| IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA |
| CA18/2020 [2020] NZCA 223 |
| BETWEEN | YAN ZHANG |
| AND | TELCO ASSET MANAGEMENT LIMITED |
| CA150/2020 | ||
| BETWEEN | YAN ZHANG | |
| AND | TELCO ASSET MANAGEMENT LIMITED | |
| Court: | Kós P and Courtney JJ |
Counsel: | Appellant in Person |
Judgment: | 8 June 2020 at 2 pm |
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT
AAn extension of time is granted to apply for leave to appeal.
BThe application for leave to appeal the substantive decision is dismissed.
CThe application for leave to appeal the costs judgment is dismissed.
____________________________________________________________________
REASONS OF THE COURT
(Given by Courtney J)
Introduction
Yan Zhang seeks leave to appeal against a decision of Judge Corkill in the Employment Court at Wellington. Mr Zhang’s former employer, the respondent, Telco Asset Management Ltd (Telco), opposes the application.
Telco disestablished Mr Zhang’s position and terminated his employment in 2017. Mr Zhang successfully challenged the termination before the Employment Relations Authority (the Authority).[1] Mr Zhang was, however, dissatisfied with the remedies granted by the Authority, and brought a late non-de novo challenge to the determination in the Employment Court.[2] Mr Zhang’s challenge was successful on two of five grounds.[3]
[1]Zhang v Telco Asset Management Ltd [2018] NZERA Wellington 84 [ERA determination].
[2]Pursuant to s 182(3) of the Employment Relations Act 2000 (ERA).
[3]Zhang v Telco Asset Management Ltd [2019] NZEmpC 151 [Substantive judgment].
Mr Zhang applied 55 days out of time (or 41 days excluding the Christmas break) for leave to appeal from the Employment Court’s decision[4] and subsequent costs decision.[5] He also applied for an extension of time to make the leave application.
[4]ERA, s 214(2).
[5]Zhang v Telco Asset Management Ltd [2020] NZEmpC 9 [Costs judgment].
Mr Zhang’s right of appeal lies under s 214 of the Employment Relations Act 2000 (ERA) and is limited to questions of law. Leave may be granted if the question of law is one that, by reason of its general or public importance or for any other reason, ought to be submitted to this Court for decision.[6]
[6]ERA, s 214(3).
Mr Zhang raises a number of proposed grounds of appeal which can be summarised as being that the Judge erred in:[7]
(a)taking the wrong approach to the counter-factual inquiry under s 128;
(b)failing to impose a penalty under s 4A;
(c)taking into account a factual finding by the Authority that was unchallenged in considering the award to be made for humiliation and loss of dignity under 123(1)(c)(i);
(d)breaching the principles of natural justice;
(e)assessing Telco’s conduct under s 103A;
(f)assessing Telco’s breach of good faith under s 4;
(g)assessing Mr Zhang’s contributory conduct; and
(h)failing to impose a penalty under s 135.
[7]All provisions cited in Mr Zhang’s proposed grounds of appeal refer to the ERA.
Mr Zhang says that leave to appeal the costs judgment should be granted because it is part of the substantive judgment under appeal. That is not correct; the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Zhang v Telco Asset Management Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2020] NZCA 223
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the Court of Appeal were twofold: firstly, whether an extension of time should be granted to Mr Zhang to apply for leave to appeal; and secondly, whether leave should be granted to appeal the substantive decision and the costs judgment of the Employment Court. Mr Zhang's application for an extension of time was based on personal circumstances, including being unrepresented, English being his second language, and caring responsibilities. The Court found these reasons to be genuine and granted the extension.
In evaluating the substantive appeal, the Court examined several proposed grounds of appeal, including the Judge's approach to the counter-factual inquiry, the failure to impose a penalty under s 4A, and various other aspects of the Judge’s assessment of Telco’s conduct and Mr Zhang’s contributory conduct. The Court found that none of these grounds raised a question of law that would justify a second appeal. Each proposed ground was either a finding of fact or a misinterpretation of the Judge's reasoning.
Regarding the costs judgment, Mr Zhang proposed two grounds of appeal, arguing that the Judge wrongly refused to treat successful challenges to findings of fact as relevant to costs and that the wrong daily rate was used in calculating costs. The Court found that the Judge had correctly identified the approach to awarding costs and that any error in the daily rate used was due to the parties' agreement on scale costs, not a judicial error. Consequently, the Court dismissed the application for leave to appeal the costs judgment.
In conclusion, the Court granted an extension of time for Mr Zhang to apply for leave to appeal but dismissed both the application for leave to appeal the substantive decision and the costs judgment.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter came before the Court of Appeal of New Zealand as an application for leave to appeal the substantive decision and costs judgment from the Employment Court. Zhang had applied for leave to appeal 55 days out of time (or 41 days excluding the Christmas break) and also sought an extension of time to file the application. The respondent, Telco Asset Management Limited, opposed both the extension of time and the application for leave to appeal.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Court should grant an extension of time to file the application for leave to appeal.
2. Whether the Court should grant leave to appeal the substantive decision of the Employment Court.
3. Whether the Court should grant leave to appeal the costs judgment of the Employment Court.
Held
1. Whether the Court should grant an extension of time to file the application for leave to appeal.
- The Court granted an extension of time to file the application for leave to appeal.
2. Whether the Court should grant leave to appeal the substantive decision of the Employment Court.
- The Court dismissed the application for leave to appeal the substantive decision of the Employment Court.
3. Whether the Court should grant leave to appeal the costs judgment of the Employment Court.
- The Court dismissed the application for leave to appeal the costs judgment of the Employment Court.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In this case, Yan Zhang sought leave to appeal against the decision of Judge Corkill in the Employment Court, challenging both the substantive decision and the costs judgment. The Court considered the application for leave to appeal on the papers, and in its judgment, the Court addressed three primary issues. Firstly, the Court granted an extension of time to file the application for leave to appeal, acknowledging the genuine reasons provided by Mr Zhang for the delay. Secondly, the Court dismissed the application for leave to appeal the substantive decision, finding that none of the proposed grounds of appeal raised a question of law that would justify a second appeal. The Court examined each of the proposed grounds of appeal, including the counter-factual assessment, the imposition of a penalty under s 4A, the award for humiliation, loss of dignity and injury to feelings, the breach of natural justice, the assessment of contributory conduct under ss 103A and 124, the duty of good faith, and the failure to impose a penalty under s 135. The Court concluded that none of these grounds demonstrated a question of law warranting further appeal. Lastly, the Court dismissed the application for leave to appeal the costs judgment, finding no apparent error in the Judge's approach to awarding costs or in the daily rate used for calculating the scale costs. The Court determined that the circumstances did not justify leave to appeal the costs judgment.