of summary judgment. The conflicts of factual and expert evidence were too extensive and the issues too complex for the plaintiffs' claims for negligence to properly be determined summarily. The Court concluded that leave to apply for summary judgment should not be granted at this late stage. The plaintiffs' application for leave to apply for summary judgment against the defendant is dismissed. Costs are reserved pending further submissions. The matter is to be listed for directions as to the next steps in the proceeding.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established