Zhang v Telco Asset Management Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA18/2020
 [2020] NZCA 516

BETWEEN

YAN ZHANG
Appellant

AND

TELCO ASSET MANAGEMENT LIMITED
Respondent

CA150/2020

BETWEEN

YAN ZHANG
Appellant

AND

TELCO ASSET MANAGEMENT LIMITED
Respondent

Court:

Kós P and Courtney J

Counsel:

Appellant in Person
T P Cleary for Respondent

Judgment:
(On the papers)

21 October 2020 at 10.30 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT
[Recall]

The application for recall is declined. 

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Courtney J)

  1. In a decision delivered on 8 June 2020 this Court dismissed Mr Zhang’s application for leave to appeal a substantive decision of the Employment Court and the related costs decision.[1]  In a separate decision delivered on 1 September 2020 the respondent, Telco Asset Management Limited, was awarded costs on the application.[2]  Mr Zhang has applied to have the costs decision recalled (the Costs Decision). 

  2. The circumstances leading up to the delivery of the Costs Decision are as follows.  Telco applied for costs in accordance with the Court of Appeal (Civil) Rules 2005.  It calculated the costs at a total of $11,233.  It did not seek any disbursements.  Telco’s memorandum seeking costs was received by the Court on 15 June 2020.  On 18 August 2020 the Registry forwarded the memorandum to Mr Zhang, asking for a response within 10 working days.  Mr Zhang responded the following day by email, giving reasons that costs should not be paid.  He did not indicate that he wished to file any further submissions.

  3. On 28 August 2020 the Registry advised Mr Zhang that a decision on the costs application was to be delivered on 1 September 2020.  The following exchange followed between Mr Zhang and the Registry:

    (a)On 28 August 2020 Mr Zhang emailed the Registry saying “I will have a further response within 10 working days on next Monday, is that ok?”

    (b)The Registry responded “A further response to what sorry?”

    (c)Mr Zhang emailed “As to costs application from Telco, the deputy registrar emailed us on 18 August, said I have 10 working days for response, I have a further response due on next Monday.”

    (d)The Registry replied “Your response received via email on 19 August 2020to the respondent’s memorandum seeking costs was referred to the Judge last week.  I took that email as your response to the application.

    Is there anything else you would like the Judge to consider?”

    (e)Mr Zhang said “Yes, I have more information for the Judge to consider, my name is Yan Zhang, not “Jan Zhang” on the memorandum so that the memorandum from the respondent should be dismissed, as there is no appellant called Jan Zhang.  And there is more information on Monday as I am still working on it.”

    (f)The Registry responded “Because the matter on costs has already been heard on the papers by the Judges, you must seek leave…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Zhang v Telco Asset Management Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] NZCA 516
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Court of Appeal of New Zealand heard an application for recall brought by Yan Zhang against Telco Asset Management Limited. Zhang, acting in person, sought to have the Court recall its decision to award Telco costs following an unsuccessful appeal against an Employment Court decision. The appeal itself was dismissed by the Court on 8 June 2020, and Telco was awarded costs on 1 September 2020. Zhang's application for recall was dismissed by the Court on 21 October 2020.

The central legal issue before the Court was whether there were exceptional circumstances warranting the recall of the costs decision. Zhang argued that the costs decision should be recalled because his name was incorrectly stated as "Jan Zhang" in Telco's memorandum seeking costs, and that this error was a special reason justifying recall. Additionally, Zhang submitted a further memorandum with points opposing the costs, though this was not referred to the panel in delivering the costs decision.

The Court found that recall was only justified in exceptional circumstances, such as changes in relevant statutes or judicial decisions, or if justice required it for some other very special reason. Zhang's argument did not fit into any of these categories. The Court considered Zhang's initial response to Telco's memorandum and found that it had been taken into account in delivering the costs decision. The Registry had correctly informed Zhang that any further submissions would require leave, which Zhang did not seek. Moreover, Zhang's subsequent points could not have altered the Court's decision.

The Court concluded that justice did not require the recall of the costs decision. Zhang had been provided with the opportunity to respond to Telco's memorandum and had done so. The Registry's advice to Zhang that further submissions would require leave was accurate, and Zhang did not pursue this course. The application for recall was dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

In this case, the appellant, Yan Zhang, sought leave to appeal against a substantive decision of the Employment Court and the related costs decision, which were both dismissed by the Court of Appeal on 8 June 2020 and 1 September 2020, respectively. The respondent, Telco Asset Management Limited, applied for costs in accordance with the Court of Appeal (Civil) Rules 2005, calculating the costs at a total of $11,233, and did not seek any disbursements. Mr Zhang responded to the costs application by email on 19 August 2020, stating that costs should not be paid, and did not indicate a desire to file any further submissions. The Registry informed Mr Zhang that a decision on the costs application was to be delivered on 1 September 2020, and Mr Zhang attempted to file a further response on 31 August 2020, which was not referred to the panel. The Costs Decision was released on 1 September 2020, and Mr Zhang applied to have the Costs Decision recalled.

Mr Zhang's application for leave to appeal the substantive decision of the Employment Court and the related costs decision was dismissed by the Court of Appeal on 8 June 2020 and 1 September 2020, respectively. In a separate decision, Telco Asset Management Limited was awarded costs on the application. Mr Zhang applied to have the Costs Decision recalled, arguing that there was some very special reason that justice required the judgment to be recalled. The application for recall was heard on the papers.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the judgment should be recalled based on a change in relevant statute or regulation since the hearing.
2. Whether the judgment should be recalled because counsel failed to direct the Court to a legislative provision or an authoritative and plainly relevant decision at the hearing.
3. Whether the judgment should be recalled for some other very special reason that justice requires the judgment to be recalled.

Held
1. The application for recall of the judgment was declined.
2. The court did not find any basis to recall the judgment due to a change in relevant statute or regulation since the hearing.
3. The court did not find that counsel's failure to direct the Court to a legislative provision or an authoritative and plainly relevant decision at the hearing warranted recall.
4. The court concluded that there was no very special reason that justice required the judgment to be recalled.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In this case, the Court of Appeal considered the application for recall of the Costs Decision made in Zhang v Telco Asset Management Limited. The court outlined three recognised categories under which a judgment might be recalled: a change in relevant statute or regulation since the hearing, counsel's failure to direct the Court to a legislative provision or an authoritative and plainly relevant decision at the hearing, and some other very special reason that justice requires the judgment to be recalled. The court noted that Mr Zhang was provided with an opportunity to respond to Telco's memorandum seeking costs and he did so without indicating a desire to add anything further. His response was considered in the Costs Decision. The Registry correctly advised Mr Zhang that further submissions would require leave, which he did not pursue. The court concluded that there was no basis to recall the judgment under any of the recognised categories. The court found that justice did not require the recall of the judgment in this case. The appeal was dismissed. The binding legal principle established in this case is that a judgment will only be recalled in exceptional circumstances, specifically when there is a change in relevant statute or regulation since the hearing, counsel failed to direct the Court to a legislative provision or an authoritative and plainly relevant decision, or some other very special reason that justice requires the judgment to be recalled.