Health Waikato Ltd v Elmsly

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA69/03

BETWEENHEALTH WAIKATO LIMITED


Appellant

ANDWAYNE GEORGE ELMSLY


Respondent

Hearing:8 March 2004

Coram:William Young J
Goddard J
Gendall J

Appearances:  D J Taylor for Appellant


E J Hudson for Respondent

Judgment:25 March 2004 

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT DELIVERED BY WILLIAM YOUNG J

Introduction

[1]       This is an appeal from a judgment of the Employment Court (Travis J) delivered on 1 April 2003 in which he awarded the respondent (Dr Wayne Elmsly) costs of $36,000.  The costs judgment was a sequel to a substantive decision of Travis J delivered on 20 June 2002 in which he awarded Dr Elmsly $15,000 by way of damages for breaches by the appellant (to which we will refer as Health Waikato) of his employment contract.

Background facts

[2]       In 1986, Dr Elmsly took up employment with the Waikato Area Health Board (the statutory predecessor of Health Waikato) to work as a pathologist at Waikato Hospital.  This employment came to an end in October 1997.  Dr Elmsly brought proceedings in the Employment Court claiming that the dismissal was unjustified and also alleging various other breaches of the contractual duties owed to him by Health Waikato.

[3]       We can set out the key facts reasonably briefly.

[4]       Dr Elmsly suffers from a form of depressive disorder, the onset of which predated any of the conduct on the part of Health Waikato which was the subject of complaint.  

[5]       The problems which gave rise to this litigation relate to two post-mortem examinations carried out by Dr Elmsly in 1993.  In each case, the deceased had died in the course of, or following, surgical procedures in respect of which a fellow employee of Health Waikato, Dr Long, had been the anaesthetist.  There were police investigations in relation to both of the deaths, a coroner’s inquest into one of them and a prosecution of Dr Long for manslaughter in relation to the other.

[6]       Dr Elmsly became extremely anxious about what he perceived to be pressure, adverse comments and innuendo from his colleagues in relation to his conduct and his co-operation with the police.  He spoke to both his immediate superior and the chief executive of Health Waikato about the difficulties that had arisen.  He also spoke to a Regional Manager.  In his substantive judgment the Judge found that the conduct of two of these people constituted a breach of the implied terms of the employment contract to act as a good employer and not to destroy or seriously damage the relationship of trust and confidence between employer and employee.  The Judge concluded that they did not provide appropriate support for Dr Elmsly and,  what was worse, that there was an attempt to persuade him not to co-operate fully with the police on the basis that unnecessary co-operation would serve to further isolate him from his colleagues.

[7]       Difficulties associated with all of this came to a head on 23 July 1993 when Dr Elmsly was suspended by Health Waikato in circumstances…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Health Waikato Ltd v Elmsly and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] NZCA 35
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Court of Appeal considered an appeal from a judgment of the Employment Court in which Dr. Wayne Elmsly was awarded $36,000 in costs. Dr. Elmsly had brought proceedings against Health Waikato Limited, claiming breach of his employment contract and unjustified dismissal. The substantive judgment awarded Dr. Elmsly $15,000 in damages. The appeal focused on the costs judgment, with Health Waikato arguing that the award was excessive and not reflective of Dr. Elmsly's limited success at trial.

The Court of Appeal noted that while the Judge had considered Dr. Elmsly's partial success in the litigation, the award of $36,000 was still generous given the limited damages awarded. The Court found that the Judge had taken into account an irrelevant consideration in making the award, leading to a contribution to Dr. Elmsly's costs on claims on which he failed. The Court reduced the award of costs to $20,000, allowing for two-thirds recovery of the costs reasonably incurred by Dr. Elmsly in relation to the issues on which he succeeded.

The Court also commented on the broader issue of costs in employment litigation, suggesting that a more sensible approach by defendants in making Calderbank offers and by the Courts in responding to such offers could be in the broader public interest. The appeal was allowed, and Health Waikato was awarded costs in the Court of Appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.