McKechnie Aluminium Solutions Limited v Macaulay Metals Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NEW PLYMOUTH REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA NGĀMOTU ROHE

CIV-2022-443-42

[2024] NZHC 809

BETWEEN

MCKECHNIE ALUMINIUM SOLUTIONS LIMITED
First Plaintiff

VERO INSURANCE NEW ZEALAND LIMITED
Second Plaintiff

AND

MACAULAY METALS LIMITED

Defendant

Hearing: On the papers

Appearances:

A J Sherlock and S E M Corban for the Plaintiffs P Hunt and T Clark for the Defendant

Judgment:

15 April 2024


JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE SKELTON

[Costs]


[1]    In my judgment dated 28 February 2024 I dismissed the plaintiffs’ application for leave to apply for summary judgment against the defendant on liability.1 I also found that, even if leave had been granted, the plaintiffs’ application for summary judgment would not have been successful.2

[2]    I expressed the preliminary view that costs should be reserved. However, if any party disagreed with that view, then brief memoranda could be filed and costs would be determined on the papers. The defendant filed a memorandum dated


1      McKechnie Aluminium Solutions Ltd v Macaulay Metals Ltd [2024] NZHC 358 at [89].

2 At [88].

MCKECHNIE ALUMINIUM SOLUTIONS LIMITED v MACAULAY METALS LIMITED [2024] NZHC 809

[15 April 2024]

19 March 2024 seeking an award of costs on a 2C basis, in respect of the filing of the notice of opposition and affidavits in opposition and preparation of written submissions for the hearing, and a 2B basis for the appearance at the hearing. The total amount of costs and disbursements claimed is $14,340.

[3]    The plaintiff filed a memorandum dated 22 March 2024 opposing costs and agreeing with my preliminary view that costs should be reserved.

[4]Should costs be awarded against the plaintiffs?

Legal principles – unsuccessful applications for summary judgment

[5]    Costs are ultimately a matter of the Court’s discretion, the overall objective being to achieve an outcome that best meets the interest of justice.3 That discretion is qualified by the applicable costs rules, contained in pt 14 of the High Court Rules 2016 (HCR).

[6]    Costs on an opposed interlocutory application must be fixed when the application is determined unless there are special reasons to the contrary.4 However, this rule does not apply to applications for summary judgment.5 Where a plaintiff is unsuccessful on a summary judgment application the usual position is that costs are reserved until determination of the substantive claim.6 In NZI Bank Ltd v Philpott, the Court of Appeal confirmed the reason for the different approach to costs where a plaintiff fails in an application for summary judgment:7

As with most questions of costs, they should be approached on broad principles. Whilst a defendant may be regarded as successful in one sense in resisting an application for summary judgment, it is of course not a final determination in the proceeding itself. If, ultimately, the plaintiff does succeed it seems to us in the general run of cases that the defendant should pay for both proceedings, the Court paying particular attention to the reasons why the plaintiff was unsuccessful in the first case. If…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McKechnie Aluminium Solutions Limited v Macaulay Metals Limi... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NZHC 809
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

McKechnie Aluminium Solutions Limited and Vero Insurance New Zealand Limited brought proceedings against Macaulay Metals Limited. The plaintiffs sought damages for alleged negligence. The defendant opposed the plaintiffs' application for leave to apply for summary judgment against it. The defendant also opposed the plaintiffs' subsequent application for summary judgment. The parties subsequently agreed to a separate trial of the question of liability only. The High Court was required to determine whether the defendant should be awarded costs in relation to the unsuccessful applications for summary judgment.

The Court noted that, in general, costs on unsuccessful applications for summary judgment are reserved until the substantive claim is determined. This principle applied by analogy to unsuccessful applications for leave to apply for summary judgment. However, the Court may award costs against an unsuccessful plaintiff in exceptional cases where there has been abuse of the procedure. The Court found that the plaintiffs' applications for summary judgment were not commenced erroneously, unreasonably, by way of an experiment, or with certain knowledge of failure. The Court also found that the plaintiffs reasonably believed that there was no arguable defence to their claims. The Court therefore confirmed its preliminary view that costs on the unsuccessful applications for summary judgment should be reserved.

The Court reserved costs on the unsuccessful applications for summary judgment.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established