Telecom New Zealand Ltd v Nutter

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA127/03

BETWEENTELECOM NEW ZEALAND LIMITED


Appellant

ANDVINCENT NUTTER


Respondent

Hearing:30 March 2004

Coram:Anderson P
Hammond J
William Young J

Appearances:  K D Binnie and H G Walton for Appellant


Respondent in person

Judgment:21 July 2004 

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT DELIVERED BY WILLIAM YOUNG J

Table of Contents
Paragraph Number
Introduction [1]
Background [4]
The relevant contractual provisions and Telecom’s policies [37]
The judgment of the Employment Court [41]
The issues before us [46]
The Judge’s conclusions as to unjustifiable dismissal
     Overview [48]
     The conclusion that the August 2000 employment
     agreement wiped the slate clean in relation to the
     earlier incidents involving Mr Nutter
[49]
     The Judge’s conclusion that the absence of a warning
     meant that the dismissal was unjustifiable
[53]
     Conclusion [63]
The Judge’s conclusions as to remedies
     Overview [64]
     The relevant statutory provisions [67]
     Compensation for financial loss – the principles [70]
     Compensation for non-economic loss – the principles [84]
     Did the Judge assess compensation for financial loss on
     an appropriate basis?
[86]
     Did the Judge assess compensation for non-financial
     loss on an appropriate basis?
[93]
     Was the Judge’s discount for contributory conduct
     appropriate?
[95]
     Calculations [100]
Disposition [104]

Introduction

[1]       In an Employment Court judgment delivered on 4 March 2003, Judge Shaw found in favour of Mr Vincent Nutter in personal grievance proceedings associated with his dismissal from employment by the appellant, Telecom New Zealand Limited.  The Judge required Telecom to compensate Mr Nutter by paying him 5 months loss of remuneration and associated benefits and $5,000 by way of compensation for distress and humiliation.  In a later, supplementary judgment, delivered on 3 July 2003, she fixed $30,200 as the value of the 5 months remuneration and loss of benefits.  So, allowing for the award of $5,000 for distress and humiliation, the total amount of Mr Nutter’s judgment was $35,200.

[2]       Those proceedings involved a challenge to a decision of the Employment Relations Authority which had dismissed Mr Nutter’s claim.  Because the challenge was heard de novo by Judge Shaw under s182 of the Employment Relations Act 2000, there is no need to refer to the decision of the Authority.

[3]       Telecom, pursuant to leave, appeals against the decision.  Mr Nutter seeks to challenge the quantum of the award by way of cross-appeal. 

Background

[4]       Mr Nutter began working for Telecom in the late 1980’s.  In 1999 he became an investment analyst in the access and transport group.  His manager was Mr Gavin Knight. 

[5]       Mr Nutter’s employment came to an end in June 2001.  To explain how and why this happened, it is necessary to refer to two earlier incidents.

[6]       The first of these occurred in 1999.  Mr Nutter had attempted to renew a friendship with a female Telecom employee whom he had previously taken out.  She spoke to Mr Knight about this and this resulted in a discussion between Messrs Nutter and Knight in which Mr Nutter indicated that he would not contact the employee again.

[7]…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Telecom New Zealand Ltd v Nutter and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] NZCA 154
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Telecom New Zealand Limited appealed against a decision of the Employment Court, which found that Vincent Nutter had been unjustifiably dismissed. The Court of Appeal considered two issues: whether the dismissal was unjustifiable and the level of the remedies awarded. The Court found that the dismissal was unjustifiable because Telecom did not follow its disciplinary policy, which required a written warning before a dismissal on notice could be justified. The Court also found that the compensation awarded by the Employment Court was inadequate, given Mr Nutter's age, specialised field of employment, and the difficulties he faced in finding new employment. The Court awarded Mr Nutter compensation for financial loss equivalent to 18 months' remuneration and $5,000 for non-economic loss, totalling $55,000. The appeal was dismissed, and the cross-appeal was allowed with the revised judgment amount.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Vincent Nutter was employed by Telecom New Zealand Limited from the late 1980s until his dismissal in June 2001. Nutter worked as an investment analyst in the access and transport group. His manager was Mr Gavin Knight. Nutter's employment ended following a series of incidents involving inappropriate interactions with female colleagues. In 1999, Nutter attempted to renew a friendship with a female employee, leading to a discussion with his manager, Mr Knight. Another incident in 2000 involved Nutter developing an interest in another female employee, which resulted in a formal disciplinary process. Nutter attended one counselling session but continued to engage in inappropriate behaviour towards a third female employee, Ms W, which led to his dismissal. This included flirtatious conduct, touching, and creating a voodoo doll with Ms W's hair and a piece of her clothing. Nutter's dismissal was based on the conclusion that his conduct warranted termination despite the absence of a written warning.

The case originated in the Employment Court, where Judge Shaw found in favour of Mr Nutter, ordering Telecom to compensate him for unjustifiable dismissal. The Employment Court's judgment was appealed by Telecom, and Mr Nutter sought to challenge the quantum of the award. The appeal and cross-appeal were heard in the Court of Appeal of New Zealand.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Court of Appeal should uphold the Employment Court's conclusion that Mr Nutter's dismissal was unjustifiable.
2. Whether the Employment Court appropriately assessed the compensation for Mr Nutter's financial loss.
3. Whether the Employment Court appropriately assessed the compensation for Mr Nutter's non-financial loss.
4. Whether the Employment Court's discount for contributory conduct was appropriate.

Held
1. The Court of Appeal upheld the Employment Court's conclusion that Mr Nutter's dismissal was unjustifiable.
2. The Court of Appeal found that the Employment Court did not appropriately assess the compensation for Mr Nutter's financial loss.
3. The Court of Appeal found that the Employment Court did not appropriately assess the compensation for Mr Nutter's non-financial loss.
4. The Court of Appeal found that the Employment Court's discount for contributory conduct was appropriate.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal found that the Employment Court erred in concluding that the August 2000 employment agreement rendered irrelevant the earlier incidents involving Mr Nutter, as the Court of Appeal determined that these incidents were part of the relevant background. However, the Court of Appeal upheld the Employment Court's conclusion that the dismissal was unjustifiable due to the absence of a warning, which was an independent basis for the decision. The Court of Appeal held that the Employment Court should have assessed Mr Nutter's financial loss based on a reasonable period of time, considering the circumstances of his dismissal and his age, and not merely the equivalent of 12 months remuneration. The Court of Appeal also found that the Employment Court did not sufficiently explain its assessment of non-financial loss, but did not find an error of law in the approach taken. Lastly, the Court of Appeal found that the Employment Court's discount for contributory conduct was appropriate, given the circumstances of Mr Nutter's dismissal.